Conquer Club

Skoffin wrote:MM, I've had my vote on thezz for a while now...

So you have.
I'm tired.

Seeing as I'm at L-1 by the looks of it, I'll get it over with and claim.

I'm the town Doc, so there you have it.

Night 2 I protected MM (as his investigating claim seemed to make him a target).
Night 3 I protected LSU (as he was pretty conclusively cleared) and IMO that is why there was no NK on night 3. (could be that nag is the last scum and just wasn't around but I'd have that as much less likely)

nagerous wrote:Now I am here now, trying to propose my own theories, even if they are fundamentally flawed but instead I just get turned on myself.

Well when you make those obvious wrong/poor conclusions in your arguments it ain't that surprising that you draw suspicion really.

nagerous wrote:Well played thez if you get me lynched

Not that I have been trying to do that...

Nag, you should know better than to skim so much.
I can't vote in here and yes I was only a day poster. When Selin was lynched, he was shown to have a "mason". I stated clearly that I was a mason before the role was posted. In regards to secondary powers, unfortunately I don't which is pretty sucky. Unless anyone wants to counter the doc claim by Thez I am inclined to believe him. Personally I find MM and Nag both to be scummy in nature due to the skimming bit by Nag and MM's posting just for the sake of posting especially with what he had posted. Now it's back to work for me.

Thezzaruz wrote:Seeing as I'm at L-1 by the looks of it, I'll get it over with and claim.

I'm the town Doc, so there you have it.

Night 2 I protected MM (as his investigating claim seemed to make him a target).
Night 3 I protected LSU (as he was pretty conclusively cleared) and IMO that is why there was no NK on night 3. (could be that nag is the last scum and just wasn't around but I'd have that as much less likely)

nagerous wrote:Now I am here now, trying to propose my own theories, even if they are fundamentally flawed but instead I just get turned on myself.

Well when you make those obvious wrong/poor conclusions in your arguments it ain't that surprising that you draw suspicion really.

nagerous wrote:Well played thez if you get me lynched

Not that I have been trying to do that...

Of course you haven't! You're just throwing evidence against me constantly yet not actually voting classic scum baiting as I said.

Since we're looking for someone who got culted, possibly the doctor got culted?!

Also, whats this about me not posting at all in the last night... I was there and I was posting.

Everyone keeps calling me a skimmer when I am not, I am just saying there is a CHANCE that LSU could be a mafia mason to counteract Selin's double voting.

I think that ace and Fir shouldn't be left out of the spotlight.
Unfortunatly, I can't do anything more until the day ends.
Remember, I still have my protecting power.

nagerous wrote:Everyone keeps calling me a skimmer when I am not, I am just saying there is a CHANCE that LSU could be a mafia mason to counteract Selin's double voting.

You're seriously suggesting that towns double-voter would be counteracted by a scum voteless role??? yeez

nagerous wrote:Also, whats this about me not posting at all in the last night... I was there and I was posting.

Yea sorry about that, mixed you up with Fircoal that hasn't posted for 3 weeks.

Announcement

gimpyThewonder replaces Fircoal

confirm

i'll try to read and post by tonight

Thezzaruz wrote:

nagerous wrote:Everyone keeps calling me a skimmer when I am not, I am just saying there is a CHANCE that LSU could be a mafia mason to counteract Selin's double voting.

You're seriously suggesting that towns double-voter would be counteracted by a scum voteless role??? yeez

That is what I am suggesting and I think it is quite viable.

nagerous wrote:

Thezzaruz wrote:

nagerous wrote:Everyone keeps calling me a skimmer when I am not, I am just saying there is a CHANCE that LSU could be a mafia mason to counteract Selin's double voting.

You're seriously suggesting that towns double-voter would be counteracted by a scum voteless role??? yeez

That is what I am suggesting and I think it is quite viable.

That would leave the scum outnumbered by 2 extra votes. Sure it's possible but in such a scenario I would expect 1 or 2 extra scum tbh, unless the mod really wants scum to loose. Don't think that is the case here.

Well mafia had an assassin, a doc and a roleblocker. They were pretty strong to start with.

And we had a mindcontroller, a double-voter, a dayVig, a roleblocker, a doc and a cop so far. It's a strong lineup on both sides but those 2 votes difference would have been an extra a huge advantage.

Not really when you were suggesting that there isnt even another mafia anyway but instead we're hunting cult, so what's the difference between what you suggested and my suggestion

Now you took a wrong turn again... I didn't suggest that there where no scum left, you said that LSU is scum (because of being voteless) and when I call you up on the extreme unlikeliness of that you come out with a "no scum left" claim! I think there is both a scum and a cult left.

sorry I didn't post last night, my back meds made me too loopy. word of advice if its 3am and the baby has been keeping you awake at night for weeks, be very careful on the stairs.

i read everything, but since i'm on drugs i might have missed something.

i'd like to ask MM what he did day 1? ANd when did you investigate me(formerly fircoal)?

Who would you say is the remaining scum gimpy?

Ok, well I might have overestimated the cult presence. Now that I look at it, it's doubtful that the recruiting would be passed on. if so, then there would only be one cult member at most. Can someone update a list of confirmed+roles to make it easier to see who to pressure? (Too lazy to do it myself )

Right now, I'm thinking fircoal/gimpy. Not than you have done anything scummy gimpy, but I know that fircoal was around before he got replaced. His inactivity (i.e. submarining) makes me slightly suspicious. It's nothing major, but at this point with maybe 1-2 scum left and a crapload of missed investigations ( ) we should be following any suspicion.

Honestly, I think skoffin is the scummiest besides MM. As I now realize that trying to get anywhere with the lynch of MM is going to be fruitless at this time, my vote goes over to skoffin. Vote skoffin Upon the lynching of skoffin, assuming she turns up scum, we need to lynch MM. If she is town, I dunno what to do next.

ace1217:cleared cop
Skoffin:neither cleared nor claimed
Thezzaruz:claimed doc, not cleared
Kwanton:cleared by me
Minister Masket:claimed JOAT, not cleared
gimpyThewonder:not claimed, cleared by MM
LSU Tiger Josh:cleared, voteless mason
nagerous:claimed survivor, not cleared

ace1217 wrote:Who would you say is the remaining scum gimpy?

i'd like to hear from MM b4 making any allegations.

but to be honest there doesn't seem to be a lot of scummy behavior, just a lot of frightened townies looking over their shoulders and thinking its the poerson nest to them. i'm obviously wrong b/c the game is still going. its hard to jump into a game like this, everyone i thought was scummy while reading is dead for the most part.

ace remind me again, how were you cleared as being a cop? its these damn pills you see, i miss/forget things, not trying to skim.

I'm the one who started the lynch on sam in the first place.

Thez, what were your actions?

kwanton wrote:Right now, I'm thinking fircoal/gimpy. Not than you have done anything scummy gimpy, but I know that fircoal was around before he got replaced. His inactivity (i.e. submarining) makes me slightly suspicious. It's nothing major, but at this point with maybe 1-2 scum left and a crapload of missed investigations ( ) we should be following any suspicion.

well i can't tell you why fircoal wasn't around, but frankly i've never seen him see a game through, this isn't menat as an insult to the 'chu, he just seems to join every game but not really add much insight to any of them.

illuminate me on these missed investigations