Prison Mafia TOWN WIN !!

[Darin44]

I forgot my point on the no mafia kill...

DON'T mention it in order to get town cred, but if you protected someone tonight, there's a chance that that someone was targeted by mafia. That means that you can safely assume that the person you protected is non-mafia (can't rule out third party). Anyway, you can lean towards that person (but do it secretly).

I would to say. How is it good for town if someone is handing out shanks( degaston).and if you are town why would you use it.Maybe you use it for the mafia kill. to throw town off. Plus giving out shanks sound scummy to me. now *Pixar* has one

Why does it sound scummy to hand them out? Do you find that Dega's choices of handing them to Josh and me is a bad choice? Do you feel that using it on actorday was unwarranted?

I do feel like there was better options than actorday in my opinion. We had a slight idea actorday was some sort of messenger

I thank Josh really didn't want to use it so he went for *Pixar* don't thank he would drop it just silenced

RL calling be back in about 10 hrs

[degaston]

I forgot my point on the no mafia kill...

DON'T mention it in order to get town cred, but if you protected someone tonight, there's a chance that that someone was targeted by mafia. That means that you can safely assume that the person you protected is non-mafia (can't rule out third party). Anyway, you can lean towards that person (but do it secretly).

I would to say. How is it good for town if someone is handing out shanks( degaston).and if you are town why would you use it.Maybe you use it for the mafia kill. to throw town off. Plus giving out shanks sound scummy to me. now *Pixar* has one

I don't think that handing out shanks could ever be a scum role. They would just give them to their scum buddies and get two kills per night. It is something that can make the game extra "swingy", but that's likely to be the case anyway when everyone has a power role.

I gave the first one to Ragian because I thought he was town, and had the experience to use it wisely. I couldn't be sure, but after already losing our Doctor and Detective, I decided it was worth the risk. Maybe I was wrong.

Not sure that I agree with actorday as a target, so I've been looking to see if there was any reason to suspect Ragian. There have been a couple of things he's said that I thought he should have known better, but nothing I could build a case on. I've also been thinking about there being no mafia kill last night. One possibility is that they targeted cd (unlikely, since it was obvious he was due to be mod-killed) or actor. If there was nothing else that could have prevented a kill, then that would explain it, and at the same time confirm that Ragian is not mafia. (unless this is all part of their plan, but that may be too much wine, even for me)

But I think it's more likely that the mafia were blocked somehow, and I'll have to keep Ragian as not 100% confirmed town.

[PepeAtila]

After so much reading I don't know what more to add.... by now.

[degaston]

After so much reading I don't know what more to add.... by now.

Can you explain what you hoped to achieve by visiting Pixar?

[Dunk90]

Ok, so General Bax not saying anything before getting lynched while being a cop is unusual.
1. was he really a cop or we just see him as a cop after he died?
2. does he know how to play the game?

I am back at my original opinion and I think we should lynch Pixar, but i want to see what Pepe has to say about why he was muted and if/why he visited Pixar.

Also, whoever visited me last night I think is confirmed town so you may confirm the visit.

I visited you but there was someone else present. Message didn’t say who it was

I visited i-andrei and saw you pass something him. what was it?

I passed him a tazer. I was going to use it myself, but wasn't sure on who. I figured Andrei might have a better grasp on who mafia might be and use it on them. I was afraid I might be night killed.

[i-andrei]

Ok, so General Bax not saying anything before getting lynched while being a cop is unusual.
1. was he really a cop or we just see him as a cop after he died?
2. does he know how to play the game?

I am back at my original opinion and I think we should lynch Pixar, but i want to see what Pepe has to say about why he was muted and if/why he visited Pixar.

Also, whoever visited me last night I think is confirmed town so you may confirm the visit.

I visited you but there was someone else present. Message didn’t say who it was

I visited i-andrei and saw you pass something him. what was it?

I passed him a tazer. I was going to use it myself, but wasn't sure on who. I figured Andrei might have a better grasp on who mafia might be and use it on them. I was afraid I might be night killed.

I confirm the tazer but i see no point in using it to get someone silenced.

[Ragian]

I don't understand your point, darin. If scum could hand out shanks, they'd be immensely powerful (cf. Dega's points). I'm 99% sure that Dega is not mafia. Even if he doesn't reciprocate the sentiment.

[i-andrei]

I don't understand your point, darin. If scum could hand out shanks, they'd be immensely powerful (cf. Dega's points). I'm 99% sure that Dega is not mafia. Even if he doesn't reciprocate the sentiment.

I am not sure about you also at this point.
You posted that note about chanakram after he got killed and i believed you did that so he doesn't get targetted. But you could have done that so he doesn't get protected.

I also believe at this point degaston is town and i also have darrin, pershy and dukasaur in that category.
Not sure about dunk. If he made that fazer and according to mafia.gg he should be Electrician, then he's town, otherwise i don't know.
I got Fussi almost town.

So at this point i would be willing to vote same as the people i trust to be town.

Still think Pixar should be outed right now but will leave that up for debate.

[i-andrei]

Yes, I killed actorday with a shank that I believe was given to me by josh (he said, "shank you very much," which I took to be a clue). This also means that there was no mafia kill (well, it means that to me, not to anyone who thinks I'm mafia).
.

Where did he say this?
I do have a follow-up theory but i need to see this first.

[degaston]

Yes, I killed actorday with a shank that I believe was given to me by josh (he said, "shank you very much," which I took to be a clue). This also means that there was no mafia kill (well, it means that to me, not to anyone who thinks I'm mafia).
.

Where did he say this?
I do have a follow-up theory but i need to see this first.

Page 18:

Knowing who to trust in this prison is key. I feel like there's someone here who trusts me, but they're basically just throwing their arms in the air and dealing with the chaos.

If this describes you, and you trust me, please let me know. No more details are necessary. It will help me know who I can trust!

Shank you very much.

[i-andrei]

Well then maybe you and Ragian should get your story straight:

https://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewt ... d#p5283476

If it's in anyone's interest, I received my shank N1. Didn't use it N2 because I wasn't sure who to target.

https://www.conquerclub.com/game.php?game=22404713

I gave the first one to Ragian because I thought he was town, and had the experience to use it wisely. I couldn't be sure, but after already losing our Doctor and Detective, I decided it was worth the risk. Maybe I was wrong.

Detective died N1 so after Ragian claims you gave him the shank
This means you could lie and impersonate the role, and had Josh muted so he can't contradict you.

[degaston]

Well then maybe you and Ragian should get your story straight:

https://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewt ... d#p5283476

If it's in anyone's interest, I received my shank N1. Didn't use it N2 because I wasn't sure who to target.

https://www.conquerclub.com/game.php?game=22404713

I gave the first one to Ragian because I thought he was town, and had the experience to use it wisely. I couldn't be sure, but after already losing our Doctor and Detective, I decided it was worth the risk. Maybe I was wrong.

Detective died N1 so after Ragian claims you gave him the shank
This means you could lie and impersonate the role, and had Josh muted so he can't contradict you.

Sorry, my mistake. We had only lost the doctor at that point, but I didn't go back and check when I made that post. After 28 pages, a lot has happened.
In any case, I still thought Ragian was the best combination of townieness and experience at that point.

[Darin44]

I don't understand your point, darin. If scum could hand out shanks, they'd be immensely powerful (cf. Dega's points). I'm 99% sure that Dega is not mafia. Even if he doesn't reciprocate the sentiment.

I just don't like someone giving out shanks to kill town.

[Ragian]

I don't understand your point, darin. If scum could hand out shanks, they'd be immensely powerful (cf. Dega's points). I'm 99% sure that Dega is not mafia. Even if he doesn't reciprocate the sentiment.

I am not sure about you also at this point.
You posted that note about chanakram after he got killed and i believed you did that so he doesn't get targetted. But you could have done that so he doesn't get protected.

What? What note?

I don't understand your point, darin. If scum could hand out shanks, they'd be immensely powerful (cf. Dega's points). I'm 99% sure that Dega is not mafia. Even if he doesn't reciprocate the sentiment.

I just don't like someone giving out shanks to kill town.

You're being polemic now. Of course it wasn't meant to hurt town. I just got it wrong. You have no problem with Fusi killing off Loose Canon, right? The only difference here is that I got it wrong. My experience with mafia and newbies led me to believe that actorday was indeed scum. Yes, I got it wrong, but I will maintain - even in the noose - that I made a decent choice based on the intel available to me.

[i-andrei]

Why target Chana? He didn't contribute to solving this for town at all...the same with TheJonah. I don't get the killings done.

Now, I've suspected Pix since his D1 vote for Dunk. However, 3rd party can be a lot. Maybe he has something to do with the people who end up talking jibberish? Let's hear what you have to say, Pix.

I also want to share something from D2 that I didn't make it in time to share before the day ended as I received towards the end of D2:

"chanakam did not share a note its true
they could have received great power unlike you
in order to get they were asked not to meow
instead continued to eat cat chow
now the cats are quiet and saved themselves
do not trust silent cons and save yourselves"

There are some things that I don't quite understand and need everyone's take on. It specifically mentions Chana and then he was murdered. I don't know what to make of that. Also, it says that Chana could have received powers unlike me. Does that mean that I can't receive powers? Any thoughts? I'm seriously at a loss here.

FP'ed loads. Will read later. Am teaching.

This

[Ragian]

What about that note?

[Ragian]

I asked for everyone's opinion on its meaning, but almost no one cared, so I left it. Why do you bring it up now?

[i-andrei]

You posted that note about chanakram after he got killed and i believed you did that so he doesn't get targetted fpr somethinghe knew. But you could have done that so he doesn't get protected.

[Ragian]

I need to understand what you're suggesting. Are you suggesting that I posted the note that I received (from someone who is not Chana, obviously) in order for people not to figure out something about Chana after we know everything about him? That doesn't make any sense. What do you mean so that he wasn't protected? He was dead. I seriously struggle to fathom what you're on about. Try explaining it to me as you would to a child.

[PepeAtila]

Can you explain what you hoped to achieve by visiting Pixar?

It was about what happened on day 2.
I was fully wrong about halrob, after fusibaseball telling he was responsible for Loose Canon's death (because somebody saw him to do it) he was the first vote for halrob, but quickly I felt like everybody was trusting fusibaseball without any doubt ... and then he wrote:

Also, I mostly expect to be killed over Night 2 for shamelessly leading the witch hunt to get out Halrob and set Town on what I believe to be the right track. Since I've already made myself public enemy #1, I see no reason to hold back at this juncture so am just going to start calling out people.

I think these 3 from my above group are, by this point, ACTIVELY suspicious through their contribution of zero to game, vacuous/meaningless posts, and reluctance to vote:
1) cdbridges
2) Dukasaur
3) General Bax

These 3 I find to be more believable and are mostly who I'm looking at to get the vote through for Halrob:
1) joshzam
2) TheJMac
3) actorday

And if I'm still here Day 3, I'll be pleasantly surprised but I at least want Town to have some names to go off Day 3 if Halrob flips Mafia (of course, this would all be after getting out Pepe who has declared himself).

So I was afraid somebody could kill me that night, and I asked (to Raz) and he told me if I was 'visiting' somebody and other person kill me, then the guy I am visiting will see though. So, who I trusted?

Holy cow lots of deaths. Looks like maybe a 3rd party has killed a mafia member for us? Also looks like we got some duplicate rolls that can hush people, from what I can tell that's a mafia role when I look it up? Correct me if I'm wrong. Anyone got any useful information to share? Going to be really hard to lynch someone with 3 people quiet and needing 10 votes I must say.

basically I was looking for a witness if I was killed
But the next day showed me I made 2 'errors' :
1. I did believe harolb was no defended by Mafia.
2. I did trust *Pixar* was a good witness.

Now I have a different list on who to trust and who don't, but of course so many mistakes the 2 firsts days are difficult to erase.

[pershy]

Also Josh wasn't found curled up in a ball with white hair in a scene - but is talking gibberish. I guess it's a given but I don't understand why it wasn't stated in the scene.

Did you miss this?

joshzam is found curled up crying under the staircase, his hair has turned white
He is speaking gibberish.
You will not get anything out of him today on day 4

Oh yes I did miss that - thank you.

Listen I still have to read through what has happened since yesterday but I just wanna air a crazy idea that was niggling at me.
It seems there were no mafia kills - so far like most of you I have trusted josh until now - he always seems to be investigative to me. But he could be fooling us as well - he's a good mafia player.
Anyway I still wanna trust him - but I was just wondering if there was no mafia kill cause HE tried to make the kill and couldn't cause he targeted pixar or got silenced. Anyway it's a crazy idea - but I'm just putting it out there and have to mull it over and see if it's plausible.

[Darin44]

I don't understand your point, darin. If scum could hand out shanks, they'd be immensely powerful (cf. Dega's points). I'm 99% sure that Dega is not mafia. Even if he doesn't reciprocate the sentiment.

I am not sure about you also at this point.
You posted that note about chanakram after he got killed and i believed you did that so he doesn't get targetted. But you could have done that so he doesn't get protected.

What? What note?

I don't understand your point, darin. If scum could hand out shanks, they'd be immensely powerful (cf. Dega's points). I'm 99% sure that Dega is not mafia. Even if he doesn't reciprocate the sentiment.

I just don't like someone giving out shanks to kill town.

You're being polemic now. Of course it wasn't meant to hurt town. I just got it wrong. You have no problem with Fusi killing off Loose Canon, right? The only difference here is that I got it wrong. My experience with mafia and newbies led me to believe that actorday was indeed scum. Yes, I got it wrong, but I will maintain - even in the noose - that I made a decent choice based on the intel available to me.

I didn't say, I don't have no problem with Fusi killing Loose Canon Because I do. Now you are on the same list. The I just don't know about list.

[Darin44]

Also Josh wasn't found curled up in a ball with white hair in a scene - but is talking gibberish. I guess it's a given but I don't understand why it wasn't stated in the scene.

Did you miss this?

joshzam is found curled up crying under the staircase, his hair has turned white
He is speaking gibberish.
You will not get anything out of him today on day 4

Oh yes I did miss that - thank you.

Listen I still have to read through what has happened since yesterday but I just wanna air a crazy idea that was niggling at me.
It seems there were no mafia kills - so far like most of you I have trusted josh until now - he always seems to be investigative to me. But he could be fooling us as well - he's a good mafia player.
Anyway I still wanna trust him - but I was just wondering if there was no mafia kill cause HE tried to make the kill and couldn't cause he targeted pixar or got silenced. Anyway it's a crazy idea - but I'm just putting it out there and have to mull it over and see if it's plausible.

I thought about that myself too.

[Ragian]

Okay, we don't see eye to eye on that, then. Fusi did away with an anti town role. That's definitely a positive move. I was convinced that I did the same.

[i-andrei]

I need to understand what you're suggesting. Are you suggesting that I posted the note that I received (from someone who is not Chana, obviously) in order for people not to figure out something about Chana after we know everything about him? That doesn't make any sense. What do you mean so that he wasn't protected? He was dead. I seriously struggle to fathom what you're on about. Try explaining it to me as you would to a child.

When i read the below i tought you kept this intentionally D2 to protect chanakram, t
Who likely knew something about Mafia.
Now, i'm thinking you could be mafia and you didn't share it so chanakram wouldn't get protection from a town player so you killed him N2.
Makes sense now?

I also want to share something from D2 that I didn't make it in time to share before the day ended as I received towards the end of D2:

"chanakam did not share a note its true
they could have received great power unlike you
in order to get they were asked not to meow
instead continued to eat cat chow
now the cats are quiet and saved themselves
do not trust silent cons and save yourselves"