The Thing - Mafia Style [Winner=The Thing]

[nagerous]

Nice one.... I wasn't even on the last bandwagon if you check your data mate.

Also, regarding passive play... you can check all my games, I haven't posted much in mafia for a long time, I'm afraid. It is a sad but true fact.

The same can be said about pancakemix, using the fact that he played quietly and passively against me as evidence is weak, very weak.. the guy had to be replaced!

[spaceghst44]

there were two people going against fifth, and both got killed. I think this is a set up and I am going with my gut.

[b]vote ani[/b

he hops around with his votes, never makes a clear distinction about who he is after, makes sure not to be the first or last vote, and is very vague.

[animorpherv1]

there were two people going against fifth, and both got killed. I think this is a set up and I am going with my gut.

[b]vote ani[/b

he hops around with his votes, never makes a clear distinction about who he is after, makes sure not to be the first or last vote, and is very vague.

I don't think I've vote hopped at all this entire game, I stuck to one vot e a day, every day. I have (to me at least) made some distinctions, and they are clear. As for the last one, well, I was 2nd last. And there have been times (I think) that I have been first.

[nagerous]

there were two people going against fifth, and both got killed. I think this is a set up and I am going with my gut.

vote ani[/b

he hops around with his votes, never makes a clear distinction about who he is after, makes sure not to be the first or last vote, and is very vague.

I don't know what anyone else thinks but this post reeks scum, you talk about a possible set up but sounds to me like you and f1fth targetted people that were against f1fth as clearly indicated and then throw in a WIFOM that mafia wouldn't target people that are against them..


Then you have the nerve to throw a vote against ani for being a noob.. Ani is a noob, he will always be a noob, is he scum? Probably not.. my own personal view anyway. Its Bolt, has given off quite a town vibe in my eyes too so I am going to put good money on the mafia partnership being you and f1fth. Pushing for the easy lynch of ani on the final day is low and sounds exactly like something scum would do!

[b]vote spaceghst and a pre-emptive vote on f1fth ready for the next day once one mafia is lynched!

[nagerous]

EBWOP: vote spaceghst

[spaceghst44]

EBWOP: vote spaceghst

just like in all the other games, this is a mistake, the thing will win, I am nothing more than a researcher. everyone can feel free to pile them up though. I don't mind.

[spaceghst44]

unvote vote nag

[Its Bolt]

Its space-f1fth or nag-ani... rereading to figure out which

[spaceghst44]

it is not me, but feel free to vote for me anyways.

[F1fth]

I don't know about Ani, but I'm pretty sure that Nag is scums. He knows there won't be a second day because if the wrong person gets lynched then we lose, so he;s just trying to get us on with a quick lynch.

And yes, you avoided making the same scummy move on sam's lynch (as if you needed to do anything) AFTER I pointed out my suspicion of you because you'd already done it several times before:

Wrong on several counts.

One, the scum cannot lose the first day because the game starts with a night phase and the thing has a 100% chance to recruit.

Two, there are only two mafia. The first night someone was recruited (of course) and the second night ga7 was protected by the doctor, or so he claimed. But since he turned out to be town as well as our doctor, we can assume that he was telling the truth. That makes two scum, sir.

Three, I'm not scum. I would defend myself more so, but you haven't quite explained your case against me.

The reason I figure you are suspicious of me is because of the Stroop bandwagon, but it turns out that that was the exact same reason we lynched Stroop in the first place (except it was in regards to the ga7 bandwagon instead of his own). Point is though, you got it wrong.

I would consider my top suspect at the moment nagerous. He's been extremely quiet since he replaced and has been quick to jump on bandwagons with little-to-no explanation (both Stroop's and ga7's).

[Its Bolt]

Who did everyone replace? I am reading the early game over a bit and it would be pretty benificial to figure it out. Starting to lean neg-sg at this point given how active f1fth was and that ani really did say some things that I would expect a newbie cult player to stumble on and give out more then they know

Later game though makes me say f1fth-ani though so... huh

[nagerous]

f1fth, for ga7 the game had reached a deadset... look at the time stamps... no-one had voted in ages and I had just replaced and it was clear that ga7 would be the only one lynched that day as no-one was posting, so I just helped move the game along a little, simple as... a pro-townish thing not a scummy thing.


As for Stroop, my reasoning is simple, ga7 a cleared townie advocated strongly that stroop was scum and I have always trusted ga7's judgement in the past hence my vote.

I have not been extremely quiet, I only just replaced when ga7 was about to be lynched and have contributed just as much as the next man since then.

Also, how the f*ck am I the only pushing for a quick lynch on your scum buddy space ghst??? If I was, I would be pushing against animorph like space is..

[animorpherv1]

I have to go with my instinct on this one.
vote:f1fth we set him up as a possible thing, and our lynch. Something just doesn't ring true on him right now.

[F1fth]

I'm not just going to let this happen, and roll over like town has done this entire game. The game is at stake at this point, so you better damn well be sure I'm scum before you make your vote. What is this something about me, Ani? I'm playing desperately, because I'm in a very desperate situation: town is about to get sweeped.

Nagerous, you argue that I WIFOM'd. That's fine because if I were scum I might have, but if I were town scum wouldn't kill me because I was a top suspect for town because of the Stroop wagon. The point of understanding the WIFOM concept is that you can't use it as justification for either side of the argument, because the whole point of it is that there are two equally likely outcomes.

And see, here's the problem with your defense: regardless of why you say you put no input forward, you did put no input forward. You played it like scum would play it: staying out of the spotlight. I have always given my reasons, always put my opinions and thoughts out there, and I have opened myself to being judged. You have played the game very sneakily thus far, and the fact is it almost seems like you've avoided commenting on anything that might draw attention to you, until it's lynch-or-lose on one of the last days, of course. There's no surprise there that you're just going for the win.

And how can you tell space "shame on you for voting Ani (a newer player)" when you did the same thing to space (he doesn't know about Ani's history, thus you can't argue he was going for an easy lynch). Plus, space makes just as many faux pas if not more than any (and he has far less experience) than Ani, so yes you were/are trying to achieve the easy lynch.

Besides, I believe that Ani is your scumbuddy, so of course you wouldn't vote for him.

Vote Nagerous

[animorpherv1]

*reserves the hammer*

I'll let nag speak before I put him up.

[F1fth]

unvote

Stop the hammertime.

[Natewolfman]

Its Bolt
animorpherv1
spaceghst44
nagerous
F1fth

Vote Count

nagerous - 1 vote (spaceghst44)
f1fth - 1 vote (animorpherv1)
spaceghst44 - 1 vote (nagerous)

Not Voting: F1fth, Its Bolt

with 5 players it takes 3 to lynch

[F1fth]

Still waiting to hear from space, bolt, and nagerous again before we do lynch -1. I could probably just keep the vote on Nag since I'm pretty sure I'm right about him, but I figure why risk it?

[spaceghst44]

f1fth, for ga7 the game had reached a deadset... look at the time stamps... no-one had voted in ages and I had just replaced and it was clear that ga7 would be the only one lynched that day as no-one was posting, so I just helped move the game along a little, simple as... a pro-townish thing not a scummy thing.


As for Stroop, my reasoning is simple, ga7 a cleared townie advocated strongly that stroop was scum and I have always trusted ga7's judgement in the past hence my vote.

I have not been extremely quiet, I only just replaced when ga7 was about to be lynched and have contributed just as much as the next man since then.

Also, how the f*ck am I the only pushing for a quick lynch on your scum buddy space ghst??? If I was, I would be pushing against animorph like space is..

I am keeping my vote here because I am tired of people who do not read, if he did read he would know I that I changed my vote to him and off of ani.

[nagerous]

Oh dear this is bad... I declared my exact reasons for my votes. I guarantee I am town and f1fth and space ghst are scum, animorph and bolt if you have any sense you will see that they are setting me up, please read my arguments very clearly.


I'm 100% sure animorph is town now, considering he didn't hammer me, if he had hammered me he would have won the game there and then. Its Bolt did not hammer me either so I'm pretty confirmed that he is town too.

Conclusion:

Space and f1fth are mafia

Lets lynch them, starting with space.

Also, space you say you keep your vote on me because I was skimming, I clearly noticed you had changed your vote to me, I was explaining my reasoning behind my vote on space before he pulled an OMGUS on me...

if you get me lynched though guys, very nicely played fellas.

[spaceghst44]

Also, space you say you keep your vote on me because I was skimming, I clearly noticed you had changed your vote to me, I was explaining my reasoning behind my vote on space before he pulled an OMGUS on me...

if you did then this

Also, how the f*ck am I the only pushing for a quick lynch on your scum buddy space ghst??? If I was, I would be pushing against animorph like space is..

would say this

[quote="nagerous should have"]
Also, how the f*ck am I the only pushing for a quick lynch on your scum buddy space ghst??? If I was, I would be pushing against animorph like space DID.

no shame in being a skimma, but a lot of shame in being a liar about being a skimma.

[animorpherv1]

I see no difference in that, space.

Seriously, though, your either thinking about it too much, or not enough. Something in telling me too hard, which leads me to think that you may be the thing. unvote vote space

[spaceghst44]

I see no difference in that, space.

Seriously, though, your either thinking about it too much, or not enough. Something in telling me too hard, which leads me to think that you may be the thing. unvote vote space

and you are an idiot. I am not thinking about it at all. I think you are the thing, but I want to keep my vote on nag because he is an idiot. Don't worry, you are next for seeing no difference between the present and past tense.

[animorpherv1]

I see no difference in that, space.

Seriously, though, your either thinking about it too much, or not enough. Something in telling me too hard, which leads me to think that you may be the thing. unvote vote space

and you are an idiot. I am not thinking about it at all. I think you are the thing, but I want to keep my vote on nag because he is an idiot. Don't worry, you are next for seeing no difference between the present and past tense.

tense dpesn't make a difference.

[spaceghst44]

I see no difference in that, space.

Seriously, though, your either thinking about it too much, or not enough. Something in telling me too hard, which leads me to think that you may be the thing. unvote vote space

and you are an idiot. I am not thinking about it at all. I think you are the thing, but I want to keep my vote on nag because he is an idiot. Don't worry, you are next for seeing no difference between the present and past tense.

tense dpesn't make a difference.

you are right, because then and now are the same.........