[SPECIAL] Surprise Mafia - Over - Mafia Wins - MVP Aladdin

by **Metsfanmax** on Sun Apr 03, 2016 8:35 pm

Although, it's perfectly possible that IB is a mafia rolecop and had an investigation on N0 and got lucky. So maybe that is the way to go. I'm just not sure, and none of the other cases are more appetizing.

by **benga** on Sun Apr 03, 2016 11:49 pm

need to read thru a bit before posting

by **rizky_biznezz** on Sun Apr 03, 2016 11:56 pm

I have no idea I did find the hot shot thing strange but I'm not sure why pancake would try and keep IB in the spotlight as suspicious if they were on the same team.. Like I said before could have just been so there was some negative association between the 2 if one got lynched but it could have easily got IB lynched if we all jumped onboard..

As for the others could be any of them catchers is quiet, mets has claimed a power role that is pretty easy to fake, player has stepped up since being accused, Mitch could be playing us all..
Gotta go back to work will check back later

by **WingCmdr Ginkapo** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 2:37 am

WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:Vote Count

Mets (3) - /, IB, Mitch
IB (2) - Catchers, Players
Player (2) - WhiteRose, Rizky

Deadline - 05/04/16 - 13:00 CC time, 6 to lynch

Edited. Cheers Aladdin

by **AladdinSane** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 4:27 am

WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:
WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:Vote Count

Mets (3) - /, IB, MetsMitch
IB (2) - Catchers, Players
Player (2) - WhiteRose, Rizky

Deadline - 05/04/16 - 13:00 CC time, 6 to lynch

by **PLAYER57832** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 6:51 am

Can someone remind me where I can find the official CC time, please?

by **PLAYER57832** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 6:54 am

never mind, I found it :oops:

by **Metsfanmax** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 7:08 am

rizky_biznezz wrote:I have no idea I did find the hot shot thing strange but I'm not sure why pancake would try and keep IB in the spotlight as suspicious if they were on the same team.. Like I said before could have just been so there was some negative association between the 2 if one got lynched but it could have easily got IB lynched if we all jumped onboard..

There was virtually zero risk of IB actually getting lynched at the time, so I think it would have been a smart play on pcm's part -- he is experienced to know that throwing some shade on fellow mafia is a good long run strategy.

Day's almost over, so I don't have much of a choice but to vote IB and hope that we can at least coalesce around this.

by **rizky_biznezz** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 8:18 am

Its possible but it could have easily backfired everyone was pretty suspicious of IB and his info he could have easily been next if we didn't get the sausage info.. He also pushed suspicion on rish for his jailing choices and helped get his lynch..

Catchers, player and / weren't on the lynch so I'm curious about them at the moment (yes I am aware that I wasn't either for the record)

by **the white rose** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 9:36 am

oh dear, with just a day to go this is looking more and more like a nolynch.

whatever happenned to the idea of following my lead?

by **AladdinSane** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 9:43 am

PLAYER57832 wrote::oops: never mind, I found it

LOL. Wen I saw you asking fer wear is teh CC time, I thort "Oh no you dident! Now yer just funking wit us" and I was orl set to vote fer you. Den I carmed down and thort tings over, and I'm gonna vote you enyway.

Basically I can't wait eny longer for Benga's vote. I tink Mets is a linch fer tomorow if he dozent get NKed tonite, and I don't like teh looks of IB's wagen - CM, you, and now Mets. Nope, I'm going wit teh twusted playas, TWR and RB.

VOTE PLAYER

I prob won't get a chanse to chek in tomorow until after teh dedline, so dis is prob it fer me.

by **AladdinSane** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 9:48 am

Insidently, I'm tinking we shood ask our hiden Doc, if their is wun, to NOT pertect Mets tonite. Dat way, if Mets dozent get NKed tonite, we know it wozent becorse he was pertected. As teh last claimed invesitmagative roll, known not to be pertected, Mets shood present an iresistabul target to Mafia if he is Town. And if he IS Town, beter fer him to be NKed then fer us to waste a linch on him. On teh other hand, if he is Mafia, he'll servive teh nite and we linch him tomorow.

by **PLAYER57832** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 9:51 am

rizky_biznezz wrote:Its possible but it could have easily backfired everyone was pretty suspicious of IB and his info he could have easily been next if we didn't get the sausage info.. He also pushed suspicion on rish for his jailing choices and helped get his lynch..

Catchers, player and / weren't on the lynch so I'm curious about them at the moment (yes I am aware that I wasn't either for the record)

That would have been my very first mafia vote EVER. I cannot remember what I voted then or why. I imagine I would have been reluctant to railroad anyone.

by **AladdinSane** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 9:52 am

the white rose wrote:oh dear, with just a day to go this is looking more and more like a nolynch.

whatever happenned to the idea of following my lead?

Yeh, I tink it is about time fer dat to hapen. Well, my vote is their.

by **PLAYER57832** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 9:53 am

the white rose wrote:oh dear, with just a day to go this is looking more and more like a nolynch.

whatever happenned to the idea of following my lead?

Well, for my part, you targeted me. That pretty much took my willingness out... and left me questioning my trust as well.

by **PLAYER57832** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 9:58 am

AladdinSane wrote:Insidently, I'm tinking we shood ask our hiden Doc, if their is wun, to NOT pertect Mets tonite. Dat way, if Mets dozent get NKed tonite, we know it wozent becorse he was pertected. As teh last claimed invesitmagative roll, known not to be pertected, Mets shood present an iresistabul target to Mafia if he is Town. And if he IS Town, beter fer him to be NKed then fer us to waste a linch on him. On teh other hand, if he is Mafia, he'll servive teh nite and we linch him tomorow.

This sounds like you are putting mets under the bus.

Now, I ask why would that not make you scummy? I have been leaning toward saying you are town, but wanting to lynch me... and still dismissing IB, even though you yourself came up with some pretty good reasoning for IB to be scum, and now basically saying "mets has to die so we can prove he is not scum?" Let's just say we go with the mets lynch, who is next, then?

by **PLAYER57832** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 10:00 am

AladdinSane wrote:
PLAYER57832 wrote::oops: never mind, I found it

LOL. Wen I saw you asking fer wear is teh CC time, I thort "Oh no you dident! Now yer just funking wit us" and I was orl set to vote fer you. Den I carmed down and thort tings over, and I'm gonna vote you enyway.

I should know better than to post before I have had my coffee in the morning. If you check the time, it was before 8AM... I work late nights, so get up to get my kids off, go back to take a nap and THEN have my coffee, with few exceptions.

by **AladdinSane** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 10:06 am

PLAYER57832 wrote:This sounds like you are putting mets under the bus.

Now, I ask why would that not make you scummy? I have been leaning toward saying you are town, but wanting to lynch me... and still dismissing IB, even though you yourself came up with some pretty good reasoning for IB to be scum, and now basically saying "mets has to die so we can prove he is not scum?" Let's just say we go with the mets lynch, who is next, then?

Well, teh qwestjun dat has been raised about Mets is why Mafia dident NK him last nite, and NKed Deg insted? I ackshually argued dat Deg woz not a bad choise fer Mafia last nite, as he was part of a sizabul voting blok of twusted playas, and so it wozent too incriminating fer Mets to servive last nite.

But if Mets servives anuther nite without been NKed, it will def look suspishus. Mets is teh only claimed investimagative roll left, and as teh pool of playas shrinks, his chanses of fingering Mafia wit a gun increese. Mafia HAS to be geting wurried about dat if he is Town. Hense, if dey leeve him alive tonite, I tink their is a good chanse Mets will flip Mafia.

by **Metsfanmax** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 10:11 am

rizky_biznezz wrote:Its possible but it could have easily backfired everyone was pretty suspicious of IB and his info he could have easily been next if we didn't get the sausage info..

As I'm pretty sure I said then, town will never resist lynching a claimed scum/non-town catch on D1. IB is experienced enough to know that. I don't think it would have backfired.

He also pushed suspicion on rish for his jailing choices and helped get his lynch..

That's a good point. I forgot about that. unvote

the white rose wrote:oh dear, with just a day to go this is looking more and more like a nolynch.

whatever happenned to the idea of following my lead?

Fair enough. Can't afford a no-lynch. vote PLAYER

Aladdin wrote:Insidently, I'm tinking we shood ask our hiden Doc, if their is wun, to NOT pertect Mets tonite. Dat way, if Mets dozent get NKed tonite, we know it wozent becorse he was pertected. As teh last claimed invesitmagative roll, known not to be pertected, Mets shood present an iresistabul target to Mafia if he is Town. And if he IS Town, beter fer him to be NKed then fer us to waste a linch on him. On teh other hand, if he is Mafia, he'll servive teh nite and we linch him tomorow.

Obviously, as town, I would prefer to be protected. However, if you all are going to lynch me anyway, then what's the point? I see Aladdin's logic, even if I don't fully agree with it. Anyway, there's no point in trying to tell the doc what to do, because even worse than me not being protected is everyone knowing who the doc is going to protect, because then mafia know who not to shoot, and get a guaranteed kill.

by **AladdinSane** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 10:30 am

Metsfanmax wrote:Anyway, there's no point in trying to tell the doc what to do, because even worse than me not being protected is everyone knowing who the doc is going to protect, because then mafia know who not to shoot, and get a guaranteed kill.

Well, if you are Town, dey willl get a garanteed kill tonite. If yer Mafia, den - asuming 6 Town left out of 10 (and 6 out of 9 after today's linch, hopefuly), dey wood have to gess witch of those 6 was been pertecked. Obviusly not TWR, but dat still leeves odds of 1/5. Even if we linch Town today, odds wood still be 1 in 4.

I know it kind of sucks to be in yore shoos rite now if yer Town - it looks like if Mafia dont kill you, you'll look like Mafia and get linched - but I gess dat's teh way it goes sumtimes.

by **AladdinSane** on Mon Apr 04, 2016 10:33 am

If we don't ask teh Doc to do dis, we'll have a difficult choise to make if Met's servives teh nite - i.e. did he servive becorse he was Town and perteckted, or becorse he is Mafia?

I don't mind eether way, i.e. if we asked teh hyprtheticul hiden Doc not to perteckt Mets, or not. It wood be good if wun or moor of the twuested playas eether endorses teh idee or shoots it down