War of the Triple Cult (Day 6)

[Thezzaruz]

Seeing as kagetora is AWOL why don't we just save our mod th ehassle of finding a replacement and lynch him? I saw his name come up as a suspect a couple of times a while back.

About as bad an idea as you could possibly have come up with, almost went to the top of my "acting scummy" list tbh.

[pmchugh]

We kill a cult leader, we have crippled the cult. That is one less cult we have to worry about as the game goes on. There's always time to lynch Pmc Unvote Vote derf for acting scummy, and bandwagoning.
FoS Will for lurking.

I cannot believe you haven't been lynched yet, I can almost hear the desperation in your posts. Your motto atm is just "anyone but me" and even now you are still continuing with your bandwaggoning.

Lets see you had voted for me, derf and fos'd will in your last few posts.

Me- Because I suspected you and was on the list of three.
Will- Because he wasn't responding to accusations (which makes him an easy target) and he was on the list of three.
Derf- BANDWAGONING- lmao your just as bad as he is even worse IMO considering you are jumping on a wagon on him and are prepared to jump on will's or mine. Plus the reason your currently voting him is so that you don't eliminate another option dropping it to 50%.

You fit nearly all of your own criteria for scum, you even admitted you were a good lynch target, you've bandwaggoned before and during today and this all adds up to you being a cult leader. Even after that their is a 33% chance you were recruited last night. Your a perfect lynch target and the fact your not in claiming territory is one of life's greatest mysteries.

Okay people, we have like 3 or 4 targets for a lynch. Let's pick 1 and get enough votes on them so they have to actively defend themselves and we get some info..

I don't understand why sheep isn't clearly the favourite target.

He is my favorite target, but the town seems to be angling for william for some reason...

one other thought to throw into the ring here. Seeing as kagetora is AWOL why don't we just save our mod th ehassle of finding a replacement and lynch him? I saw his name come up as a suspect a couple of times a while back.

That is an absolutely horrible idea. His claim is almost confirmed so why would you advocating lynching what we almost for certain know to be a protown power role?

So your going to vote will off cause thats what everyone else thinks?

Can anyone please give a good reason why will is a better target? Cause he doesn't post as much, yeah cause posting scummy things is less suspicious than posting little, in that case why don't we just lynch the least active player every day?

[spiesr]

So your going to vote will off cause thats what everyone else thinks?

No, I am still voting for sheep and want him lynched.

FOS those trying to split the vote.

[captainwalrus]

Mabey pmc and sheep are in cahoots now and last night sheep recruited pmc. Just a random theory.

[william18]

Norsemans logic is terrible. No evidence except for that I don't post much. "O wait, I know, lets disregard the entire case on sheep and vote will, or better yet, kage!!! I know they won't be much of a hassle". I hope everyone see's my point here. Im so tempted to vote sheep right now but your spewing more nonsence then space did.


Vote Norse

[spiesr]

I don't know will, norse is acting goofy, but I think sheep is more likely to be cult at this point. Your vote for norse is maybe a little bit OMGUSy, and more important it is throwing votes off in yet another direction. While it is important to look at all possibilities, we will have to agree on a lynch today...

[spiesr]

Also will, is dark knight mafia going to go to day ever, or have you abandoned it?

[Haggis_McMutton]

We kill a cult leader, we have crippled the cult. That is one less cult we have to worry about as the game goes on. There's always time to lynch Pmc Unvote Vote derf for acting scummy, and bandwagoning.
FoS Will for lurking.

I cannot believe you haven't been lynched yet, I can almost hear the desperation in your posts. Your motto atm is just "anyone but me" and even now you are still continuing with your bandwaggoning.

Lets see you had voted for me, derf and fos'd will in your last few posts.

Me- Because I suspected you and was on the list of three.
Will- Because he wasn't responding to accusations (which makes him an easy target) and he was on the list of three.
Derf- BANDWAGONING- lmao your just as bad as he is even worse IMO considering you are jumping on a wagon on him and are prepared to jump on will's or mine. Plus the reason your currently voting him is so that you don't eliminate another option dropping it to 50%.

You fit nearly all of your own criteria for scum, you even admitted you were a good lynch target, you've bandwaggoned before and during today and this all adds up to you being a cult leader. Even after that their is a 33% chance you were recruited last night. Your a perfect lynch target and the fact your not in claiming territory is one of life's greatest mysteries.

I've got to agree, that last vote switch of his was pretty ridiculous.
Vote sheep

Also, didn't norse claim he had some experience with the game? In that case his trying to vote for kage seems even harder to explain.

[Stroop]

We kill a cult leader, we have crippled the cult. That is one less cult we have to worry about as the game goes on. There's always time to lynch Pmc Unvote Vote derf for acting scummy, and bandwagoning.

unvote vote sheep for acting scummy, bandwagoning and having a higher chance of being cult than derf...

[sheepofdumb]

I guess it's the price I pay for being active.

Claim time.

I'm an investigator that searches for cult stuff. I checked out pmc last night, kage night 1, and Stroop night 2. Kage and Stroop didn't turn out anything but I found some cult stuff on Pmc. I can guarantee a cult lynch with him.

[sheepofdumb]

Almost forgot. I didn't want to come out just yet because I have no protection against cults. The longer I could remain hidden the more results I could get. Unvote vote Pmc.

[Suspect101]

I am going to be a replacement for this game. I have been reading/following most of this game so I should not have that much reading to do. Once I get my roll, I will make a comment. Good luck!

[spiesr]

I'm an investigator that searches for cult stuff. I checked out pmc last night, kage night 1, and Stroop night 2. Kage and Stroop didn't turn out anything but I found some cult stuff on Pmc. I can guarantee a cult lynch with him.

Questions.
1. Do you work against all cults or just one color?
2. Is your role the same as animorpher's or completely different?
3, If you knew pmc to be cult, why did you change your vote to derfderf recently? I mean, If I knew someone was cult, I would try to get them lynched, not start up the case against someone I wasn't sure about...

[pmchugh]

I guess it's the price I pay for being active.

Claim time.

I'm an investigator that searches for cult stuff. I checked out pmc last night, kage night 1, and Stroop night 2. Kage and Stroop didn't turn out anything but I found some cult stuff on Pmc. I can guarantee a cult lynch with him.

lol awful claim.

You claimed the same role as mpjh. Day 2 we nearly lynched stroop because he investigated him and found him to have cult stuff in his house. So if you investigated him night 2 you would have got the same result. kage also is a power role so the same thing might have happened there if you were telling the truth.

Then the fact you find me guilty, meaning you can divert the lynch to me instead is a clear claiming strategy.

Then after that theirs the fact you said:

Ok, I have a role that allowed me to search Stroop's house last night. He keeps cult stuff in his home. I voted for him because of his earlier contradictory statements and because of what I saw during the search.

That seems like a bit deeper search than you see in most games. If stroop turns out not to be cult you are the first person I'm voting for. I wasn't sure about stroop at all mostly because I saw his no lynch vote as him just kidding around. He has since gotten more serious with the game. Is there really anything other than the no lynch vote? I haven't really seen anything.

Basically saying you are supicious of the claim you just made .

unvote sheep vote sheep for emphesis.

[Stroop]

I guess it's the price I pay for being active.

Claim time.

I'm an investigator that searches for cult stuff. I checked out pmc last night, kage night 1, and Stroop night 2. Kage and Stroop didn't turn out anything but I found some cult stuff on Pmc. I can guarantee a cult lynch with him.

According to mpjh, I had cult stuff; you would have gotten a cult result on me night 2.

[Natewolfman]

I am going to be a replacement for this game. I have been reading/following most of this game so I should not have that much reading to do. Once I get my roll, I will make a comment. Good luck!

Suspect101 replaces kage!

please continue

[norsemsn1066]

Hey william............nice tit-for tat vote there guy. Also a very good way to wast a vote and miss an oppertunity to get an actual scum and not a vanillager.

I must have missed the claim by kage in my reading. I will have to go back a check again. maybe I missed a page of posts while reading. That is unless someone will quote said post for me.

Acting goofy????? That\s a laugh...........I\m trying to lite a fire under you guys to actually 'play' and I get this kind of response? It's no wonder to me why the Mods of the games on this site and Mafiascum.net are always looking for replacemenets for games. Anyone that has a different style or philosophy about how to play is auto scum to you folks. Your way to rigid in the way you go about this. LAL works but is not always a good waay to go about this.

Now that sheep has claimd I think I'll take this oppertunity to
UNVOTE

I\'ll wait to see what you guys do first as I'm acting 'goofy'

[Suspect101]

This game would be a lot better to jump into if mpjh did not erase all the posts he made.

I guess it's the price I pay for being active.

Claim time.

I'm an investigator that searches for cult stuff. I checked out pmc last night, kage night 1, and Stroop night 2. Kage and Stroop didn't turn out anything but I found some cult stuff on Pmc. I can guarantee a cult lynch with him.

According to mpjh, I had cult stuff; you would have gotten a cult result on me night 2.

This does not have to be true. From reading the posts it seems that investigators can only detect 1 color, so if they are blind to your color, he would find nothing on you, but someone else could. But I cannot trust mpjh’s claim or posts.

Question for the mod. If you become cult, but are not the leader, what happens to you once the cult leader is dead? Do you go back to town or what?

The reason I bring this up is If we believe SHEEP and PMC is cult but not cult leader, maybe we can get PMC to rat out the leader by forcing a lynch on him.

So we can do a few things, get PMC to rat, and lynch who he says. If that person is not who he says, lynch him.
OR lynch PMC and if he is not who sheep says, lynch sheep.

This is all based on if PMC will return to the town side if he is not the cult leader.

[spiesr]

To clarify the thing that you were doing that was goofy was:
Voting for some who has claimed to be and is accept as a critical pro-town power role. This who said that you did so because they were not posting. That person has not logged in since Feb 15. He is clearly not just submarining and voting for he won't cause him to post. So you were advocating the lynch of a essentially confirmed pro-town power who was played by someone who has left the site and was going to be replaced, but you said we should lynch him instead. That is goofy.

[spiesr]

This game would be a lot better to jump into if mpjh did not erase all the posts he made.

Yes

This does not have to be true. From reading the posts it seems that investigators can only detect 1 color, so if they are blind to your color, he would find nothing on you, but someone else could. But I cannot trust mpjh’s claim or posts.

Actually I don't believe sheep claimed to be color based. He seemed to just be able to search out if some one was in a cult at all.

This is all based on if PMC will return to the town side if he is not the cult leader.

I don't believe that to be how it will work.

[Suspect101]

This game would be a lot better to jump into if mpjh did not erase all the posts he made.

Yes

This does not have to be true. From reading the posts it seems that investigators can only detect 1 color, so if they are blind to your color, he would find nothing on you, but someone else could. But I cannot trust mpjh’s claim or posts.

Actually I don't believe sheep claimed to be color based. He seemed to just be able to search out if some one was in a cult at all.

This is all based on if PMC will return to the town side if he is not the cult leader.

I don't believe that to be how it will work.

ok, well throw my theory in the trash then. lol!!

[william18]

Also will, is dark knight mafia going to go to day ever, or have you abandoned it?

I never abandone my games. I just don't have that much time on comp. I'll post scene today.

[sheepofdumb]

Ok, I have a role that allowed me to search Stroop's house last night. He keeps cult stuff in his home. I voted for him because of his earlier contradictory statements and because of what I saw during the search.

That seems like a bit deeper search than you see in most games. If stroop turns out not to be cult you are the first person I'm voting for. I wasn't sure about stroop at all mostly because I saw his no lynch vote as him just kidding around. He has since gotten more serious with the game. Is there really anything other than the no lynch vote? I haven't really seen anything.

Basically saying you are supicious of the claim you just made .

unvote sheep vote sheep for emphesis.

Good job pmc, you caught me in my lie. I'm Red cult leader. My cult members gain powers. Yesterday it was killing and the day before that it was investigation. Night two I investigated Will and found him to be immune to recruitment. Therefore, PMC IS CULT. I guarantee it. So I'll cut the town a deal. If you let me live I will help hunt cult. At the end of the game I will give you the names of all my cult members and town can win. Take it or not it's up to you.

[pmchugh]

Ok, I have a role that allowed me to search Stroop's house last night. He keeps cult stuff in his home. I voted for him because of his earlier contradictory statements and because of what I saw during the search.

That seems like a bit deeper search than you see in most games. If stroop turns out not to be cult you are the first person I'm voting for. I wasn't sure about stroop at all mostly because I saw his no lynch vote as him just kidding around. He has since gotten more serious with the game. Is there really anything other than the no lynch vote? I haven't really seen anything.

Basically saying you are supicious of the claim you just made .

unvote sheep vote sheep for emphesis.

Good job pmc, you caught me in my lie. I'm Red cult leader. My cult members gain powers. Yesterday it was killing and the day before that it was investigation. Night two I investigated Will and found him to be immune to recruitment. Therefore, PMC IS CULT. I guarantee it. So I'll cut the town a deal. If you let me live I will help hunt cult. At the end of the game I will give you the names of all my cult members and town can win. Take it or not it's up to you.

Haha your desperation is ridiculous, you just want to take me down with you because I caught you out.

You heard him he's the red cult leader he even admitted it. If your powers were killing yesterday then why did no-one die?

[spiesr]

Well, I think that the cult leader needs to be lynched today as if we let him live any longer he will get another recruit. (Not certain that he would succeed, but it is too great a risk) The real investigator may consider looking at pmc tonight (maybe will too?)
Do we think sheep told the truth about will being unrecognizable? If so that could mean will is cult?