Conquer Club

D1 list means little Vs D3 lost Sonic

SoN!c wrote:

DirtyDishSoap wrote:I think it would be generally helpful to start getting together lists of how we feel about other players atm.

Townish.
1. Sonic - Same left field posts I've seen, and I'm generally leaning this to be town.
2. Loose - Same as above but with added math. Yaaaay.
3. Mr Magoo - Refuting alot of the same non sense and not running around trying to get a train going. Being a bit more reserved.

Neutral.
1. EW - Didn't say too much until more or less prodded recently.
2. Strike - Aside from bad naming, he's also relatively quiet.
3. Max - is Max
4. Traf - Traf
5. Kong - Kong


Scummy.
1. Dev - The joke not joke was odd, or at least how it was worded.
2. Pepe - Really intent on being a follower rather than a leader. "Lol iunno, lynch this guy" is pretty lazy.

SK.
DDS

You know i can't refuse lists like this so here is mine (pretty boozed up atm):

Townish.
1. Loose (like everybody agreed)

Neutral.
1. Ragian (but a bit more up town i'd say, then again it's Ragian and he fooled me good last game till the very end..)
2. Pepe and Devante - 60+% townish but anything below 75% is "neutral"
3. Kong - Kong
4. Traf - Traf
5. DDS and Strike - i searched the sus Woff Pair (not a typo) hard and i wanna know, yes, God, i wanna know. But do we got some hard evidence here in the end? Could be (if you wanna believe), could be tunneling too, or could be nothing, just dead fish in the water (if you look at the facts)..
6. Max - is Max



Scummy.
1. EW Oh boy, i was thinking him to be a Mason until that flipped so hard due to his last string of posts..

I think the smart thing to do would not be posting this but town should not hold back on their thoughts. Placing innocent Fos always generates shit back

Where is your reread actual 90+% correct D1 list loose scum?

Ragian and Dev are in the up side... Traf and EW in the down side with you "confirmed" town because...EW said so?

Thx for providing the second name next to max. Its not pepe but loose cabin.
Loose cabin and max.

Vote loose or vote max. Both are hits. Ill follow any of those but PMC is lock town. Dds and Pepe too. Very sury like 87 % sure.

And there loose goose goes... he was here, "users browsing this forum".. running away old chap?

Watching the Tennis mate

Wimbledon old chap? Close to midnight? Whatever chap - feel free to post your D1 list or D2 list or D3 list that comes even close to 40% of mine. I believe the saying is "when hell freezes over old chap". Gg

(Loose running away again)

Unvote Pepe Vote Sonic

Come on Sonic even scum has to unvote first
US open semi mate Draper UK vs Sinner world no1

SoN!c wrote:

Spoiler

[b][color=#FF0000]Unvote[/color][/b]

Click the Show please

Loose Canon wrote:Unvote Pepe Vote Sonic

Come on Sonic even scum has to unvote first
US open semi mate Draper UK vs Sinner world no1

Umgus bad play loose cabin. Post your scummy to chubby list please. Scum never do DDS style - i did. PMC did fast rereading.


But you never did. Gg buddy. See you in the next or go down here

I see you browsing for like 20 minutes now but no reaction..sleep tight. Off to bed here

6 players left each scum faction has 1, 2 masons , 2 vanilla town.
Its 50/50 whether we lynch scum in absence of evidence.
Whether I called Pepe right or not doesn't matter (for the purposes of this argument) , thing is YOU Sonic thought I did.
You didn't fancy 1 vs 3 end game with at least 1 Mason still in play.
You cracked and offered up the Max option of the Pepe and Max might be scum thought.
Max is bad maths, I'd said so, but you'd cracked, and incriminated yourself because of that.

There is no way a Sonic who was calculating what is best for town would have gone for Max over Pepe in these circumstances.

And if you are town you have caused your own mislynch by rubbish play.
But I think you are a baddun, and it will be a correct lynch.

Now you're going for volume of posts over value.

Time for you to claim Mason if you can.

I reckon time is coming to a close for you, you and maybe my fellow townies just don't all quite realise it yet.

GG Sonic you played well D1 D2 and early part of D3.

Getting into bed here.. so just a quick roll.

"6 players left each scum faction has 1, 2 masons , 2 vanilla town"

Your scum Loose. Your saying "Each scum faction has 1 or 2 masons???" Masons are town..,?,,???. You'd know if you were town

Yep Jack has lost, like you, I'm going to bed too.

Get some sleep - if you can.

Loose Canon wrote:There are 2 votes on Pepe (- me and Sonic) , I actually don't want more votes on Pepe till we have assessed the situation as to who the current lynch candidates are.

I would like everyone to think IF there was no further information who they would and would not be prepared to lynch D3, currently.


And as I've suggested it I'll kick it off with mine;

DDS - NO
Sonic - YES - he may be scum if so more likely with EW
PMC - NO
Max - NO (definitely not he can't be with EW)
Pepe - YES - he may be scum if so more likely with Traf

Last night (real time) Sonic chose to flood the forum with posts about D1 lists, rather than take up the above challenge.
I didn't make a D1 list there was nothing I really saw worthy of a list back then, is that really so bad on D1?

Sonic is highly like to be sum and highly likely to be Werewolf with EW.
I say lynch the beast.
Lynch The Beast, Lynch The Beast, Lynch The Beast ... come on all join in...Lynch The Beast, Lynch The Beast

SoN!c wrote:Getting into bed here.. so just a quick roll.

"6 players left each scum faction has 1, 2 masons , 2 vanilla town"

Your scum Loose. Your saying "Each scum faction has 1 or 2 masons???" Masons are town..,?,,???. You'd know if you were town

This is a misread. It's each scum faction has 1. There are two town masons and two vanilla town.

SoN!c wrote:

SoN!c wrote:

DirtyDishSoap wrote:I think it would be generally helpful to start getting together lists of how we feel about other players atm.

Townish.
1. Sonic - Same left field posts I've seen, and I'm generally leaning this to be town.
2. Loose - Same as above but with added math. Yaaaay.
3. Mr Magoo - Refuting alot of the same non sense and not running around trying to get a train going. Being a bit more reserved.

Neutral.
1. EW - Didn't say too much until more or less prodded recently.
2. Strike - Aside from bad naming, he's also relatively quiet.
3. Max - is Max
4. Traf - Traf
5. Kong - Kong


Scummy.
1. Dev - The joke not joke was odd, or at least how it was worded.
2. Pepe - Really intent on being a follower rather than a leader. "Lol iunno, lynch this guy" is pretty lazy.

SK.
DDS

You know i can't refuse lists like this so here is mine (pretty boozed up atm):

Townish.
1. Loose (like everybody agreed)

Neutral.
1. Ragian (but a bit more up town i'd say, then again it's Ragian and he fooled me good last game till the very end..)
2. Pepe and Devante - 60+% townish but anything below 75% is "neutral"
3. Kong - Kong
4. Traf - Traf
5. DDS and Strike - i searched the sus Woff Pair (not a typo) hard and i wanna know, yes, God, i wanna know. But do we got some hard evidence here in the end? Could be (if you wanna believe), could be tunneling too, or could be nothing, just dead fish in the water (if you look at the facts)..
6. Max - is Max



Scummy.
1. EW Oh boy, i was thinking him to be a Mason until that flipped so hard due to his last string of posts..

I think the smart thing to do would not be posting this but town should not hold back on their thoughts. Placing innocent Fos always generates shit back

Where is your reread actual 90+% correct D1 list loose scum?

This doesn't necessarily have to be town, sticking traf on the middle/bottom of your list with no reason could be a distancing thing and all the other players are as unknown to you as they would be as town.

I think I have to do what I have been putting off; actually try read sonic and loose Canon. I love that you guys are active and wish more people were but its definitely more of a slog with so many posts

SoN!c wrote:

Loose Canon wrote:We have to lynch day 1 and every day.
Does anyone disagree?

I looked up mafia wiki and looked for "best to play scenario's" based on mafia wiki stats on this scenario. I deleted that idea in the end because the game only starts when everybody has confirmed their role invite..

Only 9 confirmed sofar? So first we need to wait on everybody's confirmed status. That means waiting on Max too and whatever he wants to say

And the deleted idea was basically to ask EW what would be the best play here (having no PR). Last game lynching D1 turned out to be a bad idea so hearing EW and following EW seems plan? 7 to 11 chance EW is town and if he is not we will notice it when he posts something deviant perhaps? Also Lynching D1 means very blind (as good as random) odds that we will lynch on 4/11 odds hitting scum (very low chance)? Is not helping if we lynch town. We should hear very experienced players first is my idea. Though nut to crack here

This post, as one of sonics first is very intruiging. It shows respect for EW, which would mean he would be high up sonics kill list as opposing faction. They did take two nights to kill him though. As same faction, this would be one helluva ballsy move to do post one, as it clearly links you. Yes, yes, I know, WIFOM.

This post, as one of sonics first is very intruiging. It shows respect for EW, which would mean he would be high up sonics kill list as opposing faction. They did take two nights to kill him though. As same faction, this would be one helluva ballsy move to do post one, as it clearly links you. Yes, yes, I know, WIFOM.

Not only this one but more like the chubby to scummy list where i have EW as scum later on the day.

Its stupid to think im EW's scumpartner like Loose is saying so my guess is he is and he knows he has to pin it on somebody else.
Only then it makes sense what he is doing.

Yeah but it is possible you are trafs partner. Like, that would explain your lock town read on me, I can't be EWs partner even more than you because I shouted about killing him yesterday (yes I know, wifom, but cmon).

Having said that, if I was trafs partner my very first post was to say he was lock scum, so the town readn is acceptable.

You just aren't clear of being trafs partner.

By the way, me and Sonic being EW polarised should be very helpful, there can't be that many options for EWs partner.