[FINISHED] Board Game Mafia: Endgame - Piece of Peace

[Metsfanmax]

So, by that logic, you should be voting for Strike, yes?

By that logic, I think Strike is a good lynch candidate. If I had to choose between Strike and a mafia, I'd choose the mafia, so there's no reason for me to rush into a vote yet.

vote mets

What is your reasoning for voting me?

[strike wolf]

Sorry, I've been exhausted. Long story short. I was curious about Mets and Mitch's claims so I investigated Mets and it came back mafia.

[madmitch]

good now everyone knows the truth,

[Ragian]

So, by that logic, you should be voting for Strike, yes?

By that logic, I think Strike is a good lynch candidate. If I had to choose between Strike and a mafia, I'd choose the mafia, so there's no reason for me to rush into a vote yet.

vote mets

What is your reasoning for voting me?

Mitch has you as scum. And we only had one kill last night.

@Strike, are you voting?

[strike wolf]

This is where as survivor my priorities are different than town's. Mets as mafia would be revealed, he now has no real reason to kill me, it would be a waste of effort. However, if Rizky is SK, he still has reason to kill me to prevent me from revealing him. So lynching mafia vs SK to town is about the same trade off, one scum. However I would much rather lynch the potential SK.

[Ragian]

So, the kill last night. Was that the SK or was it mafia?

N1 we have two deaths:

The night was an active one.

A loose button didn't belong on the game board; it might have some day when the situation was more desperate, but right now no one knew where it would belong, which side it would choose. They never would. When it was turned around, a clang of plastic on plastic could be heard as the button fell to a heavy blow to the eye.

dakky21 Loose Button (unaligned backup) has been killed!

As the candlestick rolled from the scene, a voice could be heard calling out form the observatory. "Red looks good on you, da? Not the first time you've worn it, not the last." "I didn't kill Boddy, I don't know why everyone always thinks I do things I don't... It was the pipe, I just do what needs to be done." "Still, I could use someone like you..."

Elsewhere

A rolling click could be heard as fate turned. "Six" Random odds against random odds. "Urgh Hit... We're taking on water!" came a reply as the hull was breached with a plastic clank. "Return fire! Set coordinate for volley at B, 7." The canons fire blindly, and the round found the most interesting scene.

Back at the mansion

"Fine, you've convinced me; forget town, my light is shining red from now on! We're unstoppable; you take the world, and I kill the stragglers." Just as the candlestick made its pledge, the volley smacked into body mansion, snuffing it for good.

WingCmdr Ginkapo, Candlestick (Cult Vigilante / action miller) has been killed!

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch. You have until Sunday April 17th
Day Two Start!

There's the vig (I presume) killing dakky and there's that volley thing. That's battleships, right?

N2 we had two deaths:

That night a small dark disk flew through the night, almost invisible in the cool darkness. Its target was sharper than most, pointedly so. A wooden pencil sketched out the results of the night on a score card, when suddenly jet black flew across the striking white sheet. The pencil rolled at the last moment, poking back, but the disk flipped! Beneath the black was a blinding white. The two struck out at each-other, leaving the pencil filed down to shavings.

mandalorian2298 Pencil from Yahtzee (Town Watcher) has been killed!

The disk cursed, "Damn, no one's ever marked my light side before... It doesn't matter though, I always flip just right when it matters. No one can corner me without a board!" Just then, a sound from the skies "E, 5," it was over...

Whatsausage Reversi piece (Mafia Godfather) has been killed!

Elsewhere, another victim was conquered by a risky move; another space occupied by the red armies.

Day Three Begins! With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch. Deadline Wed 27

We have battleships again here with the E5, yes?

Ready, Aim, Fire!
Another volley was launched into the air that night, this time hitting one of the seven spaces occupied by a rather loquacious and sesquipedalian individual, right between the Q 10 and the D 2. This voluminous Pinoideae framework served as the receptacle for minuscule alphabetic slates. As such, it often dragooned individuals in speech that fell into a desideratum, then passed adjudication and punitive effects upon them upon unsuccess. Despite these considerable endowments, the wooden rack fell into oblivion with a thundering fissure.

HotShot53 Scrabble Rack, Town PR JOAT has been killed!

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch!

Day Four Start!

Here again we have what I think is battleships (if I'm wrong in what it is, please correct me).

Do we think this firing with the letters is mafia or SK? I'd like to clear that up.

[Ragian]

Last night it was only the SK doing the killing. When looking for an SK, we are looking for someone who has tried not to antagonise anyone and not draw attention to himself (from neither town (why is this guy not voting for scum?) nor from scum (why is this guy so good at nailing us?)). Yes?

Anyone fit that category?

[rizky_biznezz]

This is where as survivor my priorities are different than town's. Mets as mafia would be revealed, he now has no real reason to kill me, it would be a waste of effort. However, if Rizky is SK, he still has reason to kill me to prevent me from revealing him. So lynching mafia vs SK to town is about the same trade off, one scum. However I would much rather lynch the potential SK.

If u are cop then wouldn't mafia still want to get rid of u if we dont kill them first.. Unless u arent planning on using ur abilities to help us anymore... wouldn't we be better going for mafia? Whatever is going on with the other kill it has been mostly good for us.. Doesn't explain why only one kill though

[rizky_biznezz]

Makes a lot of sense ragian..

LSU did u see anything last night?

[Ragian]

Now, I'm 99% sure that Mets is scum, but I actually agree that we should find the SK first. Given that I will unvote in order for non-dead people to pitch in. We sure need LSU.

It weirds me out that Strike would want to look for the last SK and then investigate mets rather than someone who isn't almost-confirmed scum.

[Ragian]

I trust LSU and mitch with like... 95%

I'm not at all doubting the fact that town will win, but it would be nice to not have to guess too much towards the end.

[rizky_biznezz]

maybe im looking at it the wrong way then... i was thinking if we lynch scum then possibly still one night kill... if we try for the possible SK and get it wrong then we still may have 2 kills during the night and we have lynched an innocent..

google said sk's goal is to be the last player alive so sk is separate from mafia and we have to kill both to win?

[Ragian]

Hey, I'm all for killing the last scum first, mate. I'm just playing along with strike's thoughts.

[madmitch]

I am ready to vote for Mets again unless you guys think we should try to find the SK ? But who is it ? Who is left and the best choice ? strike is cop , town , I trust Ragian and LSU , and we know Mets is scum so who is left? Rizky, BuJaber and AOG ,who do you guys like for the SK ?

[Metsfanmax]

Sorry, I've been exhausted. Long story short. I was curious about Mets and Mitch's claims so I investigated Mets and it came back mafia.

Looks like you got tripped up on the Wishbone too, same as Mitch. I am town.

[madmitch]

How many wishbones does that chicken have?

[Ragian]

I think we should defo wait till we hear what LSU has to say.

[Ragian]

@mets, do you agree that mafia didn't kill last night or were unsuccessful in killing at least?

[Metsfanmax]

@mets, do you agree that mafia didn't kill last night or were unsuccessful in killing at least?

Yes, assuming there are any mafia left. The day scenes seem to indicate that the battleship guy is the one who killed Whatsausage, meaning he's not mafia, and the battleship guy is the one who killed Hotshot. It strongly suggests third-party SK.

[BuJaber]

This is one scenario I didn't think about.

We're almost done with this game. There's no reason to trust anyone. Everyone is a suspect. Pick one, vote, we'll move on. If you want my thoughts, Ragian isn't SK, but he could still be mafia in my eyes. AoG is a possible SK.

Something in me doesn't trust LSU. Even though he practically confirmed his role with Mandy.. something about his plays throughout bothers me.

[Ragian]

This is one scenario I didn't think about.

We're almost done with this game. There's no reason to trust anyone. Everyone is a suspect. Pick one, vote, we'll move on. If you want my thoughts, Ragian isn't SK, but he could still be mafia in my eyes. AoG is a possible SK.

Something in me doesn't trust LSU. Even though he practically confirmed his role with Mandy.. something about his plays throughout bothers me.

Why are you ignoring mitch's and strike's words that mets is scum?

[BuJaber]

This is one scenario I didn't think about.

We're almost done with this game. There's no reason to trust anyone. Everyone is a suspect. Pick one, vote, we'll move on. If you want my thoughts, Ragian isn't SK, but he could still be mafia in my eyes. AoG is a possible SK.

Something in me doesn't trust LSU. Even though he practically confirmed his role with Mandy.. something about his plays throughout bothers me.

Why are you ignoring mitch's and strike's words that mets is scum?

I'm ignoring anything strike says because even if he's telling the truth there's no reason to believe him. We have enough confirmed town to figure out what we need on our own.
Is that a misguided belief? I value your opinion.

So basically we have mitch versus mets. Mitch has no reason to lie but mets could be telling the truth about the wishbone thing.

At least 3 of you think we should go for SK first. We know Mets isn't SK, so I didn't feel the need to address his scuminess.

Out of curiosity is there a doctor in this game? Seems weird not to have one with so many killer roles. Maybe that's why we only had 1 kill Night 3. We'll find out at the end of the game anyway

[Ragian]

I'm fairly certain that the reason for no nightkill must be found elsewhere.

Also, I'm not saying that we must find the SK first at all. I'm just saying that we might as well look for him and if no solid is learned, then we off mets. Here's my list of possible SKs:
- AoG (fairly unattached and in the background)
- BuJ (no reasons other than it could be him as anyone else at this point)
- Rizky (claimed BP prematurely to gain town cred)
- Strike (I honestly don't know what would happen if cult recruited an SK - would he keep on kiling? Would recruiter die like if he recruits scum?)

Solid town:
- madmitch
- LSU
- Ragian ('cause mitch says so)

Anyway, check out mets's voting history:
D1

Final Vote Count

the white rose: (1 vote) TimWoodbury

dakky21: (2 votes) the white rose, Whatsausage

mandalorian2298: (1 vote) LSU Tiger Josh

TimWoodbury: (9 votes) HotShot53, mandalorian2298, WingCmdr Ginkapo , madmitch, rizky_biznezz, Ragian, BuJaber, dakky21, strike wolf

LSU Tiger Josh: (1 vote) Iron Butterfly

BuJaber: (1 vote) Ragian

WingCmdr Ginkapo: (1 vote) Army of GOD,

HotShot53: (1 vote) Metsfanmax

Tim is lynched!

After a single round, the players did a lap and passed go; their reward, a certain piece of paper. One so alluring it threatened to tear the town apart. To avoid this, the town decided to put the money itself in jail; it would go quietly though, struggling until it was torn to shreds. Never again would the capitalism threaten to buy out every space, never again would people be sent to work at the railroads with nothing more than a tiny plastic house and still be forced to pay luxury taxes.

TimWoodbury, Green Monopoly Money (Mafia Roleblocker) has been lynched!

You have until Sunday to send in your actions!

D2

Final Vote Count

the white rose: (8 votes) Army of GOD, LSU Tiger Josh, Ragian, HotShot53, madmitch, rizky_biznezz, mandalorian2298, strike wolf,

HotShot53: (2 votes) Iron Butterfly, Metsfanmax

BuJaber: (1 vote) the white rose

No lynch: (1 vote) BuJaber

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

D3

Final Vote Count

Metsfanmax: (1 vote) Ragian
Iron Butterfly: (6 votes) HotShot53, Army of GOD, BuJaber, LSU Tiger Josh, Metsfanmax, madmitch
HotShot53: (1 vote) Iron Butterfly

Nevermind mitch looking at mets with a smoking gun if you're caught up on a wishbone thing. Look at him not voting for the two scumsters. If that's not a tell-tale sign, I don't know what it.

[Ragian]

Meant to hightlight mets's name in all three vote counts, and also there's a grammar boobie towards then end. Bear with me, it's very early

@mod, could you prod LSU?

[Metsfanmax]

Nevermind mitch looking at mets with a smoking gun if you're caught up on a wishbone thing. Look at him not voting for the two scumsters. If that's not a tell-tale sign, I don't know what it.

Yeah, maybe if this were your first game with me and also this was my first time playing mafia, it would be a "tell-tale sign." If you think for even a second, it's really not that informative. It was obvious towards the end of D1 that Tim was going down; if I was scum, I'd have a pretty good incentive to hop onto the bandwagon to get town cred. (The same is true for twr; why wouldn't I want to get credit?) Surely you must know that I'm intelligent enough and experienced enough to have considered that angle if I were really scum. Also, anyone who's played even one game with me knows that I routinely poo-poo cases in the early game, because they're usually crap.