pmchugh wrote:edocsil wrote:Pmc. Pros/cons of telling them the others identities? My kneejerk is fk no, but it may prevent us from being shot by the warring factions.
My kneejerk is the same, especially with jak threatening to "take me to the gallows". I think it is personal really, at least one person should remain hidden IMO though, at least while the rest of us live if you catch my drift. If it were up to me, town would know less than they already do. I said what I said not for their benefit.
And jak, I don't see why the recruits have to be from our group and not town and given the way the game has panned out I don't think it is true. Edoc is the only one I am not sure about tbh, when I said I thought he could be recruited yesterday I meant it, but he at least stayed true to what he claimed he would do last night.
Alright. I was thinking much the same. We should be fine if the two others claim, but I don't want them to know the Merovingen's identity honestly. As far as me being recruited, well I worry more about those who don't have an action to begin with. There is no way for them to be caught at no longer having an action.
Jak, Doom, Town, for now I'll offer this. If a wagon begins to form on one of ours, we will let you know. We don't want to waste daytime any more then you do, it's just more of a chance for us to be killed. I suggest that two of us come forward to help the town narrow the spectrum, and reduce our own chances of being killed. I will leave the choice up to them for now, if I piss off my own faction too badly there could be problems for me, but I think they will agree that their claiming is beneficial to their survival.
Now for as for who we should hang.
Cult is your largest threat (and ours too honestly) so the head of that should be taken out first if we can.
I suspect that Aage is the cult leader for 2 reasons basically.
Meta ~ the role has been replaced twice and quickly. This suggest a powerful and important role, and he is not Neo, Trinity, The Oracle, Morpheus or The Merovingen. IIRC recruits only began after Aage showed up. This could easily be because of a change in management. Aage Smith prefers recruits while CM5 Smith prefers dead people. Who knows, but its at least as solid as a delayed recruit ability theory.
Beyond that Aage is setting off my scumdar like crazy. Yes, it's only gut, but I am certain that he is anti town, and I cannot shake the feeling. He is acting a lot like me, and I am not town. He is also good enough to keep from making grievous threats. He has also been fairly antagonistic of the town heroes, albeit not without reason. In addition he is one of the 6 characters whose identity I do not know. With a suspected 4-5 original scum (not counting cultists for this, just the leader) remaining, my chances of making a mistake are slim enough that I want to advocate his lynch.
Thoughts?
)
