Page 18 of 27
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 1:25 pm
by misterman10
Fircoal wrote:bryguy wrote:im still confused
we know
Vote Count
MM10 (1) Bryguy,
Bryguy (2) McSnipe, cena,
7 Alive, 4 to lynch,
actually vote someone you idiots.
bryguy, get your vote off of me, voting just for the sake of voting is noobish and scummy. I let you off with it cause your worse than NES, but you still haven't unvoted after everybody told you how scummy you were.
VOTE BRYGUY because he is getting on my fucking nerves
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:14 pm
by McSnipe
misterman10 wrote:Fircoal wrote:bryguy wrote:im still confused
we know
Vote Count
MM10 (1) Bryguy,
Bryguy (2) McSnipe, cena,
7 Alive, 4 to lynch,
actually vote someone you idiots.
bryguy, get your vote off of me, voting just for the sake of voting is noobish and scummy. I let you off with it cause your worse than NES, but you still haven't unvoted after everybody told you how scummy you were.
VOTE BRYGUY because he is getting on my fucking nerves
PRAISE THE LAWD!
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:17 pm
by mr. incrediball
that puts him on -1... has he already claimed?
if not, big fos on everyone who voted him
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:18 pm
by life-saver
mr. incrediball wrote:that puts him on -1... has he already claimed?
if not, big fos on everyone who voted him
According to him, he is a "Super Doc" who has two lives, but once one is used, he becomes a regular townie. I highly doubt it.

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:22 pm
by mr. incrediball
life-saver wrote:mr. incrediball wrote:that puts him on -1... has he already claimed?
if not, big fos on everyone who voted him
According to him, he is a "Super Doc" who has two lives, but once one is used, he becomes a regular townie. I highly doubt it.

i doubt a noob would make that up, since it definately sounds like a fircoal role.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:22 pm
by mr. incrediball
mr. incrediball wrote:that puts him on -1... has he already claimed?
if not, big fos on everyone who voted him
EBWOP (just noticed) i meant If so.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:25 pm
by life-saver
mr. incrediball wrote:life-saver wrote:mr. incrediball wrote:that puts him on -1... has he already claimed?
if not, big fos on everyone who voted him
According to him, he is a "Super Doc" who has two lives, but once one is used, he becomes a regular townie. I highly doubt it.

i doubt a noob would make that up, since it definately sounds like a fircoal role.
It's been at least one night, correct? My theory is that if he is mafia, his partner told him to claim Super Cop so no one would want to lynch him. Simple, but probably unlikely.

Only if that person knew that Bryguy would be a total noob today, which the only people I can think of are... Well, teh people he's played with. If we don't lynch him today, I will investigate him tonight.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:27 pm
by mr. incrediball
life-saver wrote:mr. incrediball wrote:life-saver wrote:mr. incrediball wrote:that puts him on -1... has he already claimed?
if not, big fos on everyone who voted him
According to him, he is a "Super Doc" who has two lives, but once one is used, he becomes a regular townie. I highly doubt it.

i doubt a noob would make that up, since it definately sounds like a fircoal role.
It's been at least one night, correct? My theory is that if he is mafia, his partner told him to claim Super Cop so no one would want to lynch him. Simple, but probably unlikely.

Only if that person knew that Bryguy would be a total noob today, which the only people I can think of are... Well, teh people he's played with. If we don't lynch him today, I will investigate him tonight.

forgot about scum buddies
good points there
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:29 pm
by life-saver
life-saver wrote:mr. incrediball wrote:life-saver wrote:mr. incrediball wrote:that puts him on -1... has he already claimed?
if not, big fos on everyone who voted him
According to him, he is a "Super Doc" who has two lives, but once one is used, he becomes a regular townie. I highly doubt it.

i doubt a noob would make that up, since it definately sounds like a fircoal role.
It's been at least one night, correct? My theory is that if he is mafia, his partner told him to claim Super
DOC so no one would want to lynch him. Simple, but probably unlikely.

Only if that person knew that Bryguy would be a total noob today, which the only people I can think of are... Well, teh people he's played with. If we don't lynch him today, I will investigate him tonight.
Just noticed that.
MIB, I am unsure about what to do. We need to find el scumo amigos.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:32 pm
by ga7
I think we won't learn anything more from Bry today, and I'm not comfy with proof-by-lynch either way, but that's a good point actually.
Either way, that means he's not the day SK, so I believe it's time to put pressure on someone else. Since it'd have been in Mib's best interest to hammer Bry and plead confusion if he was, I'll go ahead and vote my last suspect, Cena. Basically he's been acting kinda townie, but some things that happened around the daykill time made me tick, he was pretty active right when my previous incarnation got killed.
Vote Cena
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:34 pm
by mr. incrediball
despite bryguy's uncontested pro-town claim, mcsnipe is still eager to get bry lynched. now mcsnipe may not be the most likely of people to drop a tell like that, but i'm gonna throw caution to the wind here and vote mcsnipe
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:34 pm
by ga7
Btw LS, you might want to clear the matter once and for all on Bry but right now MM looks like a good option for investigation IMO. Well, will depend of the lynch too, as you prefer anyway as both investigations will be helpful.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:36 pm
by ga7
Mib, McSnipe was proven Reverse Jester. So, a bit useless lynch right now as we need to nail a killing scum.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:40 pm
by mr. incrediball
ga7 wrote:Mib, McSnipe was proven Reverse Jester. So, a bit useless lynch right now as we need to nail a killing scum.
really?
unvote
fos incrediball for skimming

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:42 pm
by life-saver
ga7 wrote:Btw LS, you might want to clear the matter once and for all on Bry but right now MM looks like a good option for investigation IMO. Well, will depend of the lynch too, as you prefer anyway as both investigations will be helpful.
So true. Although something in my gut tells me that Bry here won't have an important scum role... MM10- I'm not sure about him, I can barely get a read on that guy.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:52 pm
by Fircoal
ga7 wrote:I think we won't learn anything more from Bry today, and I'm not comfy with proof-by-lynch either way, but that's a good point actually.
Either way, that means he's not the day SK, so I believe it's time to put pressure on someone else. Since it'd have been in Mib's best interest to hammer Bry and plead confusion if he was, I'll go ahead and vote my last suspect, Cena. Basically he's been acting kinda townie, but some things that happened around the daykill time made me tick, he was pretty active right when my previous incarnation got killed.
Vote Cena
\
note don't pay attention to the time of the day kills, I did them went I felt like it. ^_^
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:57 pm
by life-saver
Fircoal wrote:ga7 wrote:I think we won't learn anything more from Bry today, and I'm not comfy with proof-by-lynch either way, but that's a good point actually.
Either way, that means he's not the day SK, so I believe it's time to put pressure on someone else. Since it'd have been in Mib's best interest to hammer Bry and plead confusion if he was, I'll go ahead and vote my last suspect, Cena. Basically he's been acting kinda townie, but some things that happened around the daykill time made me tick, he was pretty active right when my previous incarnation got killed.
Vote Cena
\
note don't pay attention to the time of the day kills, I did them went I felt like it. ^_^
D:<
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:58 pm
by bryguy
mr. incrediball wrote:ga7 wrote:Mib, McSnipe was proven Reverse Jester. So, a bit useless lynch right now as we need to nail a killing scum.
really?
unvote
fos incrediball for skimming

oops, i skimmed that also
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 5:00 pm
by life-saver
bryguy wrote:mr. incrediball wrote:ga7 wrote:Mib, McSnipe was proven Reverse Jester. So, a bit useless lynch right now as we need to nail a killing scum.
really?
unvote
fos incrediball for skimming

oops, i skimmed that also
-sigh-
Skimming=Bad. Good boy. *gives doggie biscuit*
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 5:04 pm
by ga7
Ah damn. I thought since it was different from the previous day there might be something there. Anyway, my vote stands as since the Bryguy lead started he just voted and laid low.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 5:07 pm
by life-saver
ga7 wrote:Ah damn. I thought since it was different from the previous day there might be something there. Anyway, my vote stands as since the Bryguy lead started he just voted and laid low.
He was also pushing for a claim, although I don't know what Bry's VC was then....
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 5:08 pm
by bryguy
life-saver wrote:ga7 wrote:Ah damn. I thought since it was different from the previous day there might be something there. Anyway, my vote stands as since the Bryguy lead started he just voted and laid low.
He was also pushing for a claim, although I don't know what Bry's VC was then....
ok, im confused by what life said, and i had not meant to lay low, i was having trouble finding the board

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 5:10 pm
by ga7
We were talking about Cena not you... I'll have to reread to find back how all this happened anyhow.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 5:10 pm
by life-saver
bryguy wrote:life-saver wrote:ga7 wrote:Ah damn. I thought since it was different from the previous day there might be something there. Anyway, my vote stands as since the Bryguy lead started he just voted and laid low.
He was also pushing for a claim, although I don't know what Bry's VC was then....
ok, im confused by what life said, and i had not meant to lay low, i was having trouble finding the board

We are talking about cena, not you.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 5:26 pm
by ga7
Alright, just reread and while day 1 wasn't really relevant there's a few things that don't sit right for me...
cena-rules on beginning of night 1 wrote:score 1 to cena
and how did nag die?
cena-rules wrote:gratz shadow
*takes a bow*
Hmmm who to kill next
Ill review the thread and give a list of suspects
Then at day 2 he started a lead on MM10, but never participated in the actual discussion. After a while it looks like he felt the wind turn and bandwagonned on Bryguy. When it came to claiming, he tried to get more details about the role but never unvoted, just voiced his disbelief. Rest of his posts have no input.
The quotes look a bit slippery too... All in all the case isn't hell strong but seeing the people left, it kinda adds up.