Extreme Ways wrote:@Loose, if your logic would be correct, why wouldn't it also extend to hard claims instead of only softclaims? You're basically claiming that full role info is worth more for town, when almost always it is the opposite D1.
@Ragian, good point. It's just the vote timing that didn't sit well with me. I'm curious though, are you entertaining the jester idea or am I the only one who is thinking he is way more likely to be a third party than scum?
Maybe? Jester has always just been such an uncommon role on this site outside of the old Chu games which were always zany that I rarely account for them in my logic.
My list:
Town: I'm all alone. There's no one here beside me.
Townish:
1. DDS: think DDS has been pretty reasonable so far. Almost too reasonable compared to some of his behavior but it's also day 1 which he's always advocated as a no lynch/conservative play period of the game.
2. Duke: I don't agree with a lot of what he says but when I read back through his posts, they seemed consistent.
3. Extreme is well-reasoned for the most part. I don't know if I follow him on the Son!c Jester logic but otherwise I've mostly agreed with him.
Neutral:
1. Ragian-Just no strong read on him at this point.
2. Charle-Not active enough for me to feel comfortable giving a detailed read. Engagement overall feels genuine.
3. Trafa-No strong read.
4. Darin-A bit defensive but dont know if that actually says much either way. Would like to hear from him more.
5. Anyone I forget to mention Here.
Ambivalent:
1. Pixar-I think the wagon on him was stupid. I'm kind of against forcing him to claim for what was a joke wagon. I would however be lying if how he avoided defending himself didn't rub me the wrong way at times.
2. Son!c: Very active but seems to be prone to wild theories and trying to make the facts fit them.
3. Loose-I was leaning town but his behavior and insistence on trying to get softclaims out there strikes me as weird. Maybe his voteless condition has something to do with him trying to find a specific character in the game.
4. Anyone who jumped in on Pixar after the third vote not mentioned elsewhere. The wagon was BS and it would be easy for scum to slip in somewhere.
Scummish:
1. Razor-I don't like the way he went after Pepe and Rage earlier ad it really felt like he picked two people and then came up with reasons for suspecting them. He's also gone quieter since the game started turning more serious.
Needs to be prodded/replaced:
1. Drake-Get back in here!
2. Bax-If he's as bad as people say, just replace him please.
3. Max-unless I'm mistaken, he's also not posted in a while.
. And I guess there's some that somehow enjoy the interface of chessc*m, but to me it's so ugly and unintuitive.