Yo Ho, A Pirate's Life! [2/16] Endgame: Pirates Win!

[isaiah40]

My guesses are on sully and doom as being mafia, now that my gut told me wrong about neb. unvote. Let's get the parrot sqwaking shall we? vote sully

[soundman]

Modkill. The day will continue.

[jak111]

Modkill. The day will continue.

With this, Isaiah is back on the cleared list.

Like I said though, I still want New Guy's info or some sort of info to go on for the lynch.

[Victor Sullivan]

Wait... Would someone remind me why DoomYoshi's cleared? I'm not so convinced he's town...

-Sully

[SPARTACUS1974]

so are you going to give us some more info victor?

[jak111]

Wait... Would someone remind me why DoomYoshi's cleared? I'm not so convinced he's town...

-Sully

Well he's not 100% cleared but he's a bit cleared from being blocked on a night of 3 kills. Though the reason you're not cleared is because you beat around the bush. Depending on what New Guy brings back on whatever he did to you, you may or may not be lynched today.

[thehippo8]

Wait... Would someone remind me why DoomYoshi's cleared? I'm not so convinced he's town...

-Sully

Your captain meends more from you than this. I will ask one more time ,,, tell me what you learned each night ... I am your Captain now speak!

And a little pressure ... unvote vote sully

[Victor Sullivan]

I'd rather not elaborate. I have nothing to contribute at the moment, so I don't see the point in outing myself.

-Sully

[SPARTACUS1974]

sully you need to give us some more info or my vote will go on you ,we have had 3 nights so you must have some sort of info from those if not what is your actual use for town?

[Victor Sullivan]

I populate the town? And, technically speaking, I've only had two nights.

-Sully

[SPARTACUS1974]

I populate the town? And, technically speaking, I've only had two nights.

-Sully

populate the town?

[Victor Sullivan]

I populate the town? And, technically speaking, I've only had two nights.

-Sully

populate the town?

Yes, I, by default, help the town through my being apart of the town faction, thus making it larger.

-Sully

[SPARTACUS1974]

so no use at all

[Victor Sullivan]

Is a Vanilla Townie useless? Should you just lynch a Vanilla Townie just because he/she has no night action? IMO, no night action does not equal uselessness.

-Sully

[SPARTACUS1974]

no vt are usefull with helping us get the lynch and appling presure but you have done yourself no favours in being uncooperative we need town to help us not sit back and just post squalks.
so who help us now what are your thoughts on the game?

[soundman]

Vote Count:

SPARTACUS1974
isaiah40 - Doom - (L4)
thehippo8
Victor Sullivan - Isaiah, Hippo - (L3)
TeeGee - Spartacus - (L4)
new guy1
DoomYoshi
jak111

With 8 alive it takes 5 to make someone walk the plank.

[jak111]

Vote Count:


Victor Sullivan - Isaiah, Hippo - (L3)

With 8 alive it takes 5 to make someone walk the plank.

If two more vote for him, I will hammer, alright?

[new guy1]

Alright, I just got home. I have no usful information to contribute CURRENTLY, though Sully seems to be hinting that he is a VT. But if this is true, and he is a VT then IDK why he would say that he "choose not to use his action". My 2c worth currently, and I dont have much time currently to type more up cause I just got home, have to take a shower, have dinner, and then play a different game, so I will try to talk tomorrow, at school.

[jak111]

Alright, I just got home. I have no usful information to contribute CURRENTLY, though Sully seems to be hinting that he is a VT. But if this is true, and he is a VT then IDK why he would say that he "choose not to use his action". My 2c worth currently, and I dont have much time currently to type more up cause I just got home, have to take a shower, have dinner, and then play a different game, so I will try to talk tomorrow, at school.

Good eye New, I think we have our lynch target. I'll still wait to see if it's what the rest of the town wants (2 more votes) Then I will hammer.

That'll leave us down to 2 MAIN suspects, so if Sparta jails Hippo like he said he can, then we should be able to wrap this up .

[DoomYoshi]

It doesn't technically clear Isaiah. Just because he got a gun and used it doesn't mean he is town. It means that for some reason Teegee thought he was town. However, before he was modkilled, Teegee still denied that there was a reason to think Isaiah was town.

Yea I don't understand how victor thinks he can claim a power role and then hint at being vt. What makes victor immune to claiming after pressure?

Unvote vote victor

[SPARTACUS1974]

i still cant see him being a vt after all the fuss he made about not wanting to claim before and reveal his power so
vote victor

[Victor Sullivan]

Fine. I'll claim when I get home from work.

-Sully

[jak111]

Fine. I'll claim when I get home from work.

-Sully

You have approximately 7 hours from now, in which case I will hammer you.

[Victor Sullivan]

Fine. I'll claim when I get home from work.

-Sully

You have approximately 7 hours from now, in which case I will hammer you.

Alright, I'm here. I am Parrot, a mere Commuter, as I can fly away. I thought hinting at my being a power role might direct kill actions toward me, but it doesn't seem like I was very successful. I can only use my action every other night, thus why I didn't use my action Night 2. I won't be able to 'commute' again until Night 5.

-Sully

[thehippo8]

Alright, I'm here. I am Parrot, a mere Commuter, as I can fly away. I thought hinting at my being a power role might direct kill actions toward me, but it doesn't seem like I was very successful. I can only use my action every other night, thus why I didn't use my action Night 2. I won't be able to 'commute' again until Night 5.

-Sully

There are two meanings to commuter.

The Redirector (also known as the Commuter, Magnet, or Bus Driver) comes in several flavors: One has the option of choosing two targets each Night; any actions directed to target A happen to target B instead. Another targets two players, and any actions take by target A happen to target B instead of the targets chosen by A. A third variant swaps targets between two players, so that anything targeting player A happens to player B and vice versa. The Redirector can have any alignment, though is more commonly scum, since scum can use the ability more usefully.

and

The Commuter is a role that "leaves Town" each Night, thus making them ineligible to be targeted by Night actions. By extension, they cannot use any Night actions they may have. Because they cannot use Night actions, almost all Commuters are pro-Town. It is worth noting that because in flavor it physically leaves the game for the Night instead of being protected somewhere in Town, Commuter is considered the ultimate in Untargetability, trumping even things like Strongman. Most Commuters cannot Commute each Night. Instead, they generally have Odd-Night or Even-Night modifiers attached. Alternatively, they may be X-Shot and need to choose if they want to Commute each Night. Commuter blends all the strongest aspects of Bulletproof and Ascetic. It is futile to target them at all while they commute. However, the only roles that may be helpful if they targeted the Commuter are investigative, so in all other cases, Commuter is strong and difficult to use improperly. Commuter is not an implausible scum fakeclaim, as it explains immunity to kills and (occasionally) blocked actions. If you are an X-Shot Commuter, keep this in mind.

So we either believe he's the second type (which are rarely scum but can't be ruled out and a really good fake-claim) or he's the first type (which kind-of explains some things and frankly isn't entirely convincing). I'm not prepared to take a risk personally because it's all just too convenient. Also, flavour-wise, the first is more likely to be what the mod was thinking IMHO if true but I'd expect that the Captain's parrot on a pirate ship would be far more useful to the Captain that this so I can only assume that it's a little rotter and my vote stays.