[FINISHED] Board Game Mafia: Endgame - Piece of Peace

[rizky_biznezz]

Ok so rage blocked the kill that fits too..

I still don't see why we wouldn't go for scum first get rid of one guaranteed threat.. They were my thoughts before i was a suspect and im sticking with it.. We have investigative roles that could clear me during the night.. Are we sure there is nothing else that could be causing the deaths?

[Ragian]

What are you suggesting in relation to the kills, then?

[madmitch]

LET'S get rid of the scum first, then at night I will ask RISKY if he is the SK or ask STRIKE if he is town aligned ? give me your choice and protect me, oh shit I forgot about AOG, is he really a docter? Let me know what you want town.

[Ragian]

I don't see any reason why AoG would lie, but we need his actions before we judge him.

@mitch, be careful with stating your night actions here. Scum might have powers to meddle.

[madmitch]

@ Ragian thanks , but got this far in this game by being honest, figure we have 1 mafia, 1 sk and a possible cult left and all the good guys know who, if I get killed you guys know who to go after.

[Ragian]

I'm all for honesty, man. Don't confuse honesty with transparency, though. If scum and SK know our moves, they'll plan theirs accordingly. Let's keep them in the dark. I'm confident that you will choose wisely for town come the night.

[Army of GOD]

I think a mass claim would help us right now. Town outnumber SK + mafia by a large margin I would think, considering we've only killed cult and scum thus far

[Metsfanmax]

Ok so rage blocked the kill that fits too..

Ok, but we also have a doctor. Doctors happen to be able to stop kills too. So Ragian's argument that him blocking me proves I'm scum is not strong.

[Army of GOD]

Ok so rage blocked the kill that fits too..

Ok, but we also have a doctor. Doctors happen to be able to stop kills too. So Ragian's argument that him blocking me proves I'm scum is not strong.

I forgot to send in a night action last night...


told you you'd be underwhelmed

[Metsfanmax]

Also, we don't actually know that there are any scum left. I have been working on the assumption that there is one more because numerically it isn't crazy and because it always helps to be conservative. But it makes so much more sense to kill known cult or find the SK, even if you think there's a good chance I am mafia.

[Army of GOD]

now, I don't think that necessarily proves anything. I offered the info that I was possibly blocked N2, so maybe Ragian took it and ran, pretending like he's a role blocker (which isn't necessarily a town role anyway)

but most of our leads are lukewarm at best, so I think this will be a slight shot in the dark unless more information comes out

anyway, vote Metsfan

[Ragian]

You definitely need to entertain the idea that I cooked that up based on your information, but saying that I blocked both you and BuJ makes either me or rizky the SK. I would've made room for others to be considered the SK if I were indeed him.

[Metsfanmax]

I guess strike isn't happening, so I'll take my next best option and unvote, vote rizky

[rizky_biznezz]

Grr I just lost my post.. I don't have time to redo it I gotta go but i will add more later sorry

Fpd by mets.. Correction I will add more if I'm still alive lol

[BuJaber]

Grr I just lost my post.. I don't have time to redo it I gotta go but i will add more later sorry

Fpd by mets.. Correction I will add more if I'm still alive lol

Lol so we have to hold off now until you can post?

[BuJaber]

It would be so cool at this point if mitch was the last scum and LSU the SK.. total 180 degree turn of events.

[madmitch]

wouldn't be cool for me

[rizky_biznezz]

Lol buj no u don't have to wait for my post.. Although I'm at work so this isn't it..

So just quickly...
I am wondering why ppl think I would be trying to get rid of mafia if I was the SK.. Aren't mafia helping me by killing ppl? Plus if mets is the last scum and it ends the game doesn't that make me lose? Also I think I would have been trying to set someone else up as the killer if it was me. .

[strike wolf]

Depending on the way the game was going may effect how the SK plays. In a lot of ways a prolonged game favors the SK if he can keep mafia from targeting him. However an SK can't afford to vary too much from town. Too much variance could draw attention. Town has been pretty spot on to this point with lynching scum. Therefore you following them have been reasonably spot on and like a follower, you were on the back half of both day1 and day 2 lynches. You were absentee day 3. So yeah. I can see. The difference would be in night kills. An SK in a game where town was winning would be less likely to go for obvious mafia targets as night kills. Which the SK has. The SK has gone for two likely town and one person with zero attention put on him.

I would also expect the SK to say something like this:

I haven't played with a cult before so I don't know if what strike said is likely or not.. But the game hasn't ended so we still are searching for cult and they do not go to 3p or we still have mafia who were blocked or their target saved..

Can mafia choose to not take a kill?

Where you ignore the SK possibility (and seem pretty confident that it was not mafia who made the kill). Also posts expressing that we should go for mafia first over SK which you have.

Combined with the "would I do this as SK?" WIFOM of your last post and the n1 indictment of you I am about 150% confident that you are the sk.

[rizky_biznezz]

now I know we have a roleblocker leaving mafia doesn't seem like a big problem.. My concern before was we mislynch today then lose 2 more during the night.. The way I was looking at it I presumed we kill hopefully the last mafia and we win so I thought the ppl trying to avoid the mets lynch were more suspicious

[rizky_biznezz]

I'm not ignoring the SK obviously something is killing I just wanted to see if there were alternative scenarios before we start randomly lynching

[/]

Vote Count

Metsfanmax: (4 votes) LSU Tiger Josh, madmitch, rizky_biznezz, Army of God
rizky_biznezz: (3 votes) strike wolf, BuJaber, Metsfanmax

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch!
Deadline Saturday the 7th

[BuJaber]

Ragian I don't like the Mets bandwagon, something about how it played out bugs me, and I've been looking at Mets carefully, I just don't buy that he's scum. It's down to you right now, and it's ultimately your choice. I'm just sharing my opinion that I think it would be a mistake.

[Ragian]

vote Mets

Thanks for your input. While there's obviously a small possibility that Mets isn't scum, I feel that he is. And not knowing what the last scum's extra ability is (if there is indeed a final scumster), I feel that it's more important to get rid of him than the sk at this stage.

[rizky_biznezz]

I get the feeling everyone is checking me out tonight lol.. I don't think u should all use ur checks on me but seeing as I need at least 2 ppl and u can't really discuss it I will be sitting in my game box minding my own business awaiting all of ur arrivals lol..