Conquer Club

spiesr wrote:

jonty125 wrote:Regarding sheep's role ... I can't understand why pcm would make sheep unkillable (surely just standard BP for a role could bulletproof), how would the game ever end if he was mafia?

The way he describes it he can be killed, he just won't stay dead. So if he was the last remaining scum and got lynched then the game would end before he could respawn.

Being lynched doesn't have to mean that I have to be killed. A lot of immortal things end up being imprisoned.

I find Sheep's claim reasonably believable and out of the main three suspects we have been looking at I would probably lynch them in this order:

1. Mudpuppy-Just don't believe the claim.
2. KGB-no claim after several requests is suspicious.
3. Sheep-behavior not what I would want to see but more believable claim.

HotShot53 wrote:

spiesr wrote:I think I may have spotted a potential wrinkle in plans for today. Betiko appears to have made more than 3 posts while horseless without stealing one and should be dead as a result.

Mod... any comments or consequences from this? I'm guessing Betiko didn't realize he was the one without the horse... but he has posted a lot since he's been horseless.

ohhh crap!!! sorry totally forgot! (my first day with the horse game and I didn't receive any warning from PCM in between messages.... I hope he doesn't count it as a strike 3...)

anyway, strike wolf that's my horse! (I don't want to give it to mud puppy I'd rather have it between the 3 of us so we give it to mud puppy in the last minute)

regarding sheep's claim, I'm like jonty, I don't see how the hell this is supposed to work out. He either didn't explain the full mechanism or he is bullcrapping. This role is just impossible and leaves very little chance for mafia to win.

And yeah, I'd rather see kgb claim.

sheepofdumb wrote:Being lynched doesn't have to mean that I have to be killed. A lot of immortal things end up being imprisoned.

Okay, so your earlier description was somewhat misleading then, you are just regular bulletproof (indefinitely) and can be lynched as normal?

spiesr wrote:

sheepofdumb wrote:Being lynched doesn't have to mean that I have to be killed. A lot of immortal things end up being imprisoned.

Okay, so your earlier description was somewhat misleading then, you are just regular bulletproof (indefinitely) and can be lynched as normal?

I'm indefinitely regular bulletproof and can by lynched as normal.

Apologies on the lack of VCs. Have a show opening next weekend and it's getting heavy. One is upcoming.

I'm going to let Betiko slide because:

1. Lack of VCs
2. MP's horse theft was not in a place that was clear or easily visible. Most have been apart from the text body. His was not, and that's important. Also, italics is NOT different enough from the rest of the text. It could easily be missed (I missed it).

...or I would say that, but this is pretty damning.

betiko wrote:ohhh crap!!! sorry totally forgot!

If you saw it and forgot, that's your fault.

Also, I'm extending the deadline 24 hours, because I will not on at the deadline, nor will I be in a capacity to handle the deadline until the evening at the earliest.

Vote Count

Doom 2 (HotShot, MudPuppy)
MudPuppy 2 (spiesr, edoc)

Deadline is June 9 at 2 PM ET

So Betiko was not horse killed?

Well, I agree with Betiko about not giving Mudpuppy the horse and I am not gonna give it to the cop so

Betiko that's my horse

update:

KGB is posting.

strike wolf wrote:1. Strike->KGB
7. Doomyoshi>Betiko
8. Spiesr> MudPuppy
10. Hotshot>Strike
13. Jonty->Doomyoshi
16. KGB->sheep
17. Edoc>Hotshot
18. Sheep->Jonty125
19. Betiko>Spiesr
20. Mudpuppy>Edocsil

pancakemix wrote:Apologies on the lack of VCs. Have a show opening next weekend and it's getting heavy. One is upcoming.

I'm going to let Betiko slide because:

1. Lack of VCs
2. MP's horse theft was not in a place that was clear or easily visible. Most have been apart from the text body. His was not, and that's important. Also, italics is NOT different enough from the rest of the text. It could easily be missed (I missed it).

...or I would say that, but this is pretty damning.

betiko wrote:ohhh crap!!! sorry totally forgot!

If you saw it and forgot, that's your fault.

Also, I'm extending the deadline 24 hours, because I will not on at the deadline, nor will I be in a capacity to handle the deadline until the evening at the earliest.

to be perfectly honnest I did see it but I forgot. I was posting from my ipad and wasn't on the page to remind me of the new horse participants; I thought that I would open a new tab to check the previous page at the end of writting my message to see who i would send it to.. and forgot! then as no one noticed, I completely forgot about it and kept on posting withoout passing the horse (and you weren't around to give me a yellow card...).

anyway, hotshots, that's my horse!

For those who doubt that there is 2 cults: Why do you think Rodion and aage are different colors?

We are at LYLO. I doubt I can win now, so good game to cult 2.

Taking a new look at the deadline, I am unlikely to be on around the time it happens. So I do not believe I will be a good choice for handing the horse off to Mudpuppy.

strike wolf wrote:So Betiko was not horse killed?

He will die at the end of the day.

In that case, Vote Mudpuppy. Doom is cult but I am fairly convinced that KGB and/or Mudpuppy are anti-town. I give Mudpuppy slightly better chances of not being town than KGB due to the claim, so I have voted him. Without a recruiter, Doom is of secondary importance.

Acknowledging that Doom might be telling the truth and there is a second cult out there, this would be my scenario: My top bet would still be for the leader to either be Mudpuppy or KGB due to behavior and lack of solid claims (Deputy is super weak and unbelievable and KGB hasn't given one). Betiko is likely to have been recruited as governor's can be very useful for cult. Either way he will be dead soon. I would suspect that Sheep is part of Doom's cult from an earlier comment where he excluded Sheep from possible mafia picks out of him, KGB and Mudpuppy. Jonty is proven town and Hotshot is the cop, though in this scenario he could be part of the secondary cult. even so he'd likely be a recruit not the recruiter and of secondary importance. The same goes for Spiesr and Edoc, if they are cult, I would lean more towards them being recruits.

pancakemix wrote:

strike wolf wrote:So Betiko was not horse killed?

He will die at the end of the day.

In addition to whomever does not have a horse correct?

strike wolf wrote:In that case, Vote Mudpuppy. Doom is cult but I am fairly convinced that KGB and/or Mudpuppy are anti-town. I give Mudpuppy slightly better chances of not being town than KGB due to the claim, so I have voted him. Without a recruiter, Doom is of secondary importance.

Acknowledging that Doom might be telling the truth and there is a second cult out there, this would be my scenario: My top bet would still be for the leader to either be Mudpuppy or KGB due to behavior and lack of solid claims (Deputy is super weak and unbelievable and KGB hasn't given one). Betiko is likely to have been recruited as governor's can be very useful for cult. Either way he will be dead soon. I would suspect that Sheep is part of Doom's cult from an earlier comment where he excluded Sheep from possible mafia picks out of him, KGB and Mudpuppy. Jonty is proven town and Hotshot is the cop, though in this scenario he could be part of the secondary cult. even so he'd likely be a recruit not the recruiter and of secondary importance. The same goes for Spiesr and Edoc, if they are cult, I would lean more towards them being recruits.

I agree with your analysis... but I would rather pressure KGB for a claim before deciding which to lynch. So I will unvote, vote kgb

spiesr wrote:

pancakemix wrote:

strike wolf wrote:So Betiko was not horse killed?

He will die at the end of the day.

In addition to whomever does not have a horse correct?

I'm not sure quite how this is working now... but in any case, to be safe, Betiko, that's my horse!

spiesr wrote:

pancakemix wrote:

strike wolf wrote:So Betiko was not horse killed?

He will die at the end of the day.

In addition to whomever does not have a horse correct?

I don't think so. The horse was not included in the last vote count and I don't think he is going to add a death to the total like that.

vote mudpuppy for self-preservation

I think it s a bit stupid to put a 3 strikes rule that will depend on pcm's conections, i posted consecutively 3 times that day with no time to get a warning. My first time in the horse game so obviously less alert about it.

Bah lol, just scewed it again lol, strike that s my horse

The horse game is done for the day, to be clear.

vote mudpuppy gg and gl town then. last post from me!

DoomYoshi, I have a question for you. What reason do we have to believe that you are in aage's cult instead of Rodion's (going off of the assumption that the different colors really do mean there are two cults.)? I mean, is there any evidence that suggests your affiliation one way or the other?

No evidence other than my word.