Page 17 of 27
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 11:10 am
by freezie
2) After rereading everything, why do you(Aegnor) have it out for sheepofdumb? I have yet to locate a good reason for this. Just curious...
Althought he was thoroughly going against dwight the last 6 pages?
3) From what I can tell, there are still three potential "groups" responsible for the killings on board our ship. Right? Althought, it seems we somewhat lucked out the last night, but I'm not quite sure why unless two groups voted the same person. Or, night action missed?
1 mafia, very high probability of a serial killer, and a vigilante on our side. The vigilante won't kill every nights, that unless he is sure to hit a mafia. Well almost sure.
We also have a doc, and if we got a good one, he might have protected someone. But then our vig did a mistake...unless the doc protected the vig's target who happened to be a mafia...
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 2:25 pm
by jnd94
Mandalorian replaces CaptainPlanet!
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 2:35 pm
by The1exile
jnd94 wrote:Mandalorian replaces CaptainPlanet!
YIPEE!!!
Mandy, come share your wisdom with us all.
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 2:36 pm
by willis
jnd94 wrote:Mandalorian replaces CaptainPlanet!
Prepare for the most random theories and rants.....
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 2:44 pm
by LSU Tiger Josh
Welcome to the ship Mandy
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 3:30 pm
by Aegnor
Yey Mandy is here, let the fun random accusations commence.
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 4:57 pm
by mandalorian2298
Hi guys!
Sorry for the delay but I had to reread the thread. (BTW, Narc DID vote for XenCobra, Talapus).
Aegnor wrote:Yey Mandy is here, let the fun random accusations commence.
Lol. A most prophetic of posts.
I know that this will raise hair on few heads (of those who were in the Sherwood game and who know what this could lead to
). However, after I rered the thread I have to
vote Aegnor. Why?, you ask (fearing that explanation will be 80 pages long). Two things.
1. At the end of the Day 1, when Chad was as good as lynched, you made a long and well elaborated post that ended with you unvoting Sheep and voting Falcon:
Aegnor wrote:falcon wrote:FOS Chad22342On page 3 (or 4 or 5???), he jumped on one bandwagon, then changed his mind and jumped on the other one all within two minutes.
very suspicious young man
Then after some people voted for chad this happnes:
falcon wrote:Whoa, hold your horses for minute.
While I admit Chad has been doing some suspicious things (Double FOS Chad22342) Its still too early to start a bandwagon. Let him explain himself and he or someone else will show themselves to be scummy.
falcon wrote:
I just read through all your posts again and second time through they didn't seem quite as suspicious, so unFOS Chad22342
We're here to catch scum not lynch innocents
The 2nd and 3rd quotes happen on the same page. Chad may seem scummy to you, but I believe has just done some noobish mistakes. However, Falcon builds what seems to him, a feasible badnwagoning case on Chad, but suddenly after he puts a Doubles fos on him, decides Chad's behavior is excusable.
While Exile's theory sounds plausible, where both Chad and Falcon are scum trying to cover each other (I didn't see much accusations coming from Chad's behalf so personally, I wouldn't go that far, but I can't rule it out at this point), I think that Falcon's behavior is pretty suspicious and I'd like to hear what he has to say about changing is mind so quick.
For now I'll
Unvote SheepVote FalconUntil he provides some explanations.
[/quote]
The only reason why for this post and a totally irellevant vote (Chad was as good as hung at this point) would be for you to wash your hands of Chad-lynch. If you are mafia, then you would know that Chad isn't mafia and so you wanted to underline that you have nothing to do with a (at that time probable) pro-town being lynch.
2. The begining of Day 2 and Xen makes a Cultie accusation against XenCobra. Aegnor's post:
Aegnor wrote:Ok this game is going nowhere. No one posts anything meaningful, so I'll stir things up a bit:
VOTE SHEEP
Just a random vote, since I have no leads so far.
There was no need for a random vote at this point, since a bandwagon on XenCobra has started. Yet you choose to ignore it and your "random vote" stayed harmlessly on Sheep 'till the end of Day 2.
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 5:03 pm
by dwightschrute
Talapus wrote:What we know:
Active Players - Voted For -
Dwightschrute - - No vote, No vote
pancakemix - - No vote, XenCobra
sheepofdumb - - Chad22342, XenCobra
freezie - - Falcon, XenCobra
dominationnation - - Chad22342, No vote
Spurgistan - - trestain, No vote
CaptainPlanet - - Chad22342, No vote
Anarkistsdream - - No vote, No vote
Willis - - Falcon, XenCobra
LSU Tiger Josh - - Falcon, Anarchy Ninja
Talapus - - Chad22342, XenCobra
the1exile - - Chad22342, No vote
Anarchy Ninja - - No vote, XenCobra,
Skittles! - - No Vote, XenCobra
trestain - - Chad22342, XenCobra
I GOT SERVED - - No vote, XenCobra
XenHu - - Chad22342, XenCobra
Aegnor - - sheepofdumb, sheepofdumb,
Alright, a few things I've noticed after going back through and rereading everything. First off, I believe these votes to be accurate, but feel free to correct me if I'm wrong.
1) Anarkistsdream & Dwightschrute - Why haven't you voted yet? Or at least say no lynch? The first day I can understand, but 2 days in a row?
2) After rereading everything, why do you(Aegnor) have it out for sheepofdumb? I have yet to locate a good reason for this. Just curious...
3) From what I can tell, there are still three potential "groups" responsible for the killings on board our ship. Right? Althought, it seems we somewhat lucked out the last night, but I'm not quite sure why unless two groups voted the same person. Or, night action missed?
4) We all seem pretty jumpy at this point and are ready to blame anyone at a moments notice. But looking at the vote counts above, it helps paint a clearer picture of who wants what.
Right now, we need a good theory. Your thoughts?
ther is nothing wrong with not voting, i had no good reason to vote for anyone so u cant accuse me of something like that, just because im not jumping on bandwagons and stuff like that
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 5:06 pm
by mandalorian2298
dwightschrute wrote:ther is nothing wrong with not voting, i had no good reason to vote for anyone so u cant accuse me of something like that, just because im not jumping on bandwagons and stuff like that
He can when he adds submarrining to to the accusation. You have kept your head pretty low, Dwight. That suggests to me that your head is more important to you then finding scum.
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 5:08 pm
by dwightschrute
mandalorian2298 wrote:dwightschrute wrote:ther is nothing wrong with not voting, i had no good reason to vote for anyone so u cant accuse me of something like that, just because im not jumping on bandwagons and stuff like that
He can when he adds submarrining to to the accusation. You have kept your head pretty low, Dwight. That suggests to me that your head is more important to you then finding scum.
very clever, but that is untrue, i have realized it is better to post nothing than post crap in a game of mafia (i no ur all gonna say im a hypocrite, but im changing my ways)
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 5:52 pm
by Aegnor
Nice theories Mandy, but where did I ever double fos chad?
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 5:58 pm
by jnd94
VOTE COUNT
2-Talapus (XenHu, AD)
2- dwightschrute (aegnor, LSU Tiger Josh)
1- Aegnor (mandalorian)
With 19 ALIVE IT TAKES 10 TO LYNCH!!!!!!
Day WILL END FRIDAY AT 8:00 PM CENTRAL TIME!!!!!!!
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 5:59 pm
by dominationnation
youve got a good point about aegnor mandy. FOr now I will unvote and wait to see if anymore eviidence about him comes up
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 6:01 pm
by Aegnor
dominationnation wrote:youve got a good point about aegnor mandy. FOr now I will unvote and wait to see if anymore eviidence about him comes up
I dont think he has a good point, he said that I doubled FOSed chad, and he based his case on it. I never did it. Check for yourself. Read again the stuff he quoted me, and see my reasoning for voting falcon.
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 6:02 pm
by jnd94
dominationnation wrote:youve got a good point about aegnor mandy. FOr now I will unvote and wait to see if anymore eviidence about him comes up
of course you change your vote RIGHT after I put the vote count in, while you almost never have spoken!
Ill have to edit it......
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 6:12 pm
by mandalorian2298
Aegnor wrote:dominationnation wrote:youve got a good point about aegnor mandy. FOr now I will unvote and wait to see if anymore eviidence about him comes up
I dont think he has a good point, he said that I doubled FOSed chad, and he based his case on it. I never did it. Check for yourself. Read again the stuff he quoted me, and see my reasoning for voting falcon.
Please bold the part of my post in wich I speak about double-fosing Chad.
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 6:14 pm
by mandalorian2298
mandalorian2298 wrote:Aegnor wrote:dominationnation wrote:youve got a good point about aegnor mandy. FOr now I will unvote and wait to see if anymore eviidence about him comes up
I dont think he has a good point, he said that I doubled FOSed chad, and he based his case on it. I never did it. Check for yourself. Read again the stuff he quoted me, and see my reasoning for voting falcon.
Please bold the part of my post in wich I speak about double-fosing Chad.
Lol, never mind that. Falcon Double FOSed Chad and you qouted him, and I quoted your quote.
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 6:17 pm
by willis
Mandy is off his rocker again.........
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 6:18 pm
by Aegnor
mandalorian2298 wrote:[
Please bold the part of my post in wich I speak about double-fosing Chad.
Wow , you are actually right, I read my own stuff while thinking it you was you who said that. Ok I take it back.
Anyway I still stand by my vote on Falcon, at the time he seemed more suspicious to me than Chad. I honestly believed Chad was making some noobish mistakes with his bandwagoning. Falcon's behavior on the other hand, was a bit strange in my taste.
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 7:28 pm
by dominationnation
jnd94 wrote:dominationnation wrote:youve got a good point about aegnor mandy. FOr now I will unvote and wait to see if anymore eviidence about him comes up
of course you change your vote RIGHT after I put the vote count in, while you almost never have spoken!
Ill have to edit it......
sorry. I have had a long day and havnt been able to get to a computer. Im back now though
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 7:28 pm
by freezie
In another way, I don't beleive there is 2 cults at the start of the game. I always thought ( correct me if I am wrong ) that there is a single cult leader/recruiter and he must recruit his members starting from night 1.
That leaves me to think there is no cult member in the game, he has been lynched day 1. So Falcon would have blindly went against and then defended Chad.
So his case is he was trying to find something suspicious, I am far from beleive he had a clue about Chad beeing cult leader or not.
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 7:31 pm
by XenHu
freezie wrote:In another way, I don't beleive there is 2 cults at the start of the game. I always thought ( correct me if I am wrong ) that there is a single cult leader/recruiter and he must recruit his members starting from night 1.
That leaves me to think there is no cult member in the game, he has been lynched day 1. So Falcon would have blindly went against and then defended Chad.
So his case is he was trying to find something suspicious, I am far from beleive he had a clue about Chad beeing cult leader or not.
Good point. However, I still am keeping my vote where it is for now.
-X
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 7:33 pm
by Aegnor
So am I.
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 7:33 pm
by LSU Tiger Josh
Very interesting suggestions Mandy.
Posted: Thu May 17, 2007 7:38 pm
by freezie
Vote: Aegnor
More I think about it, more it seems you are on sheep's case for no reasons. Also throwing an accusation against falcon when it was clear he couldn't have known Chad's role.