Inglington Mafia -End Game- Town Win!!!

[Stephan Wayne]

i think your right but were are these details going to come form?
untill then i keep my vote

[Nickbaldwin]

Random votes on day two.... Or are they not so random? Does Stroop actually suspect me or does he just want to bump off the town to get closer to his win.

FOS stroop

[ga7]

ok so we should have some clues by now as to who it is? im still pretty new to this but i honestly dont see any good givaways... or are you saying things like the random vote for nick could have been a clue as to either innocents or guilt? ahh thinking... no vote from me yet i need to review the posts again

By random voting I mean people throwing their vote with either no reason or a joke one. I wouldn't give it too much importance as this is a newbie game but it's usually a scumtell when people try to wagon without a good reason

Anyway, since we lynched a mafia on day 1 there is at least one lead: the vote count.

#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-
Vote count

Simon Viavant 5- (Hologram,Ga7,Knighthawk,Realmfighter,Stephen Wayne)

Realmfighter 1-(Stroop)

Stroop 1-(ga7)

Knighthawk 2-(Nickbaldwin,Natewolfman)

Not voting:Simon Viavant,

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch.

#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-#-

The way the wagon went, I think Simon's scumbuddies would have tried to avoid voting him, although it's not 100% sure. Coincidentally, all the people that did not vote for Simon didn't post either until the lynch scene...
So we have Nick, Nate, Stroop that didn't vote for him. His scumbuddy might be amongst them...

Thanks mafia!

Why do you know Mafia killed Hologram? Why not a Vig?

Right, so we're now probably with 6 townies against 1 mafia godfather...

I haven't seen Nickbaldwin since his random vote... vote Nick

I think it's also likely there's a GF left, but that compiled with the previous post makes me think you know a lot about the mafia. Maybe because you're part of it, AHA!
Vote Stroop

Btw, seeing as we had a SK I wonder if Stephen is really a Jester. A pity a vig didn't take a shot at him, maybe we don't have one :s
Anyway I suppose there's at least one mafia member remaining, possibly Godfather, so yet another anti-town would be a bit harsh. It depends of the mod though I guess. Alternatively Stephen could be scum hammering his buddy for clearance in a pretty weird way

[ga7]

I just realized I put Stroop at L-1. Unvote just in case until he answers.

[Nickbaldwin]

So we have Nick, Nate, Stroop that didn't vote for him. His scumbuddy might be amongst them...

I was sleeping while the decision to lynch Simon was made. When I went to sleep, Simon was on 2 votes, I woke up to find him lynched.

[Stephan Wayne]

Simon Viavant 5- (Hologram,Ga7,Knighthawk,Realmfighter,Stephen Wayne)

Realmfighter 1-(Stroop)

Stroop 1-(ga7)

Knighthawk 2-(Nickbaldwin,Natewolfman)

Not voting:Simon Viavant,

i think ga7 has a good point (and also i perfect way to throug suspition around)
stroop had a ramdom vote but nick and nate voted knighthawk
i dont get ga7s moves but i guess i have to trust him
unvote
vote nickbaldwin

[knighthawk]

vote Natewolfman cause if i read correctly he's the only one of three that does not have a vote yet for him and who didn't vote for Simon

[Nickbaldwin]

Simon Viavant 5- (Hologram,Ga7,Knighthawk,Realmfighter,Stephen Wayne)

Realmfighter 1-(Stroop)

Stroop 1-(ga7)

Knighthawk 2-(Nickbaldwin,Natewolfman)

Not voting:Simon Viavant,

i think ga7 has a good point (and also i perfect way to throug suspition around)
stroop had a ramdom vote but nick and nate voted knighthawk
i dont get ga7s moves but i guess i have to trust him
unvote
vote nickbaldwin

My vote was random.... you fool.

[Nickbaldwin]

Since you cocked up last time Stephen I would vote you.

But I have a feeling you're a jester so I won't.

[Stephan Wayne]

Simon Viavant 5- (Hologram,Ga7,Knighthawk,Realmfighter,Stephen Wayne)

Realmfighter 1-(Stroop)

Stroop 1-(ga7)

Knighthawk 2-(Nickbaldwin,Natewolfman)

Not voting:Simon Viavant,

i think ga7 has a good point (and also i perfect way to throug suspition around)
stroop had a ramdom vote but nick and nate voted knighthawk
i dont get ga7s moves but i guess i have to trust him
unvote
vote nickbaldwin

My vote was random.... you fool.

your not dead yet and ill take my vote back when i need to just trying to get a reation

[Nickbaldwin]

ga7 got a reaction. I was asleep, over here it was getting on for 1am when even the 3rd vote for simon came in. How that makes me suspicious I am unsure.

[ga7]

Frankly I'm more concerned about Stroop amongst the 3 but it's good to have a reaction from the others. Considering the speed the wagon on Stephen had Nick's excuse seems credible.
It's a good thing we're quite ahead with 2 scum dead as I have a feeling it won't be easy to get the rest heh

[ga7]

Frankly I'm more concerned about Stroop amongst the 3 but it's good to have a reaction from the others. Considering the speed the wagon on Simon had Nick's excuse seems credible.
It's a good thing we're quite ahead with 2 scum dead as I have a feeling it won't be easy to get the rest heh

EBWOP, I keep mixing them

[Natewolfman]

wow that was alot of posting between last night and this morning

ok after reviewing... Nick i do belive was a random vote so i dont think it is him... of course random vote is 100% sure.

heres my question though, do we know for certain that the two mafia people knew each other in game? and if they did that would mean that Ga7 and knighthawk are most likelly* clear (unless they are really good at avoiding us )

HOWEVER

i dont think that clears Realmfighter or Stephen Wayne... they may have voted for the partner seeing that he would be voted out to help avoid suspicion... so on that note,

vote Stephen Wayne

because i dont trust that 5th vote... after all he did choose to lynch him when the others were saying we should wait for his word

[Natewolfman]

Oh and about the Jester thing... i dont know, i dont think we have one wouldnt it have been mentioned on the first post? and he may have been trying to save himself by acting like a jester... and if he IS the mafia guy, and we all belve he is a jester, we are screwed

[Nickbaldwin]

I'm not sure about the Jester theory either, not had a Jester in a game yet so I don't know whether it would be mentioned or not.

I'm going with Stroop or Stephen, not sure which to choose.

[ga7]

I like the way you avoided to answer the accusations on you, Nate.
You make a good point about Stephen anyway, but I still think it could go either way and I certainly don't want to give a lousy jester a win.

Come to think of it, it would make no sense if there was a jester but no vig on the town side. How would we be able to get rid of him? The SK and Mafia would avoid killing him to make us waste a lynch. Furthermore if he is indeed the jester we don't know if the game would stop if he's lynched or not... Most mods make it continue, but in small games it's not always so.

Here's my proposal: since the mafia roleblocker is gone, if there is someone who is actually the town vig, please claim now. That way we know it's better to not lynch Stephen but to get him NKed, and if no one comes out we can safely lynch him for being a probable mafia.

[ga7]

Btw, jesters presence is not mentionned. Some mods like to claim they won't use that role though, as it's pretty hated
Mafia always know each other, except in rare weird games. This wouldn't be designed as such I believe.

[Natewolfman]

I like the way you avoided to answer the accusations on you, Nate.

didnt see the point in addressing it, knight voted for me for the game we played so i voted for him cuz i beat him in said game *shrugs* thats my only excuse for my vote so i didnt think it was much worth mentioning at the time

as for the jester bit, i can see why its hated, i dont like the idea of it at all and the few times ive played with friends, i had never heard of it... though we also had a couple more roles
1) Mafia X2
2) Sherif & Deputy
3) Doctor & Nurse
4) Assassin
of course this is with a large group of 16+ people or so, but ya never heard of a jester and dont like the idea of it lol

[Stephan Wayne]

unvote


Natewolfman you fool im the one doing the mob killing lay off your starting to look suspicious

[Nickbaldwin]

I like the way you avoided to answer the accusations on you, Nate.
You make a good point about Stephen anyway, but I still think it could go either way and I certainly don't want to give a lousy jester a win.

Come to think of it, it would make no sense if there was a jester but no vig on the town side. How would we be able to get rid of him? The SK and Mafia would avoid killing him to make us waste a lynch. Furthermore if he is indeed the jester we don't know if the game would stop if he's lynched or not... Most mods make it continue, but in small games it's not always so.

Here's my proposal: since the mafia roleblocker is gone, if there is someone who is actually the town vig, please claim now. That way we know it's better to not lynch Stephen but to get him NKed, and if no one comes out we can safely lynch him for being a probable mafia.

I'm not a vig but I am a killing role on the town side.

[ga7]

unvote


Natewolfman you fool im the one doing the mob killing lay off your starting to look suspicious

Uhh... This is confusing. What do you mean Stephen? Did you kill Hologram?

Nick: is killing your only ability?

[Nickbaldwin]

Yes, and only in certain conditions.

[Stroop]

Thanks mafia!

Why do you know Mafia killed Hologram? Why not a Vig?

Scum, a SK, and a vig in a 9-player game? The thought didn't cross my mind. It could've also been a Jack-of-all-Trades or whatever... I just assumed it was the mafia, I apologize for speaking before thinking

Right, so we're now probably with 6 townies against 1 mafia godfather...

I haven't seen Nickbaldwin since his random vote... vote Nick

I think it's also likely there's a GF left, but that compiled with the previous post makes me think you know a lot about the mafia. Maybe because you're part of it, AHA!
Vote Stroop

Maybe you're getting nervous because I know so much about you! AHA! It was just a vote to see what others thought of it, I could have FOSed, but a vote is so much more dramatic. Also, one vote isn't too harmful when we need four.

[Stephan Wayne]

ok now am confused