Coheed & Cambria mafia - Town Winnn.

[mandalorian2298]

I'm guessing Flores is your kill Mandy?

Why do you ask? Have you killed someone who is not Flores? vote Clive

I believe he is just trying to ensure there is no Bus Driver or something in this game, or that a Doctor did not protect the person whom you did choose...

A little defensive there, Mandalorian?

Asking would be understandable. Guessing makes me suspicious. A little protective there, Nark?

To questions to two players:

1) To mandy who claimed to be a vig: who did you target last night?

2) To Iliad, who claimed to be inventor/doctor: what action did you do and on whom?

.

Er, this is kind of embaressing, but I targeted you. It was because of this post.

Although I don't believe that pancake is scum (as explained before), we need a lynch to have clues for further rounds.

Unvote: dano

Vote: pancake

.

I always find it suspicious when people say that they don't believe that person, who is about to get lynched, is scum and then proceed to join the bandwagon (especially when the lynchee turns out to be pro-Town). So, I decided to take a stab and try to eliminate you, since I know that you are hard to lynch (as has been proven in the 'Alen-a-Dale affair' ) This way I can save the crazy theories which no one is going to believe for my own personal executions and use the totally believable theories (as is the theory about Clive being scum) for the public forum. Twice the killing, twice the fun.

[ga7]

I won't have much time to post as much as I would like in this game for the next few days, but a question comes to mind: what did you do Illy?

[Clive]

I'm guessing Flores is your kill Mandy?

Why do you ask? Have you killed someone who is not Flores? vote Clive

Because the method in which Flores was killed is the method I would expect from a vig.

The fact that you didn't kill any of the dead is a bit odd, but as someone mentioned, there are roles that can affect things like that...

[militant]

Core blimey, 3 kills O_o

[Clive]

Core blimey, 3 kills O_o

For a game of this size, I don't find it surprising.

1 Mafia kill (Killed)
1 3rd party serial killer type role (Slain)
1 Vig (Shot)

Although thinking about, the shot and killed things could go the other way round. I would be surprised to see any more than 3 killing parties, though.

With Mandy claiming Vig, I figured there's a good chance of him being SK, but with him (claiming) target on Selin, it doesn't really tell us anything. The fact he made it through the night makes it less likely he's SK imo, though.

[/]

Your theory sounds good, though, from The Writer's scene and character, I believe he likely has a "lyncher" type of role, seeking out specific characters to get rid of his problems.
This may mean the third kill was from a serial killer, and Mandy (the vig) was blocked. (or the other way around, since we don't have much to go on.)

[Iliad]

I won't have much time to post as much as I would like in this game for the next few days, but a question comes to mind: what did you do Illy?

I protected AD. He claimed yesterday and though his elusive claim was scummy I decided it would be good if he did in fact survived.


Btw I may also not be able to post as much due to parents

[Selin]

Although I don't believe that pancake is scum (as explained before), we need a lynch to have clues for further rounds.

Unvote: dano

Vote: pancake

.

I always find it suspicious when people say that they don't believe that person, who is about to get lynched, is scum and then proceed to join the bandwagon (especially when the lynchee turns out to be pro-Town). So, I decided to take a stab and try to eliminate you, since I know that you are hard to lynch (as has been proven in the 'Alen-a-Dale affair' ) This way I can save the crazy theories which no one is going to believe for my own personal executions and use the totally believable theories (as is the theory about Clive being scum) for the public forum. Twice the killing, twice the fun.

If you hadn't skimmed my earlier analysis about pancake, you could have been right.

Here is it once again:

Regarding pancake there are two options in my opinion:

1) pancake is townie
2) both pancake and mandy are scum

Most probably the first option is true.

.

It would be helpful if you explained how you came to these two options.

Mandy is a very experienced good player. During the bandwagon of him, we reached a state where he was at lynch -2. Pancake was online at that time, he even made a post stating that mandy was at lynch -2, but didn't vote him.
a) If pancake had been scum/cult and mandy had been town, in my opinion he wouldn't have missed the opportunity to get rid of a good town player and voted mandy hoping that someone would drop the hammer.
b) If pancake had been townie and had no idea about what fraction mandy can be, he would have tended not to vote mandy in order not to loose a potential experienced townia.
c) If pancake and mandy had been both scum, he again wouldn't have voted mandy not to loose a scum partner.

When I made a search in google about mandy's role being Hundriah, I could only find 3 results, only 3
And one of them was mandy's post itself. The other two came from the same resource and Hundriah's name was mentioned there only in one line. This lead me to the conclusion that mandy made either a super fake claim (congrats to him in this case) or told the truth about his characters name at least. Therefore I believe that mandy is not scum (he may be a townie, cultie or neutral). In this case option c is not valid anymore and the probability that pancake is townie is significantly higher than the probability that he is scum.

Regarding mandy, we will have more clues during later phases and we will have the possibility to check whether or not he told the truth regarding to his role and sanity. He haven't answered my question yet. I wanted to know, if he is a day vig or a night vig.

.

[Skittles!]

VOTE COUNT

Clive (1) - Mandalorian2298

Need to prod some people, possibly replace.

[jnd94]

Hrm......don't have too many ideas on what you guys have come up with now, but will be back in a a lil bit hopefully with something to say.

[ga7]

I won't have much time to post as much as I would like in this game for the next few days, but a question comes to mind: what did you do Illy?

I protected AD. He claimed yesterday and though his elusive claim was scummy I decided it would be good if he did in fact survived.


Btw I may also not be able to post as much due to parents

Ok. Vote Selin [Wilhelm Ryan - Mafia Godfather]

.

[mandalorian2298]

I won't have much time to post as much as I would like in this game for the next few days, but a question comes to mind: what did you do Illy?

I protected AD. He claimed yesterday and though his elusive claim was scummy I decided it would be good if he did in fact survived.


Btw I may also not be able to post as much due to parents

Ok. Vote Selin [Wilhelm Ryan - Mafia Godfather]

.

Er, is this some kind of an inside joke or have I been proven right yet again?

I'm guessing Flores is your kill Mandy?

Why do you ask? Have you killed someone who is not Flores? vote Clive

Because the method in which Flores was killed is the method I would expect from a vig.

The fact that you didn't kill any of the dead is a bit odd, but as someone mentioned, there are roles that can affect things like that...

So, you are either lying and am right about you being Scum, or you are actually n00bish enough to believe that Day Scenes are a realistic description of night actions. Either way, tsk, tsk Iliad.

[jnd94]

I do agrre with Mandy on this. looks like Clive messed up and is trying to dig himself out of a a growing ditch.

Vote Clive

[Anarkistsdream]

GA7... Is that really the Selins role?

[Selin]

It was very interesting for me to see that neither the claimed town vig, nor the claimed town doctor was killed last night. Actually both should have been top priority targets of scum. Do we have a really noob scum team or are mandy and iliad lying? If someone has information about what they did last night, this might be important to detect, if they told the truth with their claims and night target choices.

.

[Iliad]

I won't have much time to post as much as I would like in this game for the next few days, but a question comes to mind: what did you do Illy?

I protected AD. He claimed yesterday and though his elusive claim was scummy I decided it would be good if he did in fact survived.


Btw I may also not be able to post as much due to parents

Ok. Vote Selin [Wilhelm Ryan - Mafia Godfather]

.

Er, is this some kind of an inside joke or have I been proven right yet again?

I'm guessing Flores is your kill Mandy?

Why do you ask? Have you killed someone who is not Flores? vote Clive

Because the method in which Flores was killed is the method I would expect from a vig.

The fact that you didn't kill any of the dead is a bit odd, but as someone mentioned, there are roles that can affect things like that...

So, you are either lying and am right about you being Scum, or you are actually n00bish enough to believe that Day Scenes are a realistic description of night actions. Either way, tsk, tsk Iliad.

Don't you mean clive? Otherwise I'm very confused

[mandalorian2298]

Lol. I do mean Clive.
Sorry Illiad.

[Selin]

Lol. I do mean Clive.
Sorry Illiad.

Another slip...

.

[Clive]

So, you are either lying and am right about you being Scum, or you are actually n00bish enough to believe that Day Scenes are a realistic description of night actions. Either way, tsk, tsk Iliad.

Um, what??

Yes, they do, that's the way i've always known it. If there was no such flavour in night scenes then all kills would share the same method, probably "killed".

Jnd's vote on me looks very crap.

[Anarkistsdream]

Selin, you breezed through a role accusation without saying shit... Any reason why?

Vote Selin

[Selin]

Selin, you breezed through a role accusation without saying shit... Any reason why?

Vote Selin

You should have known why.

.

[jnd94]

Selin, you breezed through a role accusation without saying shit... Any reason why?

Vote Selin

You should have known why.

.

[Anarkistsdream]

Selin, you breezed through a role accusation without saying shit... Any reason why?

Vote Selin

You should have known why.

.

Allowing people to make assumptions in a game like mafia is not very intelligent, and rarely benefits those that allow them.

Please be more specific.

[mandalorian2298]

GA7, IF YOU DON'T EXPLAIN YOUR CLAIM ABOUT SELIN WITHIN THE NEXT 24 HOURS, I WILL HAVE TO ASSUME THAT YOU ARE JUST SCUM STIRRING TROUBLE.

[militant]

GA7, IF YOU DON'T EXPLAIN YOUR CLAIM ABOUT SELIN WITHIN THE NEXT 24 HOURS, I WILL HAVE TO ASSUME THAT YOU ARE JUST SCUM STIRRING TROUBLE.

ga7 and flores are out on holiday I presume, they asked me to sit there fery few games for them which I am doing currently, not verywell though Sorry Flores, so Yes, I tink they will be back by the weekend although not totally sure