Conquer Club Newbie Mafia #1: Day 4 ends 9-4 1600

by **dakky21** on Thu Sep 04, 2014 6:31 pm

Let's play another one?

I think I learned something, but everything is still blurry.

by **grt** on Fri Sep 05, 2014 9:26 am

I'm up for another :-)

by **Djfireside** on Sat Sep 06, 2014 9:07 am

damn and I was right since day 1

Djfireside wrote:But now comes the point that BW you brought on.

First off...

Endgame422 wrote:## Vote grt I believe James is town. Mafia would prefer next night so his asking for an extension seems to be a show of good faith. Just going with grt because it ties him and James.

Im with Codie, I dont understand. This will tie into my next comment but Endgame, Jonty and Dakky all voting grt for weird reasons and having a hardpress on it seems really scummy to me.

So I will finish with...

jonty125 wrote:##Vote Djfireside, there were much better targets than JamesKer for a claim i.e. grt. Your vote was just shameless bandwagoning to get a claim.

Why is GRT a better target...

Dakky voted grt for no reason,
grt voted dakky, in response stating lets see what happens
endgame voted grt

Thats it. No posts by grt nothing. Why are they a better target? You are doing to me what you are blasting me for and with even worse of a reason. I at least said what I was doing. You are trying a swing BW on a guy who is a controversal target I think.

##Vote Jonty125

by **StorrZerg** on Sat Sep 13, 2014 7:03 pm

viewtopic.php?f=609&t=207731

If you played or coached, I'd like your feedback in this thread thanks!

by **Iron Butterfly** on Sat Sep 13, 2014 7:37 pm

I did not like the voting system. It gave more power to Jonty. He was first to vote on the last day, which made his vote the lynch if there was a tie, which there was. When he voted along with me he sealed the game for himself as the only way to win was for three of us to vote him. It did not help that I did not understand the voting system toll the end and then it was to late.

The problem was that with the set up it really was a guessing game. Jonty was very agreeable with me this game, which i did notice but aside from that he really did nothing scummy. The new guys made all the newbie mistakes to seem scummy.

Having the cop die and no other PRs made it extremely difficult especially with people who have not played before. The new guys were hard to read. Having coaches made it harder because you don't know if they were speaking or their coaches.

If you make another newbie game add more PRs to liven it up.