Conquer Club

Posted: **Sun Dec 11, 2016 7:24 pm**

The1exile wrote:With Mandy's additional information, at least we're all on the same page (which I, obviously, was not previously, not having a wincon to compare to). It seems to me that the existence of wild pokemon - likely the majority of this game - shows we should return to trainer tracking. However, I'm believing MM's town credentials atm. Mets is acting scummy but I can easily see him just acting like a dick because he's annoyed at this update from a player perspective.

Seems a bit unfair to keep my vote on you after seeing the disadvantage you were under, sooo Unvote.

I don't usually re-read Day 1 until after Night 1 usually but I might have to in this case with mandy's new info. Should be a few players (barring myself of course) making accidental trainer reveals. Hell I might need to draw up a pad of notes for this game judging by how it's gone so far. That'll be a first.

Metsfanmax wrote:Ok, I quit. mandy, please replace me.

I understand that yer annoyed about mandy's intervention (pretty unprecedented if my memory is to be believed. Even Fircoal hasn't done this, and he's done pretty much everything), but that's no reason to quit.

Posted: **Sun Dec 11, 2016 7:39 pm**

Also something's been bothering me recently and I've just found out what it was.

strike wolf wrote:So first off Unvote Kwanton. So there is one thing that Mandy's post suggests, that people who don't know about wild pokemon win cons are most likely town trainers. So Masket. You are now towards the top of my town list. Tal conveniently ignores this.

It also makes this game a bit more difficult as all those who were semi-cleared based on knowing role info are now back in the mix. In fact, at least one was likely lying to preemptively clear themselves.

Trust good ol' MM to question a point that seems to validate myself, but it needs to be said. That isn't what mandy's post said at all.

mandalorian2298 wrote:It neither confirms nor denies it, since I have, as I have done in my previous game, made Mafia immune to PM quoters. Exile was officialy the last one of 26 players to learn VCs for Wild pokemon, which were, in Mafia PMs, attached bellow their own VCs, along with sample Wild Pokemon PMs.

I thought that last part was obvious to you guys. I had to do it otherwise any...cough...pokemon could just use my giant Role PM template as lie detector instead of playing Mafia.

He's saying that ALL players know about wild Pokemon win conditions.

Posted: **Sun Dec 11, 2016 8:03 pm**

Metsfanmax wrote:mitch is just being careless as usual. We Wild Pokemon were told how many types there were (i.e. Fire), but mitch interpreted that to mean that there were only five Wild Pokemon. I actually made the same mistake when I first read my role PM.

You didn't have to say it. Exile had not yet confirmed he knew that. And that info was not in the win condition section so it is possible it wasn't in what Mandy sent him.

Posted: **Sun Dec 11, 2016 8:04 pm**

And you already asked to be replaced before that post. Why are you still saying anything anyway?

Posted: **Sun Dec 11, 2016 8:28 pm**

kwanton wrote:
Metsfanmax wrote:mitch is just being careless as usual. We Wild Pokemon were told how many types there were (i.e. Fire), but mitch interpreted that to mean that there were only five Wild Pokemon. I actually made the same mistake when I first read my role PM.

You didn't have to say it. Exile had not yet confirmed he knew that. And that info was not in the win condition section so it is possible it wasn't in what Mandy sent him.

It had nothing to do with Exile, I was trying to stop mitch from getting lynched for a stupid reason. And besides, Skittles confirmed it too.

Posted: **Sun Dec 11, 2016 8:46 pm**

what an idiot I am, there are 4 more types running around in Kanton region .does not say how many, sorry,

Posted: **Sun Dec 11, 2016 8:54 pm**

Metsfanmax wrote:
kwanton wrote:
Metsfanmax wrote:mitch is just being careless as usual. We Wild Pokemon were told how many types there were (i.e. Fire), but mitch interpreted that to mean that there were only five Wild Pokemon. I actually made the same mistake when I first read my role PM.

You didn't have to say it. Exile had not yet confirmed he knew that. And that info was not in the win condition section so it is possible it wasn't in what Mandy sent him.

It had nothing to do with Exile, I was trying to stop mitch from getting lynched for a stupid reason. And besides, Skittles confirmed it too.

Stop posting. You quit the game.

Posted: **Sun Dec 11, 2016 8:56 pm**

Metsfanmax wrote:It had nothing to do with Exile, I was trying to stop mitch from getting lynched for a stupid reason. And besides, Skittles confirmed it too.

madmitch wrote:#-o what an idiot I am, there are 4 more types running around in Kanton region .does not say how many, sorry,

So Mets is actually protecting mitch. Defending or however you want.

Why I find this interesting... because I'll claim a wild pokemon as well. But with a little difference... I'm already taken. I know which Pokemon I am, and I know who taken me as a starting pokemon. So I will do whatever my trainer decides and I can't do anything about it.

Seems mitch is Mets Pokemon....

unvote

Posted: **Sun Dec 11, 2016 9:09 pm**

kwanton wrote:
Metsfanmax wrote:
kwanton wrote:
Metsfanmax wrote:mitch is just being careless as usual. We Wild Pokemon were told how many types there were (i.e. Fire), but mitch interpreted that to mean that there were only five Wild Pokemon. I actually made the same mistake when I first read my role PM.

You didn't have to say it. Exile had not yet confirmed he knew that. And that info was not in the win condition section so it is possible it wasn't in what Mandy sent him.

It had nothing to do with Exile, I was trying to stop mitch from getting lynched for a stupid reason. And besides, Skittles confirmed it too.

Stop posting. You quit the game.

No, I'll be a good citizen and continue to post until I am replaced. I am not quitting because I want to, I am quitting because I was asked to.

Posted: **Sun Dec 11, 2016 9:17 pm**

Metsfanmax wrote:
kwanton wrote:
Metsfanmax wrote:
kwanton wrote:
Metsfanmax wrote:mitch is just being careless as usual. We Wild Pokemon were told how many types there were (i.e. Fire), but mitch interpreted that to mean that there were only five Wild Pokemon. I actually made the same mistake when I first read my role PM.

You didn't have to say it. Exile had not yet confirmed he knew that. And that info was not in the win condition section so it is possible it wasn't in what Mandy sent him.

It had nothing to do with Exile, I was trying to stop mitch from getting lynched for a stupid reason. And besides, Skittles confirmed it too.

Stop posting. You quit the game.

No, I'll be a good citizen and continue to post until I am replaced. I am not quitting because I want to, I am quitting because I was asked to.

Stop being a little bitch. You're not a good citizen, you're a bitch.

Posted: **Sun Dec 11, 2016 9:25 pm**

dakky21 wrote:
Metsfanmax wrote:It had nothing to do with Exile, I was trying to stop mitch from getting lynched for a stupid reason. And besides, Skittles confirmed it too.

madmitch wrote:#-o what an idiot I am, there are 4 more types running around in Kanton region .does not say how many, sorry,

So Mets is actually protecting mitch. Defending or however you want.

Why I find this interesting... because I'll claim a wild pokemon as well. But with a little difference... I'm already taken. I know which Pokemon I am, and I know who taken me as a starting pokemon. So I will do whatever my trainer decides and I can't do anything about it.

Seems mitch is Mets Pokemon....

unvote

So you're not a wild Pokemon, just a Pokemon.

As I'm on my phone I'm not going to trawl back like 10 pages, but who was it that suggested we try and pair up players to try and figure out who is scum? I know who said we shouldn't bother (Skoffin) but can't remember who suggested it.

Posted: **Sun Dec 11, 2016 9:32 pm**

Skittles! wrote:So you're not a wild Pokemon, just a Pokemon.

No, my role is Wild Pokemon, but 2 days later I got another role that I was claimed and that I can't no more attack or defend - that will my trainer decide. That's why I believe mitch is Mets pokemon and that's why I unvoted him. More pairs to be found though...

Posted: **Sun Dec 11, 2016 9:33 pm**

I already claimed Wild Pokemon for myself.

Posted: **Sun Dec 11, 2016 9:35 pm**

dakky21 wrote:
Skittles! wrote:So you're not a wild Pokemon, just a Pokemon.

No, my role is Wild Pokemon, but 2 days later I got another role that I was claimed and that I can't no more attack or defend - that will my trainer decide. That's why I believe mitch is Mets pokemon and that's why I unvoted him. More pairs to be found though...

Oh wow okay. Can't imagine your trainer would be happy that you're claiming though?

Posted: **Mon Dec 12, 2016 12:03 am**

Minister Masket wrote:Also something's been bothering me recently and I've just found out what it was.

strike wolf wrote:So first off Unvote Kwanton. So there is one thing that Mandy's post suggests, that people who don't know about wild pokemon win cons are most likely town trainers. So Masket. You are now towards the top of my town list. Tal conveniently ignores this.

It also makes this game a bit more difficult as all those who were semi-cleared based on knowing role info are now back in the mix. In fact, at least one was likely lying to preemptively clear themselves.

Trust good ol' MM to question a point that seems to validate myself, but it needs to be said. That isn't what mandy's post said at all.

mandalorian2298 wrote:It neither confirms nor denies it, since I have, as I have done in my previous game, made Mafia immune to PM quoters. Exile was officialy the last one of 26 players to learn VCs for Wild pokemon, which were, in Mafia PMs, attached bellow their own VCs, along with sample Wild Pokemon PMs.

I thought that last part was obvious to you guys. I had to do it otherwise any...cough...pokemon could just use my giant Role PM template as lie detector instead of playing Mafia.

He's saying that ALL players know about wild Pokemon win conditions.

I had assumed that it was badly worded by Mandy to mean that everyone whow needed the win con received it as he goes on to specifically mention it being in mafia pms. Obviously as a claimed trainer you are saying you and other trainers had access to pokemon win cons.

So who recruited dakky...

Reread through page 10. So far willing to say that Buj is town.

Posted: **Mon Dec 12, 2016 2:32 am**

Well a lot happened since I was here last. And apparently a lot more drama. Just a suggestion but we can all tone it down a bit. We're all trying to find Team Rocket here. We have a common goal. Sure we may to find those members and lynch them but that doesn't mean they're any less loved irl.

Anyway I find the whole Met's wagon a bit weird imo. It feels like Mets is getting annoyed in a way that seems suicidal if scum. If you were scum woudl you really want be on the record yelling, "STOP MAKING IT EASIER FOR TOWN!" Exactly. I think he is genuinely upset with how the game is being handled. I don't think that's necessarily a scum thing. Some people really value fair play. I don't know too much about Mets so I can't make this call from any authority but I do feel like people are being a bit jumpy when they throw their votes onto him. AD, aage, Serbia - what makes you so sure that mets is scum?

BuJaber wrote:
WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:
Indeed as I have said to Legionairre, there is limited incentive for me to scumhunt strongly. So dont sit about waiting for me to do so.

If you guys stop asking me for information, I will stop with the sarcastic posting. Its very simple.

So the case on wing is partly based on this quote?
TELL ME PLEASE HOW THAT MEANS HE HAS NO INTEREST IN SCUMHUNTING???? How about YOU read it again. He just doesn't want people to rely on him for it, and look towards him like he has some sort of crystal ball. If you think I'm wrong then please attach a phone number of an english teacher with your post so that I can improve my comprehension.

and I'm the one getting accused of skimming.

Ummm I think you need to reread that post. Because he states that he has limited incentive for him to scumhunt strongly. He doesn't say that he doesn't want people to rely on him. Those are words that you feed into him. Stop trying to protect him from something that's not there.

The Weird One wrote:
Fircoal wrote:As for TWO, I'm not sure if he's clueless scum or if he just missed the important peice. While I certainly FOS him, my vote is still on Serbia for now. I would like to see him respond though.

You seem to be rolling with the "either you're third party survivor or you're scum" rather smoothly...And as with any game I've been in, whatever my alignment is makes no difference to my being clueless. You should know this, by now.

Yes which is why I FOS'd you instead of voting you. I am well aware that you can be clueless regardless of role. That was my point. Maybe I didn't state it the best way but I did account for it.

Minister Masket wrote:So my question now is if Wing's list and this reasoning is accurate, why has he only named 5 or 6 players? Where are the other dozen?
Role power limitation, or something more suspicious? Hmm.

Because he doesn't know the other dozen? Look I don't agree with the absolutes Wing is doing but it is BS to try to case suspicion on him for that. How is he supposed to know who all the wild Pokemon are? It seems like you're trying to make a case to divert attention from yourself which is scummy.

dakky21 wrote:
Skittles! wrote:So you're not a wild Pokemon, just a Pokemon.

No, my role is Wild Pokemon, but 2 days later I got another role that I was claimed and that I can't no more attack or defend - that will my trainer decide. That's why I believe mitch is Mets pokemon and that's why I unvoted him. More pairs to be found though...

Something smells fishy. Day 1 capture? That's certainly something new. I also find it interesting that dakky would be targeted.

Posted: **Mon Dec 12, 2016 4:32 am**

I either don't believe dakky's claim, or that's he's been recruited into a non-town faction.

Vote dakky21

Posted: **Mon Dec 12, 2016 5:04 am**

Serbia wrote:
Metsfanmax wrote:
kwanton wrote:
Metsfanmax wrote:
kwanton wrote:
Metsfanmax wrote:mitch is just being careless as usual. We Wild Pokemon were told how many types there were (i.e. Fire), but mitch interpreted that to mean that there were only five Wild Pokemon. I actually made the same mistake when I first read my role PM.

You didn't have to say it. Exile had not yet confirmed he knew that. And that info was not in the win condition section so it is possible it wasn't in what Mandy sent him.

It had nothing to do with Exile, I was trying to stop mitch from getting lynched for a stupid reason. And besides, Skittles confirmed it too.

Stop posting. You quit the game.

No, I'll be a good citizen and continue to post until I am replaced. I am not quitting because I want to, I am quitting because I was asked to.

Stop being a little bitch. You're not a good citizen, you're a bitch.

This is just lame. It's all he said, she said. Get over it and move on. It gets so pathetic to read. Let's play a game.

@dakky, when were you claimed? What do you mean by "two days later"?

Posted: **Mon Dec 12, 2016 5:17 am**

The case on Mets is very weak. There are numerous reasons why someone would be upset by Mandy's posts. Most of them are actually indicative of a town or wild pokemon alignment.

Mets if you have real life reasons to quit, do so, don't do it because a bunch of players were aggressive towards you. Maybe it's their personality, maybe it's their way of putting pressure to scumhunt.

Dakky's claim is very strange.

Serbia soft-claimed wild pokemon a few posts back, but all his votes have been on either tim, mitch, or MM. And now he jumps on Mets. It's not sitting right with me.

I don't think Mitch is the right lynch anymore, I'm going to go with Ragian's case & Unvote Vote Marashu.

Posted: **Mon Dec 12, 2016 5:35 am**

I think we should all calm down and cease being dickbag and antagonising people out of the game, and the attitude towards mets in ridiculous. He, regardless of possible alignment, is justified in feeling put off by people playing the mod rather than the game. Whether you personally believe the mod revealed too much game info is beside the point - any mod unfairly favouring one team would be off-putting for any game and some people do not want to win or lose based on that, which is a fair feeling to have. I've won as mafia before because town handed me the game and it doesn't feel like victory at all. If mets believes the mod has unbalanced the game then it is fair for him to feel put off by that. Personally I would prefer mets to stay in the game rather than use up our replacement pool. If we are going to replace people based on "omg I don't like you" then half a dozen of you would be gone by now.

Anarkistsdream wrote:There are those of us who were trainer hunting from the beginning, me included... That is why I have not posted since Friday... Because these other arguments have been ridiculous until mets decided he should be a complete cunt.

So you are saying because no one was talking about what you wanted to talk about, instead of trying to force your input on in anyway, you decided to be weaksauce and just walk off for a few days? Is this what you plan to do throughout the game? Pls, don't be such a vagina.

As for Dakky -
to confirm - You started this game as a wild pokemon, and sometime during this Day 1 you have been caught by a trainer?

Well it would seem trainers are not limited to night activity in that case, and more wild pokemon will likely be nabbed soon. Good thing a whole bunch of people revealed themselves eh :lol:

Posted: **Mon Dec 12, 2016 6:38 am**

Skoffin wrote: If we are going to replace people based on "omg I don't like you" then half a dozen of you would be gone by now.

Favourite statement of the game so far =D>

Posted: **Mon Dec 12, 2016 8:08 am**

Skoffin wrote:I think we should all calm down and cease being dickbag and antagonising people out of the game,

Is this what you plan to do throughout the game? Pls, don't be such a vagina.

...............

Skoffin wrote:
Well it would seem trainers are not limited to night activity in that case, and more wild pokemon will likely be nabbed soon. Good thing a whole bunch of people revealed themselves eh

A, You are Wild Pokemon, you wouldnt find this funny.
B, You are town trainer, you wouldnt be surprised
C, you are team rocket. Well this makes sense.

Posted: **Mon Dec 12, 2016 8:39 am**

Unvote. My vote on mets was completely OMGUS, a drunk rage vote, based on his request to be replaced. I hate when people quit, and I was voting for a quitter. He's since continued playing the game. Hopefully he just pulls up his big boy pants and moves on. And I apologize for contributing to the decline of the game.

You're going to go back and see that I voted for a bunch of people who have since claimed to be wild pokemon, and say that doesn't sit right with you? Please, for the love of The Town, point out the people who have only voted for scum, so I can be just like them and also vote for scum. It's Day 1 bro, virtually all of us will get a few votes wrong on Day 1.

Marashu has been non-existent. Because he's scum? Or because he's not really participating?

Posted: **Mon Dec 12, 2016 8:39 am**

Fircoal wrote:AD, aage, Serbia - what makes you so sure that mets is scum?

It's a rare scenario where a policy lynch overlaps with a scum-aimed lynch.
In his earlier statement he said he wanted to play the players, not the mod. He has done nothing but play the mod since then. I think avoiding the actual game and only responding to outside interference makes you look alive even though you're not really playing.
As to his "I quit" shenanigans, you read the thread. If he seriously thinks this game is so unwinnable for him when Mandy interferes and confirms so little, he can't be town right? :roll:

Thirdly, this:

Metsfanmax wrote:Disagree. Tim has had exactly this type of tantrum before in other games and it's not alignment-indicative.

does not logically follow into a scum read on Tim. He says it's not alignment-indicative, and he is quite right. Doesn't make Tim scum, doesn't explain his vote.

I have nothing to do with the flame war between Mets, Nark and Serbia.

Posted: **Mon Dec 12, 2016 8:53 am**

Fircoal is scum for deliberately misreading dakky. Dakky said he is someone's starter Pokemon, not a day 1 recruit. Mandy already said night actions will be resolved in the day. Masket can confirm how it works. It's great, if dakky flips town we kill masket. It's win/win at this point.

Conquer Club

Indigo League Mafia/RPG Final Scene

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!

Re: Indigo League Mafia/RPG Day 1 - Full speed ahead!