DoomYoshi wrote:A yoshi rollcall is when a random list of people is generated. Then the first person in the list says who they think is the scummiest. Then the second person lists who they think is scummiest. Ideally, there will be enough defending and OMGUSing by the end of it we won't need to reach the end, we will have proper cases.
everywhere116 wrote:A Yoshi rolecall?
Blue yoshi, green yoshi, red yoshi, and yellow yoshi. All here!
Everyone knows that Black Yoshi is the most powerful.
How is that any better than just voting out the inactives? I snub your idea...UNVOTE VOTE ROUSSALlIER
Put that in your scumdar and smoke it.
1)Inactives can be replaced or modkilled if necessary. We don't want to waste a lynch.
2) Since people don't have to give reasons for voting an inactive, scum can easily hide in a BW.
3) no discussion is generated when voting for an inactive and discussion is what exposes scum.
4) Rous may never show up. If we lynch him, we may get lucky like in Pirates. More likely we will lynch a townie and he or she will have no chance to defend.
Are those 4 reasons good enough or do you want more?
DoomYoshi wrote:A yoshi rollcall is when a random list of people is generated. Then the first person in the list says who they think is the scummiest. Then the second person lists who they think is scummiest. Ideally, there will be enough defending and OMGUSing by the end of it we won't need to reach the end, we will have proper cases.
everywhere116 wrote:A Yoshi rolecall?
Blue yoshi, green yoshi, red yoshi, and yellow yoshi. All here!
Everyone knows that Black Yoshi is the most powerful.
How is that any better than just voting out the inactives? I snub your idea...UNVOTE VOTE ROUSSALlIER
Put that in your scumdar and smoke it.
1)Inactives can be replaced or modkilled if necessary. We don't want to waste a lynch.
2) Since people don't have to give reasons for voting an inactive, scum can easily hide in a BW.
3) no discussion is generated when voting for an inactive and discussion is what exposes scum.
4) Rous may never show up. If we lynch him, we may get lucky like in Pirates. More likely we will lynch a townie and he or she will have no chance to defend.
Are those 4 reasons good enough or do you want more?
Those are great reasons...carry on with your experiment...I'll check back in here in about 30 or so pages...
Neb, I'm not saying that being inactive is a good thing or that it should go unpunished. I am just saying that if 13 people band together and kill someone who probably won't ever come back, then the game is headed nowhere fast.
not to be on Neb's side, but a yoshi role call this early would be very difficult to do. Especially with little to go off of. I know if you were to look at my posts you would be analyzing like 4. Unless your main case was me submarining. I would agree to this on day 2 if we don't have any major leads to go into though, or even much later in day 1.
not to be on Neb's side, but a yoshi role call this early would be very difficult to do. Especially with little to go off of. I know if you were to look at my posts you would be analyzing like 4. Unless your main case was me submarining. I would agree to this on day 2 if we don't have any major leads to go into though, or even much later in day 1.
It only works when you have very little to go off of. If you have lots to go off of, you don't need one.
not to be on Neb's side, but a yoshi role call this early would be very difficult to do. Especially with little to go off of. I know if you were to look at my posts you would be analyzing like 4. Unless your main case was me submarining. I would agree to this on day 2 if we don't have any major leads to go into though, or even much later in day 1.
It only works when you have very little to go off of. If you have lots to go off of, you don't need one.
Oh ok, I don't think I have been in a game where you have done that though, so that would make more since.
I think we need to see if they do respond to the prods.
I was in a game with the yoshi roll call and I think it was good. It generated a lot of discussion. There is not much to go on here except old Nebby is playing wierd this game
I say while we await the inactives we should start a yoshi-call.
I have been busy in other games and have had real life stuff as well. I am starting to hate random joke voting day, which is why I have been quiet as well. There is no rhyme or reason. We have three random bandwagons. Granted you have to start somewhere. I reserve my vote till I find a case I beleive the person is scum.
I have been busy in other games and have had real life stuff as well. I am starting to hate random joke voting day, which is why I have been quiet as well. There is no rhyme or reason. We have three random bandwagons. Granted you have to start somewhere. I reserve my vote till I find a case I beleive the person is scum.
It would be awesome if everyone just decided not to talk till there was a case.
If we all stay quiet what would we ever build a case on?
I have been busy in other games and have had real life stuff as well. I am starting to hate random joke voting day, which is why I have been quiet as well. There is no rhyme or reason. We have three random bandwagons. Granted you have to start somewhere. I reserve my vote till I find a case I beleive the person is scum.
It would be awesome if everyone just decided not to talk till there was a case.
If we all stay quiet what would we ever build a case on?
Rock Paper Scissors or Red Pill, Blue Pill, No pill?
I have been busy in other games and have had real life stuff as well. I am starting to hate random joke voting day, which is why I have been quiet as well. There is no rhyme or reason. We have three random bandwagons. Granted you have to start somewhere. I reserve my vote till I find a case I beleive the person is scum.
It would be awesome if everyone just decided not to talk till there was a case.
If we all stay quiet what would we ever build a case on?
I have been busy in other games and have had real life stuff as well. I am starting to hate random joke voting day, which is why I have been quiet as well. There is no rhyme or reason. We have three random bandwagons. Granted you have to start somewhere. I reserve my vote till I find a case I beleive the person is scum.
It would be awesome if everyone just decided not to talk till there was a case.
If we all stay quiet what would we ever build a case on?
If everyone talked who would listen?
All of us. Since by talking we are typing and should all be able to read.
I have been busy in other games and have had real life stuff as well. I am starting to hate random joke voting day, which is why I have been quiet as well. There is no rhyme or reason. We have three random bandwagons. Granted you have to start somewhere. I reserve my vote till I find a case I beleive the person is scum.
It would be awesome if everyone just decided not to talk till there was a case.
If we all stay quiet what would we ever build a case on?
If everyone talked who would listen?
All of us. Since by talking we are typing and should all be able to read.
I have been busy in other games and have had real life stuff as well. I am starting to hate random joke voting day, which is why I have been quiet as well. There is no rhyme or reason. We have three random bandwagons. Granted you have to start somewhere. I reserve my vote till I find a case I beleive the person is scum.
It would be awesome if everyone just decided not to talk till there was a case.
If we all stay quiet what would we ever build a case on?
If everyone talked who would listen?
All of us. Since by talking we are typing and should all be able to read.
unless someone is blind!
Is anyone blind here?
Anyway if there is they managed to get the info somehow to see the game was in signups and join it so somehow the blind guys are doin ok. Leave them alone.
