Some7hingCLEVER wrote:isiah has been inactive except to ask sully if he was soft claiming or claiming which is something everyone was already asking and that was the first usefull thing ..actually the first thing he ever said since about page 29 and i can assume since he posted something on the last page he is watching (lurking?) putting one comment out every six pages and the comments dont do didly squat
sorry to bring this back up but im not seeing anything else to do and am extremely bored lol
Yea sorry, my wife ended up in the hospital last week, so I was only logging in to take my turns. I am almost caught up reading everything now.
Some7hingCLEVER wrote:isiah has been inactive except to ask sully if he was soft claiming or claiming which is something everyone was already asking and that was the first usefull thing ..actually the first thing he ever said since about page 29 and i can assume since he posted something on the last page he is watching (lurking?) putting one comment out every six pages and the comments dont do didly squat
sorry to bring this back up but im not seeing anything else to do and am extremely bored lol
Yea sorry, my wife ended up in the hospital last week, so I was only logging in to take my turns. I am almost caught up reading everything now.
VS is at L-4, kiwi didn't vote and we have 6 days until deadline. VS, I'm willing to have a stab at your role are you an a Apprentice (can learn the skill of any dead player). Link to the parrot been its copying.
NO PARROTS ON THIS SHIP!! ONLY MONKEYS!
War doesn't determine who's right; it determines who's left.
VS is at L-4, kiwi didn't vote and we have 6 days until deadline. VS, I'm willing to have a stab at your role are you an a Apprentice (can learn the skill of any dead player). Link to the parrot been its copying.
VS is at L-4, kiwi didn't vote and we have 6 days until deadline. VS, I'm willing to have a stab at your role are you an a Apprentice (can learn the skill of any dead player). Link to the parrot been its copying.
NO PARROTS ON THIS SHIP!! ONLY MONKEYS!
Are you a pirate's monkey? Or are we really playing One Piece the mafia. Would be totally epic by the way.
VS is at L-4, kiwi didn't vote and we have 6 days until deadline. VS, I'm willing to have a stab at your role are you an a Apprentice (can learn the skill of any dead player). Link to the parrot been its copying.
NO PARROTS ON THIS SHIP!! ONLY MONKEYS!
Are you a pirate's monkey? Or are we really playing One Piece the mafia. Would be totally epic by the way.
I aren't a pirate's monkey but its my PR with my monkey related role.
War doesn't determine who's right; it determines who's left.
Okay, I'm not defending Sully, but he's a parrot. My bet is he's a third party survivor, or a Watcher. Either way, I think the group is moving in the wrong direction.
My suspicions are still on Kiwi. I've read her posts for the game over, and almost all of them either involve her saying that she's sitting back and figuring things out, or she's pointing out inactives...of which she is not very active. Yet, somehow, she continues to skate by without adding anything to this game.
I understand Sully isn't adding anything either, so if that's the way the vote goes, fine. Let's just not lose sight of Kiwi in all this.
Okay, I'm not defending Sully, but he's a parrot. My bet is he's a third party survivor, or a Watcher. Either way, I think the group is moving in the wrong direction.
My suspicions are still on Kiwi. I've read her posts for the game over, and almost all of them either involve her saying that she's sitting back and figuring things out, or she's pointing out inactives...of which she is not very active. Yet, somehow, she continues to skate by without adding anything to this game.
I understand Sully isn't adding anything either, so if that's the way the vote goes, fine. Let's just not lose sight of Kiwi in all this.
Neb
I asked about one person who had gone inactive after they had been quite active. I'm not sure how I am acting scummy. In the beginning, I didnt vote because I was waiting to see what happened after Isaiah's investigation. I did not vote for TeeGee. Not sure how you are being anymore involved in the game than I. Should I count your posts? Further, should I anally pick apart what you have said? Think you should be looking elsewhere.
Okay, I'm not defending Sully, but he's a parrot. My bet is he's a third party survivor, or a Watcher. Either way, I think the group is moving in the wrong direction.
My suspicions are still on Kiwi. I've read her posts for the game over, and almost all of them either involve her saying that she's sitting back and figuring things out, or she's pointing out inactives...of which she is not very active. Yet, somehow, she continues to skate by without adding anything to this game.
I understand Sully isn't adding anything either, so if that's the way the vote goes, fine. Let's just not lose sight of Kiwi in all this.
Neb
I asked about one person who had gone inactive after they had been quite active. I'm not sure how I am acting scummy. In the beginning, I didnt vote because I was waiting to see what happened after Isaiah's investigation. I did not vote for TeeGee. Not sure how you are being anymore involved in the game than I. Should I count your posts? Further, should I anally pick apart what you have said? Think you should be looking elsewhere.
I suggest you go back and actually read my posts. I'm a little biased, but my contributions outweigh yours by far. I'm at least giving something for town to think about. I'm not afraid to make a case, right or wrong, on someone. Your posts have lacked any real substance...a common tactic for mafia, so that they don't raise any suspicions against them. It just doesn't make sense to me why you are calling others out for inactivity, when your posts basically add up to nothing much...the same as an inactive person. And you also say "you're sitting back and reading"...how does that help the town? Remember, I have no idea who you are...and there's no way you're convincing me you're town. If you think "you should be looking elsewhere." is a good solid defense, then you're not understanding the game.
new guy1 wrote:oh, well in that case, vote no survivors as he is innactive... apparently. sorry again, i would not know, ive had to catch up on many games and so have lost track of activity levels.
fastposted- idk if this is correct, but he either watches someone and sees who they visit, or he watches someone and sees who they visit (im assuming it is the first one and the second is a watcher, but thats what im confused on.).
heyyoooooooo found another inactive lol this is the most recent thing of substance that new guy has given us this was feb. 28 about 15 real days i see that he has posted but really nothing of real value i think he should say something FOS new guy
i agree sully could be 3rd party or town so i dont think there is any need to pressure just yet with what jonty has said about the parrot role and we can check him out at night. use isasaih if he town we will get the info. i know i been under active the last few days sorry all been busy at work but all good now .
but looking at recent posts there are quite a few others that are sitting back and waiting so i think we should apply a little presure to those .
SPARTACUS1974 wrote:i agree sully could be 3rd party or town so i dont think there is any need to pressure just yet with what jonty has said about the parrot role and we can check him out at night. use isasaih if he town we will get the info. i know i been under active the last few days sorry all been busy at work but all good now .
but looking at recent posts there are quite a few others that are sitting back and waiting so i think we should apply a little presure to those .
I just had a guess at his role. He could be linked with an amnesiac watcher or similar
War doesn't determine who's right; it determines who's left.
Finally finished reading through everything, and am wondering why Sully half-claimed without any pressure?? SO I am going to place my vote on Sully. Something seems fishy about him.
Finally finished reading through everything, and am wondering why Sully half-claimed without any pressure?? SO I am going to place my vote on Sully. Something seems fishy about him.
SPARTACUS1974 wrote:i agree sully could be 3rd party or town so i dont think there is any need to pressure just yet with what jonty has said about the parrot role and we can check him out at night. use isasaih if he town we will get the info. i know i been under active the last few days sorry all been busy at work but all good now .
but looking at recent posts there are quite a few others that are sitting back and waiting so i think we should apply a little presure to those .
I just had a guess at his role. He could be linked with an amnesiac watcher or similar
yea i agree i just been looking at similar roles and the parrot may be able to talk to the captain about what he hears or see's at night ?
suggest you go back and actually read my posts. I'm a little biased, but my contributions outweigh yours by far. I'm at least giving something for town to think about. I'm not afraid to make a case, right or wrong, on someone. Your posts have lacked any real substance...a common tactic for mafia, so that they don't raise any suspicions against them. It just doesn't make sense to me why you are calling others out for inactivity, when your posts basically add up to nothing much...the same as an inactive person. And you also say "you're sitting back and reading"...how does that help the town? Remember, I have no idea who you are...and there's no way you're convincing me you're town. If you think "you should be looking elsewhere." is a good solid defense, then you're not understanding the game.
Sergeant 1st Class Nebuchadnezer
Posts: 0 Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2012 10:26 pm Medals: 1 Standard Achievement (1)
neb, if YOU would actually go back and read my post; I had inquired about one person, that had been previously quite active. On day one I felt that when everyone wanted to lynch someone, I did not think it was enough to put a vote one someone. It was then decided that Isaiah would track someone at night. Further, I am unclear how biased opinions are helpful. From what I have learned, thoughtful and unbiased decisions ensure better outcomes. You are on a witch hunt! That would surely be one tactic that mafia would use...creating an emotional biased opinion upon someone that there is no clear evidence against.
Finally finished reading through everything, and am wondering why Sully half-claimed without any pressure?? SO I am going to place my vote on Sully. Something seems fishy about him.
Lol...didn't you do the SAME thing?
Not really, i half claimed at first, then came out and fully claimed.
SPARTACUS1974 wrote:yea i agree i just been looking at similar roles and the parrot may be able to talk to the captain about what he hears or see's at night ?
The parrot may talk to scum on what the captain says as well.
i agree with that judgement. That just knowing that one is a parrot is not enough, which side that one works for is...and that is a good question that needs to be addressed and responded to.
isaiah40 wrote:Okay Sully time to fess up!! Who are you working for, town or scum!??
Oaky Isaiah40, time to play more games with sully. In not one game have I ever seen him NOT soft claim his role. He is obviously the parrot, I would bet my own role on it. The parrot in EVERY MOVIE/BOOK is with the captain. And almost every time I can remember, the parrot actually exposes the killers. Though I would not clasify it as a watcher I would more willingly go with a cop. I believe this case should be dropped, how could a parrot actually kill someone? Plus, in the game overview, it clearly states that the mafia got on at the last stop. The parrot would have been here at the beginning of the storyline, and that is that.
isaiah40 wrote:Okay Sully time to fess up!! Who are you working for, town or scum!??
Oaky Isaiah40, time to play more games with sully. In not one game have I ever seen him NOT soft claim his role. He is obviously the parrot, I would bet my own role on it. The parrot in EVERY MOVIE/BOOK is with the captain. And almost every time I can remember, the parrot actually exposes the killers. Though I would not clasify it as a watcher I would more willingly go with a cop. I believe this case should be dropped, how could a parrot actually kill someone? Plus, in the game overview, it clearly states that the mafia got on at the last stop. The parrot would have been here at the beginning of the storyline, and that is that.
SPARTACUS1974 wrote:
isaiah40 wrote:Okay Sully time to fess up!! Who are you working for, town or scum!??
lmao as if he gonna say he is scum the parrot will be town
Sully, does have a habit of fakeclaiming his role, and FTR he didn't in the first Official game, slightly off topic there. But what guarantee is the parrot town. He could be mafia and peck his target to death. And I've never seen a pirate film where the parrot rumbles the killers (I haven't seen many pirate films) but the point is the how is a swab scummy. He's just a low-ranked sailor. He could have very easily being VT and therefore the parrot could very easily be scum. If VS flips scum look into these two guys.
War doesn't determine who's right; it determines who's left.
