Someone said I went quiet its true, I had two exams I hadn't bothered studying for the last two days and just ran an exhausting 9 miles

Anyway I will catch up a bit.
shieldgenerator7 wrote:My reason for FOSing PMC is for the concept of NKing a survivor. I understand the difference between the two situations he described, but the way he presented it made is sound as tho vigging the survivor would change the "3 mafia, 1 survivor, 3 town" into: "3 mafia, 4 town", when in reality it changes it into "3 mafia, 3 town", which is obv a scum win.
You completely misquoted my example, it is "3 mafia, 1 survivor and 4 town" versus "3 mafia 4 town". One is a win for mafia, the other isn't.
shield wrote:So what's the diff between vigging and lynching the survivor? Lynching is more calculated and town usually gains more info, whereas if we vigged him it would waste a town power role's night action and it's the decision of jsut one person.
Its not a waste of a town power role because normally vigs should NOT shoot night 1.
shield wrote:Vigging him would be killing him just to kill him b/c he's a survivor. Lynching would be more of getting info from his BW and killing him b/c his claim and actions don't line up.
We would reach a lynch anyway, and potentially get scum and lots of other information. Info from lynch + vig >= info from lynch.
jgordon1111 wrote:I am talking from a outside view here I am neither town nor mafia,I knew I was done when I tried to draw attention away from the Doc.
Then why do it? Why claim under little pressure as well? Your play is bizarre for a survivor tbh.
safariguy5 wrote:jgordon1111 wrote:thechuck51 wrote:jgordon1111 wrote:my list of possible scum
Safari guy,you are predictable. You cant help it for some reason, thats why I brought up the meta gaming against you earlier. and the fact thats how I killed you N3 in that game.
Doom is second for the obvious reasons.
And of course their is chuck who finally came in and said he was to busy with other games to be really involved with this one.
This and matrix are my first mafia games. Trying to stay current in both has been very difficult for me. If you look in the matrix thread, I was inactive for a couple of days in there as well. I am not neglecting one game for the other.
Tonight I have been able to catch up and I've come to a logical conclusion. A lynch of non-town is good. a survivor is non-town. you claim to be a survivor. therefore a lynch of you is good.
vote jgordon
At least now you are voting of your own accord, for your own reason. Good keep playing like that dont be lead because others tell you they know more.
you see something you dont like or trust,or you have a valid reason FOS or vote it.
Second game and you are learning.
Predictability may not be a bad thing. If I play the same in every game, then it's more difficult to figure out alignment from game to game.
How about this, you're so certain I'm scum, why don't you put your money where your mouth is? I'll volunteer to take the lynch on the condition that you be lynched tomorrow if I turn up town. I'll say it right now, I'm town.
You claim to know a lot about mafia jgordon, you need to realize your "scum sense" or whatever is not as good as you think it is. Also, attacking me for voting you is about as blatant an OMGUS as you can get.
But hey, as you say, it's all part of the learning process right? Little humble pie never hurt anyone. I'll even help you out.
unvote vote safariguy5
I find this whole back and forth rather bizarre as well. Why are you so sure he is scum safari?
I was going to comment on jgordons watcher scenarios which were deeply flawed and point out there are other threats (e.g. busdriver).. but it appears chap beat me to it and used it to fos me:
chapcrap wrote:Also, I really, really likes SG7's post when he came back into the game. Go check it out again. Something it opened my eyes to was using a vig on jgordon. As / has already mentioned, the tone of the game suggests that there is a likely a mafia busdriver. Using a vig for a NK is a bad idea because with a mafia busdriver, you will essentially give the mafia two kills at night. The one person who brought it up and pushed for it was pmc. As a self proclaimed veteran, he should have known better and also known what he was doing. My thought: he did know. FOS pmc.
However I would still argue that this scenario is very unlikely, mafia busdriver is well known as one of the most unbalanced roles in the game. While it may be a possibility it is a lot rarer than you make out, maybe 1 in 15 games that I have played in (usually fircoal games) and I don't buy the way / read the mod. If I am wrong then feel free to bring this back up, but I still amn't too concerned by it.
chapcrap wrote:My vote will stay on Doom. Yes, I agreed with what you had to say about you fully exposing jak's claim. However, that doesn't mean you can't be pressured. As stated, at that time, I didn't see anyone else compelling and as I am still looking for scum, I went ahead and pressured someone for information, not for a lynch. My vote will stay until you claim. I think it's odd that pmc advocates you not claiming after previously stating that pressuring someone for claiming was good. FOS pmc again.
I have never said this. Claims are not the point of BWs- for the billionth time.On the jgordon wagon I agree with new guy and I wouldn't be surprised to see a few scum lurking on there and trying to go for the easy lynch. I have a few other thoughts brewing but they are not quite there and I don't want to talk about too many things in one post or people will ignore parts.