Page 4 of 39
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 5:06 am
by Skoffin
Ahoy mate, not sure if I ever played with you; if we have it was a long time ago.
@Tim changing playstyle is a valid option and I see no reason for it to be viewed as scummy, especially when his previous style was getting him a bad reputation and getting him rekt as town in other games. So do explain why trying a new approach is scummy in this circumstance.
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 6:21 am
by Ragian
Fircoal wrote:Ragian wrote:You don't know what town cred means?
But WHAT would gain town cred? How?
To me, it seemed like legion reiterated what I had already stated in an attempt to say, "See how good a townie I am." --> Town cred.
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 9:08 am
by legionnare
Ragian wrote:Fircoal wrote:Ragian wrote:You don't know what town cred means?
But WHAT would gain town cred? How?
To me, it seemed like legion reiterated what I had already stated in an attempt to say, "See how good a townie I am." --> Town cred.
To me, it seemed like I was reiterated what you had already stated because that's how mafia works, one person calls out an error and others concur...creating a voting bloc...
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 1:24 pm
by Ragian
Right. You didn't realise mine was a joke?
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 1:37 pm
by DirtyDishSoap
Skoffin wrote: Ahoy mate, not sure if I ever played with you; if we have it was a long time ago.
Nope, forum frequenter, not new to mafia, just new to mafia on here if that makes sense.
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 1:43 pm
by Fircoal
DirtyDishSoap wrote:Skoffin wrote: Ahoy mate, not sure if I ever played with you; if we have it was a long time ago.
Nope, forum frequenter, not new to mafia, just new to mafia on here if that makes sense.
You've played mafia here before o.o
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 1:49 pm
by madmitch
Welcome to the sandbox DDS
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 2:48 pm
by nagerous
DirtyDishSoap wrote:Skoffin wrote: Ahoy mate, not sure if I ever played with you; if we have it was a long time ago.
Nope, forum frequenter, not new to mafia, just new to mafia on here if that makes sense.
Lads, let's get him.
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 2:51 pm
by dakky21
nagerous wrote:DirtyDishSoap wrote:Skoffin wrote: Ahoy mate, not sure if I ever played with you; if we have it was a long time ago.
Nope, forum frequenter, not new to mafia, just new to mafia on here if that makes sense.
Lads, let's get him.
Why do you want to get a newcomer on CC mafia forums? I guess he is what he says, new here and you want to get him right away? Nice strategy....
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 3:29 pm
by Metsfanmax
dakky21 wrote:nagerous wrote:DirtyDishSoap wrote:Skoffin wrote: Ahoy mate, not sure if I ever played with you; if we have it was a long time ago.
Nope, forum frequenter, not new to mafia, just new to mafia on here if that makes sense.
Lads, let's get him.
Why do you want to get a newcomer on CC mafia forums? I guess he is what he says, new here and you want to get him right away? Nice strategy....
Why are you so defensive about a joke comment?
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 3:38 pm
by WingCmdr Ginkapo
Are you still looking for replacements?
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 4:34 pm
by strike wolf
I'm good at the moment I think. Thanks.
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 5:07 pm
by TimWoodbury
Skoffin wrote: Ahoy mate, not sure if I ever played with you; if we have it was a long time ago.
@Tim changing playstyle is a valid option and I see no reason for it to be viewed as scummy, especially when his previous style was getting him a bad reputation and getting him rekt as town in other games. So do explain why trying a new approach is scummy in this circumstance.
changing strategy is still change of strategy weather for good reason or not (his reason is good and acceptable) but still if we know he played a certian way in previous games under certian situations and does the opposite here it will throw up red flags
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 5:20 pm
by Djfireside
Fircoal wrote:DirtyDishSoap wrote:Skoffin wrote: Ahoy mate, not sure if I ever played with you; if we have it was a long time ago.
Nope, forum frequenter, not new to mafia, just new to mafia on here if that makes sense.
You've played mafia here before o.o
Not to play the jump on new guy route but Fircoal is right, and with nothing else to run with Ill take a misstep in that and run with it, call it what you will
Vote DirtyDishSoap
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12*
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 6:04 pm
by nagerous
Joking aside that has to be viewed as a misstep and definitely worthy of a FOS.
If DDS is already going to be underplaying his mafia credentials here the question is why?
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 7:51 pm
by dakky21
TimWoodbury wrote:changing strategy is still change of strategy weather for good reason or not (his reason is good and acceptable) but still if we know he played a certian way in previous games under certian situations and does the opposite here it will throw up red flags
Yes Tim, you are right, it throws up red flags (it's a clear meta), but consider it this way, maybe I want to see what will happen if I don't claim D1 and try to hunt scum without proving I'm town based on role PM's. Having two games active at a same time makes this even more complicated because claiming here can impact the claims in the other game. Let's just try something new, shall we?
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12*
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 8:49 pm
by Samlen
I approve of trying new things out, especially if previous tactics normally lead to being lynched on day 1 =p But you could do with a little lightening up Dakky, you take some of the jokes a bit too seriously.
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 9:05 pm
by legionnare
Ragian wrote:Right. You didn't realise mine was a joke?
Right. You didn't realise mine was taking the piss?
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2017 9:57 pm
by Ragian
legionnare wrote:Ragian wrote:Right. You didn't realise mine was a joke?
Right. You didn't realise mine was taking the piss?
I realised your content was an attempt at taking the piss that clearly had already been taken. I like your squirming, though. It's one vote.
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12* Replacem
Posted: Sat Feb 11, 2017 12:23 am
by DirtyDishSoap
nagerous wrote:DirtyDishSoap wrote:Skoffin wrote: Ahoy mate, not sure if I ever played with you; if we have it was a long time ago.
Nope, forum frequenter, not new to mafia, just new to mafia on here if that makes sense.
Lads, let's get him.
Vote NagerousClearly mafia.
Unvote nagerousEdit - Just to tackle the "new" part for anyone who misunderstands. I'm not new to the game mafia. I am new to "here". Does any of that make sense?
And Fircoal! I think I played like once, waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay back in the day.
I do want to point out though that Djfireside is pretty quick on throwing a vote out on D1 without any substantial evidence other than me being new.
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12*
Posted: Sat Feb 11, 2017 8:06 pm
by Skoffin
DDS -
For the record, you should not be editing your posts. If you make a mistake or forget to add something then you will just have to make a second post stating so. TimWoodbury wrote:Skoffin wrote: Ahoy mate, not sure if I ever played with you; if we have it was a long time ago.
@Tim changing playstyle is a valid option and I see no reason for it to be viewed as scummy, especially when his previous style was getting him a bad reputation and getting him rekt as town in other games. So do explain why trying a new approach is scummy in this circumstance.
changing strategy is still change of strategy weather for good reason or not (his reason is good and acceptable) but still if we know he played a certian way in previous games under certian situations and does the opposite here it will throw up red flags
That's a ridiculous argument; you are essentially saying that no one should ever consider adapting their style of play or aim to improve their performance because it might make it harder for other people (such as yourself) to figure out their alignment. That problem is not on Dakky to resolve, that would mean that you should adapt and get better at feeling scumtells and slips. Preposterous.
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12*
Posted: Sat Feb 11, 2017 8:29 pm
by dakky21
Skoffin wrote:That's a ridiculous argument; you are essentially saying that no one should ever consider adapting their style of play or aim to improve their performance because it might make it harder for other people (such as yourself) to figure out their alignment. That problem is not on Dakky to resolve, that would mean that you should adapt and get better at feeling scumtells and slips. Preposterous.
What I'm wondering here is... just like that Civ game where benga tried to "defend" me... why are you so hardly trying to explain the strategy change to Tim? It reminds me of his play, being scum and trying to act as town. If we had declarations here, you'd already offer me peace... I just don't like it so I'll FOS you, let's see what happens next.
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12*
Posted: Sat Feb 11, 2017 8:37 pm
by Skoffin
If pointing out something I think is dumb counts as valiantly defending someone then ok, bro.
For the record, I'd never offer you peace. Not sure why you would insult me so.
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12*
Posted: Sat Feb 11, 2017 9:32 pm
by dakky21
Skoffin wrote: If pointing out something I think is dumb counts as valiantly defending someone then ok, bro.
For the record, I'd never offer you peace. Not sure why you would insult me so.
Why the change of the color/tone? Just curious. Me insulting you? Can you quote where I insulted you?
Re: Balance Not Included Come Back Mafia *D1 12/12*
Posted: Sat Feb 11, 2017 9:37 pm
by Skoffin
I keep accidentally clicking the wrong one.
You wrongfully assumed I'd offer you peace in this game or any game if I were able to do so as a point against me, this is simply untrue. There are few people I would so casually offer peace to.