[OFFICIAL] Charle's Fun Mafia - "Game On" Day 4

[SoN!c]

EW his legacy is also his scum ideas about Kingm.
DDS flipped after Chana"s AI post. Loose pointed out it could be Max related rather then Chana's. But whoever the scumpartner is it all trails back to DDS. Self voting is just stupid IF town. And especially stupid IF town PR.

Both town roles suiciding to get me is mindblowing dumbness. Because im town. And since i believe suiciding is always dumb IF town how was i to know they where town too. FUBAR!

[hjelp]

@Well SoN!c, you did survive so it's possible that you're a SK.
There was only one kill.

[SoN!c]

@Well SoN!c, you did survive so it's possible that you're a SK.
There was only one kill.

I get it im a suspect. But if im SK my whole play untill now would be super dumb.

[SoN!c]

Im not stupid and i like to think im not superdumb..

[chanakam2020]

It is terrible Hal is not telling what he did last night.
Also it is raising my suspicion.
.
Everyone know your claimed as COP.
And you are telling you will not tell what you did last night untill we tell our roles.
What you expecting ?
Scum to tell they are scums and Serial Killer to tell he is Serial Killer ?

.
Why not you are telling what you did last night.
I am starting to doubt about Hal now.
.
Hal are you really the COP ?
.
About N1 you said your investigation blocked by higher authority.
And
Now you are not telling us what you did at N2.
.
I cant understand the logic
& Earlier we discussed it is quite unlikely town has 4 power roles.
So I am starting to doubt whether you are really a COP.
.
Is it possible to have a game setting with only a Tracker, but No COP ?
.
Hal Are you really COP or Are you the Serial Killer ?
.

[SoN!c]

I wanted to post this:

Both town roles suiciding to get me is mindblowing dumbness. Because im town. And since i believe suiciding is always dumb IF town how was i to know they where town too. FUBAR!

But apparently it edited a previous post... so let's have Devante in here so he can make sure i did no edit or delete on purpose

[SoN!c]

Last edited by SoN!c on Mon Sep 22, 2025 9:50 pm, edited 1 time in total.

9.50 pm and the new post at 9.52....

[SoN!c]

Maybe my police patrols thwarted the second attempt, my men don't spend all their time eating doughnuts chan

We vote Chana? Say the word


And town: we follow Halrob!

[Loose Canon]

A tactic I've seen used by doctor is to self protect N1.
Doctors also often can't protect the same player on consecutive nights.

Fpd by sonic

[halrob64]

to be honest Loose thats a dumb post it is senseless to bring a lynching onto yourself especially when you are someone who is town and has a role.
What I will tell you is this, you need to change your thinking and ally yourself to me and other town people.
Just look at Chanakam's post, its crazy if he is town, he is asking me to tell what I found last night. If I found out someone definitely had town role and I exposed that role it would leave them wide open and Chanakam knows that, he seems desperate for the information.
So:
1 If I found out someone had a town role and I exposed them, then I would most likely be allied to the mafia.
2 If I found someone had a town role and I am not willing to expose them it means I am an honest cop and I'm protecting them.
3 If I found out someone had a scum role then as an honest cop I would out them.
4 If I found out someone was scum then I would protect them if I was a dishonest cop
I think its pretty obvious why I am not telling what I have found out at this point, Chanakam is certainly being aggressive in trying to find out what I know, so Loose don't make the same mistake in D3 otherwise we wont have any town people left

[Kingm]

to be honest Loose thats a dumb post it is senseless to bring a lynching onto yourself especially when you are someone who is town and has a role.
What I will tell you is this, you need to change your thinking and ally yourself to me and other town people.
Just look at Chanakam's post, its crazy if he is town, he is asking me to tell what I found last night. If I found out someone definitely had town role and I exposed that role it would leave them wide open and Chanakam knows that, he seems desperate for the information.
So:
1 If I found out someone had a town role and I exposed them, then I would most likely be allied to the mafia.
2 If I found someone had a town role and I am not willing to expose them it means I am an honest cop and I'm protecting them.
3 If I found out someone had a scum role then as an honest cop I would out them.
4 If I found out someone was scum then I would protect them if I was a dishonest cop
I think its pretty obvious why I am not telling what I have found out at this point, Chanakam is certainly being aggressive in trying to find out what I know, so Loose don't make the same mistake in D3 otherwise we wont have any town people left

If you found a townie, yeah then you should for sure not expose them.
And I do agree with you Hal, somethings smells with Chana, hmm.

[hjelp]

...
Just look at Chanakam's post, its crazy if he is town, he is asking me to tell what I found last night. If I found out someone definitely had town role and I exposed that role it would leave them wide open and Chanakam knows that, he seems desperate for the information.
...

If Chana is a Mafia, there is no need to know the information since it's unlikely to be any power left. At the most one power. And if a Mafia then would know anyhow. So why asking ?? if a Mafia.
I think it would be crazy to post that if Chana is a Mafia.

[chanakam2020]

Maybe my police patrols thwarted the second attempt, my men don't spend all their time eating doughnuts chan

We vote Chana? Say the word

And town: we follow Halrob!

What Hal saying here is he has some supportive mens.
He said "my men" instead "I" which means some other cop supportive.
.
But it could not be you Sonic.
If you are the one who protected 2nd kill then you should be dead by now according to the description of Symbiotic role.
So you are not his police patrol.
.
If Hal saying truth that means there is another town powe role holder apart from Hal, Sonic.
If it is true it is good news for twon as town has more protections & powers.
.
But my curious mind doubting about it.
Becuase at some point earlier we discussed it is unlikely there is 4 Town Power Role holders
&
Now Hal is indicating about a 5th power role holder.
IMAO
.

[chanakam2020]

to be honest Loose thats a dumb post it is senseless to bring a lynching onto yourself especially when you are someone who is town and has a role.
What I will tell you is this, you need to change your thinking and ally yourself to me and other town people.
Just look at Chanakam's post, its crazy if he is town, he is asking me to tell what I found last night. If I found out someone definitely had town role and I exposed that role it would leave them wide open and Chanakam knows that, he seems desperate for the information.
So:
1 If I found out someone had a town role and I exposed them, then I would most likely be allied to the mafia.
2 If I found someone had a town role and I am not willing to expose them it means I am an honest cop and I'm protecting them.
3 If I found out someone had a scum role then as an honest cop I would out them.
4 If I found out someone was scum then I would protect them if I was a dishonest cop
I think its pretty obvious why I am not telling what I have found out at this point, Chanakam is certainly being aggressive in trying to find out what I know, so Loose don't make the same mistake in D3 otherwise we wont have any town people left

If you found a townie, yeah then you should for sure not expose them.
And I do agree with you Hal, somethings smells with Chana, hmm.

Yep I agree, If Hal found a town he should not name the player now
and especially if he found a town power role holder.
If he found a town player he can later tell the name if we are going near to lynch that player.
.
So at this point no need to tell the name.
But I think Hal can tell some thing more specific like
1 . "I investigated some one & he is a Townie & I am not telling his name for now "
2. "I investigates some one & he is Mafia & I am not telling his name for now"
3. "I investigates some one & he is Serial Killer/Wolf & I am not telling his name for now"
Or
4. "I investigates some one & he is a BadBoy & I will never tell his name" (In case Hal needed our votes)
.
Beign more specific about his night action without telling the name will be usefull for our attempt to solve the game I think.

After all we still do not have 100% sure fact about hals claim as COP.
N-1 Hal said some thing about higher authority
N2 Hal said about his men in patrol
So Hal has not yet provided any sure evident about his COP role claim.
.
So I am expecting more specific description of Hals N-2 action like above 1,2,3 or 4
so that we can verify Hals calims at later stages of the game.

somethings smells with Chana, hmm.

I guess some thing wrong with your nose.
Our town doctor Ragian is dead.
Otherwise you could have get tearment for your nose.

Lol

[Loose Canon]

What hal has said is nonsense.

Mafia know who each other are, so they already know who isn't mafia.
They will kill player or players who are not them each night anyway.

Therefore saying who he investigated and whether the result was guilty, not guilty, or no result gives mafia no information they don't have already and paints no more target on a player's back than they have already.

Halrob for spouting such nonsense should
1. Name the player he investigated
2. Tell us whether the supposed result was guilty, not guilty or no result
3. EXPLAIN WHY HE INVESTIGATED THE PLAYER HE'S CLAIMING HE INVESTIGATED

[Loose Canon]

I'm now wondering if Mafias power to compensate for the powers that town had but have now lost 3 - maybe all of - is Charle gave them safe fake claims at the beginning of the game?

That would to my way of thinking fit with the "Fun" title that Charle gave to the game.

[chanakam2020]

I'm now wondering if Mafias power to compensate for the powers that town had but have now lost 3 - maybe all of - is Charle gave them safe fake claims at the beginning of the game?

That would to my way of thinking fit with the "Fun" title that Charle gave to the game.

After all now we are reduced to 9 players and We discussed and agreed that 4 out of initial 13 are bad boys.
2x2 bad boy factions a gang of 3 bad boys + 1 lone wolf of a serial killer.
None of them killed or lynched yet.
So
out of 9 currently alive 4 are Bad boys.
We need 5 votes to lynch.
.
No more room for mislynch.
If we lynch a wrong one today it is game over.
.

[Charle]

Vote Count:

King (1) - Sonic

9 Alive - 5 Needed for a Lynch!

[Loose Canon]

@Sonic

Ragian and EW must surely have been wrong about you.
Your heart is as pure as the driven snow, and your generousity knows no bounds.
You are more eager than anyone I know to root out the bad apples amongst us.
A difficult task as you are too well aware in towns current predicament.
You are alas, too often misunderstood.

But hypothetically speaking, if by some slender and completely improbable chance you have fallen in with a bad crowd this time;
Intelligent (I forgot to mention your intelligence) gentleman as you are, you would realise that at some point any serial killer that walks amongst us would pose a threat to mafias interests as well as those of the good townsfolk (of which I must stress you must surely be one of).
At such point as you might also then be undecided as to which amongst us is the serial killer, but you recognise that whoever it is needs to be dealt with, but which you then consider it might be Max.

Could you then please in the interests of participation, exert whatever completely hypothetical influence you may have managed to garner with those mafia ruffians, to please kill Max.

[Devante]

Ok I'm caught up. Couple things here

What hal has said is nonsense.

Mafia know who each other are, so they already know who isn't mafia.
They will kill player or players who are not them each night anyway.

Therefore saying who he investigated and whether the result was guilty, not guilty, or no result gives mafia no information they don't have already and paints no more target on a player's back than they have already.

Halrob for spouting such nonsense should
1. Name the player he investigated
2. Tell us whether the supposed result was guilty, not guilty or no result
3. EXPLAIN WHY HE INVESTIGATED THE PLAYER HE'S CLAIMING HE INVESTIGATED

Hal what Loose says here is normally how we do this. If townie you don't reveal unless they are about to get lynched, otherwise telling us whether you were blocked or had an investigation that worked all gives us info that only mafia would have at this point. Anything that shes some light on night events is always helpful for town

As for D3 so far, several have shifted from how they were discussing things while rags and extreme were around. Their points still ring valid to me and given they were both willing to put themselves on the spotlight to confirm their suspicious and that they are both confirmed town now I will stick with what their direction was. And I also do not buy the claimed role for this player has stated.

VOTE SONIC

[chanakam2020]

@Sonic
Acoording to the role description of Town Symbiotic you are alive means the one you visited at night was not targetted to kill by bad boy.
Am I correct ?

So
N-1 you went to Hal ?
N-2 to whom you went ?
.
The one Sonic visited was not attempted to kill by bad boys mean that one could be possibly in bad boys faction.
So telling who you visited N-2 will give us some more pieces of info to solve this game.
.

[halrob64]

OK I visited Loose he is innocent, so he is an ally of mine

[halrob64]

Why did I investigate Loose, well he was pushing to lynch either EW who he believed 95% Mafia
or Ragian, not quite sure why.
He kept banging on about me being 40% Mafia so it was totally muddying the waters.
I am new to this game, I am learning the rules of the game but I wanted to investigate someone who was clearly trying to push an agenda that other people were Mafia, clearly they were not.
So lets reset the button, we know one definite town-Loose, the town cop me, no one else has come forward unless there are 2 of us thats clearly not going to happen.
If mafia already knows who are town then why not declare fully who is town and who is mafia?

[Loose Canon]

Oh well that's good to know.

So I'm clean eh?

Well maybe pass the word on to that hooker friend of yours.
I hear she is filthy.

[halrob64]

Yes she said you were crap so she moved on to me