Page 16 of 27
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 3)
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 7:17 pm
by william18
ga7 wrote:william18 wrote:Perhaps the Thing just basically failed. But here are the scenerio's.
1) The Thing recruited another person
2) The Thing did not succeed at killing or assimilating.
The odds are on number 1.
Oh wait, that means you do know how things work. Or rather, how the thing works. *wide grin*
Since the rouge killed(or so I believed) I assumed the thing chose to recruit.
EBWOP
(read how I said or)
Vote Ga7 for trying to focus on me and divert attention.
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 7:20 pm
by william18
Nvm someone died that night.
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 8:26 pm
by william18
Opps, accidentally pressed edit instead of quote. Nate do you want me to change it back?
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 3)
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 8:28 pm
by william18
william18 wrote:ga7 wrote:william18 wrote:Perhaps the Thing just basically failed. But here are the scenerio's.
1) The Thing recruited another person
2) The Thing did not succeed at killing or assimilating.
The odds are on number 1.
Oh wait, that means you do know how things work. Or rather, how the thing works. *wide grin*
Since the rouge killed(or so I believed) I assumed the thing chose to recruit.
EBWOP
(read how I said or)
Vote Ga7 for trying to focus on me and divert attention.
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 3)
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2008 9:31 pm
by spiesr
ga7 wrote:spiesr wrote:Just a quick poll here:how many people suspect ga7 enough to lynch him?
Again, why not just vote me instead of being all pussy about it? It's not like there's any votes in the air or I'd be in danger of getting lynched. Fishing much?
Because I don't yet suspect you enough to lynch you...
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 12:50 am
by F1fth
Hmm, I think I believe ga7.
My reasoning is this:
The only way ga could have pulled this off as scum is if he was the original thing and assimilated the doctor night 1. However, if he did so, then he would have no reason to not try to kill/assimilate ace tonight. That would have clearly been the smart move, so unless ga is pulling the WIFOM of the century as well as got super lucky with a night 1 assimilation, I don't think he could be scum. That also means that the doctor is probably still on our side.
That said, I'm not sure who would be a good choice to pressure today.
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 9:49 am
by dunc_2007
I'm inclined to believe ga7, because why the hell would he claim what he did if he were scum? I can tell you why he wouldn't:
1) It would draw attention to him, something scum don't normaly want. In a game like this, it would be a lot easier for the scum to lay low and let the townies lynch each other.
2) He would be better off waiting and letting one of his scumbuddies claim doc if they were ever accused.
3) Sooner or later, when the doc doesn't turn up, people would surely begin to suspect him.
Also, fifth makes a valid point. Wouldn't he have killed ace last night if he knew there was no doc to worry about?
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 10:31 am
by william18
F1fth wrote:Hmm, I think I believe ga7.
My reasoning is this:
The only way ga could have pulled this off as scum is if he was the original thing and assimilated the doctor night 1. However, if he did so, then he would have no reason to not try to kill/assimilate ace tonight. That would have clearly been the smart move, so unless ga is pulling the WIFOM of the century as well as got super lucky with a night 1 assimilation, I don't think he could be scum. That also means that the doctor is probably still on our side.
That said, I'm not sure who would be a good choice to pressure today.
Not exactly, he could be lying about the doctor protecting him, thus trying to lure the doctor out. So the doctor could just be in the crowd keeping quite.
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 10:41 am
by spiesr
william18 wrote:Not exactly, he could be lying about the doctor protecting him, thus trying to lure the doctor out. So the doctor could just be in the crowd keeping quite.
I think that the doctor would come out and tell us he is lying so we could lynch him, unless you have info that says otherwise?
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 10:43 am
by spiesr
dunc_2007 wrote:2) He would be better off waiting and letting one of his scumbuddies claim doc if they were ever accused
If ga7 and the doctor are thing then they can still claim doctor later if they need...
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 3:57 pm
by drake_259
Ga7 is pretty much at a deadlock, i think we should leave him alive for now and think about lynching him at a further date
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 4:25 pm
by ga7
It was precised the PM I received was sent to me, the doc and the thing, so yes the doc would know if I was BSing. Guess what, the doc isn't coming out.
william18 wrote:ga7 wrote:william18 wrote:Perhaps the Thing just basically failed. But here are the scenerio's.
1) The Thing recruited another person
2) The Thing did not succeed at killing or assimilating.
The odds are on number 1.
Oh wait, that means you do know how things work. Or rather, how the thing works. *wide grin*
Since the rouge killed(or so I believed) I assumed the thing chose to recruit.
EBWOP
(read how I said or)
Vote Ga7 for trying to focus on me and divert attention.
Did you just skim my post or did I strike a nerve? Which one is it uh?
This is a detail, but your way of explaining that is far less clear. What about the rest of my post? Do you have any viable arguments besides "oh I NO! the doc is a moron that doesn't want to come out and is waiting to be NKed instead of outing him as scum!!1!"?
drake_259 wrote:Ga7 is pretty much at a deadlock, i think we should leave him alive for now and think about lynching him at a further date
Again, you can't say I'm a deadlock without presenting ANY argument against my post.
Moving on, I still want to hear from Stroop and the bunch of inactives, but seeing Will's blind reaction I might be for once right in my feeling heh.
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 4:37 pm
by drake_259
ga7 wrote:drake_259 wrote:Ga7 is pretty much at a deadlock, i think we should leave him alive for now and think about lynching him at a further date
Again, you can't say I'm a deadlock without presenting ANY argument against my post.
Well its either you are who you say you are or its that you were the doctor and got turned by the thing, either is likely as the other which means its a deadlock for the time being. i also said to keep you alive because just in case you are telling the truth, it could be handy keeping you around
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2008 4:43 pm
by william18
ga7 wrote:It was precised the PM I received was sent to me, the doc and the thing, so yes the doc would know if I was BSing. Guess what, the doc isn't coming out.
william18 wrote:ga7 wrote:william18 wrote:Perhaps the Thing just basically failed. But here are the scenerio's.
1) The Thing recruited another person
2) The Thing did not succeed at killing or assimilating.
The odds are on number 1.
Oh wait, that means you do know how things work. Or rather, how the thing works. *wide grin*
Since the rouge killed(or so I believed) I assumed the thing chose to recruit.
EBWOP
(read how I said or)
Vote Ga7 for trying to focus on me and divert attention.
Did you just skim my post or did I strike a nerve? Which one is it uh?
This is a detail, but your way of explaining that is far less clear. What about the rest of my post? Do you have any viable arguments besides "oh I NO! the doc is a moron that doesn't want to come out and is waiting to be NKed instead of outing him as scum!!1!"?
I didn't skim your post, I just responded to the only argument that actually needed to be replied to.
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Wed Dec 24, 2008 3:10 am
by Stroop
ga7 wrote:Moving on, I still want to hear from Stroop and the bunch of inactives, but seeing Will's blind reaction I might be for once right in my feeling heh.
Sorry if I missed it, but what is it you want to hear from me?
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Wed Dec 24, 2008 9:25 am
by spiesr
Your hopping on wagons in the middle and overall scuminess.
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Wed Dec 24, 2008 10:14 am
by Stroop
spiesr wrote:Your hopping on wagons in the middle and overall scuminess.
I explained why I was on both wagons on page 22. As for being in the middle... someone's gotta be there?
Overall scumminess, eh? I suppose that just naturally comes with the bandwagons
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Wed Dec 24, 2008 11:25 am
by dunc_2007
drake_259 wrote:ga7 wrote:drake_259 wrote:Ga7 is pretty much at a deadlock, i think we should leave him alive for now and think about lynching him at a further date
Again, you can't say I'm a deadlock without presenting ANY argument against my post.
Well its either you are who you say you are or its that you were the doctor and got turned by the thing, either is likely as the other which means its a deadlock for the time being. i also said to keep you alive because just in case you are telling the truth, it could be handy keeping you around
I agree with this. Though I find the scenario that ga7 was the doc unlikely, if no doc turns up by the endgame, we'll know who to lynch. But until then, I think it's best we keep him around.
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Wed Dec 24, 2008 11:29 am
by LSU Tiger Josh
The only problem with that is by end game any of the "things" could possibly still try to claim that.
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Thu Dec 25, 2008 1:44 pm
by spiesr
Crud, deadends... When is the deadline?
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Fri Dec 26, 2008 8:03 am
by Natewolfman
spiesr wrote:Crud, deadends... When is the deadline?
with the lack of conversation im going to set a deadline, but since we havnt had much voting yet,
im going to place a 2 week eadline on it!
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Sat Dec 27, 2008 10:15 am
by ga7
Would someone care for rereading and giving opinions on the remaining players because I'm too lazy to do it?
Nate, could you prod Pancake please? I have a feeling he's gone off again
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Sat Dec 27, 2008 4:22 pm
by F1fth
From what I've seen, I'd say that William's knee-jerk reaction to ga7 is our biggest lead. Given the nature of the voting system and the fact that we still have around 2 weeks, I'll refrain from placing my vote on him and instead will encourage discussion on the matter.
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Sat Dec 27, 2008 4:23 pm
by ace1217
Vote william
Re: The Thing - Mafia Style (Day 4)
Posted: Sat Dec 27, 2008 10:48 pm
by spiesr
ace1217 wrote:Vote william
Real helpful, way to contribute to the discussion.
FOS ace for voting with zero explanation.
Although I thought he was smart enough not to do that as scum....