Conquer Club

Iron Butterfly wrote:I have to concur. This is day one.Sometimes its the small things that gets people lynched.

At this point of the game on day one Colton is more helpful to town lynched. If he flips Town it tells us the double voter is mafia. If he flips mafia it would put a magnifying glass on those who wanted a no lynch. My vote stays.

I was on the fence about removing my vote after the claim or not... in the end I came to the same conclusion as you that overall it would be more beneficial for the lynch to go through since there was still a decent chance he was scum. I'm really glad now I left my vote alone lol.

While it's too bad that met's got fired, at least that allowed the firing of colton to go through, so that makes storr about as town as someone can be right now.

I agree with looking at virus tomorrow, as I said in a previous post he hasn't done anything overtly scummy, but he has been "scummarizing" and could very well be scum

why didnt you bother making that comment?

regarding, not removing your vote, and that you would rather him lynched than no lynch happen???

HotShot53 wrote:

Iron Butterfly wrote:I have to concur. This is day one.Sometimes its the small things that gets people lynched.

At this point of the game on day one Colton is more helpful to town lynched. If he flips Town it tells us the double voter is mafia. If he flips mafia it would put a magnifying glass on those who wanted a no lynch. My vote stays.

I was on the fence about removing my vote after the claim or not... in the end I came to the same conclusion as you that overall it would be more beneficial for the lynch to go through since there was still a decent chance he was scum. I'm really glad now I left my vote alone lol.

While it's too bad that met's got fired, at least that allowed the firing of colton to go through, so that makes storr about as town as someone can be right now.

I agree with looking at virus tomorrow, as I said in a previous post he hasn't done anything overtly scummy, but he has been "scummarizing" and could very well be scum

Do not for a moment think that because someone voted to lynch Colton that that somehow proves they are town.

sure, its a case by case basis. Its unlikely 2 mafia voted for their partner though. Sure perhaps one of them, but in the remaining outsiders, it gives us something to push on. Also we can look who pushed on colton, with meh reason.

also the only person colton pushed on was myself, so you can take that for what you will.

StorrZerg wrote:why didnt you bother making that comment?

regarding, not removing your vote, and that you would rather him lynched than no lynch happen???

To be honest, because it was so close to the deadline, I figured it wouldn't really influence anyone either way, and the only thing it would do would be to draw more attention to myself if colton turned out to be town.

Iron Butterfly wrote:Do not for a moment think that because someone voted to lynch Colton that that somehow proves they are town.

Obviously it's not "proven", but it's about as close proven to it as you can get right now, since storr sort of led the lynch of colton, even cast the deciding vote after firing mets and lowering the amount needed for a firing... without all that there would have been a no-lynch. I would think he could be a serial killer, except I've never seen a public day-time serial killer before. So unless storr is even crazier than usual, I'd say he's town.

HotShot53 wrote:

StorrZerg wrote:why didnt you bother making that comment?

regarding, not removing your vote, and that you would rather him lynched than no lynch happen???

To be honest, because it was so close to the deadline, I figured it wouldn't really influence anyone either way, and the only thing it would do would be to draw more attention to myself if colton turned out to be town.

I think this is the scummiest thing i've seen this game.



You very well knew the situation at the time wasn't good considering mets wasn't voting, limited time, as well as not knowing who would be around to help the vote if mets didnt vote.
So a towns input that "hey a lynch is good in this situation even though you might not agree mets" would have been very helpful.

which brings us to this point
as town, why are you worried about the lynch if colton is town. You know its good to learn the information and miss lynches do happen. imo its scummier that you didnt say anything, since mets was not voting, and you decided to not say anything. I see great scum motivation in not talking.

YO, WHO EVER YOU ARE YOU KNOW WHO YOU ARE.

i need a sign baby i need a sign

Charm and hotshot were right on the back of you with colton IB. The smart money at that time was a DD lynch. My inclination on them just now is a town read.

StorrZerg wrote:

HotShot53 wrote:

StorrZerg wrote:why didnt you bother making that comment?

regarding, not removing your vote, and that you would rather him lynched than no lynch happen???

To be honest, because it was so close to the deadline, I figured it wouldn't really influence anyone either way, and the only thing it would do would be to draw more attention to myself if colton turned out to be town.

I think this is the scummiest thing i've seen this game.



You very well knew the situation at the time wasn't good considering mets wasn't voting, limited time, as well as not knowing who would be around to help the vote if mets didnt vote.
So a towns input that "hey a lynch is good in this situation even though you might not agree mets" would have been very helpful.

which brings us to this point
as town, why are you worried about the lynch if colton is town. You know its good to learn the information and miss lynches do happen. imo its scummier that you didnt say anything, since mets was not voting, and you decided to not say anything. I see great scum motivation in not talking.

As I said, I don't think making a comment would have helped anything. Also, I was 50-50 on whether colton was town or scum, so I was willing to leave my vote there and let him be fired, but I wasn't confident enough to push it strongly after he claimed. I was I think the second vote on him though, and encouraged pressure on him throughout the day... so if you think I am scum, you must think I am awful at it lol.

HotShot53 wrote:

StorrZerg wrote:why didnt you bother making that comment?

regarding, not removing your vote, and that you would rather him lynched than no lynch happen???

To be honest, because it was so close to the deadline, I figured it wouldn't really influence anyone either way, and the only thing it would do would be to draw more attention to myself if colton turned out to be town.

Iron Butterfly wrote:Do not for a moment think that because someone voted to lynch Colton that that somehow proves they are town.

Obviously it's not "proven", but it's about as close proven to it as you can get right now, since storr sort of led the lynch of colton, even cast the deciding vote after firing mets and lowering the amount needed for a firing... without all that there would have been a no-lynch. I would think he could be a serial killer, except I've never seen a public day-time serial killer before. So unless storr is even crazier than usual, I'd say he's town.

I was not referring to him.

This game has been comical in many ways.

so who do we lynch next IB?

Iron Butterfly wrote:

HotShot53 wrote:

Iron Butterfly wrote:Do not for a moment think that because someone voted to lynch Colton that that somehow proves they are town.

Obviously it's not "proven", but it's about as close proven to it as you can get right now, since storr sort of led the lynch of colton, even cast the deciding vote after firing mets and lowering the amount needed for a firing... without all that there would have been a no-lynch. I would think he could be a serial killer, except I've never seen a public day-time serial killer before. So unless storr is even crazier than usual, I'd say he's town.

I was not referring to him.

This game has been comical in many ways.

Oh, that's who I was referring to, and you were responding to me, so I thought you were disagreeing with me about storr. Obviously everyone else who voted for colton doesn't get a completely free pass.

StorrZerg wrote:so who do we lynch next IB?

You and I have different styles. Suspecting someone does not make me right...nor you. The best course of action is to wait and see what tomorrow brings.

Hi Guys!
I'm off on a cruise for a few days. I'll be returning on Thursday morning cc time.
I would suggest putting some pressure on Crasp and Legion - my nose is twitching about those two.

Iron Butterfly wrote:

StorrZerg wrote:so who do we lynch next IB?

You and I have different styles. Suspecting someone does not make me right...nor you. The best course of action is to wait and see what tomorrow brings.

I disagree waiting is a good idea. Good chance you could die in the night, considering one of the earlier people to push colton, and several people are town reading you.
Thus knowing who you suspect is good, its not bout being right its about the thought process and having people react to your accusations.

So, cool thing i got a USB flash drive from someone (item) that has a program on it (does an action is my guess).
(So someone has a night action to send an item)

Catch is, it could do something bad.

So this is something to talk about. should i open it or not.

Every time I've seen things given out it's been from a town... I don't think I've seen a scum inventor before. So I would use it.

fair, but it doesn't mean this is an invention role. Could be someone that gifts an item that does something. Might be random, like maybe it could save me, give me a cop check, or kill me.
Or it could be someone with several items to give.

It could be the 3rd party role.

StorrZerg wrote:So, cool thing i got a USB flash drive from someone (item) that has a program on it (does an action is my guess).
(So someone has a night action to send an item)

Catch is, it could do something bad.

So this is something to talk about. should i open it or not.

A flash drive contains information. I highly doubt it kills. This could get interesting.

Iron Butterfly wrote:

StorrZerg wrote:So, cool thing i got a USB flash drive from someone (item) that has a program on it (does an action is my guess).
(So someone has a night action to send an item)

Catch is, it could do something bad.

So this is something to talk about. should i open it or not.

A flash drive contains information. I highly doubt it kills. This could get interesting.

in this mafia game no one "dies" people get "fired" it could be a virus that gets me fired.

semantics

as an after thought.You have two choices.

Open it or do not open it. I do not wish to spend 3 pages obsessing about why it should not be opened. It is suppose to be opened.

We are in the night.Mafia would not get two kills. In fact if you do die(fired ) everyone will know not to open such a thing in the future.

Open it lets see what it is storr.

fineee ill do it

for science

Wellll...its 2 hours already.