Conquer Club

Ragian wrote:I still don't get it, Pika. To me, it's counter intuitive to lynch someone whom you think is town in order to verify it. Ultimately, mafia is about gut feeling. I think it unwise to go to night in an attempt to check if your town read of someone is accurate because you don't learn anything, and scum gets a kill.

I'd much rather pursue someone I think scum.

dakky21 wrote:

madmitch wrote:

Kamikaze Jawa wrote:I'm also not sure why you flip between MM and HS, and your unwavering support of dakky this entire day has been somewhat suspicious (defending him long before we got his claim). That too seems suspicious mitch.

Believe me I have not supporting Dakky and I was going to vote for him until he came out with his claim, I don't want to die early again and granted you have not played in games with Dakky and myself, if you did you would see Dakky is always on my ass and loves to get me killed one way or the other

madmitch wrote:Can we have a vote count please

Skoffin wrote:
We still need to hear from moe people. I stuck up for Masket a bit, but now I too am getting cranky at his lack of contribution; I'm eager to hear what he has to say, and to prove that my assessment of him was not incorrect.

Samlen wrote:You do realize that there is every chance that dakky hits town and not scum? He has no extra info other than basing off scumtells in thread. Which, at that point, why kill a townie to have them shoot what we see as the scummiest person when we could just lynch them without loosing a townie? Also please stop assuming everyone complaining about you is scum cause that does not help town whatsoever.

Kamikaze Jawa wrote:

HotShot53 wrote:
So your reason for voting me is that I'm staying out of the limelight, although I have been posting more than you and have tried to contribute to current events every time I catch up, while you have barely commented on anything? Seems a bit like a OMGUS vote to me.

In truth, I tend to forget about MM even being here until someone mentions his name so I'm going to agree it's a little dodgy trying to throw you under the bus for inactivity when he's more inactive and less contributory.

HotShot53 wrote:If dakky is a vengeful towny, then thorth should definitely not be on the lynch, I don't want dakky to shoot him and us be down 2 town. Dakky, if you can't shoot thorth, who do you think is scum to shoot at?

I don't know about dakky intentionally trying to be lynched... getting lynched just so you can take a mostly random shot seems to be a net negative. I will wait to vote dakky per pik's post, although I think that's a bit complicated to have a second voting like that lol

MudPuppy wrote:

madmitch wrote:Can we have a vote count please

Should that include your recent vote against yourself my quote-challenged friend?

BuJaber wrote:Mitch fix your vote...(Unvote and vote again) unless you intended to vote for yourself.

dakky21 wrote:

Skoffin wrote:Chu can't die anyway, so I'd say DDS might be better watching Nag. I hide behind DDS, which will clear him if he's town like we assume and give us an extra person tomorrow. We lynch either dakky/DJ today, which should mean only one of them is left to lynch tomorrow.

I'm powerless since Mets died so I guess it's better to lynch me tonight and have DJ tomorrow.

Thorthoth wrote:I'm going to keep this simple. Obviously there is still more to learn, but for Day 2 Lynch follow this handy guide:

1. Townish (or scumarining): DirtyDishSoap, Pikanchion, Ragian, Samlen, MudPuppy, ZaBeast, BuJaber, T.R.F.P.B.I*., skoffin, Kamikaze Jawa, MInister Masket

2. Giving off blatant scumminess: madmitch, FloresDelMal, dakky21

We should pick the lynch candidate from category 2, and since Dakky is already far along in the process and may have the 'vengeful' ability we should focus on lynching him now.

@ dakky, if you actually turn out to be town, that would be great, then I recommend you venge-kill madmitch, though Flora is also tempting.

* The Role Formerly Played By Icepack.

dakky21 wrote:I never wanted to get myself lynched to be able to shoot someone, but also I never had a role like this where I can post rubbish and even look like scum because I'd eventually have a chance to kill one of them. Since we learned nothing in D1, voting and unvoting patterns will be the key to who will I target. I also agree we should lynch me today and like Pika suggested make a vote who to kill if you don't want me to pick someone who I think is scummiest. That way a lot of information will come to surface on D3.

Kamikaze Jawa wrote:

Pikanchion wrote:(which incidentally is exactly the cause of some being unable not to read you specifically as scummy in almost every game Skoffin)

So you're saying she's just scummy in general?

I find that it's better to always look a little bit scummy as it reduces your chances of getting night killed

Ragian wrote:Unvote vote skoffin for ultimate skimming if DonkeyFace was directed at me.

HotShot53 wrote:After re-reading the day, I don't believe dakky and would be willing to vote/hammer him.

DirtyDishSoap wrote:Going to echo with Bu here and say this discussion isn't getting us anywhere. Going back to my original gut feelers: Vote ZaBeast.

This entire Dakky situation has been nothing but a confusing cluster f*ck. As I stated earlier, I think it's better we seek an alternative and pressure different players.