I started with a nagging feeling that one of the loud players was scum, I reread him and loose a bit. I questioned his reasoning being very similar to that he was accusing others of. The loose claims, which narrowed the field and it seemed like sonic was much more likely. Sonic then went quiet, so I goaded him and questioned his world view.
Then, I very clearly as you can see from the thread, reread sonic and seen very sus day 1 behaviour, that included lying.
Compare this to sonics feelings on Pepe, where one day sonic is accusing him, the next he isn't and all he ever does by way of explanation is make claims on how he is confident about things (there are easily 5 examples of this).
Anyway, here are all my pre sonic voting me posts where you can see I am clearly go from suspicious to outright stating I think he is scum.
Spoiler
[quote="pmchugh"]
I do now get the feeling one of sonic or LC is wolf. Not sure which one yet but it felt like they took my slight hint at rag and hard with it.[/quote]
[quote="pmchugh"]
I think I have to do what I have been putting off; actually try read sonic and loose Canon. I love that you guys are active and wish more people were but its definitely more of a slog with so many posts :lol:[/quote]
[quote="pmchugh"][quote="SoN!c"][b][color=#FF0000]Unvote[/color][/b]
Also, Loose seems he does not want to go for Max anymore (like set in stone today and after he wanted to kill him that strongly D1)? It gives me the creeps, deja-vu EW feeling when EW didnt wanted to push for Traf anymore. But in reality Traf was his nightkill. Saying A in here during the day but acting B during the night..
"Max - NO (definitely not he can't be with EW)"
"Sonic - YES - he may be scum if so more likely with EW"
Its pretty simple if you ask me: Loose thinks PMC and DDS are the masons. He knows he cant touch them for mislynch. And he does not want to lynch the other scum either because he needs the double night kills..
He thinks Max is scum just like me and PMC are thinking. So he is buttering Max up so Max doesn't kill him tonight. And he cant have town lynch Max because then he is all alone against 4 town..
Vote [b][color=#FF0000]loose cannon[/color][/b][/quote]
This logic could also apply to you. Like, you think Max is scum. You think me and DDS are masons. Therefore you started to push LC. Lc gets killed, you kill Max, we kill Pepe and you win.
Like, if you think both Max and LC are scum, why vote LC out first, rather than Max?[/quote]
[quote="pmchugh"]Actually sonic and max doesn't make sense, who would be EWs partner. I feel like there is a limited number of available scenarios.[/quote]
[quote="pmchugh"]Ok, honestly not mad about the claim. I feel like this game is highly solvable.
Possibilities I am considering
Traf + Max
Traf + Sonic
Pepe + EW
I kind of think it has to be Pepe because I don't see Max - EW or Sonic - EW. I guess DDS could be scum, which would through off all my possibilities.[/quote]
[quote="pmchugh"]Kind of leaning towards Sonic and Pepe. Sonic today misreads me and DDS as the masons, he said so himself. So he tries to protect Pepe who he thinks is EWs partner to preserve the kill, getting Max and LC lynched to win.[/quote]
[quote="pmchugh"][quote="SoN!c"]Pepe is a wild card flying high in the sky. Max is another wild card. Its like a Mexican stand off with 4 : me, pmc, you and DDS. And nobody is noticing the other 2.
Nobody includes max and pepe and thats ok. But there are 2 scum in here.
Im thinking DDS, LC and Pepe as scum right now. But like i said paranoia dust needs to settle first.
And not receiving london calling antenna at all.
FP by loose again[/quote]
Why did you change your mind on Pepe sonic? What changed?[/quote]
[quote="pmchugh"]Shall we start taking bets on sonics reason for why he stopped being the top poster the moment LC claimed?
I was eating dinner 4/1.
I have a life, I don't just sit on CC. 7/5
I was out with friends/partner 6/1.
I was working 8/1
Sleeping 10/1
None of your business 3/1[/quote]
[quote="pmchugh"][quote="SoN!c"][quote="pmchugh"]Shall we start taking bets on sonics reason for why he stopped being the top poster the moment LC claimed?
I was eating dinner 4/1.
I have a life, I don't just sit on CC. 7/5
I was out with friends/partner 6/1.
I was working 8/1
Sleeping 10/1
None of your business 3/1[/quote]
Lol PMC, im in Crete on holiday? Like i said well in advance? Even on holiday im no silent sub for days: I still check in in the morning and just before sleep time. And if i check in between its on my wife's phone.[/quote]
You posted at 2,4,5 and 6 something today.
I think its you with traf, who do you think our two scum are now after LCs claim?[/quote]
[quote="pmchugh"][quote="SoN!c"]If you are mason loose your the most stupid mason ive ever seen (well at least i know im not making friends here).
"sonic with EW" is plain silly stupid. Ask EW silly. And its not Pepe either but im sure you still think we are a scumpair :lol:[/quote]
While I agree that Loose has that completly wrong, EW and you would be nuts, you no longer have a coherent map of this game. You say I am town, you say Pepe is town, you say LC and DDS are masons and you, that's 5 town. Who is EWs partner of not Pepe?[/quote]
