Page 22 of 28

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2012 5:34 pm
by /
crazymilkshake5 wrote:I already said that i dont remember who i gave the muffin to N1.

WTF, are you roleplaying derpy too hard? :roll:
... I explicitly said I got a muffin night one, why would I lie about this?
tsk tsk, are you really town too?

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2012 5:44 pm
by crazymilkshake5
/ wrote:
crazymilkshake5 wrote:I already said that i dont remember who i gave the muffin to N1.

WTF, are you roleplaying derpy too hard? :roll:
... I explicitly said I got a muffin night one, why would I lie about this?
tsk tsk, are you really town too?

wait you did? sorry, I dont recall that.

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2012 5:56 pm
by shieldgenerator7
Official Vote Count:

Pmchung (1) - Haggis
Sheep (1) - /
TFO (1) - Sheep
Milkshake (2) - Nagerous, TFO

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch

Deadline May 1st


I will be gone for 7-10 days but will make sure I take care of my responsibilities as co-mod for this game.

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2012 6:22 pm
by dazza2008
I don't have a clue here. But Milkshake does not know what his muffins do and doesn't seem to know where he send them and he doesn't read the thread. It is all a bit scummy to me. Vote Milkshake.

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2012 6:25 pm
by crazymilkshake5
looks like im going to be lynched. which is kinda good. because RL is getting cramped.

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2012 7:48 pm
by pmchugh
Dude, giving up completely at L-2? Personally I think TFO + sheep are better lynches but I am tempted to vote CMC out of pure boredom. Anyone wanna swap onto TFO?

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2012 9:25 pm
by sheepofdumb
I still don't see how I would have a kill but w/e.

Milkshake needs to hunt down his action PM. You have an 75 message sentbox. Do you mean to tell me that in the few weeks this game has been running you've sent 75+ messages or deleted them? I still have messages I sent back in 2008. This game will likely outlast your busy schedule. So take some time and find those PM's.

Unfortunately I'm going to be gone this weekend. I'll be back on the 29th so I'll be able to throw in my vote if need be. Right now I'm between TFO and Milkshake. I don't want to put Milkshake at L-1 before he has a chance to respond but consider my vote on him. I think TFO is scummy too so I'll keep my vote on him in case something comes up this weekend.

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2012 9:58 pm
by crazymilkshake5
sheepofdumb wrote:I still don't see how I would have a kill but w/e.

Milkshake needs to hunt down his action PM. You have an 75 message sentbox. Do you mean to tell me that in the few weeks this game has been running you've sent 75+ messages or deleted them? I still have messages I sent back in 2008. This game will likely outlast your busy schedule. So take some time and find those PM's.

Unfortunately I'm going to be gone this weekend. I'll be back on the 29th so I'll be able to throw in my vote if need be. Right now I'm between TFO and Milkshake. I don't want to put Milkshake at L-1 before he has a chance to respond but consider my vote on him. I think TFO is scummy too so I'll keep my vote on him in case something comes up this weekend.

w/e stands for?
This is the last PM i sent, fully quoted, time to the minute.
show

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2012 11:24 pm
by /
w/e = Whatever

also since this incredibly pointless point won't be dropped no matter how obvious anything is, why don't you just ask the mod like I said back on page 27?

and to PMC, fine, I'm having trouble caring at this point, the win condition thing seems vague, etc. if you all don't eliminate a kidnapping faction today, not my fault. Unvote vote TFO

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Fri Apr 27, 2012 12:09 am
by TheForgivenOne
There is literally nothing else I can say to defend myself. I wouldn't willingly claim a role that I knew was dead unless I actually had the role. Again, we don't know if a Healer is a doctor. How the hell wouldn't VS know he is a doctor?

And milkshake does seem to know what the Muffins do, as I recall him asking for 1 night.

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Fri Apr 27, 2012 11:34 am
by nagerous
I think TFO's claim seems legitimate, a much better one than milkshake's at least. VS's role seems different to doctor, I don't think we can lynch TFO based on that. Also his name claim seems much more solid to me.

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Fri Apr 27, 2012 11:35 am
by nagerous
pmchugh wrote:Dude, giving up completely at L-2? Personally I think TFO + sheep are better lynches but I am tempted to vote CMC out of pure boredom. Anyone wanna swap onto TFO?


I don't see why you continually protect milkshake? Seems really suspicious to me .

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Fri Apr 27, 2012 3:04 pm
by pmchugh
nagerous wrote:
pmchugh wrote:Dude, giving up completely at L-2? Personally I think TFO + sheep are better lynches but I am tempted to vote CMC out of pure boredom. Anyone wanna swap onto TFO?


I don't see why you continually protect milkshake? Seems really suspicious to me .


I just think he is likely town because of the way he originally claimed. There is something fishy going on here and I am not sure what, everyone seems too believable but I don't see much choice now. I hope you are right or at least not leading town as scum, unvote vote CMC

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Fri Apr 27, 2012 9:57 pm
by crazymilkshake5
pmchugh wrote:
nagerous wrote:
pmchugh wrote:Dude, giving up completely at L-2? Personally I think TFO + sheep are better lynches but I am tempted to vote CMC out of pure boredom. Anyone wanna swap onto TFO?


I don't see why you continually protect milkshake? Seems really suspicious to me .


I just think he is likely town because of the way he originally claimed. There is something fishy going on here and I am not sure what, everyone seems too believable but I don't see much choice now. I hope you are right or at least not leading town as scum, unvote vote CMC

If you meant CMS (me) then i'll be at L-3, but i have said everything. I am an open book. But if/once i get lynched, then you see im town. I suggest that you all go after Nag. He seems the must scummy IMHO.

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Fri Apr 27, 2012 10:21 pm
by /
crazymilkshake5 wrote: I suggest that you all go after Nag. He seems the must scummy IMHO.

Why should we? You aren't. :lol:
If you are town, why aren't you voting who you claim to think is scum?

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Sat Apr 28, 2012 7:15 am
by crazymilkshake5
at this point in time it would be like trying to stab someone from 10 feet away.

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2012 12:13 pm
by shieldgenerator7
Official Vote Count:

Pmchung (1) - Haggis
TFO (2) - Sheep, /
Milkshake (4) - Pmchung, Nagerous, Dazza, TFO L-1

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch

Deadline Tomorrow

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2012 12:53 pm
by pmchugh
LYNCH HIM BEFORE THE DEADLINE!

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2012 1:03 pm
by crazymilkshake5
pmchugh wrote:LYNCH HIM BEFORE THE DEADLINE!

a little eager are we? vote pmc

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2012 1:33 pm
by pmchugh
Yes, I am eager for a lynch before the deadline. Surely you aren't going to say that a NL on day 3 with two killers is a good idea?

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2012 4:23 pm
by /
Alright, unvote vote Crazymilkshake sorry, but the game needs to move on.

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2012 4:27 pm
by sheepofdumb
I was just about to do that.

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2012 4:40 pm
by crazymilkshake5
so... are you going to kill nag or what?

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2012 5:45 pm
by sheepofdumb
You're dead milkshake. / hammered you.

Re: MLP: Friendship is MAFIA (8/13) Day 3 *Cold Chill*

Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2012 7:28 pm
by crazymilkshake5
sheepofdumb wrote:You're dead milkshake. / hammered you.

yeah i know, but my scene hasnt been posted yet. so technically im not "dead"