Yo Ho, A Pirate's Life! [2/16] Endgame: Pirates Win!

[TeeGee]

yea your right he is active in our other games so where are ya ghostly?

unvote vote ghostly

Come play with us ghostly.. we have rum

unvote vote ghostly

[TeeGee]

EBWOP

yea your right he is active in our other games so where are ya ghostly?

unvote vote ghostly

Come play with us ghostly.. we have rum

unvote vote ghostly

Let me make that Bold

unvote vote ghostly[/quote]

[thehippo8]

Yoohoo, are you there ghostly?

unvote: vote ghostly

[jak111]

just curious, but are there equal numbers of mafia: town? I'm still trying to figure out who is who and if one can assume they are equal that may help me. glad to hear that you are around Tee Gee.

I think I read somewhere that the mafia:town rate is usually around 25-35%

Also
Unvote Vote ghostly

As jak said, unlike NoS who is seemingly inactive across the board, ghostly has this more sketchy activity to his name!

Well, I said NoSurvivors IS active as well, just not in this one, so we have both of them to lynch.

Unvote, Vote Ghostly
Might as well get one of them out of the way first.

[jak111]

Hopefully if the others are bothering keeping up with the current posts, perhaps we can put them BOTH at L1?

[SPARTACUS1974]

not sure we want them at l1 just yet that gives scum a chance to kill then say they made a mistake lol.
but i agree we should be working on both of them they are active just not in here.

[crazymilkshake5]

Wow, 5 posts in a row voting for Ghostly, idk if i should switch or not... I honestly dont see a reason to, they both havnt been active , so ... ... ... ... ... ... .... ... .... ... .... ... ... ya, ill keep my note on NoS. dont want to put ghostly at i think it would be l2

[ghostly447]

Hey guys, I am here. Sorry for my recent inactivity. I really have no reason for it besides I am in the process of getting lynched in another game, so it took priority in trying to defend myself. I will reread and try to post something of substance tonight.

Again, sorry.

[Leehar]

just curious, but are there equal numbers of mafia: town? I'm still trying to figure out who is who and if one can assume they are equal that may help me. glad to hear that you are around Tee Gee.

I think I read somewhere that the mafia:town rate is usually around 25-35%

Also
Unvote Vote ghostly

As jak said, unlike NoS who is seemingly inactive across the board, ghostly has this more sketchy activity to his name!

Well, I said NoSurvivors IS active as well, just not in this one, so we have both of them to lynch.

Unvote, Vote Ghostly
Might as well get one of them out of the way first.

In another mafia tho? I'm still fine with voting NoS, but since he quit in another mafia game, I thought it'd be better if we got a replacement for him that is actually active?

Hey guys, I am here. Sorry for my recent inactivity. I really have no reason for it besides I am in the process of getting lynched in another game, so it took priority in trying to defend myself. I will reread and try to post something of substance tonight.

Again, sorry.

Well now you're close to getting lynched in both games so see where it got you

Also, cms made a nice point. While I applaud everybody in thinking our cases are so great that they're worth following on, it'll only hurt everyone's chances if all we're doing is just voting without offering much else since it essentially makes us all just sheep? Just something to remember for later on if all we've done is bandwagon from one vote train to the next, so even if you have little observations on scumtells you think others have dropped r anything, it's worth mentioning!

[jonty125]

just curious, but are there equal numbers of mafia: town? I'm still trying to figure out who is who and if one can assume they are equal that may help me. glad to hear that you are around Tee Gee.

I think I read somewhere that the mafia:town rate is usually around 25-35%

Also
Unvote Vote ghostly

As jak said, unlike NoS who is seemingly inactive across the board, ghostly has this more sketchy activity to his name!

Well, I said NoSurvivors IS active as well, just not in this one, so we have both of them to lynch.

Unvote, Vote Ghostly
Might as well get one of them out of the way first.

In another mafia tho? I'm still fine with voting NoS, but since he quit in another mafia game, I thought it'd be better if we got a replacement for him that is actually active?

Hey guys, I am here. Sorry for my recent inactivity. I really have no reason for it besides I am in the process of getting lynched in another game, so it took priority in trying to defend myself. I will reread and try to post something of substance tonight.

Again, sorry.

Well now you're close to getting lynched in both games so see where it got you

Also, cms made a nice point. While I applaud everybody in thinking our cases are so great that they're worth following on, it'll only hurt everyone's chances if all we're doing is just voting without offering much else since it essentially makes us all just sheep? Just something to remember for later on if all we've done is bandwagon from one vote train to the next, so even if you have little observations on scumtells you think others have dropped r anything, it's worth mentioning!

Well, I think TeeGee is definitely dropping scumtells: left, right and center with his bandwagoning. Worst I've seen for a long time. Anyway I believe there's enough pressure on ghostly what L- is he at?

[Leehar]

just 5 voted so far I think so -4?

[jak111]

just 5 voted so far I think so -4?

Yep, and NoS is at -5, I'm willing to hammer either of them since I brought both of their cases up, but I just need to see which the rest of you prefer, since NoS is not as active in the forums I think Ghostly is our main candidate... but not by much.. And Ghostly I am in that game as well and their FoS'ing me and voting on and off for us, you don't see me inactive in here. (Which no offense to the people in the other game, but they're one track minded and not worth really much of my time, I keep up with it and all, just still not worth it to me)

[jonty125]

I see little merit in both cases but I will vote whoever is needed to give town a majority.

[crazymilkshake5]

I see little merit in both cases but I will vote whoever is needed to give town a majority.

as will I, but for now i will keep my vote on NoS.

[Leehar]

Whoever we can get to crumble first looks like the best bet
Since ghostly's here and said he may be able to put up a defense, lets see what he has to say

[ghostly447]

just 5 voted so far I think so -4?

Yep, and NoS is at -5, I'm willing to hammer either of them since I brought both of their cases up, but I just need to see which the rest of you prefer, since NoS is not as active in the forums I think Ghostly is our main candidate... but not by much.. And Ghostly I am in that game as well and their FoS'ing me and voting on and off for us, you don't see me inactive in here. (Which no offense to the people in the other game, but they're one track minded and not worth really much of my time, I keep up with it and all, just still not worth it to me)

Did you seriously just say you would be willing to lynch me based off inactivity while I CLEARLY stated that I am busy in RL, and therefore that is why I was only active in 1 game? Just because I didnt post in here, doesnt mean I dont read it. If thats the case then you may as well vote victor out of all his games (except he cant post in any!) or maybe go after another person who doesnt post much.

Now, boiling down to my analysis of the last few pages, I believe the fishy things are:

Isaiah claiming...Twice.

Jak acted a little scummy by not explaining why he was voting sully, but I know how he feels. Sometimes even a joke wagon is needed to get conversation going (and it did). Also defended the case mentioned below.

Jonty I think may be mafia actually. Going back to page 17, he seemed to just about overkill the Jak case, but yet after reading it all I do not feel he accomplished anything in proving jaks guiltiness (if there is any). Just some nonsense and then even some vote counts (though I dont know why they are there besides to show the CLEVER put someone at L-1 which could have been a noob mistake). May be an interesting person to watch, because (though I hate to bring it back up): (found on Page 18 I believe) I think he was hinting that he MAY be a power role. So like a said, doc should consider protecting him, and watcher should consider watching him just in case mafia try any funny business anyways (plus the least that can happen is the watcher knows who the doctor is and has to stick their neck out to confirm the doctor)

b) if I'm not a power role, mafia can by a process of elimination have a smaller pool of people who can be power roles. I am not saying town should never claim. And they should claim when they reach L-2 through a case as they can be protected as its better than cop being protected than being lynched


Now, overall. I would be willing to bet that the jak v jonty case making was actually town v town arguments. Dont ask me why, it is something that triggers my brain, but just the way both of them went about handling the cases made against them, and in the making of their own, I just do not feel either are actually mafia.

Now I will add one last thing. I accomplished catching up on 17 and 18 (a hell of a lot of reading) and will continue to read, but I am analyzing as I go. Has sully dropped any hints as to his character yet as he normally does?

[soundman]

Vote count:

SPARTACUS1974
crazymilkshake5
isaiah40 - some7 - (L8)
thehippo8
Victor Sullivan
Some7hingCLEVER - isaiah - (L8)
TeeGee
new guy1
ghostly447 - Leehar, spartacus, Teegee, thehippo, jak111 - (L4)
NoSurvivors - CMS, new guy, Victor, Neb - (L5)
Gilligan
kiwi3
Leehar
jak111 - jonty - (L8)
jonty125
Nebuchadnezer

With 16 alive it takes 9 to make someone walk the plank.

Deadline: None yet. We'll see how this day goes.

[Gilligan]

soundman, please replace me. I don't have the time to commit to this game...

[soundman]

soundman, please replace me. I don't have the time to commit to this game...

Will do. Sorry to see you go.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Goodbye Gilligan
Ok so can everyone take a good look at Isiah
I'm the only one trying to apply pressure (sorry I've been in active)
Butt he still has his vote on me for 0 reason whatsoever
Apparently trying to make me look scum to save his booty (no pun intended)
he just does not sit right with me

[Some7hingCLEVER]

I guess I can back off since its the interest of town but im keeping my vote on him

[isaiah40]

This why I still have my vote on you some.

Well I have never seen someone do that
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT
Ok so if ur tracker town wouldnt vote for you considering town outnumbers mafia there is no need to lie so for this reason my vote stands

You still voted for me, which is still a little scummy to me. IMO, only mafia would want me lynched so that I could not track anyone at night. So for this reason my vote stays on you!

[Nebuchadnezer]

How did NoSurvivors go from L-2 to suddenly nobody notices him?

I hate to see inactives go down, but if he's inactive, let's just get him out. I pray he's not some power role like cop or doc, or he's really screwed us with his inactivity. Of course, he could still post something...

[isaiah40]

Oh and Some7hingCLEVER, you need to prove to me that you are not mafia other than saying

Apparently trying to make me look scum to save his booty

[ghostly447]

This why I still have my vote on you some.

Well I have never seen someone do that
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT
Ok so if ur tracker town wouldnt vote for you considering town outnumbers mafia there is no need to lie so for this reason my vote stands

You still voted for me, which is still a little scummy to me. IMO, only mafia would want me lynched so that I could not track anyone at night. So for this reason my vote stays on you!

I think he is more confused on if you are, or are not fake claiming since you DID claim twice.

And Isaiah, I love how you take stuff out of paragraphs that people write such as you did here.