Optimus Prime wrote:It seems like the fair and just solution is that if you earned a medal for graphics, gameplay, XML, or whatever in regards to a map, it should just count as a map contribution medal across the board. I say the best way to do it is to make your Top 5 list based on the total number of medals that person has, regardless of the reasoning behind why they got it in the first place. Map development incorporates many different aspects. With the graphic designer, it wouldn't look good, without the person to write the XML it wouldn't play at all because it literally wouldn't work.
Just my two cents.
Count the medals and go by that, don't make it overly complicated.
I agree with this. If someone has X amount of medals that should be what counts towards the total tally. I don't think it is my place, qwert place, or anyone elses place to decided what medals do and don't count for a member.
For mapmaking, the only two realistic ways of doing it are a) Mapmaking Medals, or b) Names on Maps.
Medals is easy to do, and makes most sense.
Names on maps.... you could include anybody who has their name on a map as a creator/signature/contributor/special thanks/territory name. For the most part this would likely be similar to the medals total, although gimil gets a mention on Madagascar, Wicked gets a mention on Madness, etc. etc. etc.
PB: 2661 | He's blue...If he were green he would die | No mod would be stupid enough to do that
Shrinky wrote:update top 5 to 4k points in terms of number of games. thai robert breached 4k sometime back and he is definitely one of the top 5 quickest in terms of games
I added him and mhennigan, ty, bad news is it knocks me off that list
gimil wrote:Widowmakers is on 20 medals. I do not think it is fair that qwert has 'decided' that those who made the classic shapes map don't get their medal counted. They put the work in and obviously admin decided they deserved it.
ok, how would you suggest it gimil?
It seems like the fair and just solution is that if you earned a medal for graphics, gameplay, XML, or whatever in regards to a map, it should just count as a map contribution medal across the board. I say the best way to do it is to make your Top 5 list based on the total number of medals that person has, regardless of the reasoning behind why they got it in the first place. Map development incorporates many different aspects. With the graphic designer, it wouldn't look good, without the person to write the XML it wouldn't play at all because it literally wouldn't work.
Just my two cents.
Count the medals and go by that, don't make it overly complicated.
well OP, this is what I was thinking and had in mind the 1st time I wanted to recognize all the map makers and their hard work and making CC awesome, but qwert disagreed, and i figured he knew more about maps then me obviously, but if a majority of you agree, then I will go by my original idea of most medals by map makers.
sounds like OP, andy, gimil, mr benn and others agree with this, so this is what i will do.
It will just take me some time to find the top 5 map makers with most medals, but I got a good list to start out with.
thank you all very much for posting your thoughts.
p.s. gimil, i luv your avatar
only if OP could find a great pic to post of her in hot and sexy
gimil wrote:Widowmakers is on 20 medals. I do not think it is fair that qwert has 'decided' that those who made the classic shapes map don't get their medal counted. They put the work in and obviously admin decided they deserved it.
ok, how would you suggest it gimil?
It seems like the fair and just solution is that if you earned a medal for graphics, gameplay, XML, or whatever in regards to a map, it should just count as a map contribution medal across the board. I say the best way to do it is to make your Top 5 list based on the total number of medals that person has, regardless of the reasoning behind why they got it in the first place. Map development incorporates many different aspects. With the graphic designer, it wouldn't look good, without the person to write the XML it wouldn't play at all because it literally wouldn't work.
Just my two cents.
Count the medals and go by that, don't make it overly complicated.
well OP, this is what I was thinking and had in mind the 1st time I wanted to recognize all the map makers and their hard work and making CC awesome, but qwert disagreed, and i figured he knew more about maps then me obviously, but if a majority of you agree, then I will go by my original idea of most medals by map makers.
sounds like OP, andy, gimil, mr benn and others agree with this, so this is what i will do.
It will just take me some time to find the top 5 map makers with most medals, but I got a good list to start out with.
thank you all very much for posting your thoughts.
p.s. gimil, i luv your avatar
only if OP could find a great pic to post of her in hot and sexy
I think Doing map makers is a great idea
IF YOU JOIN MULTIPLE OF MY 2 PLAYER GAMES AND FIND YOURSELF FOED IT IS ONLY TEMPORARY I AM ON A MEDAL HUNT.
-ASSASSIN07
Top 5 to 3K Score Fastest-Games 1. Jac99 76 2. Gibbom 80 3. SJUstickman 91 4. Thai Robert 109 5. Old Maxwell 112
Top 5 to 4K Score Fastest-Days 1. Skillerman 113 2. Blitzaholic 178 3. Prankcall 241 4. Fantasiasian 259 5. King Herpes 292 *
Top 5 to 4K Score Fastest-Games 1. Thai Robert 180 2. Mhennigan 338 3. Skillerman 373 4. Sjnap 670 5. Poo-maker 776
Top 5 to 5K Score Fastest-Days 1. King Herpes 322 * 2. Poo-maker 455 3. Skyt 475 * 4. Scott-land 554 5. Sjnap 680
Top 5 to 5K Score Fastest-Games 1. Sjnap 947 2. Poo-maker 1122 3. King Herpes 1231 * 4. Skyt 1737 * 5. Scott-land 3228
Top 5 Longest # 1 on Scoreboard-Days (Must be Active) 1. Blitzaholic 170 2. Sjnap 77 3. Pilate 39 4. Poo-maker 38 5. King Herpes 29 *
Top 5 Longest # 1 in Scoreboard-Games (Must be Active) 1. Blitzaholic 1045 2. Gibbom 121 3. Alstergren 79 4. Scott-land 77 5. Sjnap 73
Top 5 Most Points Won in One Game 1. Pimphawks70 700 1. H3ll0 gains 700 3. Owner1997 684 4. Lame 506 5. Stdboy 500 5. Benjij 500
Top 5 Largest Gap in Scoreboard Leads from 1st to 2nd (Must be with different Player) 1. King_Herpes* 1252--5824 over Rabbiton 4572 2. Blitzaholic 1120--4386 over Eye84free 3266 3. King_Herpes* 1054--5796 over Karelpietertje 4742 4. Blitzaholic 837--4121 over Jork 3284 5. Sjnap..... 805---5403 over Lt.Pie 4598
Top 5 Most Points off a Single Map 1. Magepluka 13937 2. Assassin07 8000 3. Scott-land 6421 4. AAfitz 5491 5. Lt.Pie 5436
Top 5 Members in Clan Point Average 1. Knights at the Round Table 3842 2. Legends of War 3829 3. The Spankin' Monki's 3667 4. The Horsemen of the Apocalypse 3551 5. Bullet Proof Bandits 3288
Top 5 Most Wins that hit 3K Score + 1. Johnnnyrocket24 9294 1. Blitzaholic 6591 2. Big Whiskey 4035 3. Dragon Dor 3026 4. David Wain 2962
II. 1st 5 + Top 5 Game Type Lists
1st 5 to Team in 500 Games Together 1. Eye84free + Ptlowe 2. Blitzaholic + Osujacket 3. Johnnyrocket24 + Dupa 4. David Wain + Nephilim 5. Eye84free + Cmeb4udie
1st 5 to Play 5000 Games 1. Johnnyrocket24 2. Clapper011 3. Hotdoggie 4. Julia Gulia 5. Paradicecity9
1st 5 to Win 100 Singles 6 Player Games 1. RL_Orange 2. Julia Gulia 3. Maniacmath17 4. Steve Monkey 5. Mbohn2
1st 5 to Win 100 Assassin Games 1. Julia Gulia 2. Paradicecity9 3. Hotdoggie 4. Firth4eva 5. Bigstevie36
1st 5 to Win 100 Terminator Games 1. Wacicha 2. Fireside Poet 3. Dixie 4. Glide 5. John1099
1st 5 to Win 500 Doubles Games 1. Eye84free 2. Eddymush 3. Cmeb4udie 4. David Wain 5. Alstergren
1st 5 to Win 1000 Doubles Games 1. Eye84free 2. David Wain 3. Cmeb4udie 4. Nephilim 5. Dividedbyzero
1st 5 to Win 500 Triples Games 1. Blitzaholic 2. Osujacket 3. Johnnyrocket24 4. Jork 5. Big Yuma Ripper
1st 5 to Win 1000 Triples Games 1. Johnnyrocket24 2. Blitzaholic 3. Osujacket 4. Dupa 5. Djt5483
1st 5 to Win 100 Quads Games 1. Blitzaholic 2. Xtratabasco 3. Hiddendragon 4. Big Whiskey 5. Osujacket
1st 5 to Win 300 Quads Games 1. Blitzaholic 2. Big Whiskey 3. Hiddendragon 4. Johnnyrocket24 5. Xtratabasco
1st 5 to Win 500 1 vs 1 Games 1. Fatharry 2. Johnnyrocket24 3. Benjikat 4. Blitzaholic 5. Paradicecity9
1st 5 to Win 3000 Games 1. Johnnyrocket24 2. Blitzaholic 3. Dupa 4. Clapper011 5. Fatharry
Top 5 Most Games Played 1. Johnnyrocket24 12118 2. Clapper011 10123 3. Paradicecity9 8999 4. Rbelgrod 8988 4. Fatharry 8821 5. Blitzaholic 8777
Top 5 to Team in Most Games Together 1. Fireside Poet + Dixie 1913 2. David Wain + Nephilim 1511 3. Blitzaholic + Big Whiskey 1358 4. Johnnyrocket24 + Dupa 1353 5. Blitzaholic + Osujacket 1325
III. 1st + Top 5 Foundry Lists
1st 5 Maps Made 1. Classic 1. USA 1. Asia 4. Middle East 5. Brazil
1st 5 to Play 50 Maps 1. Blitzaholic 2. Gilligan 3. David Wain 4. Aerial Attack 5. Cronus
1st 5 to Win 50 Maps 1. Blitzaholic 2. Aerial Attack 3. Benjikat is Dead 4. Cronus 5. Wild Tiger
1st 5 to Win 100 Maps 1. Benjikat is Dead 2. Gilligan 3. Barterer2002 4. Player57832 5. Amazzony
1st 5 to Win 100 Maps with 5 Kills on each Map 1. Benjikat is Dead 2. Player57832 3. Blitzaholic 4. Conquerace 5. Mobajobg
Top 5 Map Makers 1. Cairnswk 23 2. Widowsmaker 22 3. Yeti 12 4. DiM 9 5. Qwert 8
1st 5 to Receive a Special Contribution "Medal" 1st - wicked 2nd - Optimus Prime 3rd - yeti_c 4th -widowsmaker 5th -wacicha
V. 1st + Top 5 Tournament Lists
Total Tournaments by Type
1.Standard Tournaments:496 2. Doubles Tournaments:69 3. Terminator Tournaments:28 4. Sport League Tournaments:21 5. Triples Tournaments:19 5. Assassin Tournaments:18 7. Quads Tournaments:13 7. Large Team Tournaments:12 7. Fog of War Tournaments:12
Top 5 Tourney Winners 1. Killmanic 30 2. Blitzaholic 29 3. Godd 19 4. BaldAdonis 15 5 Big Whiskey 14 5. White Moose 14
Top 5 Tourney Organizers 1. Barterer2002 48 2. Optimus Prime 40 2. Blitzaholic 40 4. Natewolfman 38 5. Amazzony 34
when are they doing an update? been over a month
I lost track, I think I am in the process of winning my 30th and 31st tourney title, but my medals say I only won 23
Top 5 Tourney Winners 1. Blitzaholic 31 2. Killmanic 30 3. Godd 19 4. BaldAdonis 15 5 Big Whiskey 14 5. White Moose 14
Top 5 Tourney Organizers 1. Barterer2002 48 2. Optimus Prime 40 2. Blitzaholic 40 4. Natewolfman 38 5. Amazzony 34
when are they doing an update? been over a month
I lost track, I think I am in the process of winning my 30th and 31st tourney title, but my medals say I only won 23, and not sure why it copy and pasted all that above
Last edited by Blitzaholic on Sat Jun 13, 2009 4:58 pm, edited 1 time in total.
For mapmaking, the only two realistic ways of doing it are a) Mapmaking Medals, or b) Names on Maps.
Medals is easy to do, and makes most sense.
Names on maps.... you could include anybody who has their name on a map as a creator/signature/contributor/special thanks/territory name. For the most part this would likely be similar to the medals total, although gimil gets a mention on Madagascar, Wicked gets a mention on Madness, etc. etc. etc.
I reraly want to know why 6 people get medals for Classic Art,that why im not counting these medals,because its not fair for all others map makers, who for much biger job get max 2 medal. Ofcourse for yours CA Clan is good that nobody know who work what on these map. But i dont want to waste mine energy on you, Blitz do like CA and Andy say, because they every time correct, and again mine view is wrong(why im not supprised)
Top 5 Tourney Organizers 1. Barterer2002 48 2. Optimus Prime 40 2. Blitzaholic 40 4. Natewolfman 38 5. Amazzony 34
when are they doing an update? been over a month
I lost track, I think I am in the process of winning my 30th and 31st tourney title, but my medals say I only won 23, and not sure why it copy and pasted all that above
There is a bit of backlog with the hall of fame due to Gilligan finishing up his school semester. It will be taken care of in due time, you will just need to be patient.
Top 5 Tourney Organizers 1. Barterer2002 48 2. Optimus Prime 40 2. Blitzaholic 40 4. Natewolfman 38 5. Amazzony 34
when are they doing an update? been over a month
I lost track, I think I am in the process of winning my 30th and 31st tourney title, but my medals say I only won 23, and not sure why it copy and pasted all that above
There is a bit of backlog with the hall of fame due to Gilligan finishing up his school semester. It will be taken care of in due time, you will just need to be patient.
ty OP, I just took over 1st place with 31 tourney titles championships, may have 32 or 33 in a few more days
Big Whiskey wrote:up to 38 medals now-I have also been waiting over a month but like op said it will happen soon.So waiting on 6 new medals.
exactly, been over a month, i think 5 weeks now, I am not sure why gilligan is the only one that can update it? It is a lot of work and should be shared by 2 or 3 people. just my 2 cents
For mapmaking, the only two realistic ways of doing it are a) Mapmaking Medals, or b) Names on Maps.
Medals is easy to do, and makes most sense.
Names on maps.... you could include anybody who has their name on a map as a creator/signature/contributor/special thanks/territory name. For the most part this would likely be similar to the medals total, although gimil gets a mention on Madagascar, Wicked gets a mention on Madness, etc. etc. etc.
I reraly want to know why 6 people get medals for Classic Art,that why im not counting these medals,because its not fair for all others map makers, who for much biger job get max 2 medal. Ofcourse for yours CA Clan is good that nobody know who work what on these map. But i dont want to waste mine energy on you, Blitz do like CA and Andy say, because they every time correct, and again mine view is wrong(why im not supprised)
well qwert, I am trying to be open and fair here, I here your suggestion, but when gimil, op, ca, andy, mr.benn, etc. when a majority is saying give the map makers credit by medals, well, I just going with majority rules. again, I hear you qwert-validation, ok, and i do not know the map making details like you all, hence, this is why i asked other who are more experienced, most are saying go by the medals, if this is ok, I think I will do it this way, unless many others start objecting.
qwert wrote:I must say,that you must check very carefull who get medal for what. Rule is that only 2 medal can be awarded for creating a map,but in some cases(i think that these is not right) 6 people get medal for creating a map(Classic Art). Who realy deserve medal for work on these map,its still mistery for many map makers,except for these 6 people who know exactly who work what.These is not correct,and i will not count these medals. Also i think that you need to create new category-Top 5 XML Developers,because you now have in your list only people who not create any graphic on map,and work only in XML development(Yeti,C).These will be more correct.
I am not sure how they work that either, but I am sure they are being fair and honest.
XML Designer 1.Yeti_c-13 2.Coleman-8 3.Lanyard-3 4.Zimmah-3 5.High.Commander-2
I'm not sure you should split them out like this, as some mapmakers do their own XML...
mr.benn this was qwerts suggestion, i have not added this to page 1, I think I will be going by most medals, I just need to go thru and see who is top 5 more most medals for map making, or should I call it top 5 for Map Contributions?
It is a lot of work and should be shared by 2 or 3 people. just my 2 cents
