[OFFICIAL] C9 Mafia - GAME OVER - TOWN WINS!!

[Endgame422]

Where are you camping that you can check this forum every 20 minutes?lol
Or is it one of those wi-fi included pay to campgrounds?

[StorrZerg]

Where are you camping that you can check this forum every 20 minutes?lol
Or is it one of those wi-fi included pay to campgrounds?

3g, happen to belucky this weekend

[Endgame422]

Not that anyone is going to give me much credit right now as storr and his voting block are against me but my guess as to our mafia is IB/slander.
IB claims cop to cover his ass for the hammer with a believable call on storr being town.
Also explains why slander is voting against storr instead of IB,with my vote there and your plus 1 of WCG(who is also hitching his wagon to storr but i think its cuz he doesn't know what else to do,and reads storr as def town)
IB says he thinks slander is a good lynch candidate but will follow storrs vote no matter what which removes him from any suspicion because storr was cleared by IB earlier.
If we lynch slander and he flips mafia then IB can say "told you he was scum" and then try to pull out a last round win by getting a town lynch by saying "I copchecked so and so and they are scummy."
If we lynch a townie he can say"i just followed your lead storr."
IB talked all this about slander but i don't even think he's put a vote to him once.

[Iron Butterfly]

I don't even know what to say here.
IB and storr are both proven liars in this game.
And yet they are essentially the only people who are safe right now.
Why lie repeatedly about your role storr? You said yourself lying about doc only hurts town.
Why lie about the hammer IB? If you were confident he was scum(and your the cop) why not just start with that(on day two) instead of some BS about your wife?
Just to "spice up" a game with a bunch of newbies?

You had me fooled for a bit. It was interesting that the moment I called you as Town you removed your vote.

I explained why I did what I did already...twice even. I guess your not married either but there is a constant truth to that especially when she needs to use the computer and I am just checking the threads. As far as who is safe...Myself, Storr, Virus and Wing.

Storr withheld information but did not specifically lie but that's semantics I guess. The fact of the matter the ends justify the means. I know Storr is Town. He knows Virus is Town. Virus's opinion and observation means something. As the game has wore on more and more things fit into place. You and Slander are responding as mafia who know they have been found out. Now you throw Slander under the bus.

I will say this. Do not sell your selves short. You both played a Hell of a game and could have won it...seriously. MP made a very bad newbie mistake which could have cost us the game. Luck saved us as we also had a doc. Without the doc you very well would have won as you both played like pros.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Neither Slander or End have worked out that IB could cop claim as Mafia because no one counter claimed Mud. It seems like they dont actually believe this scenario.

Either IB has played Mafia amazingly or this game is finished now.

[Slander]

Neither Slander or End have worked out that IB could cop claim as Mafia because no one counter claimed Mud. It seems like they dont actually believe this scenario.

I think he constructed this entire bluff because he expected at least one town to come forward and counter claim off MP. He took no counter claim as a sign we were in a copless game.

[StorrZerg]

Haven't explained why pushing me over ib is the best option in your world

[Slander]

Not much of a different between one mob and the next.

[StorrZerg]

Not much of a different between one mob and the next.

Absolutely is since you can't be sure that ib is with someone else.

Lynching ib provides a safety net if you are wrong. It's simple Choice.

If you want to clam up and not progress the game then, that's fine, but you will never get the required 4 votes lynch myself.

[Slander]

Unvote StorrZerg

Vote Iron Butterfly

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

So why exactly are you not reading me as town? No mind meld between us?? Geez.

With your saving Virus there is now you three for sure in my book. I am not going to try and convince you of my towniness. If you don't have a town read on me by now you never will.

This is why I have Slander as top on my list. Slander is one group. End and Wing the other. The better lynch would be slander in my book.

I dont get it IB - Why is Slander top of your list?

[Iron Butterfly]

Mafia is like a puzzle.

Everyone Town is a piece with with their own unique perspective who's job is to find mafia.

My perspective is such that I know Storr to be Town through a cop check, which through extension makes Virus Town. From my perspective that leaves three yourself included.

As the game wears on things that passed me by, that I overlooked, scum tells if you will, now make sense and help the pieces fall into place.

Slander was at the top because today I was unsure about you and End, who was mafia out of you two. With Slander some of the little things added up and made sense, which would be hard to explain unless you have played many games of mafia. I tried to explain a little when I mentioned my first time I had to play the bad guy. I then tried to envision what it may have been like for Slander having his first game and getting mafia, how he has come across to me psychologically.

As this day has progressed End has made me equally comfortable with his lynch.

Now you explain to me why End should take precedence over Slander or why you think he is scummier.

[StorrZerg]

Unvote StorrZerg

Vote Iron Butterfly

Great now you gotta convince others that ib is the devil.

it doesn't matter post game if you had the right reads and lost.

[elonpuckhog]

VOTE COUNT:

Iron Butterfly (2) - endgame, slander (L-2)
endgame (1) - Wing

6 alive, 4 to lynch

Soft Deadline 4/23

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Virus - Who are you voting for? As one of the known town your thoughts are very much welcome.

[virus90]

endgame and or slander, i told they where my top scum candidates in a previous post. not voting till we agree on the way to go. and i still think a no lynch is an option at the end of the day.

[Iron Butterfly]

endgame and or slander, i told they where my top scum candidates in a previous post. not voting till we agree on the way to go. and i still think a no lynch is an option at the end of the day.

I do not believe a no lynch is needed. I am going to investigate Slander or Endgame.In my opinion it needlessly draws out the game. The only way it works to our benefit, and by that I mean we know with 100% certainty is that I live and you believe me. If that is the route wanted by the majority, and I am sure mafia will vote favorably to the idea, I will not oppose it as it is still a win.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

The investigation route wont work with a no lynch today. Mafia can kill Storr tonight and you tomorrow (Doc heroics aside). Leaving us with only 1 investigation result. That is the same as if we lynch someone today.

[StorrZerg]

still thinking about it. if virus is for it, we can go into the night with a no lynch.

Ib checking slander or endgame

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

I dont agree with no lynch today, dont believe it gains us any information. But if that what Virus wants to do then I will go along with it. Town should still win which is the important thing.

[Iron Butterfly]

*grin* Storr seems like the type of guy who hops out of the shower to take a pee.

[Slander]

The idea that we would choose not to lynch today is comical.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

The idea that we would choose not to lynch today is comical.

Can you explain why please?

[Slander]

The idea that we would choose not to lynch today is comical.

Can you explain why please?

Because we'll be in the same position tomorrow only potentially missing another townie.

[StorrZerg]

The idea that we would choose not to lynch today is comical.

Can you explain why please?

Because we'll be in the same position tomorrow only potentially missing another townie.

Still think I'm mafia after no other medic caim and a for sure save lol