Slow day is slow.
I think replacing thor is wishful thinking. The closer the game is to finishing, the least worth it (from the replacement perspective) it is to replace. And I'd say this game is very close to finishing.
I'd like to get MM's opinions, and whether TFO was actually notified that he was shot or was just going by Sam's word.
If we end the day without thor, can I send him a pm to remind him to send you any night action he might have (unless you want to do it)? I can cc you the mail as well.
I was thinking of this.
(link to the thread) The day has ended in the Hobbit Mafia. We're now night 7, please send any night action you might have directly to LoVo in the next [72h]. Don't reply to this mail, I don't want to see them.
ZaBeast wrote:Slow day is slow.
I think replacing thor is wishful thinking. The closer the game is to finishing, the least worth it (from the replacement perspective) it is to replace. And I'd say this game is very close to finishing.
I'd like to get MM's opinions, and whether TFO was actually notified that he was shot or was just going by Sam's word.
If we end the day without thor, can I send him a pm to remind him to send you any night action he might have (unless you want to do it)? I can cc you the mail as well.
I was thinking of this.
(link to the thread) The day has ended in the Hobbit Mafia. We're now night 7, please send any night action you might have directly to LoVo in the next [72h]. Don't reply to this mail, I don't want to see them.
Thorthoth can't access his Inbox on a Forum Ban. so that won't work.
Yes, I received a PM that my Vest had been hit.
Game 1675072
2018-08-09 16:02:06 - Mageplunka69: its jamaica map and TFO that keep me on this site
TheForgivenOne wrote:Thorthoth can't access his Inbox on a Forum Ban. so that won't work.
I guess you know better than me. I was under the impression it was possible because of this.
BuJaber wrote:Well unfortunately not everyone follows instructions to the letter. But Bernie has read both the role PM and the prodding PM, so I saw no reason to delay the start of the game when he's receiving the information.
EDIT - I have just been told that Bernie has been forum banned for a month. So I have contacted skoffin about replacing him.
Thinking back on it, there is a slight chance Sam could be scum. Both times he shot someone, there was only one body. He could have taken the scum kill N4 and killed KJ. That would require TFO covering him (pretending he's been shot N5). Therefore, for sam to be scum, TFO has to be too. I don't think it's likely, since Sam has a strong name claim and that would require a scum team of 5 members (though one that can't kill at night), but it's still a possibility. Therefore, I suggest we lynch TFO today, as there has to be at least one scum between pika and TFO. Hopefully MM has received the killing item, so we won't have to wait for thor to come back.
I'd rather have the game moving again as well as I'm leaving in less than a week for the two following weeks.
Not much I can do when other people aren't posting but I'll put my vote where my mouth is and Vote TFO for the reasons mentionned above. As with mitch, we see what his role is and we go from there. Unfortunately, I don't have strong opinions on who is scum between pika and TFO (though I'd lean slightly more on TFO being scum than pika)
Possibilities:
TFO is the only scum left: gg town
TFO is non-bulletproof scum: Sam is scum as well (because this implies Sam lied about being vig)
TFO is bulletproof scum: That's where the killing item could come in handy, but Sam is probably fine, especially if TFO's role doesn't mention him being notified about being hit.
TFO is bulleproof town: Sam is town, Pika is scum
Honestly scum bulletproof seem likely and I"m leaning more towards a scum busser for tfo's role. Don't know if we'll get a replacement so no point in waiting for them. I"ll put him at L-1 with Vote TFO
Well three of the people who have made a post today are voting for the same person, with the other person who has made a post (and isn't forum banned) being the one we're voting for, so anybody reading this has already done as much as they can to progress the game short of committing suicide...
If you want something to happen then hunt down Minister Masket for us =P
BILBO Bilbo Baggins “If more of us cared about food and home above gold, this world would be a merrier place”
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Bilbo Baggins, an Even-Night Commuter allied with Thorin’s Company. Bio
Bilbo Baggins is a Hobbit of the Shire. He is a wealthy and well-respected Hobbit before reluctantly agreeing to be hired as a burglar in Thorin’s Company. Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Even-Night Commute: On even nights, you may choose to leave the town for the night, rendering you unable to be targeted by night actions. Win Condition
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
DirtyDishSoapSpoiler
THORIN Thorin II Oakenshield “If this is to end in fire, then we will all burn together”
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Thorin II Oakenshield, a Gunsmith allied with Thorin’s Company. Bio
Son of Thrain, grandson of Thror, after his childhood home of Erebor was taken by the dragon Smaug he became the King-In-Exile of Durin’s Folk. A very skilled warrior and natural leader, he is super determined to regain his home and destroy the beast that brought such misery upon his people. Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Gunsmith:Each night you may PM the name of a player to inspect and I will tell you if they have a gun or not Win Condition
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
ZaBeastSpoiler
BALIN Balin “I thought to myself then, There is one I could follow, There is one I could call King”
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Balin, a Vanilla Townie allied with Thorin’s Company. Bio
A dwarf lord, Balin, son of Fundin is old and wise, he is one of Thorin’s closest friends and advisors. He is distantly related to Thorin, and is a descendent of the noble house of Durin. Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Win Condition
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
SkoffinSpoiler
KILI Kili “I will not hide behind a wall of stone while others fight our battles for us! It is not in my blood”
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Kili, a Mason allied with Thorin’s Company. Bio
Younger brother to Fili and nephew to Thorin, Kili possesses the invincible courage of youth. A very skilled fighter and expert archer as one of the youngest in the company he is determined to make his mark Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Mason: You know that your brother Fili (player) is also allied with Thorin’s Company. Each night you may communicate with them. Win Condition
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
Minister MasketSpoiler
FILI Fili “I belong with my brother!”
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Fili, a Mason allied with Thorin’s Company. Bio
Older brother to Kili and nephew to Thorin, he has never travelled far nor seen the fabled dwarf city of Erebor. A skilled fighter, he sets off on the adventure with little idea of the challenges and dangers that lie before him. Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Mason: You know that your brother Kili (player) is also allied with Thorin’s Company. Each night you may communicate with them. Win Condition
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
ThorthothSpoiler
ORI Ori “I don’t like green food….Have they got any chips?”
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Ori, an Innocent Child allied with Thorin’s Company. Bio
Ori is a talented artist, and can often be found writing and drawing in his journal. One of the youngest in the company and not much of a skilled warrior, his courage and determination sometimes surprises himself. Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Innocence: Once during the game, you may PM me and ask me to confirm your alignment publicly in the game thread. Win Condition
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
SamlenSpoiler
BARD Bard the Bowman “I was born and bread on these waters, Master Dwarf. If I wanted to kill you, I would not do it here.”
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Bard the Bowman, a 2-Shot Vigilante allied with Thorin’s Company. Bio
Bard is a man of Laketown and captain of a company of archers. He is the heir of Girion and to the Kingdom of Dale. Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Vigilante: Two times per game, you may PM me the name of a player at night you would like to kill. You may only use one shot per night. Win Condition
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
RagianSpoiler
BEORN Beorn “If you must know more, his name is Beorn, He is very strong, and he is a skin-changer.”
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Beorn, a Jailkeeper allied with Thorin’s Company. Bio
Beorn is a warrior with great strength who can turn into a great black bear. He has a love for all living things except for goblins and orcs. He is wise, mysterious and powerful, possessing incredible strength and durability. Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Jailkeeper: Each night, you may PM me the name of a player, and that player will not be able to use any night actions nor will they be able to be targeted for any killing actions. Win Condition
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
MudPuppySpoiler
GANDALF Gandalf the Grey “Do you wish me a good morning, or mean that it is a good morning whether I want it or not; or that you feel good this morning; or that it is a morning to be good on?”
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Gandalf the Grey, an Inventor allied with Thorin’s Company. Bio
Gandalf, originally named Olorin is an Istar, sent by the west to combat the threat of Sauron. As a wizard he has spent many years among the free people of Middle Earth. He has begun to grow more concerned that the enemy is once again regaining strength and is concerned for the enemies use of the Lonely Mountain. Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Inventor: Each night you may PM me the name and the gadget you wish to give to a player to use that night. You have 4 gadgets to give out. A sword (one shot kill), A Mithril shirt (one shot doctor), Light of Earendil (one shot investigation), Elven rope (one shot roleblock). Win Condition
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
BuJaberSpoiler
BOFUR Bofur "With a love of music and a fine singing voice"
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Bofur, a Vanilla Townie allied with Thorin’s Company. Bio
Bofur a descendent of the Dwarves of Khazad-dum, but not of Durin's Folk. He and his family hailed from the Blue Mountains. He and his family not being from Erebor, they care less for the quest to reclaim the mountain and more for the adventure along the way. Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Win Condition
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
PikancionSpoiler
GLOIN Gloin
“Who is this? Your brother?...That is my wife! ….And who is this horrid creature? A goblin mutant? …. That is my wee lad, Gimli.”
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Gloin, a Vanilla Townie allied with Thorin’s Company. Bio
Gloin, son of Groin and father to Gimli, he is outspoken and opinionated. He is the only dwarf in the company who has a wife, she is an acclaimed beauty with a particularly fine beard. Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Win Condition
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
nickthesticks Kamikaze JawaSpoiler
DAIN Dain II Ironfoot “I will not stand down before any elf!”
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Dain II Ironfoot, a Vanilla Townie allied with Thorin’s Company. Bio
Lord of the Iron Hills and cousin to Thorin Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Win Condition
You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
FloresDelMal TheForgivenOneSpoiler
NECROMANCER Necromancer of Dol Guldor “It is the shadow of an ancient horror. One that can summon the spirits of the dead.”
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Necromancer of Dol Guldor, a Bulletproof Goon allied with The Enemy. Bio
Disguised as a necromancer Sauron is the most evil and dangerous threat to the people of middle earth. After your defeat at the end of the second age you are residing in Dol Guldor regaining your strength before seeking out the one ring again. Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Bulletproof: You are not to be able to be killed at night. Communication: Each night you may talk with other members of The Enemy, member and member. You also know there is a spy for your faction in the game. Factional Kill: Each night your faction is allowed to kill one person in the game. Any member of The Enemy can PM me a name of a person you would like to kill. Win Condition
You win when the mafia control 50% of the votes in play and nothing in the game can prevent that. Fake claim
You know that Dwalin is not in the game.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable
madmitchSpoiler
SMAUG Smaug “I am the king under the mountain”
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Smaug, a Goon allied with The Enemy. Bio
For almost 200 years Smaug has hoarded the Lonely Mountain’s treasures to himself. Considered to be the last great dragon to exist in Middle Earth. He is said to be 130 metres long and possesses extreme physical strength. Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Communication: Each night you may talk with other members of The Enemy, member and member. You also know there is a spy for your faction in the game. Factional Kill: Each night your faction is allowed to kill one person in the game. Any member of The Enemy can PM me a name of a person you would like to kill. Win Condition
You win when the mafia control 50% of the votes in play and nothing in the game can prevent that. Fake claim
You know that Bombur is not in the game.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
dakky21Spoiler
BOLG Bolg
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Bolg, a Vengeful Goon allied with The Enemy. Bio
The son of Azog the defilier, Bolg is the Orc leader of the Misty Mountains. He leads armies of orcs and goblins from the capital Mount Gundabad. He is murderous, merciless, sadistic and a cruel warrior. Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Vengeful: If you are ever lynched at any point in the game, you may PM me the name of a player and that person will also be killed as well. Communication: Each night you may talk with other members of The Enemy, member and member. You also know there is a spy for your faction in the game. Factional Kill: Each night your faction is allowed to kill one person in the game. Any member of The Enemy can PM me a name of a person you would like to kill. Win Condition
You win when the mafia control 50% of the votes in play and nothing in the game can prevent that. Fake claim
You know that Dori is not in the game.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
Hotshot53Spoiler
Sauraman Sauraman the White
Welcome to The Hobbit Mafia, username. You are Sauraman the White, a Spy allied with The Enemy. Bio
An Istar who was originally sent by the west to oppose Sauron. He however desires the one ring for himself and now wants to ally with Sauron and then betray him. The White Council that he leads has no idea what his true intentions are. Abilities Vote: During the day, you may use your vote to aid in lynching a player. Spy: As a spy, you do not have access to nightly communication with the other members of The Enemy, member, member and member. Your faction knows there is a spy, but does not know who it is. You can not be killed by a mafia kill, nor can you be recruited. If you are the only mafia member remaining you will not be able to perform the factional kill. Win Condition
You win when the mafia control 50% of the votes in play and nothing in the game can prevent that. Fake claim
You know that Elrond is not in the game.
The game thread is here.
Please confirm in thread that you have read and understood your role pm and read and understand the rules. Posting confirm or some variation in the thread is acceptable.
Thoughts:
So the setup I think worked well...The fizzle out of activity is/was quite annoying. Simply not enough of truly active players for this kind of game with little investigative/power roles. Combine with the kill order of certain players who push conversation and action didnt help.
As annoying as thor was/is he actually picked up roles and tells pretty well. For a first timer it wasnt so bad. Just needs to work on staying not banned.
Thanks for the game Lv. I think the issue is not the roles but the player base (or lack thereof). I don't think adding more investigative roles would add more to the activity of players. When there are few investigative roles, you can mostly go with what is said, so I would expect this does not inhibit discussion. It's likely there's just not enough players for big games (even if big games are fun, I'd rather have half the people than half of the town lurking).
btw, I don't think you should have given the opportunity to use the gifts the night they were given. I feel like they should have been processed at the end of the night like the rest since there was a jailor and someone with a roleblocking item (not that it had any impact, but still).
I don't get why mitch shot KJ D4 though. Surely he can understand it's better to shoot confirmed than unconfirmed town.
That puts me at a 100% win rate for all the games I've started so far (damn you, chess mafia )
ZaBeast wrote:I don't get why mitch shot KJ D4 though. Surely he can understand it's better to shoot confirmed than unconfirmed town.
I was literally the only person who was pushing him, I'd been suspicious of him for days and asking questions that he couldn't answer. I'd hoped people would pick up on my questions that he refused to answer but unfortunately no one did until it was far too late.
)
