Rock N' Roll Mafia 3/14 Endgame: Town Wins

by **dazza2008** on Tue Aug 27, 2013 1:00 pm

I'm not sure I believe your claim at all.

by **new guy1** on Tue Aug 27, 2013 1:01 pm

dazza2008 wrote:I'm not sure I believe your claim at all.

Just wondering, what do you find fishy about it?

by **dazza2008** on Tue Aug 27, 2013 1:25 pm

I don't know exactly. Just a feeling I have if I had anything more solid than a gut feeling I would post a case and vote. Going to read back through and see if anything jumps out.

by **new guy1** on Tue Aug 27, 2013 3:45 pm

dazza2008 wrote:I don't know exactly. Just a feeling I have if I had anything more solid than a gut feeling I would post a case and vote. Going to read back through and see if anything jumps out.

Alright, just wanted to see if there was a misinterpretation you needed cleared up or anything.

by **Iron Butterfly** on Tue Aug 27, 2013 4:33 pm

dazza2008 wrote:I don't know exactly. Just a feeling I have if I had anything more solid than a gut feeling I would post a case and vote. Going to read back through and see if anything jumps out.

At the moment there is no way to know he is telling the truth. If there really are 4 mafia we could be at endgame and screwed. He would have no choice but to say he was blocked.

by **new guy1** on Tue Aug 27, 2013 4:38 pm

Iron Butterfly wrote:
dazza2008 wrote:I don't know exactly. Just a feeling I have if I had anything more solid than a gut feeling I would post a case and vote. Going to read back through and see if anything jumps out.

At the moment there is no way to know he is telling the truth. If there really are 4 mafia we could be at endgame and screwed. He would have no choice but to say he was blocked.

Take it how you will. I came out with my role to prevent a mass claim, which can be taken as good or bad depending on your mindset. I did not waste time to speak up because I wanted this discussion to have time to work itself out. Ill wait.

by **dazza2008** on Tue Aug 27, 2013 4:56 pm

So if we don't mass claim what do you suggest? I can't see a clear case and i have looked through a few times. If you told the truth the info helps but it doesn't make any lynch any easier. I think a mass claim might be best here still.

by **new guy1** on Tue Aug 27, 2013 5:21 pm

dazza2008 wrote:So if we don't mass claim what do you suggest? I can't see a clear case and i have looked through a few times. If you told the truth the info helps but it doesn't make any lynch any easier. I think a mass claim might be best here still.

Thats the thing. I rushed in to my claim and didnt think about what would happen after I told everyone there was only 3 mafia. I can see where a mass clam would be necessary and Im willing to have everyone claim, but Im just saying I DID have good intentions. Just didnt think everything through in my haste.

by **jonty125** on Wed Aug 28, 2013 2:47 am

I believe the claim, I don't want a massclaim but I don't have anything else to offer.

by **Nebuchadnezer** on Wed Aug 28, 2013 7:04 am

Iron Butterfly wrote:
dazza2008 wrote:I don't know exactly. Just a feeling I have if I had anything more solid than a gut feeling I would post a case and vote. Going to read back through and see if anything jumps out.

At the moment there is no way to know he is telling the truth. If there really are 4 mafia we could be at endgame and screwed. He would have no choice but to say he was blocked.

But spiesr confirmed he targeted Newguy. So that would mean they are both mafia, working together, or they are both town. The fact that he said he was blocked isn't as scummy as it might ordinarily be. (I guess spiesr could be mafia roleblocker and then the town roleblocker blocked me...but that doesn't make sense as the town roleblocker would have come forward a long time ago!)

Newguy's questions and answers are a bit weak, in that they don't really add anything. They are also questions that mafia would already know or could deduce the answers to. If there's a questionable part of newguy's claim, it's the information he provided...not the fact that spiesr blocked him.

by **dazza2008** on Wed Aug 28, 2013 7:50 am

What question about the game did you ask new guy? I know you say you got blocked but what were you asking?

by **DoomYoshi** on Wed Aug 28, 2013 8:51 am

@neb: spiesr could be town and still have blocked new guy1 who could still be mafia... i don't know why you are saying they must be working together.

by **Nebuchadnezer** on Wed Aug 28, 2013 9:10 am

DoomYoshi wrote:@neb: spiesr could be town and still have blocked new guy1 who could still be mafia... i don't know why you are saying they must be working together.

Yup, I just realized that as I was reading back through...

by **spiesr** on Wed Aug 28, 2013 10:30 am

DoomYoshi wrote:I would rather massclaim now. Partially that has to do with the fact that I am already ousted. The other main thing is that if new guy is correct and we are NOT at LYLO, it is better to get claims on the table now, since LYLO lies can be a gamebuster.

Alright, who needs to go next?

by **new guy1** on Wed Aug 28, 2013 10:39 am

The question I had finalized that was to be asked (after being rejected on a couple others) was "How many people in the final vote count of Kgb were mafia?" because then I could narrow the scum pool to those players. I do not know if this question is viable as I got no comments on it, but I am trying it again tonight, provided I live to that point.

by **jonty125** on Wed Aug 28, 2013 11:14 am

new guy1 wrote:The question I had finalized that was to be asked (after being rejected on a couple others) was "How many people in the final vote count of Kgb were mafia?" because then I could narrow the scum pool to those players. I do not know if this question is viable as I got no comments on it, but I am trying it again tonight, provided I live to that point.

That question reminds of chapcrap's role in edoc's Golden Pantheon Mafia. Just saying.

by **new guy1** on Wed Aug 28, 2013 11:20 am

jonty125 wrote:
new guy1 wrote:The question I had finalized that was to be asked (after being rejected on a couple others) was "How many people in the final vote count of Kgb were mafia?" because then I could narrow the scum pool to those players. I do not know if this question is viable as I got no comments on it, but I am trying it again tonight, provided I live to that point.

That question reminds of chapcrap's role in edoc's Golden Pantheon Mafia. Just saying.

I was not in Pantheon, so I dont know what you are insinuating

. Again, I dont know if the question will go through, but I sent in a list of like 3 or 4 questions and two got shot down immediately, the others did not get comments, so they MIGHT be fair game. Ill see when the time comes around.

by **jonty125** on Wed Aug 28, 2013 11:45 am

new guy1 wrote:
jonty125 wrote:
new guy1 wrote:The question I had finalized that was to be asked (after being rejected on a couple others) was "How many people in the final vote count of Kgb were mafia?" because then I could narrow the scum pool to those players. I do not know if this question is viable as I got no comments on it, but I am trying it again tonight, provided I live to that point.

That question reminds of chapcrap's role in edoc's Golden Pantheon Mafia. Just saying.

I was not in Pantheon, so I dont know what you are insinuating . Again, I dont know if the question will go through, but I sent in a list of like 3 or 4 questions and two got shot down immediately, the others did not get comments, so they MIGHT be fair game. Ill see when the time comes around.

Surely you can PM the mod in the day about what questions you can ask?

by **new guy1** on Wed Aug 28, 2013 11:54 am

jonty125 wrote:
new guy1 wrote:
jonty125 wrote:
new guy1 wrote:The question I had finalized that was to be asked (after being rejected on a couple others) was "How many people in the final vote count of Kgb were mafia?" because then I could narrow the scum pool to those players. I do not know if this question is viable as I got no comments on it, but I am trying it again tonight, provided I live to that point.

That question reminds of chapcrap's role in edoc's Golden Pantheon Mafia. Just saying.

I was not in Pantheon, so I dont know what you are insinuating . Again, I dont know if the question will go through, but I sent in a list of like 3 or 4 questions and two got shot down immediately, the others did not get comments, so they MIGHT be fair game. Ill see when the time comes around.

Surely you can PM the mod in the day about what questions you can ask?

I probably can, and in fact will. I countered that by giving lists of questions and at least one of them worked every time, plus I have enough time in the night phase to come up with more anyways. Ill send in the other two questions to get pre approval.

by **strike wolf** on Wed Aug 28, 2013 5:00 pm

Reminder 1 week to deadline.

by **DoomYoshi** on Wed Aug 28, 2013 6:10 pm

There were 13 items in your list. Here they are in random order:

2. jonty
12. Dazza
11. Neb
10. Commander9
13. Iron Butterfly
5. Pancakemix Ghostly447
9. Liteme Doomyoshi
7. Stubbs
8. Warlord New guy1
14. Spiesr

MASSCLAIM GO! GO! GO!

by **jonty125** on Thu Aug 29, 2013 3:28 am

The Beatles-Town Doctor

N1: dazza2008
N2: thechuck51
N3: thechuck51

by **dazza2008** on Thu Aug 29, 2013 5:14 am

Eric Clapton-Town Double Voter

Not used my power yet obviously.

by **DoomYoshi** on Thu Aug 29, 2013 8:13 am

dazza2008 wrote:Eric Clapton-Town Double Voter

Not used my power yet obviously.

proofs in the pudding

by **dazza2008** on Thu Aug 29, 2013 8:30 am

DoomYoshi wrote:
dazza2008 wrote:Eric Clapton-Town Double Voter

Not used my power yet obviously.

proofs in the pudding

Yes but I can't give proof till the mod posts a vote count and ??? or something appears.

Rock N' Roll Mafia 3/14 Endgame: Town Wins

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Re: Rock N' Roll Mafia 10/14 D4: Deaf, Dumb, Blind and Dead

Who is online