Chess Mafia [Game Ended - 3rd party wins]

[Ragian]

No, he hasn't. You only know that he didn't die that one time. That does not mean that he's unlynchable, nor that he's the king, nor that I'm scum.

Would you believe me if we lynched Mandy who will flip town?

[mandalorian2298]

No, he hasn't. You only know that he didn't die that one time. That does not mean that he's unlynchable, nor that he's the king, nor that I'm scum.

Would you believe me if we lynched Mandy who will flip town?

No!

Because it's easy to know that I'm Town just by looking deeply in my wide, innocent eyes.

[Thorthoth]

No, he hasn't. You only know that he didn't die that one time. That does not mean that he's unlynchable, nor that he's the king, nor that I'm scum.

Would you believe me if we lynched Mandy who will flip town?

No!

Because it's easy to know that I'm Town just by looking deeply in my wide, innocent eyes.

Seriously, why isn't mandy even being mentioned as possible scum? It must be some bogus meta-explanation unknown to me.

[dakky21]

Seriously, why isn't mandy even being mentioned as possible scum? It must be some bogus meta-explanation unknown to me.

Did you skim the part where Ragian claims to be a cop and that he investigated Mandy last night and got a "town" result?

[Thorthoth]

Seriously, why isn't mandy even being mentioned as possible scum? It must be some bogus meta-explanation unknown to me.

Did you skim the part where Ragian claims to be a cop and that he investigated Mandy last night and got a "town" result?

Yes, I did forget about that.... but if Mandy is town why is he going after me? Something doesn't add up.

[ZaBeast]

Still got to go with Pika ,he has told the truth so far.

@ Rags ,I want to get caught up trying to figure who is good and evil like the exchange between you and Pika, Just because Pika couldn't be hung does not mean your are scum and Dakky seems to be scum a lot, so for now I like Mandy's reasons for Thorth, not saying my mind can't be changed

That's not what you were saying at the beginning of the day

Don't have much to add, I find mitch a much more viable lynch option, mandy seems singling out on thor for no good reason. I don't really like his (thor) playstyle, the way he's asking questions, but not offering much in terms of hunting, but he's done the same on all the games he played so far. His playstyle is going to get old real quick though. I think we'd benefit from a deadline.

[BuJaber]

Up to now where it might be dwindling down a bit, there was plenty of activity and discussion and so I felt there was no need for a deadline.

If at least 3 other people express interest in a deadline I will set one.

As a reminder: per rule 12 if a deadline is reached before anyone hammers the day will end with no lynch.

[Ragian]

Impose a deadline. This is going nowhere.

[Thorthoth]

Deadline please... though hopefully not my dead line.

[Pikanchion]

If we lynch Thorthoth we don't need a deadline...

[Skoffin]

it's fun to stay at the Y M C A

[Pikanchion]

Or you could always test the "Pikanchion's unkillable-ness is only one-shot" theory :3

[madmitch]

Still got to go with Pika ,he has told the truth so far.

@ Rags ,I want to get caught up trying to figure who is good and evil like the exchange between you and Pika, Just because Pika couldn't be hung does not mean your are scum and Dakky seems to be scum a lot, so for now I like Mandy's reasons for Thorth, not saying my mind can't be changed[/quote
@ Zabeast meant to say Rags, I didn't want to get caught up .....and that bit about Dakky was from past games, seems like every one always compare past games and I figure why don't I ?

[ZaBeast]

That's not the point though. It's this part I'm talking about

Just because Pika couldn't be hung does not mean your are scum

You're saying right here the fact he's unlynchable (or at least at least 1-shot unlynchable) doesn't mean he's right on Ragian. And now you go on to say he's been right so far, while we don't know Ragian's role for sure. And if you were convinced he's been right so far, you should still be on a Rag lynch.
Also, you don't see how saying someone is more likely to be scum since he's been scum in a lot other games isn't flawed? Feel free to use meta, but use it right.

[madmitch]

this game is a mind f*ck to me , I thought Rags was scum when Pika said he was and especially after Pika survived the lynch , why scum didn't try to take him out at night is beyond me??? but when Rags said he was cop now that is another ball game, if he is telling the truth than Mandy is town if not then Mandy is scum, and for the meta ,you are right I don't know how to use it properly so it's best if I don't do it anymore

[mandalorian2298]

this game is a mind f*ck to me knew who I , I thought Rags was scum when Pika said he was and especially after Pika survived the lynch , why scum didn't try to take him out at night is beyond me??? but when Rags said he was cop now that is another ball game, if he is telling the truth than Mandy is town if not then Mandy is scum, and for the meta ,you are right I don't know how to use it properly so it's best if I don't do it anymore

Whoa there, skippy! I Ragian is not Cop but scum he could still deduce that I'm Town by the virtue of me not being in his Mafia.

@Ragian, Pika, Zabeast&dakky Since we seem to be at an impasse on Both Thorth and Mitch, and sincel as one of them is probably Town, as well as Mute Skoffin, it appears that one among the five of us is scum.

To while away the time constructively, let's all FOS the person that we suspect the most out of us five.

I thought I knew who I want to FOS but then I started thinking so I now need to think some more.

[Ragian]

Easy. Pika. I know for a fact that he's lying.

[Pikanchion]

I could say the same about you.

[Skoffin]

Dakky Piku

[Ragian]

I could say the same about you.

You could, but your nose would grow even bigger if you did.

[Pikanchion]

Then why aren't you voting for me, eh?

[Ragian]

You are my second choice, but D1 lynch didn't go quite as well as planned. Also, as I've stated, I have a hard time understanding why you would flat out lie. Had I been lynched, everyone would have seen that you were full of it. Therefore, I'm sticking with the other one I'm confident is anti-town.

[Pikanchion]

Well we could just all vote Skoffin :3

It would be funny!

[Skoffin]

I approve.

[Ragian]

Funny for me is winning the game for town, not offing skoffin (rimshot) for the hell of it.