[OFFICIAL] C9 Mafia - GAME OVER - TOWN WINS!!

[elonpuckhog]

If any player is not active early in the game, they can be replaced.

[Slander]

Very hasty setup I see ^_^
Confirmed, I did receive your PM.

I'm sorry about my late response, I'm working 12s this weekend.
I'll be more active when Monday rolls around.

This will be my first Mafia game. I decided it was time after seeing it in strategy forums for years.
I think I understand the basics of the game pretty well but feel free to point out when I screw up.

So, anyway, how do these games usually go? Do I just chat up everyone until I can feel their murderous intentions?
Apologizing in advance if I accidentally lynch a good guy.

[Iron Butterfly]

...and??

Are you town?

would it matter what my answer is?

[Endgame422]

...and??

Are you town?

would it matter what my answer is?

vote Iron Butterfly for answering questions with questions.
And because we need to get this ball rolling.

[Iron Butterfly]

...and??

Are you town?

would it matter what my answer is?

vote Iron Butterfly for answering questions with questions.
And because we need to get this ball rolling.

My answer would have been irrelevant.

Mafia would say they are Town and Town they would say they are Town.

Storr knows that.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

My two cents here:

It really does feel like one of Iron Butterfly and Storr is Mafia. Not a clue which one at the moment.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

And @WCG i think we have doc for sure.

Can you expand on this please? How do we know we have a doc?

[MudPuppy]

Mafia would say they are Town and Town they would say they are Town.

I'm a Mafia Goon... Townies can be a bit boring, Cops just aren't getting love these days, & Docs are pretty cool but need to stay in school for like 10 years.

[Endgame422]

And @WCG i think we have doc for sure.

Can you expand on this please? How do we know we have a doc?

i think the C9 setup always has a doc.
i think that there is 1 one doc,1 cop,3 vanilla townies and 2 mafia goons.
thats what that link elon posted said anyways.

[StorrZerg]

A cop and no doc is possible
or no power roles. ..
if you are doc... you gave away the game...

[Endgame422]

A cop and no doc is possible
or no power roles. ..
if you are doc... you gave away the game...

my bad!
i misread the wiki on possible set ups for this one i thought it was set in stone but i guess the only thing thats for sure is a pair of mafia goons.
Please ignore my ignorance there WCG.

[StorrZerg]

Eah.. w/e I'm not lynching you today

[Iron Butterfly]

...and??

Are you town?

would it matter what my answer is?

vote Iron Butterfly for answering questions with questions.
And because we need to get this ball rolling.

So now that you have voted me for answering a question with a question answer my question honestly.

Are you Town?

[StorrZerg]

Im towN

So we lynch MudPuppy for claiming to be goon k thx

[MudPuppy]

A cop and no doc is possible
or no power roles. ..
if you are doc... you gave away the game...

my bad!
i misread the wiki on possible set ups for this one i thought it was set in stone but i guess the only thing thats for sure is a pair of mafia goons.
Please ignore my ignorance there WCG.

Yeah,
100% chance of exactly 2 Mafia;
50% chance of a Cop;
50% chance of a Doc;
25% chance of both Cop & Doc (3 Vanilla Townies);
25% chance of 5 Vanilla Townies with no Cop/Doc

[Slander]

My two cents here:

It really does feel like one of Iron Butterfly and Storr is Mafia. Not a clue which one at the moment.

Oh. This is really how it works, lol.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

1. WingCmdr Ginkapo - Obviously Town, but I presume you will make your own judgement on this.
2. Iron Butterfly - Made the initial call on Storr, but that could be a veteran calling out another veteran to get things going. Does seem quite bothered by Storr's counter claim when we all know no-one knows anything.
3. virus90 - tbc
4. MudPuppy - Claimed Mafia,
5. StorrZerg - Involved in the IB fight
6. Endgame422 - Jumping onto the IB bandwagon, without real cause. Could be an innocent move. Seems to think we have a doc.
7. Slander - tbc

IB is the strongest candidate atm imo, but there is not much of a case for it.

[MudPuppy]

We're not going to get much of a case on anyone day one... but think it is in our best interest to lynch someone... anyone (Yeah, I know that can sound scummy). I used to be hesitant about D1 lynches... but I've since come to the conclusion that you need to take the gamble. I think most veterans would agree with that strategy... and the fact that Stor planted the seed that we maybe shouldn't do so has my Scum-dar focused on him:

So there are two mafia out of seven. Realistically we need to find them before the end of day 2....

yep 1 miss lynch, then we are at lylo.

He basically turned WingCmdr's call for action around and said if we guess wrong we're dead... to me that's more of a subtle attempt to instill fear and suggest a no-lynch vote than it is an agreement of WingCmdr's point as he was trying to make it seem. It's D1 and no cases are going to be strong... but that's good enough for me to fos Stor.

[StorrZerg]

We're not going to get much of a case on anyone day one... but think it is in our best interest to lynch someone... anyone (Yeah, I know that can sound scummy). I used to be hesitant about D1 lynches... but I've since come to the conclusion that you need to take the gamble. I think most veterans would agree with that strategy... and the fact that Stor planted the seed that we maybe shouldn't do so has my Scum-dar focused on him:

So there are two mafia out of seven. Realistically we need to find them before the end of day 2....

yep 1 miss lynch, then we are at lylo.

He basically turned WingCmdr's call for action around and said if we guess wrong we're dead... to me that's more of a subtle attempt to instill fear and suggest a no-lynch vote than it is an agreement of WingCmdr's point as he was trying to make it seem. It's D1 and no cases are going to be strong... but that's good enough for me to fos Stor.

Its called a fact checking. If we no lynch, then thats 2 day of no lynch till Lylo.

I'd much rather 2 shots of hitting mafia than 1 shot.


We all ready had one person miss read the possible set up.

Also why are you not responding to comments of people calling you out for claiming to be mafia?

[MudPuppy]

Its called a fact checking. If we no lynch, then thats 2 day of no lynch till Lylo.

I'd much rather 2 shots of hitting mafia than 1 shot....

Are you saying you're planning to vote no-lynch... or are you waiting for someone to admit to being Mafia on D1?

Also why are you not responding to comments of people calling you out for claiming to be mafia?

Are you really going to pretend my claim may have been a serious one where I slipped up and accidentally revealed myself? My "claim" was an attempt at humor to point out, as IB has also done, that any answer to the question you posed is meaningless... which makes your question meaningless... Why are you asking meaningless questions?

[StorrZerg]

Its called a fact checking. If we no lynch, then thats 2 day of no lynch till Lylo.

I'd much rather 2 shots of hitting mafia than 1 shot....

Are you saying you're planning to vote no-lynch... or are you waiting for someone to admit to being Mafia on D1?

Pretty sure its clear, that i am not in favor of no lynch by the bold statement. Seems like you are trying to drum up something from nothing.

Also why are you not responding to comments of people calling you out for claiming to be mafia?

Are you really going to pretend my claim may have been a serious one where I slipped up and accidentally revealed myself? My "claim" was an attempt at humor to point out, as IB has also done, that any answer to the question you posed is meaningless... which makes your question meaningless... Why are you asking meaningless questions?

Maybe it was a slip, its not far from mafia to admit to being mafia and claim they are joking about it. Its one of the more honest things they can say with a joke. Some people have a really hard time admitting to being town. And regarding questions, it gets reactions, reactions that can then be talked about and judged. So no the questions are not meaningless, they help to generate discussion.

To me it appears you are trying to hard to make me seem scummy, generally something like this wouldn't involve you saying something that's incorrect, then me pointing out what i said to prove you wrong. Whats hilarious, is that you actually quote what i said, and make it seem like its something else, when i clearly state "I'd rather 2 lynches over 2 sleeps"

[MudPuppy]

Its called a fact checking. If we no lynch, then thats 2 day of no lynch till Lylo.

I'd much rather 2 shots of hitting mafia than 1 shot....

Are you saying you're planning to vote no-lynch... or are you waiting for someone to admit to being Mafia on D1?

Pretty sure its clear, that i am not in favor of no lynch by the bold statement. Seems like you are trying to drum up something from nothing.... Whats hilarious, is that you actually quote what i said, and make it seem like its something else, when i clearly state "I'd rather 2 lynches over 2 sleeps"

mea culpa. Sorry, misread what you were saying. So, we are in agreement that someone should be lynched D1.

[MudPuppy]

To me it appears you are trying to hard to make me seem scummy

I do think the lylo comment was scummy... though I acknowledge it could have been just a statement of fact... we've got very limited information D1. I may be grasping for straws but I still see the lylo comment as a seed you were deliberately tried to plant.

[Endgame422]

So now that you have voted me for answering a question with a question answer my question honestly.

Are you Town?

Honestly?
Yes.
And really there was nothing to go on at that point,so i just gave you a single vote.
No danger of anyone getting lynched yet so a harmless move.
Your point was originally that of course everyone will town, but now your asking the exact question?
Seems like your unsure of your position here to me.
Ill leave my vote with you IB for now since its the only one on the board.
Take care of it for me.

[StorrZerg]

Also with L-2 being only 2 votes, when claims come, I strongly recommend we only force claims with 2 votes +someone in addition wanting the claim.

Also, I think cop should claim tomorrow regardless of the check.


Thoughts on the statements would be great.