Conquer Club

So did you lie, or simply change your mind?

Lynch all liars!

nagerous wrote:So did you lie, or simply change your mind?

Lynch all liars!

I changed my mind. Kind of like how you tell someone you're going to go do something, turn around, then immediately turn around and say "I lied" and go sit down or something. Kinda like that.

Cena: please get Kalish to replace Flores <3

Selin, I agree that it seems the most likely... But there is also the possibility Ani never protected Ace, there is a SK and Cena decided to have the mafia janitor cover all NKs. That's a close second to the doc/RB lovers for me

Anyway the "I lied" part of Holo's post is irrelevant. What is more relevant to me is that he admitted he would not be able to present anything that would make him not scum in our eyes, which I find pretty incriminating. I'm not sure why I'm the only one though

ga7 wrote:Cena: please get Kalish to replace Flores <3

Selin, I agree that it seems the most likely... But there is also the possibility Ani never protected Ace, there is a SK and Cena decided to have the mafia janitor cover all NKs. That's a close second to the doc/RB lovers for me

Anyway the "I lied" part of Holo's post is irrelevant. What is more relevant to me is that he admitted he would not be able to present anything that would make him not scum in our eyes, which I find pretty incriminating. I'm not sure why I'm the only one though

Well... My main concern is that Holo is just a new player and/or maybe doesn't have an ability that could help 'clear' himself in our eyes. I certainly don't think that comment is worth my vote, at the moment.

And, yes, please replace Flores with kalish...

But to me that implies not only that he doesn't know how to defend himself, but also that even claiming wouldn't help. At least that's what his post meant to me...

ga7 wrote:But to me that implies not only that he doesn't know how to defend himself, but also that even claiming wouldn't help. At least that's what his post meant to me...

That may be very valid...

I suppose you may be right.

Well, all I can say is we need to NOT have another no lynch...

So, if we need to pick someone, Holo, sorry, bud, but it may be you.

Maybe this is just a 'no-reveal' game. I've seen them before... of course, normally the players would be notified of that beforehand, but it could be cena's idea of a twist.
Anyways, we shouldn't prod Holo unless we have every intention of lynching him because we've already lost two roles to bandwagoning up to a claim and then giving up.

browng-08 wrote:Maybe this is just a 'no-reveal' game. I've seen them before... of course, normally the players would be notified of that beforehand, but it could be cena's idea of a twist.
Anyways, we shouldn't prod Holo unless we have every intention of lynching him because we've already lost two roles to bandwagoning up to a claim and then giving up.

Yep... That's why I withheld my vote.

I am curious as to the people that have yet to speak up much, especially since the new day started.

browng-08 wrote:Maybe this is just a 'no-reveal' game. I've seen them before... of course, normally the players would be notified of that beforehand, but it could be cena's idea of a twist.
Anyways, we shouldn't prod Holo unless we have every intention of lynching him because we've already lost two roles to bandwagoning up to a claim and then giving up.

I like the way you think it could be a 'no reveal' game, of course you wouldn't be able to reveal your role because it is a scummy role... I don't see how it could be a twist, either it is a no claim game or not - there is no middle ground unless scum was called it was no claim. All in all that didn't make sense.

That and your mafiosi wink on day one make me vote browning

Now convince me to change my mind

What I meant was that roles weren't revealed upon death. :roll: That's different from no-claim. There's an obvious reason why 'all in all that didn't make sense': you either didn't know what I was talking about, or are scum jumping on a chance to start a bandwagon.

Anarkistsdream wrote:

ga7 wrote:But to me that implies not only that he doesn't know how to defend himself, but also that even claiming wouldn't help. At least that's what his post meant to me...

That may be very valid...

I suppose you may be right.

Well, all I can say is we need to NOT have another no lynch...

So, if we need to pick someone, Holo, sorry, bud, but it may be you.

I understand. After all, it's my own doing.

PCM replaces Flores

VC coming soom

browng-08 wrote:What I meant was that roles weren't revealed upon death. That's different from no-claim. There's an obvious reason why 'all in all that didn't make sense': you either didn't know what I was talking about, or are scum jumping on a chance to start a bandwagon.

Illogical, that would make no sense, particularly on the evidence I put against you, no-one would jump on such a crazy bandwagon?

Right?????

Though, your logic you must be scum because you voted me... totally flawed and classic mafiosi response. I see your not winking any more.

Here's an idea... maybe I'm the lyncher, you're the lynchee? Surprised you didn't bring that one up in your defence mafia boy!

Except I haven't voted you. To be honest, I think you just misunderstood me.

Ok, I think you're town

unvote.

nag wrote:Illogical, that would make no sense, particularly on the evidence I put against you, no-one would jump on such a crazy bandwagon?

Right?????

Though, your logic you must be scum because you voted me... totally flawed and classic mafiosi response. I see your not winking any more.

Here's an idea... maybe I'm the lyncher, you're the lynchee? Surprised you didn't bring that one up in your defence mafia boy!

nag wrote:Ok, I think you're town

unvote.

lmfao!

nag demonstrates his ability to change his mind like, uh... <insert metaphor here>



anyhoo, about the "ani's a doc" thing... what if... an sk killed ani, and then the mafia blocked ani and killed ace?

that doesn't help.

i'm finding holo's refusal to claim under pressure annoying. withholding information from the town is always slightly scummy imo.

Confirming.

Well, I'm feeling better today, so here are my thoughts:

Hologram wrote:Think I'm lying? Go ahead and lynch me. You'll be sorry, but you'll get over it.

Hologram wrote:Selin's right, we really don't have any good leads, except the one against me, and we need to lynch. I know you're all looking for a claim from me, but it's just not time right now. If you must lynch me, do so, because I honestly don't think I can ever convince you of anything other than my being scum.

Hologram wrote:

AnarkistsDream wrote:So, if we need to pick someone, Holo, sorry, bud, but it may be you.

I understand. After all, it's my own doing.

Looks like holo sure wouldn't mind getting lynched. Jester, anyone? I don't really know enough about the books to warrant a guess as to what character might be a jester though. Can anyone help me out?

dunc_2007 wrote:Well, I'm feeling better today, so here are my thoughts:

Hologram wrote:Think I'm lying? Go ahead and lynch me. You'll be sorry, but you'll get over it.

Hologram wrote:Selin's right, we really don't have any good leads, except the one against me, and we need to lynch. I know you're all looking for a claim from me, but it's just not time right now. If you must lynch me, do so, because I honestly don't think I can ever convince you of anything other than my being scum.

Hologram wrote:

AnarkistsDream wrote:So, if we need to pick someone, Holo, sorry, bud, but it may be you.

I understand. After all, it's my own doing.

Looks like holo sure wouldn't mind getting lynched. Jester, anyone? I don't really know enough about the books to warrant a guess as to what character might be a jester though. Can anyone help me out?

Oh, I mind. I mind very much, and so will you.

Hologram wrote:

dunc_2007 wrote:Well, I'm feeling better today, so here are my thoughts:

Hologram wrote:Think I'm lying? Go ahead and lynch me. You'll be sorry, but you'll get over it.

Hologram wrote:Selin's right, we really don't have any good leads, except the one against me, and we need to lynch. I know you're all looking for a claim from me, but it's just not time right now. If you must lynch me, do so, because I honestly don't think I can ever convince you of anything other than my being scum.

Hologram wrote:

AnarkistsDream wrote:So, if we need to pick someone, Holo, sorry, bud, but it may be you.

I understand. After all, it's my own doing.

Looks like holo sure wouldn't mind getting lynched. Jester, anyone? I don't really know enough about the books to warrant a guess as to what character might be a jester though. Can anyone help me out?

Oh, I mind. I mind very much, and so will you.

Well, that's a rather ambiguous statement. I could add plenty on to that. I mind because I want to win and lynching me will give me a win. You'll mind because you'll be pissed that you just made me win. I don't trust it.

pancakemix wrote:

Hologram wrote:

dunc_2007 wrote:Well, I'm feeling better today, so here are my thoughts:

Hologram wrote:Think I'm lying? Go ahead and lynch me. You'll be sorry, but you'll get over it.

Hologram wrote:Selin's right, we really don't have any good leads, except the one against me, and we need to lynch. I know you're all looking for a claim from me, but it's just not time right now. If you must lynch me, do so, because I honestly don't think I can ever convince you of anything other than my being scum.

Hologram wrote:

AnarkistsDream wrote:So, if we need to pick someone, Holo, sorry, bud, but it may be you.

I understand. After all, it's my own doing.

Looks like holo sure wouldn't mind getting lynched. Jester, anyone? I don't really know enough about the books to warrant a guess as to what character might be a jester though. Can anyone help me out?

Oh, I mind. I mind very much, and so will you.

Well, that's a rather ambiguous statement. I could add plenty on to that. I mind because I want to win and lynching me will give me a win. You'll mind because you'll be pissed that you just made me win. I don't trust it.

I wouldn't trust me if I were you, either. But as it is, I'm not going to claim. At least not yet.

You know, we could just let a vig kill him tonight, if we're so worried about him being a jester. That is assuming we even have a vig...

You know what? I've given it some thought, and I do truly believe that there's another doc out there, and if there isn't then I'm dead whether you lynch me or I survive until night and either the Mafia or a vig will kill me then. So I might as well make myself known to the hiding doctor and do a full claim, since it's the only way we're going to get off me and onto someone we actually need to lynch.

I'm Ellemere, the Beloved Princess, and if I die, my death will be followed by an extra night scene, which is bad for everyone involved except the Mafia.

In the meantime,

FOS Stroop for acting scummy day 1 and backpedaling when someone called him on it.

unvote
Well, this is fantastic. That was a great use of Day 2...