Stool Pigeon Mafia - Game Over! Mafia Win!!! MVP- Zimmah

[shieldgenerator7]

just finished page 38. not all caught up but I'm here

[FoxMists]

The way I interpret it, is you are not allowed to even hint at anything else besides vanilla.

Please elaborate then, why you are hinting at not being vanilla but stating you are vanilla (falseclaiming?) if you are supposedly not allowed to hint at anything but vanilla?

I am doing everything I can to ensure I do not get modkilled. What you say could be said may be a gray area, I am avoiding all gray areas, there has been way too many mod kills this game.

This is an acceptable post:
I am a vanilla townie but my favorite ice cream is not vanilla.

Actually even better:
Just believe me when I say Plain Vanilla Ice Cream is just boring. It's so much better to have something like a Vanilla Sundae, it's so much better with toppings, so much more tastier than normal vanilla.

Are you then "hinting" that you are not VT? Because it sure looks like softclaiming to me, which you said you would not do.

VOTE MOB

[sensfan]

That's 5. Let's see who hammers this lying beast.

[MoB Deadly]

Are you serious guys? unvote right now!!!!

[VioIet]

Vote Count

Mob(5)- sens, dazza, chap, trini, foxxie

With 12 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

[chapcrap]

Whoa! First time I look on here since I vote.

MoB is dropping hints all over that he is the pigeon. I'm not sure we can believe him, but we need to think about this first. unvote for now. I am thinking that he could be lying. I wish the mod would clarify whether or not people can role claim and what they have been mod killed for, so we know what is going on with the kills.

Also, shouldn't it take 7 to lynch? It's usually more than half, not half.

[dazerazer]

Whoa! First time I look on here since I vote.

MoB is dropping hints all over that he is the pigeon. I'm not sure we can believe him, but we need to think about this first. unvote for now. I am thinking that he could be lying. I wish the mod would clarify whether or not people can role claim and what they have been mod killed for, so we know what is going on with the kills.

Also, shouldn't it take 7 to lynch? It's usually more than half, not half.

I agree.... MoB seems pretty adamant about this so I dont think we should vote him out... if anybody else has this role, you might wanna push to vote him off but for now Im not voting him out.

[FoxMists]

His "clues" are BS. If that's not scummy, I'm not sure what it takes to convince you...

[MoB Deadly]

Thank you both!

Are you serious Fox? Have you even looked at my clues? I said about 9 times THEY AREN'T THE ONLY VT's IN THE GAME!

[chapcrap]

Thank you both!

Are you serious Fox? Have you even looked at my clues? I said about 9 times THEY AREN'T THE ONLY VT's IN THE GAME!

His "clues" are BS. If that's not scummy, I'm not sure what it takes to convince you...

I'm not saying he isn't scummy, I'm saying slow down for a second. Voting all crazy without a little discussion and without thinking is not the best idea.

Fox, why do you think the clues are BS?

MoB, if you are saying more than 3 people are VT, then why did you say that there were 3 to begin with? It doesn't make sense to do that.

[MoB Deadly]

There are 3 that apply to my riddle

[dazza2008]

Vote Count

Mob(5)- sens, dazza, chap, trini, foxxie

With 12 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

With 12 alive should it not take 7 to lynch or am I even confused about this?

I don't know what to think of MoB's clues. It really seems scummy to me. I am going to leave my vote where it is.

[wildwilliam]

Vote Count

Mob(5)- sens, dazza, chap, trini, foxxie

With 12 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

With 12 alive should it not take 7 to lynch or am I even confused about this?

I don't know what to think of MoB's clues. It really seems scummy to me. I am going to leave my vote where it is.

she said 6 due to inactivity.........

[dazza2008]

Vote Count

Mob(5)- sens, dazza, chap, trini, foxxie

With 12 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

With 12 alive should it not take 7 to lynch or am I even confused about this?

I don't know what to think of MoB's clues. It really seems scummy to me. I am going to leave my vote where it is.

she said 6 due to inactivity.........

Ah I must have missed that. I have a sore head when I read this thread. Its too confusing for me. I wish I never joined this game.

[VioIet]

Vote Count

Mob(4)- sens, dazza, trini, foxxie

With 12 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

In the first vote count on Day 4, I stated it would be 6 to lynch because of inactivity.


Dazza, I'm sorry that this game is so confusing. It is my first time trying this variant, and I welcome constructive criticism when the game is over. However, there were a lot of player mistakes in this one, which helped add to the confusion of the game. All will be revealed at the end.

[dazza2008]

Dazza, I'm sorry that this game is so confusing. It is my first time trying this variant, and I welcome constructive criticism when the game is over. However, there were a lot of player mistakes in this one, which helped add to the confusion of the game. All will be revealed at the end.

No worries. I will still play it. I thought it would be cool to try something a wee bit different.

Sorry to critisise.

[wildwilliam]

vote fox

[FoxMists]

Thank you both!

Are you serious Fox? Have you even looked at my clues? I said about 9 times THEY AREN'T THE ONLY VT's IN THE GAME!

His "clues" are BS. If that's not scummy, I'm not sure what it takes to convince you...

I'm not saying he isn't scummy, I'm saying slow down for a second. Voting all crazy without a little discussion and without thinking is not the best idea.

Fox, why do you think the clues are BS?

MoB, if you are saying more than 3 people are VT, then why did you say that there were 3 to begin with? It doesn't make sense to do that.

Because of the statement that there were 3 VTs. Which was amended by saying there are 3 VTs in the game that fit said criteria. That however is utterly useless information. If there are more than 3 VTs and not all fit said criterion, then what good is the clue at all? It does not help us narrow anything down. Sounds like BS to me. You wanna slow down and talk, we can do that. Though I'm really not at all sure what good it will do. With no way for VTs to tell scum from mafia in any way at all this is like a crap shoot. Dazza is right, it's frustrating and confusing.

And Wild.. you need to bold your vote if you wanna kill me. Didn't feel like explaining it to us? Kind of like you didn't feel like clarifying your vote on Zimmah? The one you changed the day before he died? Hm... FOS.

unvote

edit: Cos my grammar sucks at midnight

[chapcrap]

Thank you both!

Are you serious Fox? Have you even looked at my clues? I said about 9 times THEY AREN'T THE ONLY VT's IN THE GAME!

His "clues" are BS. If that's not scummy, I'm not sure what it takes to convince you...

I'm not saying he isn't scummy, I'm saying slow down for a second. Voting all crazy without a little discussion and without thinking is not the best idea.

Fox, why do you think the clues are BS?

MoB, if you are saying more than 3 people are VT, then why did you say that there were 3 to begin with? It doesn't make sense to do that.

Because of the statement that there were 3 VTs. Which was amended by saying there are 3 VTs in the game that fit said criteria. That however is utterly useless information. If there are more than 3 VTs and not all fit said criterion, then what good is the clue at all? It does not help us narrow anything down. Sounds like BS to me. You wanna slow down and talk, we can do that. Though I'm really not at all sure what good it will do. With no way for VTs to tell scum from mafia in any way at all this is like a crap shoot. Dazza is right, it's frustrating and confusing.

And Wild.. you need to bold your vote if you wanna kill me. Didn't feel like explaining it to us? Kind of like you didn't feel like clarifying your vote on Zimmah? The one you changed the day before he died? Hm... FOS.

unvote

edit: Cos my grammar sucks at midnight

First, don't edit...it's against the rules.

Second, I agree with you about MoB I think. It's odd that he changed the wording of his 'riddle' when presented with the flaw. So, unvote vote MoB.

Also, FOS wildwilliam for that last post. What was that? You didn't even explain anything at all. Ridiculous.

[wildwilliam]

Thank you both!

Are you serious Fox? Have you even looked at my clues? I said about 9 times THEY AREN'T THE ONLY VT's IN THE GAME!

His "clues" are BS. If that's not scummy, I'm not sure what it takes to convince you...

I'm not saying he isn't scummy, I'm saying slow down for a second. Voting all crazy without a little discussion and without thinking is not the best idea.

Fox, why do you think the clues are BS?

MoB, if you are saying more than 3 people are VT, then why did you say that there were 3 to begin with? It doesn't make sense to do that.

Because of the statement that there were 3 VTs. Which was amended by saying there are 3 VTs in the game that fit said criteria. That however is utterly useless information. If there are more than 3 VTs and not all fit said criterion, then what good is the clue at all? It does not help us narrow anything down. Sounds like BS to me. You wanna slow down and talk, we can do that. Though I'm really not at all sure what good it will do. With no way for VTs to tell scum from mafia in any way at all this is like a crap shoot. Dazza is right, it's frustrating and confusing.

And Wild.. you need to bold your vote if you wanna kill me. Didn't feel like explaining it to us? Kind of like you didn't feel like clarifying your vote on Zimmah? The one you changed the day before he died? Hm... FOS.

unvote

edit: Cos my grammar sucks at midnight

my vote is in bold. you should be mod killed for editing your posts.

[trinicardinal]

Thank you both!

Are you serious Fox? Have you even looked at my clues? I said about 9 times THEY AREN'T THE ONLY VT's IN THE GAME!

His "clues" are BS. If that's not scummy, I'm not sure what it takes to convince you...

I'm not saying he isn't scummy, I'm saying slow down for a second. Voting all crazy without a little discussion and without thinking is not the best idea.

Fox, why do you think the clues are BS?

MoB, if you are saying more than 3 people are VT, then why did you say that there were 3 to begin with? It doesn't make sense to do that.

Because of the statement that there were 3 VTs. Which was amended by saying there are 3 VTs in the game that fit said criteria. That however is utterly useless information. If there are more than 3 VTs and not all fit said criterion, then what good is the clue at all? It does not help us narrow anything down. Sounds like BS to me. You wanna slow down and talk, we can do that. Though I'm really not at all sure what good it will do. With no way for VTs to tell scum from mafia in any way at all this is like a crap shoot. Dazza is right, it's frustrating and confusing.

And Wild.. you need to bold your vote if you wanna kill me. Didn't feel like explaining it to us? Kind of like you didn't feel like clarifying your vote on Zimmah? The one you changed the day before he died? Hm... FOS.

unvote

edit: Cos my grammar sucks at midnight

Fox, can you explain that edit line for me please?

[VioIet]

Vote Count

Mob(4)- sens, dazza, trini, chap

Fox (1)- william

With 12 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

[nagerous]

Sorry vio, I am very behind. Please don't hate me.

[zimmah]

Sorry vio, I am very behind. Please don't hate me.

i do

[FoxMists]

Thank you both!

Are you serious Fox? Have you even looked at my clues? I said about 9 times THEY AREN'T THE ONLY VT's IN THE GAME!

His "clues" are BS. If that's not scummy, I'm not sure what it takes to convince you...

I'm not saying he isn't scummy, I'm saying slow down for a second. Voting all crazy without a little discussion and without thinking is not the best idea.

Fox, why do you think the clues are BS?

MoB, if you are saying more than 3 people are VT, then why did you say that there were 3 to begin with? It doesn't make sense to do that.

Because of the statement that there were 3 VTs. Which was amended by saying there are 3 VTs in the game that fit said criteria. That however is utterly useless information. If there are more than 3 VTs and not all fit said criterion, then what good is the clue at all? It does not help us narrow anything down. Sounds like BS to me. You wanna slow down and talk, we can do that. Though I'm really not at all sure what good it will do. With no way for VTs to tell scum from mafia in any way at all this is like a crap shoot. Dazza is right, it's frustrating and confusing.

And Wild.. you need to bold your vote if you wanna kill me. Didn't feel like explaining it to us? Kind of like you didn't feel like clarifying your vote on Zimmah? The one you changed the day before he died? Hm... FOS.

unvote

edit: Cos my grammar sucks at midnight

Fox, can you explain that edit line for me please?

I had originially typed "The night before he died" instead of the DAY before he died. I was worried it might sound like I was implying Wild was indeed mafia by the wording, so I changed it because I'm not really sure if he is or not. Also, I didn't realise it was illegal to edit posts, but I guess that makes sense. Like I said, I'd only ever played this in live chat before so I wasn't thinking about forum differences. Sorry guys

I shall not edit anymore. And sorry Wild, I couldn't tell it was bold. Still FOS for no explanation.