Conquer Club

dgz345 wrote:i still don't know what's best for town. a potential scum lynch or no lynch. (asking for opinions here)

strike wolf wrote:I don't really like Dakkys play from an effectiveness standpoint but it seems more or less in his town meta from what little I remember so I won't vote for him unless something changes.

Ragian wrote:What do you think about the voting pattern from D1?

Ragian wrote:Do you have any evidence that a store worker would be scum?

Pikanchion wrote:Whatever.

Unvote: Tobikera
Vote: dakky21

Ragian wrote:

dakky21 wrote:I really don't know what to do as a VT. No one screams to me as scum like jfm did in last game, as I said I can read some scumtells but so far no one is jumping out of context, except maybe Pika for referring to an old game where scum won (and he was scum) because someone early claimed VT. Voting Tobi back there just for bad play (or anti-town move, call it however you wish) is scummy to me as quoting that game isn't relevant to this one at all, but gives Pika an excuse to vote someone without proper reasons.

Not really helpful, mate...

dakky21 wrote:

Ragian wrote:What do you think about the voting pattern from D1?

I think dgz is absent with his mind like he doesn't care at all for the game, I believe that he hammered without knowing he will hammer. That may be a scumtell because scum don't care who they will vote, but they don't do the hammer as it is way too suspicious, especially like dgz played D1.

ZaBeast wrote:If dgz didn't know he was the hammer (which he admitted to not knowing), the fact he actually was is irrelevant to your argument (I don't think the premise that scum never hammers is true anyways). You can't say him not knowing he was the hammer is a scumtell, but the fact he was the hammer makes it so he can't be scum, that just makes no sense.

Pikanchion wrote:

Ragian wrote:

dakky21 wrote:I really don't know what to do as a VT. No one screams to me as scum like jfm did in last game, as I said I can read some scumtells but so far no one is jumping out of context, except maybe Pika for referring to an old game where scum won (and he was scum) because someone early claimed VT. Voting Tobi back there just for bad play (or anti-town move, call it however you wish) is scummy to me as quoting that game isn't relevant to this one at all, but gives Pika an excuse to vote someone without proper reasons.

Not really helpful, mate...

Fixed that for you.

Ragian wrote:I'm not saying that Pika is doing too much to help himself, but he's my strongest town read at this point. I just can't see him push a policy lynch so vehemently and be scum. Unless, of course, he's a lyncher, too... But surely two lynchers would be too much...

dakky21 wrote:I really don't know what to do as a VT. No one screams to me as scum like jfm did in last game, as I said I can read some scumtells but so far no one is jumping out of context, except maybe Pika for referring to an old game where scum won (and he was scum) because someone early claimed VT. Voting Tobi back there just for bad play (or anti-town move, call it however you wish) is scummy to me as quoting that game isn't relevant to this one at all, but gives Pika an excuse to vote someone without proper reasons. I agree, it is very difficult for me to be able to conclusively think anyone is scum or town based on what i have read so far.

Ragian wrote:What do you think about the voting pattern from D1? Generally, I think the pattern is that the hammer is rarely scum as they know better, other than this it could be anyone on the list.
Scum could have started the train or could have just jumped on board later... it is difficult to tell.

dgz345 wrote:I said before that pika and blacky are on my scum list.

The biggest reason I voted blacky was because somewhere in the back of my head
I have the idea that a potential scum lynch is better than no lynch. But as he would not be voted before the deadline and now that the deadline is removed there is no need to do a last minute push.

Tho I'll say that the blacky vote was slow. To be fair the deadline was coming up so scum would not need to vote.

Why would me or Ragian try to push lynches before a deadline if we were scum? IF you were scum then why would you not push a lynch? You know your scum buddy/ies so its easy for you to railroad town into lynching town.

The reason I had blacky on my scum list is because he is a store employee. Madness that you still have me on your list despite all the talk above about flavour roles... with all the flavour discussion do you really think I would offer up this info if I was scum?

And pika is just a gut feeling.

Pikanchion wrote:Whatever.

Unvote: Tobikera
Vote: dakky21
As Rage said... not very helpful, and contributing to the reason why you are top of my FOS list.

Tobikera wrote:I really appreciate it when players make their responses in some other color than black. It helps differentiate things nicely. However, I would suggest they make their text BOLD and avoid orange, yellow and any other light color...hard to read. Normal to dark blue and green would be fine. Red should be reserved for communicating to the mod. Thank you for your consideration.