Conquer Club

sniffie wrote:First of all, everybody can be assured that I'm not corrupt or in favor of my own clanmates in anyway.
But, If people still think I would rule different because it's a clanmate, I'll ask one of the other hunters to take this case over.

sniff

sniff, it isn't really a matter of what any person thinks, it's a question of the optics. Judges must recuse themselves if there is the merest hint of potential bias (in either direction). That is exactly what we have in this situation. Even if you were going to rule against GeneralFault, you are his clanmate and should have left this thread for someone else. On top of being your clanmate, GF is also a mod; personally, KA should have been the only hunter anywhere near this thread.

See what you did? Now Sniffie is gone, and I am here.

I hope you're all happy. This is why we can't have nice things.

I will look over this and return with a response this evening.

sniffie wrote:First of all, everybody can be assured that I'm not corrupt or in favor of my own clanmates in anyway.
But, If people still think I would rule different because it's a clanmate, I'll ask one of the other hunters to take this case over.

sniff

sniffs... you can't win either way... you really can't... i would just give it to someone else and get out of the line of fire... cleared, you are a bastard... busted, you are a bastard... you are in a no win situation..-Jésus noir

After examining the game in question, I can't find any fault with Sniffies original assessment.

There is no hostage holding or any sign of secret diplomacy.

Cool. No hard feelings sniffie, hope you can understand the sentiment.

thanks [player]deathcomesrippin[/player]. It's not nice to be part of such an allegation, so thanks for clearing my name...