Page 22 of 67
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Tue Sep 17, 2013 5:49 pm
by The Weird One
DoomYoshi wrote:My mod requests have as much validity as her case on me. That is all. Call it sarcasm, silliness, loopiness, or call it reality. I don't care.
This is all a bit excessive...The game is all about accusing those that you feel aren't town. Defend yourself. Don't be petty. You're not helping your case when you do this.
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Tue Sep 17, 2013 7:23 pm
by safariguy5
Who am I voting fir, you have me listed as both Com9 and james.
unvote vote jamesker submaring again huh? Care to comment on the many long posts after your last one?
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Tue Sep 17, 2013 9:04 pm
by rishaed
safariguy5 wrote:Who am I voting fir, you have me listed as both Com9 and james.
unvote vote jamesker submaring again huh? Care to comment on the many long posts after your last one?
Likewise you have me voting you and Neb, while I'm pretty sure my vote is on Doom.
This day has gone on long enough and if Jameskerl doesn't seem to find the time to post that often, then I don't mind voting him with intention to lynch today. Doom can wait for tomorrow.
VOTE JAMESKERL
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Tue Sep 17, 2013 11:37 pm
by shrewstur
Anarkistsdream wrote:I agree with Iron Butterfly... We most certainly will have at least three different factions, but we basically know that already by Commander9 saying he was "basically" a cult leader.
I believe that allowing him to survive and start picking off townies is ridiculous and that all of you who aren't in agreement with me are most likely scum or some other third-party character.
As for having a post restriction, of course I do... A lot of us do. I have seen several people with the same PR as me, so far... Because my 40 PHDs are so much cooler than your ZERO!
So, as I said last night, I will keep my vote on Com9 and FOS everyone who voted him and then changed their vote.
Is there a reason to be suspicious of those who changed their votes from Commander9 to someone else? I would think that if anyone was mafia, they would either (1) know Com9 is a fellow mafia and wouldn't take the risk of bluffing a vote on him as it could cause bandwagoning, or (2) know Com9 isn't mafia and wouldn't change their vote.
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Wed Sep 18, 2013 6:15 am
by iAmCaffeine
shrewstur wrote:Anarkistsdream wrote:I agree with Iron Butterfly... We most certainly will have at least three different factions, but we basically know that already by Commander9 saying he was "basically" a cult leader.
I believe that allowing him to survive and start picking off townies is ridiculous and that all of you who aren't in agreement with me are most likely scum or some other third-party character.
As for having a post restriction, of course I do... A lot of us do. I have seen several people with the same PR as me, so far... Because my 40 PHDs are so much cooler than your ZERO!
So, as I said last night, I will keep my vote on Com9 and FOS everyone who voted him and then changed their vote.
Is there a reason to be suspicious of those who changed their votes from Commander9 to someone else? I would think that if anyone was mafia, they would either (1) know Com9 is a fellow mafia and wouldn't take the risk of bluffing a vote on him as it could cause bandwagoning, or (2) know Com9 isn't mafia and wouldn't change their vote.
(3) They have voted for Commander9 since he was bw'd, and they don't want to stand out as not wanting to vote for the "obvious candidate".
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Wed Sep 18, 2013 9:41 am
by jonty125
I'd rather see James prodded or replaced than lynched. But that doesn't mean I disapprove of a James lynch. So Fircoal, mind prodding James, please.
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Wed Sep 18, 2013 10:21 pm
by JamesKer1
Ok I'm here. Just got to check in (been pretty busy lately) and type this, the past few messages I've typed up have ended in my internet having issues and losing them. Spent a nice hour and a half working on a post loaded with quotes and stuff and poof.... You can hopefully understand my frustration, so I'll try and keep things short from now on...
First of all, UNVOTE COMM9. My vote on him isn't going to get me or the game anywhere.
Last time I counted, when I made my 1 and a half hour post loaded with quotes and proof and all the stuff I had been accused of being "too lazy to do", I counted of at least 5 times when Talapus said not to vote Comm9. In his response to my first post, he said he had never stuck up for Com... He also said that Com had a 3.5% (or something close to that, exact percent really does not matter) chance of making it through the night. How would he be able to guarantee that? If I was mafia I would definitely not be taking out Com, he would be distracting all of you guys from voting me correct? UNLESS I knew that Comm9 was mafia, which he could easily be.
Yes, a few of the times when you said not to vote Com you said that if your vote was needed to lynch him then you would pitch in... But from one post I read a while ago, you said that once in the post, yet you said 3 times not to lynch...
So for now, I'll vote Syria. But Talapus, I would like to see some real reasoning this time on why not to vote you, instead of just attacking me back. Thanks!
Btw, I've read every post here... Just so everyone knows. This is my first mafia game so if I could get some slack cut there under the promise that I won't make the same mistake again that would be great.
I'll add in quotes by EBWOP later if you really want them. I feel like quoting the same thing phrased 5 different ways though is a huge waste of time...
James
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Thu Sep 19, 2013 3:59 am
by Talapus
JamesKer1 wrote:So for now, I'll vote Syria. But Talapus, I would like to see some real reasoning this time on why not to vote you, instead of just attacking me back. Thanks!
James
Attacking you back??? Now I'm confused
. You openly stated you didn't read long posts and I clearly stated any player who won't at least take the time is usless to us. In all honestly third party would be the only role that may actually benefit from not reading long posts and I stated that as well. But I'm certainly not attacking you back for anything....you see, you have to post to make grounds for an attack. But if you really want to vote me, knock yourself out. I'm not going to list reasons why you shouldn't especially considering all you've taken out of everything since your last posts is an obvbvious fixation on me. There were several other lines of thoughts and discussions going on in this thread since your last post but those weren't even mentioned. Think it's kind of odd.
I am fascinated to hear however why you want me to give you reasoning for you not to vote me. My argument for not lynching Com9 was stated a few times as you have said and you find that suspicious. Yet you openly unvote Com9 because your vote on him won't get you or the game anywhere? Your argument sounds like you are implying I could be mafia and that Com9 could also be mafia and thus you think that's why I stated several times not to waste a lynch on him as I must know that. But if thats really what you think then why not leave your vote on Com9 as he still has several and get a discussion going about offing me in the night? Also based on your argument why the hell would you unvote Com9 and state your vote won't get you or the game anywhere when you actually also state he could be mafia?
This is such a confusing post I'm really not sure what to make of what your intentions are. You want to vote me go ahead and vote me. If you think Com9 might be mafia go ahead and vote him. But the thing that bugs me is that you didn't mention any of the other arguments or discussons in the thread and just seem focused on me because the argument I made about how I thought a lynch of com9 could be a waste. At the least dude if you think my arguments were scummy and warranted your full attention(Which obviously you did as nothing else was noted in your post and there are 36 pages of stuff) then at the least vote me. But ya, you didn't even do that....so yes, confused. Maybe it made more sense in the posts you lost to the internet gods but your line of thought here has me fairly baffled.
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Thu Sep 19, 2013 6:04 am
by DoomYoshi
too tired to decide now, but leaning towards jamesker lynch... this day is pages beyond where he is
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Thu Sep 19, 2013 12:14 pm
by Anarkistsdream
I can't change my vote, so I will just say that people should VOTE COMMANDER9.... If not, then choose somebody and let's move the game along, shall we? Just won the Pulitzer and Noble Prize because of my 40 PhDs!
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Thu Sep 19, 2013 12:22 pm
by The Weird One
I'll change my vote over only if it's needed to actually get the lynch on day 1...I'm still a bit too paranoid about a jester...
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Thu Sep 19, 2013 4:10 pm
by shrewstur
JamesKer1 wrote:Ok I'm here. Just got to check in (been pretty busy lately) and type this, the past few messages I've typed up have ended in my internet having issues and losing them. Spent a nice hour and a half working on a post loaded with quotes and stuff and poof.... You can hopefully understand my frustration, so I'll try and keep things short from now on...
Lazarus is an add-on for firefox and chrome, which allows you to recover lost text. I'd recommend it to anyone who has these problems frequently.
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Thu Sep 19, 2013 5:57 pm
by JamesKer1
Talapus wrote:You openly stated you didn't read long posts and I clearly stated any player who won't at least take the time is usless to us.
Man, and I'm not reading posts? I said that I apologize, this is my first game, and that it won't be happening again.
Talapus wrote:There were several other lines of thoughts and discussions going on in this thread since your last post but those weren't even mentioned. Think it's kind of odd.
I've read through them, every single word. Yoshi is making arguments about Skoffin's Red Walls of Truth, Anarkists still want Comm9 dead, Yoshi checked Comm to make sure that he was allowed to deny roles, and that we have a limit set by Fir's move to college, approx. one week from his post. But from everything here, you, comm, and Anarkists are at the top of my list as suspicious. And you are number one on that list, so that is why the post was directed towards you.
Yet you openly unvote Com9 because your vote on him won't get you or the game anywhere?
... And the fact that I'm still deciding on who to vote.
Your argument sounds like you are implying I could be mafia and that Com9 could also be mafia and thus you think that's why I stated several times not to waste a lynch on him as I must know that. But if thats really what you think then why not leave your vote on Com9 as he still has several and get a discussion going about offing me in the night?
Because if he really is a jester role, then lynching you would be best. If you are not scummy, it will be a mistake and we will have to suffer that. If you are Mafia, then my vote will go straight for Comm9 the next night.
..then at the least vote me. But ya, you didn't even do that....so yes, confused.
VOTE TALAPUSDoomYoshi wrote:too tired to decide now, but leaning towards jamesker lynch... this day is pages beyond where he is
Hope this is answered in the stuff above. I'm not behind, just looking to the past pages for reasoning because I don't see much in the recent ones that I agree with.
shrewstur wrote:JamesKer1 wrote:Ok I'm here. Just got to check in (been pretty busy lately) and type this, the past few messages I've typed up have ended in my internet having issues and losing them. Spent a nice hour and a half working on a post loaded with quotes and stuff and poof.... You can hopefully understand my frustration, so I'll try and keep things short from now on...
Lazarus is an add-on for firefox and chrome, which allows you to recover lost text. I'd recommend it to anyone who has these problems frequently.
Will look into this, thanks!
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Thu Sep 19, 2013 8:06 pm
by Rodion
JamesKer1 wrote:I've read through them, every single word. Yoshi is making arguments about Skoffin's Red Walls of Truth, Anarkists still want Comm9 dead, Yoshi checked Comm to make sure that he was allowed to deny roles, and that we have a limit set by Fir's move to college, approx. one week from his post. But from everything here, you, comm, and Anarkists are at the top of my list as suspicious. And you are number one on that list, so that is why the post was directed towards you.
I don't think that is correct. If I understood it well, Nark wants Commander to live but has a PR that forces him to behave otherwise (all that apart from the PhDs)?
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2013 8:30 am
by Anarkistsdream
Alright, I am honestly kind of blown away that nobody else has this level of restrictions for what they are supposed to include in their posts... Several people started out doing the same thing, talking about THEIR PhDs or having what they said were "obvious post restrictions" but I have not seen anybody keep that up throughout all of their posts. So, in my opinion, these people have continued to post without following their PR and have not been reminded to follow them. I have two things I am supposed to do in every post... Mention 40 PhDs or my intelligence and try to lynch Comm9.
If people aren't going to follow their PRs, then what's the point of having them? Of course, when only 12 of 27 people ever post, who knows who else MAY have a PR that they may or may not follow. Unless more people start to interact, and actually follow the instructions that Fircoal gave them, this game is going to quickly lose interest for me...
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:25 am
by Nebuchadnezer
It's 27 people. 36 pages. Discussion is dying. Does it pay to keep this day going? I still don't like Talapus...he's rubbing me the wrong way. But I tend to believe that he's probably town, our he wouldn't be talking so much...but that's just wifom...
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2013 10:23 am
by The Weird One
Nebuchadnezer wrote:It's 27 people. 36 pages. Discussion is dying. Does it pay to keep this day going? I still don't like Talapus...he's rubbing me the wrong way. But I tend to believe that he's probably town, our he wouldn't be talking so much...but that's just wifom...
The deadline's rolling up...Can we get an exact date on it?
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2013 1:39 pm
by safariguy5
Nope no PR for me.
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2013 5:33 pm
by Fircoal
Well peoples I have two big newses.
One is on the replacement front:
Ga7 will be replacing Stubbs and FloresDelMal will be replacing Tailsgunner.
The Second is on the deadline front:
I said the deadline would be when I move into college. Well that happens to be tomarrow. However no one has been doing anything. So I will give you all this choice. In case no one is lynched before the deadline do you want me to do it the sane way or the insane way. You each can pick which one of these it is done using.
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2013 5:36 pm
by The Weird One
Fircoal wrote:Well peoples I have two big newses.
One is on the replacement front:
Ga7 will be replacing Stubbs and FloresDelMal will be replacing Tailsgunner.
The Second is on the deadline front:
I said the deadline would be when I move into college. Well that happens to be tomarrow. However no one has been doing anything. So I will give you all this choice. In case no one is lynched before the deadline do you want me to do it the sane way or the insane way. You each can pick which one of these it is done using.
Oh bugger...I vote sane, however much I crave mental instability...
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* DEADLINE DEALS!?
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2013 5:42 pm
by sheepofdumb
Insane! Go insane!
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* DEADLINE DEALS!?
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2013 6:50 pm
by Nebuchadnezer
sheepofdumb wrote:Insane! Go insane!
All I've got...all I've got is insane! All I've got...all I've got is INSANE!
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* DEADLINE DEALS!?
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2013 7:16 pm
by Talapus
If it's a Fircoal game the only way to go is insane. Otherwise I'd question everything.
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* DEADLINE DEALS!?
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2013 7:26 pm
by rishaed
Insanity is the only real sanity!
Re: A Cino Filled Mafia (27/27) *Day 1* NES is best mafia pl
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2013 10:11 pm
by Skoffin
Anarkistsdream wrote: I have two things I am supposed to do in every post... Mention 40 PhDs or my intelligence and try to lynch Comm9.
While I certainly appreciate that you have finally answered a question I asked a few pages ago, I must say old bean that you certainly have not stuck to this post restriction 'in every post'.
No chaps, I'd really like to get this show on the road. I maintain my stance of either going for Nark or Doom, though my bias does swing somewhat towards Doom over the other for being a crotchety fellow posting some trivial nonsense. Now, let's do something before I get all British in here and jump someone like an angry spider-monkey.
Also, I must say, the insane option does appeal to me.