Moderator: Cartographers

koontz1973 wrote:Oneyed, check your settings for when you save the map. You might be compressing the map by accident without realising it. That is the only thing apart from imageshack that might be causing your files to look bad.



if you realy do not want to have your name on map let me know and I will delete you.Gilligan wrote:Oneyed, I I appreciate the credit for some XML assist, but honestly it isn't "my name on the map" worthy. All I did was really check it, cairns did all the rest. If the XML checker got his name on every map he checked, forza az would be everywhere!
I don't think it needs to be there.Oneyed wrote:if you realy do not want to have your name on map let me know and I will delete you.Gilligan wrote:Oneyed, I I appreciate the credit for some XML assist, but honestly it isn't "my name on the map" worthy. All I did was really check it, cairns did all the rest. If the XML checker got his name on every map he checked, forza az would be everywhere!
thanks to everybody who helps to bring this map to Beta![]()
Oneyed

I think it's more of a problem with BOB, and it not being able to handle bonus collections.chapcrap wrote:I think there is a problem with the XML.
In this game: Game 12463747, BOB said that Swifte was going to get a +1 bonus for holding Bratislava and 4 towns. He did not hold Bratislava. He did hold 5 CR towns though. I took Kosice from him and his bonus went away. Oddly, this also coincided with him going from 12 territories to 11 territories. However, BOB said he held the Bratislava/town bonus.

What gilligan said is 100% correct.Gilligan wrote:I think it's more of a problem with BOB, and it not being able to handle bonus collections.chapcrap wrote:I think there is a problem with the XML.
In this game: Game 12463747, BOB said that Swifte was going to get a +1 bonus for holding Bratislava and 4 towns. He did not hold Bratislava. He did hold 5 CR towns though. I took Kosice from him and his bonus went away. Oddly, this also coincided with him going from 12 territories to 11 territories. However, BOB said he held the Bratislava/town bonus.
If that is the case then no worries. I didn't actually see an incorrect bonus collected.thenobodies80 wrote:What gilligan said is 100% correct.Gilligan wrote:I think it's more of a problem with BOB, and it not being able to handle bonus collections.chapcrap wrote:I think there is a problem with the XML.
In this game: Game 12463747, BOB said that Swifte was going to get a +1 bonus for holding Bratislava and 4 towns. He did not hold Bratislava. He did hold 5 CR towns though. I took Kosice from him and his bonus went away. Oddly, this also coincided with him going from 12 territories to 11 territories. However, BOB said he held the Bratislava/town bonus.
Next time BOB shows that bonus, check the Troops Due column on the CC stats (barring he actually doesn't have the bonus) and see what it says there.chapcrap wrote:If that is the case then no worries. I didn't actually see an incorrect bonus collected.thenobodies80 wrote:What gilligan said is 100% correct.Gilligan wrote:I think it's more of a problem with BOB, and it not being able to handle bonus collections.chapcrap wrote:I think there is a problem with the XML.
In this game: Game 12463747, BOB said that Swifte was going to get a +1 bonus for holding Bratislava and 4 towns. He did not hold Bratislava. He did hold 5 CR towns though. I took Kosice from him and his bonus went away. Oddly, this also coincided with him going from 12 territories to 11 territories. However, BOB said he held the Bratislava/town bonus.

Confirm..no bonus in fact, just BoB going nutsDukasaur wrote:Yeah, I noticed that in my very first game.
Game 12456154
No wrongful bonuses were collected. Nobodies agreed it's a BOB problem, not a map problem.

Had the same issue in Game 12528158, but mine was the Praha and 4 towns bonus. I use the Continents Overview option on BOB and it showed my opponent receiving this bonus, even the game log shows he didn't.chapcrap wrote:I think there is a problem with the XML.
In this game: Game 12463747, BOB said that Swifte was going to get a +1 bonus for holding Bratislava and 4 towns. He did not hold Bratislava. He did hold 5 CR towns though. I took Kosice from him and his bonus went away. Oddly, this also coincided with him going from 12 territories to 11 territories. However, BOB said he held the Bratislava/town bonus.
Cannot see a problem with this as in large games that I looked in, they are not taken very often. A lowering of the neutral might get them into play more often.Oneyed wrote:capitals (Praha, Bratislava) will start as n3 instead of n4.
This is frowned upon. A bonus drop for small games will happen. Need to run the percentages but I can guarantee it will be higher than allowed.Oneyed wrote:and +1 for every 3 towns (in CR/SR) instead +1 for every 4 towns.

this bonus is combination of holding capital and 4 towns. and because capitals allways start as neutral nobody can hold bonus even he starts with 4/3 towns.koontz1973 wrote:Cannot see a problem with this as in large games that I looked in, they are not taken very often. A lowering of the neutral might get them into play more often.Oneyed wrote:capitals (Praha, Bratislava) will start as n3 instead of n4.This is frowned upon. A bonus drop for small games will happen. Need to run the percentages but I can guarantee it will be higher than allowed.Oneyed wrote:and +1 for every 3 towns (in CR/SR) instead +1 for every 4 towns.
so what to do?chapcrap wrote:I agree with the suggestions Oneyed. No bonus would be dropped and it would open up the game a little bit more.