Conquer Club

So, anyone up for speculation as to game setup?

safariguy5 wrote:Vote Count
ga7-3 (spiesr, wercool, gregwolf121)
wercool-4 (strike wolf, LSU Tiger Josh, Army of God, taco_man1)
cena-rules-2 (ga7, cena-rules)
taco_man1-1 (UTAlan)

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

I know it's just a humor thing strike wolf, but I remind everyone to remember to unvote before changing your vote.

Yeah I didn't unvote because I didn't expect you to count it anyways.

Not much to speculate on...We did have a night 0 so obviously we have some non-killing power roles out there but I'm sure most have already figured that out. From the size of the game I can't imagine there being much of a third party...possible cult recruiter, possible serial killer...could also mean mafia has a cop/role blocker or any other role that could apply in that scenario. there are 12 people in this game so it would be hard to imagine more than 3 (maybe 4 at most...) mafia members unless there's just a lot of power roles. Too much just joke posting to really have any kind of lead...

strike wolf wrote:Not much to speculate on...We did have a night 0 so obviously we have some non-killing power roles out there but I'm sure most have already figured that out. From the size of the game I can't imagine there being much of a third party...possible cult recruiter, possible serial killer...could also mean mafia has a cop/role blocker or any other role that could apply in that scenario. there are 12 people in this game so it would be hard to imagine more than 3 (maybe 4 at most...) mafia members unless there's just a lot of power roles. Too much just joke posting to really have any kind of lead...

I disagree joke posting is a great time to pick up on little things, when things get serious scum give nothing away if they are any good.

vote strikewolf for not understanding the genius of kwan

strike wolf wrote:Not much to speculate on...We did have a night 0 so obviously we have some non-killing power roles out there but I'm sure most have already figured that out. From the size of the game I can't imagine there being much of a third party...possible cult recruiter, possible serial killer...could also mean mafia has a cop/role blocker or any other role that could apply in that scenario. there are 12 people in this game so it would be hard to imagine more than 3 (maybe 4 at most...) mafia members unless there's just a lot of power roles. Too much just joke posting to really have any kind of lead...

unvote vote strike wolf the people that try to use logic so early on are ALWAYS scum, 100% of the time....SCUMZOR

Vote Count
ga7-3 (spiesr, wercool, gregwolf121)
wercool-4 (strike wolf, LSU Tiger Josh, Army of God, taco_man1)
cena-rules-1 (ga7)
taco_man1-1 (UTAlan)
strike wolf-2 (cena-rules, pmchugh)

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

cena-rules wrote:

strike wolf wrote:Not much to speculate on...We did have a night 0 so obviously we have some non-killing power roles out there but I'm sure most have already figured that out. From the size of the game I can't imagine there being much of a third party...possible cult recruiter, possible serial killer...could also mean mafia has a cop/role blocker or any other role that could apply in that scenario. there are 12 people in this game so it would be hard to imagine more than 3 (maybe 4 at most...) mafia members unless there's just a lot of power roles. Too much just joke posting to really have any kind of lead...

unvote vote strike wolf the people that try to use logic so early on are ALWAYS scum, 100% of the time....SCUMZOR

unvote vote cena for trying to stop any coherent posts.

pmchugh wrote:

cena-rules wrote:

strike wolf wrote:Not much to speculate on...We did have a night 0 so obviously we have some non-killing power roles out there but I'm sure most have already figured that out. From the size of the game I can't imagine there being much of a third party...possible cult recruiter, possible serial killer...could also mean mafia has a cop/role blocker or any other role that could apply in that scenario. there are 12 people in this game so it would be hard to imagine more than 3 (maybe 4 at most...) mafia members unless there's just a lot of power roles. Too much just joke posting to really have any kind of lead...

unvote vote strike wolf the people that try to use logic so early on are ALWAYS scum, 100% of the time....SCUMZOR

unvote vote cena for trying to stop any coherent posts.

kewhuqbg wbgiq4wi4 gwrqthw4quhhhhhhugbwqrgiu

seems like some pretty pointless bws. im not getting involved cuz it never goes right for me. no vote untill we get some real evidence

vodean wrote:seems like some pretty pointless bws. im not getting involved cuz it never goes right for me. no vote untill we get some real evidence

How do you propose that we accomplish such a task? Wait until day 2? What? Remember, there has already been a night 0 for non-killing roles.

Vote Count
ga7-3 (spiesr, wercool, gregwolf121)
wercool-4 (strike wolf, LSU Tiger Josh, Army of God, taco_man1)
cena-rules-2 (ga7, pmchugh)
taco_man1-1 (UTAlan)
strike wolf-1 (cena-rules)
no lynch-1 (vodean)

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

hmmm, 4 on wercool? either someone knows something or the mafia are voting together....hmmmmmmm

actually unvote it might be worth doing a no lynch today so that we have 2 days of information from our power roles to be able to use. I'm not sure why 2 other people voted after me on my initial vote, but mine was a joke vote. FOS those that tried to BW behind my vote

spiesr wrote:

vodean wrote:seems like some pretty pointless bws. im not getting involved cuz it never goes right for me. no vote untill we get some real evidence

How do you propose that we accomplish such a task? Wait until day 2? What? Remember, there has already been a night 0 for non-killing roles.

Agreed, you can't sit on your arse wating for things to happen. Mafia isn't about concrete evidence, if you win through concrete evidence then you either got lucky or the setup is unbalanced. fos

LSU Tiger Josh wrote:actually unvote it might be worth doing a no lynch today so that we have 2 days of information from our power roles to be able to use. I'm not sure why 2 other people voted after me on my initial vote, but mine was a joke vote. FOS those that tried to BW behind my vote

Cmon lsu, no lynch? The whole point of ngiht 0 is to give the town a wee night to discover things, after that we have to take proactive action. This post is mega weak from someone who should no better, it looks like setting up a group of people who look kinda scummy and waiting for one of us to pounce on it. Besides, no lynch when we already had a night? Cmon. unvote vote lsu

im going to have to vote lsu too

Vote Count
ga7-3 (spiesr, wercool, gregwolf121)
wercool-3 (strike wolf, Army of God, taco_man1)
cena-rules-1 (ga7)
taco_man1-1 (UTAlan)
strike wolf-1 (cena-rules)
no lynch-1 (vodean)
LSU Tiger Josh-1 (pmchugh)

I warned everyone to remember to unvote, wercool's second vote does not count.

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Sir, I believe I unvoted, voted cena-rules sir.

Vote Count
ga7-3 (spiesr, wercool, gregwolf121)
wercool-2 (strike wolf, taco_man1)
cena-rules-2 (ga7, Army of GOD)
taco_man1-1 (UTAlan)
strike wolf-1 (cena-rules)
no lynch-1 (vodean)
LSU Tiger Josh-1 (pmchugh)

I warned everyone to remember to unvote, wercool's second vote does not count.

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

LSU Tiger Josh wrote:actually unvote it might be worth doing a no lynch today so that we have 2 days of information from our power roles to be able to use.

Really? Especially after having had a night zero I am slightly confused as to why you would suggest this. I don't recall you having been overly in favor of no lynch day 1s in the past. (Though I can't remember if you were against them offhand, I will have to go look this one up.) Is there anything special about this game in particular that leads you to this conclusion?

wercool wrote:im going to have to vote lsu too

Way to jump on the bandwagon right of the bat there wercool...

i think im going to have to agree there with pmc and spiesr and im suspecting lsu and wercool, although with wercool im not so sure i think he may be trying to take some of the votes on him and put them on wercool, and as for lsu i think its odd that you don't want to get rid of mafia members, i do agree however that it would be wise to gather as much as we can and act accordingly, not with another night though because that would only give the mafia time to kill one of us, so im going to unvote and vote LSU then FOS on wercool

I'm glad pmc pointed those things out. I was highly suspect of voting no lynch on Day 1, but was waiting to see if anyone else said anything about it just in case it was a common thing. My gut says that we should be giving the mafia as few possibilities to kill as we can. FOS vodean, vote lsu.

Vote Count
ga7-1 (spiesr)
wercool-2 (strike wolf, taco_man1)
cena-rules-2 (ga7, Army of GOD)
taco_man1-1 (UTAlan)
strike wolf-1 (cena-rules)
no lynch-1 (vodean)
LSU Tiger Josh-1 (pmchugh, wercool, gregwolf)

Since UTAlan did not unvote, his second vote does not count.
With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Blech. Unvote, vote lsu.