madmitch wrote:@Nag ,I targeted Tim ,why because as a wp the only win condition I have is to survive to the end and team rocket doesn't , so for me to survive I have to gain more exp. and I will attack to survive hopefully I can hit a TR scum at night.
If you hoped to get a member of Team Rocket, why would you purposely go after a wild Pokemon?
strike wolf wrote:The second way Nag suggested (no resists or weakness) is more or less what I figured.
Ditto.
nagerous wrote:EBWOP
nagerous wrote:Skittles! wrote:I'm just going to go ahead and vote Mitch. While I know the majority of you have moved on from this, I'm going to try and bring it back into the forefront.
Remembering the first day and looking over the past three pages of Day 1, Skoffin was very hesitant to vote either Fircoal or Mitch. With her and Fircoal both coming out scum, I think this is a tell.
Mitch has also been very willing to skim, misread, throw out misinformation, and generally accuse anyone who goes after him as scum. I don't know his play style but a number of you have already stated that it is a bit off from his normal games. His very obvious cockiness is also a sign of someone who is very confident in their gameplay, even though everyone else can just say that he has done literally nothing (during the talkative day stages at least) to contribute to the game.
I think it's just a safe bet to throw him under the bus right now, and I plead that all wild Pokemon to defend themselves during the night to limit the casualties just incase Mitch does turn up to be a wild Pokemon. I still don't think it will be much of a loss.
The discussion the past few pages hasn't really led to any one for town/WP to go after, because either mafia are using the holiday period to scummarine, or they are really good players.
I'm also going to FOS Dakky, Talapus, legionnaire, newguy. I think Dakky and Talapus are working together in some capacity, and I think the other two are playing pretty safe in a game where it's obvious that no one is safe with how many night abilities there are.
FP'd by the mod and ragian.
True skoffin didn't vote mitch - but she didn't seem hesitant to me, here she said mitch was her second choice at the time. Why she didn't vote mitch to try and save fircoal is the only questionable element. Also, Fircoal the other scum buddy pushed a mitch lynch which is why I don't think he is the best target, unless fircoal was simply acting selfishly and in spite of mitch - who voted him...
Skoffin wrote:Still not getting the case on Masket, and the fact that so many people are willing to go for such a flimsy case tells me there are sketchy people on that wagon already. At worst Masket 'slipped' that he is a trainer; I don't think he is some idiot scum that purposely slipped that he is a trainer in hopes that people would be convinced he was a townie that dropped his role. I do, however, think he is a dumb townie that didn't realise his wording revealed what role he might have. Anyone on this lynch is either scum hoping to coast through the day before they take too much notice, or they have some win condition that involves taking out trainers.
Of those voting for Masket right now, the most suspicious to me are Tal and Mitch. I've already stated why on Mitch, and he is still posting many words that say little to nothing. Tal gets some suspicion for his post on Masket that I responded to before. Tal is a good player, and his argument on masket was pretty weak and read a lot into Masket that Masket didn't say. I don't know how he managed to twist what Masket said so far, and since mitch has enough pressure for the moment unvote vote Talapus
I'll throw legion and hotshot on the list for now too, for previously stated reasons.
Ragian wrote:@skoffin, totally knew you are a girl. You were in the HP mafia, right?
I don't know, I might have been? I don't remember all the games I was in.
You make up some good points but I think on the last or second last page of Day 1 (on phone so difficult to check) she did still say she didn't find either person particularly scummy. Mitch was an easy vote and would have helped Team Rocket out to take out a WP, but instead she let Fircoal get lynched. In a numbers game this wasn't very smart IMO.
Also, my ideas of Hotshot are: I think he's a trainer trying to come across as friendly to wild Pokemon, while we have mainly guessed that trainers are their own cult faction. However, I also have an idea that Misty and brock could be aligned to Team Ash, despite being gym leaders themselves. Those three are a team in the anime and it makes more sense for me to put them together, making trainers a much larger cult faction than originally thought. Gary is just Ash's rival, but Misty and Brock didn't have a problem with him. Maybe Gary and Ash were fighting not over wild Pokemon (Gotta catch em all etc) but also over Misty and Brock's alignment.
Another thing I am finding interesting is that TWO's alignment colour is not the same as MM's. While the Pokemon colours are signifying their type, I would've thought that TWO would have the same light blue colour as MM to say their alignment. It would not surprise me if a goal of Team Rocket was to catch Pikachu, as that was basically their goal every episode. I don't know how that would factor into their win condition anymore though.
...I'll try harder next time Kwan.
