Page 4 of 10
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 4:38 am
by Kernal_Kronic
Would we also save our doc by lynching Adam as one must die so the other survives?
Also, there seems to be a time limit on when Adam needs to be killed.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 6:28 am
by got tonkaed
Ani is voting for Adam. Why is that? Are you afraid of telling people what you know? What is your grand plan in voting for Adam? I know who you are as I asked I was informed you would know me. Someone is coming off scummy already.
Votes ho!!
Adam
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 6:34 am
by got tonkaed
First vote count
It is accurate.
Day 1 vote counts
Mandalorian2298 1 (strider24)
Ga7 1 (mandarlorian2298)
Kalisnikov1 (spinwizard)
Animorpherv1 3(ace1217,pmchugh,sierra_leon
Pmchug 1(Nickbaldwin)
Strider24 1 (spurgistan)
Im giving kalish 24 hours before i replace him or get a confirm. Also to the person who is violating their pr, im modkilling you if you do it again.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 6:46 am
by FloresDelMal
i'll replace ^^
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 7:07 am
by Kernal_Kronic
got tonkaed wrote:Ani is voting for Adam. Why is that? Are you afraid of telling people what you know? What is your grand plan in voting for Adam? I know who you are as I asked I was informed you would know me. Someone is coming off scummy already.
Votes ho!!
Adam
According to this, Ani is voting for Adam...does that mean that farside is in fact Adam?
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 10:35 am
by ga7
mandalorian2298 wrote:Vote ga7 because he is the most Fircoal-like player in this game.
OMGUS Vote Mandy for offending me beyond reason
Ani comes off as mildly scummy so far but one thing I wonder is if Alison and Diana couldn't be just for flavor or we're sure to have them as roles here...
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 11:24 am
by spinwizard
wow day 1 progress
unvote for the time being and if i was to pick 2 people atm it would be ani and guylian
ani because it sems he is on the other side to adam, (note i have no idea who adam is as ive never seen this film
) so if welynch him, it would give us a basis on what side/ sanety/ ect. adam is, get me?
and guylian as lynching adam would clearly be a bad idea, hes odvisley important to which ever side hes on so why risk his life by lynching him when we can find out his side from lynching others and reading?
So basicly,
Vote ani as it seams like the most logical thing to do.
FOS guylian and Sierra as they could be scum partners, or guylian could be just unclear as he is a new player or a noob scum members whos let it slip early, lets wait and see
On a simeler note, i doubt i've done my victory condition any good by this post 
Now don't get exited, im not anything good 
(THANKS GT, love you to ) townie survivor babeyyyyyy <3
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 11:25 am
by spinwizard
and i have no idea why i just claimed
been a long time
doesn't effect anything anyway, gogo
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 11:26 am
by got tonkaed
As much as I understand what Sierra is stating in regards to the mod's opening we do not know if a player is actually in the game? We don't know if those people are innocent or guilty.
I do believe Morph has a win condition for himself alone which to me is anti town. Has anyone ever heard of a lyncher before?
They have there own seperate win condition that is not for the town but themselves only. I suggest that ani be lynched.
If the characters do exsist I ask that I be given a chance to explain what I gain by surviving the day.
Adam
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 11:31 am
by got tonkaed
Also Murdock Sampson will be replacing Stephen Wayne upon his confirmation.
Flores i may be sending you a role pm if you are intersted depending on my response to a separate players pm.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 3:26 pm
by Murdock Sampson
got tonkaed wrote:Also Murdock Sampson will be replacing Stephen Wayne upon his confirmation.
Flores i may be sending you a role pm if you are intersted depending on my response to a separate players pm.
/confirm
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 4:04 pm
by LSU Tiger Josh
Vote Ani I also find it scummy.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 4:20 pm
by animorpherv1
got tonkaed wrote:First vote count
It is accurate.
Day 1 vote counts
Mandalorian2298 1 (strider24)
Ga7 1 (mandarlorian2298)
Kalisnikov1 (spinwizard)
Animorpherv1 3(ace1217,pmchugh,sierra_leon
Pmchug 1(Nickbaldwin)
Strider24 1 (spurgistan)
farside22 1 (animorpherv1)
Im giving kalish 24 hours before i replace him or get a confirm. Also to the person who is violating their pr, im modkilling you if you do it again.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 4:53 pm
by got tonkaed
The inital vote count was correct.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 5:12 pm
by Strider24
Unvote I am leading towards Ani at the moment as I did think he was scummy straight off the bat but at the moment I am not sure if it is enough for a vote...
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 6:04 pm
by nagerous
vote ga7
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 6:44 pm
by guylian
ga7 wrote: one thing I wonder is if Alison and Diana couldn't be just for flavor or we're sure to have them as roles here...
this could be good to find out...........and makes sense, I mean then we have a life for life situation rather than a life for 3 lives one.
it would mean we have a choice........either lynch adam and let Dr. Gordon live or don't lynch adam and Dr. Gordon dies.
or we could go for someone else entirely and see what happens to adam and Dr. gordon because i suspect we are going to have 'games' like this every day
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 6:50 pm
by pmchugh
Sierra_Leon wrote:PS: I just had an afterthought. Might it be a good idea to lynch Adam? What I get from the scene is that lynching him would save two other townies. If that's the case, it would be like giving up your chance to lynch scum on day 1, but gaining two confirmed townies in return (granted that Alison and Diana claim). If Dr. Gordon has the ability to talk to us like Adam does, it would be nice if he was able to clarify his objectives.
Why would we want to lynch a confirmed townie (adam aka farside) just to save 2 people that could be mistaken for scum and their may be a chance of saving anyway? We can have one confirmed townie and up to two non-confirmed ones or one dead townie and up still not entirely sure of two unconfirmed townies.
Too much risk and plus who is to say we wont find scum with our lynch.
fos SLp.s. spin why on earth did you claim?
spinwizard wrote:and i have no idea why i just claimed
been a long time
doesn't effect anything anyway, gogo
unvote ani What exactly is he accused of my vote was random?
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 6:57 pm
by guylian
i don't understand why anyone is a 'confirmed townie' pmchugh
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 7:02 pm
by pmchugh
guylian wrote:i don't understand why anyone is a 'confirmed townie' pmchugh
surely adam is a confirmed townie unless their is a deviation from the movie? I can't really remember it much now but im pretty sure adam was a "goodie"?
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 1:15 am
by got tonkaed
@Pmc adam was a person who was hired to take pictures of dr. gordon. He was just as guilty in Jigsaw's eyes as Dr. Gordon. If I remember correctly I think Jig Saw stated that Adam liked to watch and harmed people with what he did. Something like that. Adam was a victum as much as Dr. Gordon.
I think this is a trick by Jig saw. But I still believe Ani is anti town as it seems his win condition could be that of a lyncher.
Adam
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 1:54 am
by Kernal_Kronic
Why is ani vote not counting?
We are getting some information from Adam, whether it can be trusted or not is a different story all together. If we lynch ani & he is a Lyncher, then at least we know we can trust Adam...there is also the chance the Adam is a Lyncher & needs to Lynch ani.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 2:00 am
by got tonkaed
Vote count will come later tonight/early morning as im at work for the next bunch of hours.
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 4:17 am
by guylian
Kernal_Kronic wrote:Why is ani vote not counting?
We are getting some information from Adam, whether it can be trusted or not is a different story all together. If we lynch ani & he is a Lyncher, then at least we know we can trust Adam...there is also the chance the Adam is a Lyncher & needs to Lynch ani.
maybe ani s Dr. Gordon
Re: SAW Mafia -Day 1/Read rules...need at least 1 replace!
Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 5:23 am
by Kernal_Kronic
guylian wrote:Kernal_Kronic wrote:Why is ani vote not counting?
We are getting some information from Adam, whether it can be trusted or not is a different story all together. If we lynch ani & he is a Lyncher, then at least we know we can trust Adam...there is also the chance the Adam is a Lyncher & needs to Lynch ani.
maybe ani s Dr. Gordon
I was thinking that...Maybe each one has a specific night role (doc & watcher) depending who survives, but if ani is Dr Gordon, then he shouldn't be able to speak either
vote ani