***Finn Rock Fallout*** -- Game Over ~ Infected Win

wicked · Post by **wicked** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:33 pm

supercram, I'd like a page range...

dussle · Post by **dussle** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:33 pm

And that was me stupidly not lookng at the fact that Memorial Hosiptal was inbold (check your own if you aren't mafia) thus thinking that Andy hadn't mentioned it. That was simply me nt clarifying things. Now it e, an easy target, getting questioned by the mafia.

XenHu · Post by **XenHu** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:33 pm

After pouring through all these posts( damn that's a lot of reading) I have come to a conclusion....

VOTE: No Lynch.

Seeing as someone will be killed automaticly at night anyway( I recalled Andy saying the virus effects you mentally) I see no reason on voting anyone in perticular... It's really to early to tell (IMO) and I wouldn't want to kill a townie .

-X

PS. Agian, sorry for lack of regular posting...[/quote]

supercram · Post by **supercram** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:34 pm

dussle wrote:Hmm... true enough, but it wasn't a viscious as thing are now, it was just wicked.

ooh. i love how active you've become in this forum. nice to have you here, dussle. where were you when your buddy was NOT on the chopping block?

dussle · Post by **dussle** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:35 pm

AK_iceman wrote:The only people who lie are mafia. Why not just tell the truth if you have nothing to hide?

I didn't fact check was all, I should have. It wasn't an intentional lie.

supercram · Post by **supercram** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:35 pm

wicked wrote:supercram, I'd like a page range...

ok, wicked.

look from page 8-12. come back to me if you need more. you have to do what kyle said: "Re-read with AK's info in mind"

supercram · Post by **supercram** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:37 pm

XenHu wrote:Xenhu, bad idea. read the thread again. you haven't been here enough.

dussle · Post by **dussle** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:37 pm

supercram wrote:
dussle wrote:Hmm... true enough, but it wasn't a viscious as thing are now, it was just wicked.

ooh. i love how active you've become in this forum. nice to have you here, dussle. where were you when your buddy was NOT on the chopping block?

I had a busy week and now its Friday. I have yet to defend Autoload and I have no idea whether he's mafia or not.

wicked · Post by **wicked** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:38 pm

duh thank you. although now I understand why IC said that, doesn't prove anything, IMO.

supercram · Post by **supercram** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:38 pm

wicked wrote:duh thank you. although now I understand why IC said that, doesn't prove anything, IMO.

no proof, but does change things a bit doesn't it.

wicked · Post by **wicked** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:44 pm

nothing that I didn't already think already cram.

actually, I'm most suspicious of these two:

- Dussle, for reasons already stated
- Master Bush, for bandwagonning and not posting anything of substance. go read his posts.... lots of fluff to say he posted, but not much substance... I did that a lot when mafia as well.

however, I'm still suspicious of most everybody else, including my own damn money-grubbing whoring ex-wife. being married doesn't mean your spouse is not infected (or won't become infected).

supercram · Post by **supercram** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:44 pm

i mean, we can't PROVE anyone is mafia at this point. that would be ridiculous. you could still be mafia, for all i know. i could be mafia.

but knwoing what i know about AK and Kyle and their blatantness about it, it makes them either very good mafia or actually innocent.

if they are innocent, it makes autoload/dussle look suspicious to me.

if they are mafia, i will know it if we lynch autoload and find out he was a townie. or maybe autoload will come back and convince me i am way off.

if there are 2 mafia in thsi game, we have a 1 in 8 chance of catching one if we lynch somebody today. if we are wrong, and then mafia kills someone tonight, then tomorrow we still have a 1 in 7 chance

if we do a no lynch today, then tomorrow we have a 1 in 7.5 chance of catching a mafia. that's worse odds. simple math. if we lynch someone today and we're wrong, we make tomorrow easier for us.

wicked · Post by **wicked** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:47 pm

Who said there were only 2 mafia??? That's absurd! There has always been at least 3 mafia, plus usually a sympathizer. With the two strains out there, I think we're looking at 3-4 infecteds (either symptomatic now or later).

autoload · Post by **autoload** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:48 pm

You guys want to hear my opinion? I will give you more than opinion, I will give you FACT!

I am indeed the cop. I was a researcher during the war and my abilities as a scientist allow me each night to check one person to see if they are infected or not. I hate to have to claim this early, but I believe it is in the best interest of town that I do. Opening night, with little else to go on I PMed Andy with my choice of AK_iceman as the target of my investigation. I picked him simply because he was at the top of the list of players. I was very surprised when I got a verdict of "Infected" back from the mod. Armed with this information I sat and tried to find something I could use to point blame at AK's guilt. You guys can see what progressed.

Along with me knowing FOR SURE that AK is infected, I think but am not 100% sure obviously that both the rev and wicked are infected. More sure of the rev being infected than wicked, but still pretty sure either way. Now go back and look at the banter between these 3 people throughout the thread with the assumption that my claim as a cop is true. It will put a totally different spin on how you view them. I really didn't suspect wicked at first, but as the game progressed and arguments kept coming forth, she shot down every single argument that wasn't the dussle argument, no matter how solid the argument was. Just look at the flip flopping of the reverend most recently. You guys talk about me being a single vision attacker against AK... at least I had concrete undisputable proof to go after him. Wicked is doing the same to dussle with no such proof. She knows that most of the townies are in the dark and it is very difficult to make distinctions of who is on what side based on faith or "gut" alone.

One added thing I noticed is that my 3 infected suspects do indeed come from one each of the 3 starting locations as stated in one of our opening game theories.

I keep my vote the same and FOS: reverend_kyle and wicked

If I don't get lynched today I implore the doctor if we have one to protect me tonight. If my hunch is right about the other two mafia then this game should be wrapped up pretty quick. I dare the infected to try to kill me tonight and have my role revealed...

Master Bush · Post by **Master Bush** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:49 pm

wicked wrote:- Master Bush, for bandwagonning and not posting anything of substance. go read his posts.... lots of fluff to say he posted, but not much substance... I did that a lot when mafia as well.

If you go back to the other 2 games I was in, you will see that I post much substance anyway.

And I did just make my first really substance post about 20 minutes ago, calling dussle out on another lie.

AK_iceman · Post by **AK_iceman** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:50 pm

In Andys other games there were 3 mafia, in a twelve person game.
It wouldn't make sense for there to be less than 3 mafia now, when we have 16 players.

AK_iceman · Post by **AK_iceman** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:51 pm

autoload wrote:You guys want to hear my opinion? I will give you more than opinion, I will give you FACT!

I am indeed the cop. I was a researcher during the war and my abilities as a scientist allow me each night to check one person to see if they are infected or not. I hate to have to claim this early, but I believe it is in the best interest of town that I do. Opening night, with little else to go on I PMed Andy with my choice of AK_iceman as the target of my investigation. I picked him simply because he was at the top of the list of players. I was very surprised when I got a verdict of "Infected" back from the mod. Armed with this information I sat and tried to find something I could use to point blame at AK's guilt. You guys can see what progressed.

Along with me knowing FOR SURE that AK is infected, I think but am not 100% sure obviously that both the rev and wicked are infected. More sure of the rev being infected than wicked, but still pretty sure either way. Now go back and look at the banter between these 3 people throughout the thread with the assumption that my claim as a cop is true. It will put a totally different spin on how you view them. I really didn't suspect wicked at first, but as the game progressed and arguments kept coming forth, she shot down every single argument that wasn't the dussle argument, no matter how solid the argument was. Just look at the flip flopping of the reverend most recently. You guys talk about me being a single vision attacker against AK... at least I had concrete undisputable proof to go after him. Wicked is doing the same to dussle with no such proof. She knows that most of the townies are in the dark and it is very difficult to make distinctions of who is on what side based on faith or "gut" alone.

One added thing I noticed is that my 3 infected suspects do indeed come from one each of the 3 starting locations as stated in one of our opening game theories.

I keep my vote the same and FOS: reverend_kyle and wicked

If I don't get lynched today I implore the doctor if we have one to protect me tonight. If my hunch is right about the other two mafia then this game should be wrapped up pretty quick. I dare the infected to try to kill me tonight and have my role revealed...

What an idiot. :roll:

Master Bush · Post by **Master Bush** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:52 pm

AK_iceman wrote:
autoload wrote:You guys want to hear my opinion? I will give you more than opinion, I will give you FACT!

I am indeed the cop. I was a researcher during the war and my abilities as a scientist allow me each night to check one person to see if they are infected or not. I hate to have to claim this early, but I believe it is in the best interest of town that I do. Opening night, with little else to go on I PMed Andy with my choice of AK_iceman as the target of my investigation. I picked him simply because he was at the top of the list of players. I was very surprised when I got a verdict of "Infected" back from the mod. Armed with this information I sat and tried to find something I could use to point blame at AK's guilt. You guys can see what progressed.

Along with me knowing FOR SURE that AK is infected, I think but am not 100% sure obviously that both the rev and wicked are infected. More sure of the rev being infected than wicked, but still pretty sure either way. Now go back and look at the banter between these 3 people throughout the thread with the assumption that my claim as a cop is true. It will put a totally different spin on how you view them. I really didn't suspect wicked at first, but as the game progressed and arguments kept coming forth, she shot down every single argument that wasn't the dussle argument, no matter how solid the argument was. Just look at the flip flopping of the reverend most recently. You guys talk about me being a single vision attacker against AK... at least I had concrete undisputable proof to go after him. Wicked is doing the same to dussle with no such proof. She knows that most of the townies are in the dark and it is very difficult to make distinctions of who is on what side based on faith or "gut" alone.

One added thing I noticed is that my 3 infected suspects do indeed come from one each of the 3 starting locations as stated in one of our opening game theories.

I keep my vote the same and FOS: reverend_kyle and wicked

If I don't get lynched today I implore the doctor if we have one to protect me tonight. If my hunch is right about the other two mafia then this game should be wrapped up pretty quick. I dare the infected to try to kill me tonight and have my role revealed...

What an idiot.

That's it? If you know for a fact that he's lying then explain.

Master Bush · Post by **Master Bush** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:53 pm

I say we vote for AK Iceman. If he is mafia, then Rev is as well. If AK is not Mafia, then we know Autoload IS mafia as well as Dussle.

Master Bush · Post by **Master Bush** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:55 pm

Because one is lying, and when we found out who is or isn't, the town will have the game in hand.

Bogusbet · Post by **Bogusbet** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:56 pm

Master Bush wrote:
AK_iceman wrote:
autoload wrote:You guys want to hear my opinion? I will give you more than opinion, I will give you FACT!

I am indeed the cop. I was a researcher during the war and my abilities as a scientist allow me each night to check one person to see if they are infected or not. I hate to have to claim this early, but I believe it is in the best interest of town that I do. Opening night, with little else to go on I PMed Andy with my choice of AK_iceman as the target of my investigation. I picked him simply because he was at the top of the list of players. I was very surprised when I got a verdict of "Infected" back from the mod. Armed with this information I sat and tried to find something I could use to point blame at AK's guilt. You guys can see what progressed.

Along with me knowing FOR SURE that AK is infected, I think but am not 100% sure obviously that both the rev and wicked are infected. More sure of the rev being infected than wicked, but still pretty sure either way. Now go back and look at the banter between these 3 people throughout the thread with the assumption that my claim as a cop is true. It will put a totally different spin on how you view them. I really didn't suspect wicked at first, but as the game progressed and arguments kept coming forth, she shot down every single argument that wasn't the dussle argument, no matter how solid the argument was. Just look at the flip flopping of the reverend most recently. You guys talk about me being a single vision attacker against AK... at least I had concrete undisputable proof to go after him. Wicked is doing the same to dussle with no such proof. She knows that most of the townies are in the dark and it is very difficult to make distinctions of who is on what side based on faith or "gut" alone.

One added thing I noticed is that my 3 infected suspects do indeed come from one each of the 3 starting locations as stated in one of our opening game theories.

I keep my vote the same and FOS: reverend_kyle and wicked

If I don't get lynched today I implore the doctor if we have one to protect me tonight. If my hunch is right about the other two mafia then this game should be wrapped up pretty quick. I dare the infected to try to kill me tonight and have my role revealed...

What an idiot.

That's it? If you know for a fact that he's lying then explain.

Yeah I agree FFS, last time we lost the cop/doc in two nights for blabbing. If this is true why not try and bring about a vote before anyone was proper fingered, or even let a lynch go and protect/build a case your making this harder for us!!

AK_iceman · Post by **AK_iceman** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:57 pm

He revealed himself as the cop the first day!

If you actually followed the link to the sites Andy gave you would have learned there is more than 1 type of cop. And in the beginning it doesnt tell you what kind of cop you are.

Bogusbet · Post by **Bogusbet** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:58 pm

AK_iceman wrote:He revealed himself as the cop the first day!

If you actually followed the link to the sites Andy gave you would have learned there is more than 1 type of cop. And in the beginning it doesnt tell you what kind of cop you are.

What do you mean, I'm a noobish at this and have been drinking? 2 types of cop and where was the reveal.

AK_iceman · Post by **AK_iceman** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 5:59 pm

I cant find the link right now, gimme a sec.

I do know there is an insane or crazy cop who gives random reads.
There is a cop who always give innocent reads.
And then there is a regular cop, who gives correct reads.

I may be wrong, this is off memory from the first game.

AndyDufresne · Post by **AndyDufresne** » Fri Jan 12, 2007 6:00 pm

Vote Count

AK_iceman -- (Mach, Autoload, Master Bush)
Supercram -- (Broomhead)
Reverend_kyle -- (Freetymes)
Autoload -- (Moz, Supercram, AK_iceman)
No Lynch -- (Backglass, Dussle, Wicked, Xenhu)
Not Voting, Everyone Else

9 Total Votes are needed for a Lynch or No Lynch

--Andy