for dummies wrote:why believe him? well lets see...hmmm...well he claimed a role and at this point in time i believe him. also no one has refuted the role yet. that might just be because of the nature of is role, i don't know. but you have given me no evidence to think that you are town. i understand that dumbledore looked scummy but after a big claim like that you should always wait longer, see if there is a counterclaim, or something. even if he has looked scummy all game you can't just drop the hammer right away. and also you say i have been pushing for claims all game. well yes that's true. if someone is at lynch -1 or -2. i want a calim so that if they are really pro town they won't be hammered. i expect that after the claim it will be discussed and we will decide as a town if we believe it or not. if we don't we lynch them, if we do then we go after someone else. that is another of my main problems with you droping the hammer on dumbledore, you didn't let anyone else talk. there were around 4 of you talking for a period of time then you hammered him. the rest of us didn't have time to get a word in edgewise. and that in short is why i think you are scum.
Oh yeah also because your vote on me was of the "OMGUS" variety.
Nothing personal, but I would sincerely hope no one does refute the claim for awhile because that could be bad for us. It's already been stated that whoever Voldemort is either missed the clue or is being blocked because if nags claim is accurate...nothings happened too him yet. But we certainly don't need to paint a bulls eye on the real target yet.
Also, I've already discussed "dropping the hammer right away" in the above posts between myself and nagerous. If you paid attention, you would see that isn't exactly what happened. But it's ok, interpret the evidence the way you want and ignore the other players who just popped in to vote.
In fact, I could tear your whole arguement apart. It's all been discussed and I explained my actions rather well. You however push too hard, too fast. You've posted maybee 15-17 times the whole game and 5 of those times you've mentioned:
for dummies wrote:yeah well we still have some time before the deadline. i would say no one else should vote for him until he claims. oh and by the way when you claim we will want a chracter role (cop, dr.) and a name(harry potter, snape). We can use the names to examine the viability of your claim.
for dummies wrote:i believe mandy. he is an experienced player and i don't think he would stick his head out this far without solid proof (investigation perhaps?). of course if he is wrong. then we can just lynch him. also even though nagerous claimed a power role i want a real claim before i even think of letting him off the hook. to this point in time his defense has been: " waah waah don't vote for me, he has no evidence" wel i think he must have evidence and so far you have givven me no evidnce that you aren't scum. to that effect:
Vote: nagerous
for dummies wrote:yeah i do want a role claim. i want you to prove to me that you aren't scum. and yes when you claim i want a characters name. anyone can say i am (doctor) or (cop). it is harder to make up a character name from HP to fit the role. that way your HP name can help verify your claim or it can help expose its falseness. therefore if you want to survive today i want your claim and your name.
for dummies wrote:what is your reasoning dustn64. what brings you to the conclusion that you should vote for mandy.
and nagerous, i saw your little clues, but i didn't like them. i want a role claim or my vote stays
for dummies wrote:yeah guess why it didn't help. because people kept votinf even after they heard his name and role. i already got on the offending party's in that case. it was totally stupid. this time i hope there will be less stupidity we can discuss the role claim and its validatiy and go from there
Hmmm....notice a common theme in your posts
...Not the smartest way to play. My vote for you stands, and unless someone steps up and convinces me you are a valuble player for the town, it won't change.
.jpg)
