Alphabet Mafia 2Day 6 no night deaths

[samgrossy]

Here's a summary of what we know about the players (please add if I missed something):

Aage: Claims Jailkeeper, Supported by Saf, Last posted today
Nagerous: Not claimed, Last posted 10/11
Hippo: Claimed Vig, Last posted today
Edoc: Not Claimed, Last posted yesterday
Saf: RoleCop, last posted 10/9
Sam: Nurse, last posted today
Red: PGO (Granny), last posted 10/10
Shaggy: JOAT, last posted 10/8
DJ: No Claim, last posted 10/3
LoVo: Governor, last posted 10/15

I do this because I thought that there might be a correlation to inactivity and cult (maybe cult members aren't allowed to post), but that got shot down.

But I did notice that we need some serious prods. DJ hasn't posted in 20 days.

Which leads me to my last point... Aage, why would you have chosen to Jail DJ? Any particular reason?

[edocsil]

Your list isn't very accurate, therefore it isn't very helpful. I have claimed. BU doc. We should have hung red yesterday for his bald faced lie, and we should have had something to go on today. Instead we are sitting here dithering about who is scarier, cult or scum.

[samgrossy]

Your list isn't very accurate, therefore it isn't very helpful. I have claimed. BU doc. We should have hung red yesterday for his bald faced lie, and we should have had something to go on today. Instead we are sitting here dithering about who is scarier, cult or scum.

Good thing I asked to add something if I missed it.

[lord voldemort]

That last posted isnt to accurate though... As we were in night for quite some time...
but @ sam...i can only prevent a lynch after its happened but before scene is posted...

[aage]

Which leads me to my last point... Aage, why would you have chosen to Jail DJ? Any particular reason?

Because I hate busdrives. It was the only thing that could've prevented the CL from hanging today. Unfortunately it seems Lsu used a mafiascum standard powerrole-resolve list in which the busdriver is resolved before the roleblocker... But it looks like some of the other power roles managed to screw it up and we once again have no cult leader unless Saf found him.

@Edoc - unless mafia are all recruited?

@ Aage - Well, I made the shot (or tried to), what other explanation do you have?

Your first point is laughable, it sounds very plausible indeed that we haven't managed to lynch a single scum but the CL managed to find them all.
Other explanation I can think of is easy. DJ bussed you with either Shaggy or himself. Let's ask him.

Pretty clear cut Roleblock. We have killed what, 1 scum? Unlikely that none of them could be bothered to submit a kill. What I want to know is why isn't it already game over. It should be, unless the Cl got blocked.

My jailkeep role says that if I jail someone nobody else can target them. That means cult protection too. So instead of 1 in X, I have a 2 in X chance of preventing cult (X being the amount of players alive). Other explanations, CL got lazy, CL is already dead...


This night was supposed to bring clarity, but nobody died so we learnt nothing. Saf is our only hope of garnering anything at all. This means that we have to lynch someone today even more badly than we needed to yesterday (and WHY didn't we lynch yesterday? Seriously, people.)

[aage]

Here's a summary of what we know about the players (please add if I missed something):

Aage: Claims Jailkeeper, Supported by Saf, Last posted today
Nagerous: Not claimed, Last posted 10/11 claimed bp towny
Hippo: Claimed Vig, Last posted today
Edoc: Not Claimed, Last posted yesterday claimed BU doc
Saf: RoleCop, last posted 10/9
Sam: Nurse, last posted today
Red: PGO (Granny), last posted 10/10
Shaggy: JOAT, last posted 10/8
DJ: No Claim, last posted 10/3 claimed busdriver
LoVo: Governor, last posted 10/15

You could've just copied the list I made yesterday which would have said exactly the same except for the dates. I do agree that we need prods or replacements, or the mod will need to threaten with modkills.

[Djfireside]

I can confirm that Aage is who they say they are and that I was jailed. I was trying to bus myself with Saf as I felt still that saf is scummy to some degree so if I got targetted would have redirected to him. No kill is a bit odd but no mention on recruiting though.

[safariguy5]

I investigated sam and he indeed is the nurse. Not the CL, but could still have been recruited.

[redhedge47]

So right now what is the top proirity scum or cult

[aage]

I investigated sam and he indeed is the nurse. Not the CL, but could still have been recruited.

So right now what is the top proirity scum or cult

Both of you should be lynched for these posts. Saf, why Sam? We already knew 100% certain he was a roleblocker and not the cult leader. Redhedge, just what the actual f*ck.

DJ's post is interesting. Apparently he was blocked after all... i'd have to ask you to post the message I sent along in order to confirm, since I already said I targeted you so your current claim could still be untruthful.

That brings me to Hippo. If what DJ says is true Hippo did not use his ability last night but he did use it earlier in the game on Sam which was foiled by me. I can only conclude that Hippo was recruited sometime before last night and has lost his killing powers, which means the cult leader is definitely alive and kicking. This leaves Nagerous, Edoc, Red, Shaggy and LoVo as options for being the CL since none of their roles have been confirmed.

I wonder if Saf would mind telling us who the mafia targeted with their night kill, because we do need to find the cult leader now unlike yesterday.

[edocsil]

I investigated sam and he indeed is the nurse. Not the CL, but could still have been recruited.

So right now what is the top proirity scum or cult

Both of you should be lynched for these posts. Saf, why Sam? We already knew 100% certain he was a roleblocker and not the cult leader. Redhedge, just what the actual f*ck.

DJ's post is interesting. Apparently he was blocked after all... i'd have to ask you to post the message I sent along in order to confirm, since I already said I targeted you so your current claim could still be untruthful.

That brings me to Hippo. If what DJ says is true Hippo did not use his ability last night but he did use it earlier in the game on Sam which was foiled by me. I can only conclude that Hippo was recruited sometime before last night and has lost his killing powers, which means the cult leader is definitely alive and kicking. This leaves Nagerous, Edoc, Red, Shaggy and LoVo as options for being the CL since none of their roles have been confirmed.

I wonder if Saf would mind telling us who the mafia targeted with their night kill, because we do need to find the cult leader now unlike yesterday.

I happened to not believe the nurse/jailkeeper claims until they were actually verified. Personally I think Red would have been a better inv target for the scum, but my opinion is a bit biased there. Either way would be a win.

[aage]

I investigated sam and he indeed is the nurse. Not the CL, but could still have been recruited.

So right now what is the top proirity scum or cult

Both of you should be lynched for these posts. Saf, why Sam? We already knew 100% certain he was a roleblocker and not the cult leader. Redhedge, just what the actual f*ck.

DJ's post is interesting. Apparently he was blocked after all... i'd have to ask you to post the message I sent along in order to confirm, since I already said I targeted you so your current claim could still be untruthful.

That brings me to Hippo. If what DJ says is true Hippo did not use his ability last night but he did use it earlier in the game on Sam which was foiled by me. I can only conclude that Hippo was recruited sometime before last night and has lost his killing powers, which means the cult leader is definitely alive and kicking. This leaves Nagerous, Edoc, Red, Shaggy and LoVo as options for being the CL since none of their roles have been confirmed.

I wonder if Saf would mind telling us who the mafia targeted with their night kill, because we do need to find the cult leader now unlike yesterday.

I happened to not believe the nurse/jailkeeper claims until they were actually verified. Personally I think Red would have been a better inv target for the scum, but my opinion is a bit biased there. Either way would be a win.

It doesn't really matter whether he's town or scum aligned. My guess is that he's a mafia jailer. He's not the cult leader though, as I already explained earlier:

http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewtopic.php?p=3910208#p3910208

These are his night actions. He blocked TheHippo version 1 on night 1, who did not pop cult. He is not our man.

[samgrossy]

Aage (and the rest)
I went into an analysis in the last post of D5. I firmly beleive the CL must have been blocked at least once for us to still be alive. There are two blockers (aage and myself) and with all the cancelling out that happened, Me blocking you and you blocking me D3 and D4, that leaves just who we blocked D1 and D2. The only assumption that I make is that there were still enough people in the game to make busdriving only a random choice by the busdriver (comments DJ?). So, with that, there are only 2 possible choices for cult leader - Shaggy and Strike/Hippo.

Also, Vodean couldn't be CL because doesn't the cult revert back to normal alignment after the CL is offed? Mr T was killed after vodean was modkilled. Right? (That's an actual question!)

I'll have to go back to the record to see if DJ posted his busdrives. If not, I think was have our men. We can lynch one during the day, mafia can off the other in the night.

You can see my original post here. I think it makes sense, and I think its the best we have if DJ didn't busdrive people.

[safariguy5]

I investigated sam and he indeed is the nurse. Not the CL, but could still have been recruited.

So right now what is the top proirity scum or cult

Both of you should be lynched for these posts. Saf, why Sam? We already knew 100% certain he was a roleblocker and not the cult leader. Redhedge, just what the actual f*ck.

DJ's post is interesting. Apparently he was blocked after all... i'd have to ask you to post the message I sent along in order to confirm, since I already said I targeted you so your current claim could still be untruthful.

That brings me to Hippo. If what DJ says is true Hippo did not use his ability last night but he did use it earlier in the game on Sam which was foiled by me. I can only conclude that Hippo was recruited sometime before last night and has lost his killing powers, which means the cult leader is definitely alive and kicking. This leaves Nagerous, Edoc, Red, Shaggy and LoVo as options for being the CL since none of their roles have been confirmed.

I wonder if Saf would mind telling us who the mafia targeted with their night kill, because we do need to find the cult leader now unlike yesterday.

I have no idea where you got the idea that sam is the roleblocker. He claimed nurse and that's what I found.

[samgrossy]

As the nurse, my role pm says I protect and roleblock 1 person during the night. There was a little tussle about this when we were all claiming ("You're a Jailer and not a nurse!"), since it quickly passed and Aage and I pretty much proved it with each other on D3 and D4, no one has really questioned it.

Who did mafia target with their night kill? That would be the best info ever!

[aage]

I investigated sam and he indeed is the nurse. Not the CL, but could still have been recruited.

So right now what is the top proirity scum or cult

Both of you should be lynched for these posts. Saf, why Sam? We already knew 100% certain he was a roleblocker and not the cult leader. Redhedge, just what the actual f*ck.

DJ's post is interesting. Apparently he was blocked after all... i'd have to ask you to post the message I sent along in order to confirm, since I already said I targeted you so your current claim could still be untruthful.

That brings me to Hippo. If what DJ says is true Hippo did not use his ability last night but he did use it earlier in the game on Sam which was foiled by me. I can only conclude that Hippo was recruited sometime before last night and has lost his killing powers, which means the cult leader is definitely alive and kicking. This leaves Nagerous, Edoc, Red, Shaggy and LoVo as options for being the CL since none of their roles have been confirmed.

I wonder if Saf would mind telling us who the mafia targeted with their night kill, because we do need to find the cult leader now unlike yesterday.

I have no idea where you got the idea that sam is the roleblocker. He claimed nurse and that's what I found.

According to his claim and the evidence we have he can roleblock, therefore I called him roleblocker. The reason I'm saying it is because I'm slightly annoyed by the fact that you sabotage attempts to find the cult leader by performing irrelevant investigations.

[redhedge47]

quick note so im not accused of lurking im going on a fall break trip and wont be back till sunday I wont have internet

[nagerous]

No one has said anything particularly useful so far this game day, night actions haven't really brought any progression. What I do know is another NL will bring another night for cult recruiting so we do need to act swiftly. I still have red at the top of my suspicions, though I am not convinced by shaggy or lovo either. Personally, we should lynch one of these today and lynch fast.

[nagerous]

I am happy for safari to clear my name as well but it seems like through his investigations he is choosing to be deliberately evasive.

[samgrossy]

I feel that nagerous is right. If we don't lynch, we're screwed. I also feel that Shaggy or Strike/Hippo are our options for CL (see my previous posts)

I also feel that if the CL is killed, all the recruited players revert back to their original alignment and then it becomes better for BOTH MAFIA AND TOWN, therefore MAFIA needs to lynch the CL as badly as we do in order to win. While I would never advocate mafia and town to work together, in this case it is unavoidable.

Lastly, I don't see any good discussion about why I shouldn't beleive my analysis, so I am going to tell the world what I am doing and you all know it. The only thing, again, that I can see screwing this up is busdrives. DJ, do you care to help me out here?

VOTE SHAGGY

And tonight I am going to rolebock Hippo. That gives Saf (our resident Mafia Rolecop) the ability to verify another role, not hippo, but maybe red since his PGO claim was questioned or even Edoc, because who really actually claims BU doc in a game with two other Docs? And Aage gets a chance to jail DJ because he could busdrive this all, and cause the night to get screwed.

Come on, let's get this game over with.

[samgrossy]

I feel that nagerous is right. If we don't lynch, we're screwed. I also feel that Shaggy or Strike/Hippo are our options for CL (see my previous posts)

I also feel that if the CL is killed, all the recruited players revert back to their original alignment and then it becomes better for BOTH MAFIA AND TOWN, therefore MAFIA needs to lynch the CL as badly as we do in order to win. While I would never advocate mafia and town to work together, in this case it is unavoidable.

Lastly, I don't see any good discussion about why I shouldn't beleive my analysis, so I am going to tell the world what I am doing and you all know it. The only thing, again, that I can see screwing this up is busdrives. DJ, do you care to help me out here?

VOTE SHAGGY

And tonight I am going to rolebock Hippo. That gives Saf (our resident Mafia Rolecop) the ability to verify another role, not hippo, but maybe red since his PGO claim was questioned or even Edoc, because who really actually claims BU doc in a game with two other Docs? And Aage gets a chance to jail DJ because he could busdrive this all, and cause the night to get screwed.

Come on, let's get this game over with.

EBWOP

By asking for your help DJ, I mean can you tell us who you Busdrove on what nights, PLEASE.

[aage]

I feel that nagerous is right. If we don't lynch, we're screwed. I also feel that Shaggy or Strike/Hippo are our options for CL (see my previous posts)

I also feel that if the CL is killed, all the recruited players revert back to their original alignment and then it becomes better for BOTH MAFIA AND TOWN, therefore MAFIA needs to lynch the CL as badly as we do in order to win. While I would never advocate mafia and town to work together, in this case it is unavoidable.

Lastly, I don't see any good discussion about why I shouldn't beleive my analysis, so I am going to tell the world what I am doing and you all know it. The only thing, again, that I can see screwing this up is busdrives. DJ, do you care to help me out here?

VOTE SHAGGY

And tonight I am going to rolebock Hippo. That gives Saf (our resident Mafia Rolecop) the ability to verify another role, not hippo, but maybe red since his PGO claim was questioned or even Edoc, because who really actually claims BU doc in a game with two other Docs? And Aage gets a chance to jail DJ because he could busdrive this all, and cause the night to get screwed.

Come on, let's get this game over with.

EBWOP

By asking for your help DJ, I mean can you tell us who you Busdrove on what nights, PLEASE.

You seem to have forgotten that Saf is a mafia member (or by now a cult member). I'm inclined to not believe a word he says because if he finds the CL he'll just tell his buddies and they NK him. There is no reason for him to be truthful about any other investigations he may have performed, so I would disregard them.
also there is a post somewhere where DJ says whom he drove on the first three nights, haven't heard any after that.
I do agree that we should get this game over with... it's a goddamn drag and I have the feeling I'm the only one ever doing anything, which sucks. The rest of you are probably cult, scum or equally bored.

[edocsil]

Equally bored certainly. We can't trust each other enough to work together. Any want to place bets on the odds of us NLing again?

[samgrossy]

I feel that nagerous is right. If we don't lynch, we're screwed. I also feel that Shaggy or Strike/Hippo are our options for CL (see my previous posts)

I also feel that if the CL is killed, all the recruited players revert back to their original alignment and then it becomes better for BOTH MAFIA AND TOWN, therefore MAFIA needs to lynch the CL as badly as we do in order to win. While I would never advocate mafia and town to work together, in this case it is unavoidable.

Lastly, I don't see any good discussion about why I shouldn't beleive my analysis, so I am going to tell the world what I am doing and you all know it. The only thing, again, that I can see screwing this up is busdrives. DJ, do you care to help me out here?

VOTE SHAGGY

And tonight I am going to rolebock Hippo. That gives Saf (our resident Mafia Rolecop) the ability to verify another role, not hippo, but maybe red since his PGO claim was questioned or even Edoc, because who really actually claims BU doc in a game with two other Docs? And Aage gets a chance to jail DJ because he could busdrive this all, and cause the night to get screwed.

Come on, let's get this game over with.

EBWOP

By asking for your help DJ, I mean can you tell us who you Busdrove on what nights, PLEASE.

You seem to have forgotten that Saf is a mafia member (or by now a cult member). I'm inclined to not believe a word he says because if he finds the CL he'll just tell his buddies and they NK him. There is no reason for him to be truthful about any other investigations he may have performed, so I would disregard them.
also there is a post somewhere where DJ says whom he drove on the first three nights, haven't heard any after that.
I do agree that we should get this game over with... it's a goddamn drag and I have the feeling I'm the only one ever doing anything, which sucks. The rest of you are probably cult, scum or equally bored.

This is a crazy post. I gave everyone a plan. Day time: Lynch Shaggy Night: Roleblock hippo, see what saf comes up with, Jail DJ.

If this is not something, then what is it? If you all are bored, then just follow my plan, and see what the heck happens. I haven't seen any other plan that would work or even another plan. You just want to complain, Aage, or what?

[thehippo8]

I feel that nagerous is right. If we don't lynch, we're screwed. I also feel that Shaggy or Strike/Hippo are our options for CL (see my previous posts)

I also feel that if the CL is killed, all the recruited players revert back to their original alignment and then it becomes better for BOTH MAFIA AND TOWN, therefore MAFIA needs to lynch the CL as badly as we do in order to win. While I would never advocate mafia and town to work together, in this case it is unavoidable.

Lastly, I don't see any good discussion about why I shouldn't beleive my analysis, so I am going to tell the world what I am doing and you all know it. The only thing, again, that I can see screwing this up is busdrives. DJ, do you care to help me out here?

VOTE SHAGGY

And tonight I am going to rolebock Hippo. That gives Saf (our resident Mafia Rolecop) the ability to verify another role, not hippo, but maybe red since his PGO claim was questioned or even Edoc, because who really actually claims BU doc in a game with two other Docs? And Aage gets a chance to jail DJ because he could busdrive this all, and cause the night to get screwed.

Come on, let's get this game over with.

EBWOP

By asking for your help DJ, I mean can you tell us who you Busdrove on what nights, PLEASE.

You seem to have forgotten that Saf is a mafia member (or by now a cult member). I'm inclined to not believe a word he says because if he finds the CL he'll just tell his buddies and they NK him. There is no reason for him to be truthful about any other investigations he may have performed, so I would disregard them.
also there is a post somewhere where DJ says whom he drove on the first three nights, haven't heard any after that.
I do agree that we should get this game over with... it's a goddamn drag and I have the feeling I'm the only one ever doing anything, which sucks. The rest of you are probably cult, scum or equally bored.

This is a crazy post. I gave everyone a plan. Day time: Lynch Shaggy Night: Roleblock hippo, see what saf comes up with, Jail DJ.

If this is not something, then what is it? If you all are bored, then just follow my plan, and see what the heck happens. I haven't seen any other plan that would work or even another plan. You just want to complain, Aage, or what?

Well, clearly it is time to both prove my usefulness and to take a stand. I agree with this as a plan and accordingly ...