PMC's Newbie Game. Mafia winz!

[sully800]

Also, keep in mind I wasn't protecting Ace. I just believed that he was town, and that turned out to be true. I thought that someone else might believe him and protect him so I chose not to become involved with him at all.

There were two ways I could see the first night playing out with Ace being a townie. 1) They leave him alive in the hopes that we lynch him on day two. I suppose you would have been convinced that he was mafia, but I and maybe others would believe that he was simply insane. 2) They try to lynch Ace since they knew more about him then anyone else

I thought case 2 was more likely, and I also thought/hoped the doctor would protect Ace and therefore cancel the first night kill.

Speaking of which...both of ye doctors: Who DID you protect on night one and why? You each told us who you protected last night but not the first night, and I'm curious.

[Mr. Squirrel]

I tried to protect Ace. I never knew what happened, only that he died anyway.

Suspect, why haven't you claimed yet? You keep demanding everyone else's claims but you are unwilling to share your own. You say you don't want to "put you foot in your mouth", are you saying you don't want to look scummy?

[Simon Viavant]

So you're advocating everyone to claim now squirrelly? Obviously a conspiracy.

[sully800]

So you're advocating everyone to claim now squirrelly? Obviously a conspiracy.

suspect advocated that just a few posts earlier, and was the first to do so.

By this point I don't think we have much to lose by not claiming. I mean, you have a funny but somewhat worthless role Simon. My role COULD be useful I suppose, but I haven't found a situation yet where I did anything or thought I was going to do much of anything. Even if I managed to pick the person who was going to be lynched it would only be helpful if my other pick was mafia. We both have roles that are helpful only with random chance.

Doctors and cops I would prefer not to claim until day 2 or 3, but in this game we seem to have done they opposite and they were all the first ones to start shouting.

[The Fuzzy Pengui]

Vote Count

falko 1 - (simon)
neanderpual 1 - (falko)

Not Voting: Sully, Stroop, Mr. Squirrel, Suspect

Sorry...I know I'm dead and shouldn't be talking, but this is the second time you have written the vote count without including neanderpaul1 in the "Not Voting" category. I've been trying to figure out who the 7th person was (because I saw 2 voting and 4 not), and then noticed it was him. Just figured you may want to add it now to keep from confusion later.

[sully800]

Vote Count

falko 1 - (simon)
neanderpual 1 - (falko)

Not Voting: Sully, Stroop, Mr. Squirrel, Suspect

Sorry...I know I'm dead and shouldn't be talking, but this is the second time you have written the vote count without including neanderpaul1 in the "Not Voting" category. I've been trying to figure out who the 7th person was (because I saw 2 voting and 4 not), and then noticed it was him. Just figured you may want to add it now to keep from confusion later.

I think it is okay to post corrections from the grave. Can't imagine why that would upset anyone!

[pmchugh]

Vote Count

falko 2 - (simon, neanderpaul)
neanderpual 1 - (falko)

Not Voting: Sully, Stroop, Mr. Squirrel, Suspect

Cheers for the correction fuzzy, even thoguh your correction was wrong

[The Fuzzy Pengui]

Eh, we got that name up there; that's all that matters.

No problem, looking forward to your next game (and I promise...I won't delete my role PM this time)

[sully800]

Okay, I tried to go to sleep but I'm restless tonight.

I've had enough of this nonsense and I've come to a conclusion- I don't know what role stroop and suspect are, but I find it highly unlikely that they are working together with neanderpaul as a group of mafia. It just doesn't fit with the way this game has developed. I have a continual instinct that neanderpaul is the real doctor and therefore falko and squirrel have been lying to us all along. Time to get down to it and actually trust my instincts.

vote falko

[neanderpaul14]

Now this is just sad. You are still gonna claim that these were faked when you compare his language to mine?

Let's compare here. This is an example of my post in this thread:

I'm now very conflicted. I would like to switch my vote over to you to put some pressure there, but i also think my vote should stay on CW since until now he has done very little. I guess I'll change it for now, since my vote hasn't gotten in any more activity out of CW in the last two pages anyway.

And here is me in a PM:

I admit that suspect is acting pretty scummy, but I think fuzzy is even more scummy. For starters, he was very confused with his role. His role is very simple so I find it hard that he would have gotten it confused if that was his actual role. Plus, you were at L-2 at one point. The people voting for you were simon, sully, and fuzzy. The mafia could have easily lynched you at that point, unless two (or more?) of their members were already in on the bandwagon. This means that even if we guessed randomly there is at least a 66% chance that fuzzy is scum. That, coupled with his recent behavior makes me believe that he should be the next target for our lynch.

Notice how I speak well and use plenty of transitions to make my writing flow fairly smoothly. Now let's look at Falko's post in this thread:

Besides, since it's probably that the early lynchs can be townies, this is not bad per se to town, since it's utter worthy information in further days. I played a game where the first 2 days were lynched town, but the town could win in d3 because is easy to find scum. I say that not because it's bwouled be an ideal scenario, but to show that a lynch is the only way to town to win, no matter the mislynchs.

I bolded some of the grammatical errors not because I'm trying to be a grammar nazi, but to point out his writing style. Here is his PM now:

My second conclusion is about what you just tell me. That you actually protected Ace last night but he was killed anyway. I only can see one way, and the version of Simon makes sense. -you know, simon has claimed that he is an paranoid gun owner- as the only way to get Ace killed. Probably scum tried to kill him, but since you protect him, he wasn't "murdered" by scum. But if he tried to investigate simon, he could received a bullet an that's it.

There you go. Same writing style. Same grammatical errors. If you still deny it at this point, you are just being arrogant and making yourself look stupid. I hope the other townies notice your desperation here and finally make a move against you.

And, Falko, I'm not trying to insult your grasp of the English language by bolding your errors. I understand it isn't your first language and I find the fact that you write it so well very surprising. I've been taking Spanish lessons for four years and I still get lost when talking to actual Spanish speakers.

I don't deny that they were well faked PMs, I'm assuming you wrote the ones supposedly from you and Falko wrote those apparently from him. I'm just saying they are 100% FAKE

Squirrel and Falko are both SCUM and are in cahoots the PMs are entirely fabricated to throw suspicion away from them.

Also Squirrel claimed earlier that Falko was a proven townie. I asked him about this and he failed to respond.

[Stroop]

vote falko - I can believe that there are two doctors, just like there were two cops. One of the doctors is probably weak or has some other problem with their ability that they aren't aware of. The extra nurse is too much and it is not uncommon that one of two masons is scum.

As for my role; I am a bulletproof townie.

[pmchugh]

Vote Count

falko 4 - (simon, neanderpaul, sully, stroop)
neanderpual 1 - (falko)

Not Voting: Sully, Stroop, Mr. Squirrel, Suspect

That's a lynch!

Falko couldn't understand, why did everyone suspect her and her handsome husband? They had done no wrong thought falko and this man claiming to be a doctor when I know it's my husband who is the doctor! But the crowd gathered round and shouted abuse and the frail young women. They came to a descision and falko screamed for her life as Stroop hamemred her head in with a hammer. Mrs. Squirrel has been lynched!

Mr. Squirrel seen the savish crowd rip apart his beloved wife, he tried to cry but tears weren't enough for his agony. He realised that this was all his own fault, he had done the killings and his wife had died for him! He couldn't stand the pain so he went back to his house, got out his gun and pulled the trigger. Mr. Squirrel has suicided!

falkomagno, Nurse/ Naive Lover is dead!
Mr. Squirrel, Assasain/Lover is dead!

Night 3

72 hours as per.

[Falkomagno]

wow¡¡¡¡¡....-says the death hollows here-....

Buuu...I'm gonna scare you...bad guys¡¡¡¡¡

[pmchugh]

Suspect awoke in the morning and felt something different in the air. He walked into the town centre and seen burning buildings and dead bodies, including that of his friend neanderpual wearing his white doctor's cloak. He spotted a face he recognised, it was Stroop. Stroop snatched simon's gun from him and pointed it at suspect. Sully let out a cackle, "Things are going to change arround here..."

Congratulations to Stroop (mafia flavour cop) and Sully800 (mafia busdriver) who have won.

Neanderpual (doctor) has been killed!

Suspect101 (roleblocker) and simon viavant (random PGO) have been endgamed!

Comments and night actions in a moment.

[Suspect101]

Suspect awoke in the morning and felt something different in the air. He walked into the town centre and seen burning buildings and dead bodies, including that of his friend neanderpual wearing his white doctor's cloak. He spotted a face he recognised, it was Stroop. Stroop snatched simon's gun from him and pointed it at suspect. Sully let out a cackle, "Things are going to change arround here..."

Congratulations to Stroop (mafia flavour cop) and Sully800 (mafia busdriver) who have won.

Neanderpual (doctor) has been killed!

Suspect101 (roleblocker) and simon viavant (random PGO) have been endgamed!

Comments and night actions in a moment.

hummm....... i must have be bus drived because I roleblocked stroop.

[sully800]

hummm....... i must have be bus drived because I roleblocked stroop.

Yep! We finally switched the right people at the right time. Looks like our original guess was correct (we thought you were a roleblocker after night 1).

Then stroop found a white cloak which actually belonged to neanderpaul...we thought it meant you were a white mage!

Good game all, that was fun

[pmchugh]

Night Actions:

Night 1
fuzzy tracked ace (switched to falkomagno)
suspect blocked stroop
aceatremis investigated suspect
sully switched aceartemis and falkomagno
stroop investigates suspect (BLOCKED)
mr squirrel killed falkomagno (switched to ace)
neanderpual protected mr. squirrel

Night 2
neanderpaul protected sully800
suspect101 blocked mr. squirrel
sully switched suspect and neanderpual
mr squirrel killed neanderpaul (Switched to suspect) (BLOCKED)
stroop investigated suspect (swtiched to neanderpual)

Night 3
sully switched stroop and suspect
stroop killed neanderpaul.
suspect blocked stroop (switched to suspect) (blocked)
neanderpaul protected stroop (switched to suspect)

First off I would like to say sorry to town I think it was a little unbalanced since falko ended up being pretty much in scum and mafia busdriver is too powerful. Well done to suspect who picked out scum to roleblock every night (stroop,mr. squirrel, stroop). I think everyone did well, activity could have been higher but apart from that there were no cock ups.

And I would like to say for future refrence do not quote pm's from fellow players, sorry for forgetting to put this in the rules.

A few things I was trying to show you, don't always believe your role pm, if it says cop you could be insane/paranoid/naive you don't know. Same thing with falko being a naive lover (although I never told him that mr. squirrel was a doctor I think he just presumed it from his role).

I am going to make another for anyone that is intrested.

[Stroop]

sully switched suspect and neanderpual
stroop investigated suspect (swtiched to neanderpual)

I totally cocked up there... I wanted to know Suspect's role

Well played sully and Mr. Squirrel!

[Mr. Squirrel]

Same thing with falko being a naive lover (although I never told him that mr. squirrel was a doctor I think he just presumed it from his role).

Yea, I was incredibly surprised when he started calling me the doctor. I just ran with it, hoping that it would make him stand up for me later in the game. When neanderpaul claimed, my entire setup started falling apart. I also had to lie to my mafia members, saying that falko was actually bulletproof so that they didn't target him at night. I was trying to pull way too many strings this game and in the end it backfired.

Great game, PMC.

[Falkomagno]

yeah...I put to judge to town my role, since, it's doesn't really matter a mod kill by now

You are a Nurse Mason. You win when all threats to the town are eliminated.

Your mason partner and husband is Mr. Squirrel the two of you may communicate during the day and night. In addition to this you are also a Nurse. Should the Doctor die, you will take over his duties.

The doctor is allowed to protect one player at night and this player will not be able to be killed during that night, they may protect anyone but themselves. However you do not have this ability until the doctor dies.

Any questions feel free to ask, confrim in the signup thread and happy scum hunting!

so, it's just say that I had to protect Mr. Squirell, and been like a totally scum all he game defending an obvious scum. I could disagree with the Fuzzy penguin's lynch, but, what the hell.

Good game and congratulations to all. Pmc did a great job, a lil' unbalanced, to town, but we was terrible at lynching one cop, and get the second NKed anyway. When I see the neardenpaul claim, I was really surprising, what a shameless player I thought hahaha

[pmchugh]

Maybe I should have split up your pm a bit more.

And mafia why didn't you just win day 2? flako and mr. squirrel were both clearly voting NP and were not going to change you (stroop and sully) could have just made up a shitty excuse to vote him and won the game.

[Stroop]

Eh? Where did that happen?

[pmchugh]

Eh? Where did that happen?

Day 2 and all you would have to do during the night is avoid simon and not kill yourselves and you would of won.

Vote Count

falko 4 - (simon, neanderpaul, sully, stroop)
neanderpual 1 - (falko)

Ok squirrel hadn't voted yet but I am sure he would have done since he was scum aswell

[Stroop]

Pretty sure that is Day 3.

Mr. Squirrel never told us that he was a lover with Falko (or I just missed it), so I didn't know that lynching Falko would kill Squirrel too...

[Stroop]

On day 2 we killed The Fuzzy Pengui but our kill for the win that night was blocked.