Germany Revamp Competition - FINAL VOTE (page one)

[edbeard]

I went with I

F is 630x600 - no need to be full size here
F has colours that fit the German flag. I has colours that hark back to the original Germany map (I think). push.
F thinks that Pep did a Gameplay revamp. tisk-tisk

to sum up, like a deadly spider, the maker of map I has weaved together quite the map.

[the.killing.44]

F thinks that Pep did a Gameplay revamp. tisk-tisk

He did, and is getting a medal for it…

[TODRICH]

I vote for F

[JoshyBoy]

F is much much nicer.

[edbeard]

F thinks that Pep did a Gameplay revamp. tisk-tisk

He did, and is getting a medal for it…

that's news to me. We all know he did a Graphics revamp. I'm guessing you just skimmed the post?

[MrBenn]

The gameplay has remained unchanged from Hoff's original Germany map.
Pep worked out the current configuration, making it more accurate while retaining the gameplay connections etc.
The competition conditions stated that pep will be the second mapmaker to credited with developing the revamp.

[the.killing.44]

F thinks that Pep did a Gameplay revamp. tisk-tisk

He did, and is getting a medal for it…

that's news to me. We all know he did a Graphics revamp. I'm guessing you just skimmed the post?

Nah, I think we just have different definitions of gameplay. I include the tert layouts, names, etc.; but yeah, you're right in that the connections and bonuses haven't changed.

Got a better word?

[captainwalrus]

F thinks that Pep did a Gameplay revamp. tisk-tisk

He did, and is getting a medal for it…

that's news to me. We all know he did a Graphics revamp. I'm guessing you just skimmed the post?

Nah, I think we just have different definitions of gameplay. I include the tert layouts, names, etc.; but yeah, you're right in that the connections and bonuses haven't changed.

Got a better word?

Gameplay is just the bonuses and connections. everything else is graphics.

[rutherfoo]

I like the map that's being used for Germany now better than either of these two. I voted for F anyway, because the rainbow effect really looks gross after playing the map the way it is currently. The black/grey, red/pink, yellow/orange stripes effect really made the map look nice to me, and it's why I started to play it.

[the.killing.44]

Well done, WM. Grats on the win mate.

If you're going to edit this, please get over it. Contest is all but over.

[fumandomuerte]

Well done, WM. Grats on the win mate.

If you're going to edit this, please get over it. Contest is all but over.

Wow, didn't expect WM to be the designer of I. Great job mate.

[Joe B.]

I like map "I" a little better. Impassable borders are a little clearer. Otherwise, both well done.

[danryan]

Map I is beautiful! Get it up and playable please!

[samuelc812]

Congratulations Map I

I would have been happy for either map to win, the.killing.44 and myself collaborated to create Map F

~Sam

[WidowMakers]

Thanks Sam.

For all that don't know, I created map I.
I have contacted MrBenn to figure out how he wants to proceed with the development.

I look forward to getting your feedback and getting this map done as soon as possible.
Thanks again everyoen who participated.
As far as I know it was the most participated revamp we have ever had here.
Lots of great work. It is always great to see how other people think and express themselves on the canvas.

Also great map Sam and killing. Loved the color and title treatments.

WM

[Bruceswar]

I am really happy I won. If D could not win I was the next best thing. Congrats widow maker!

[sully800]

What revamp competition has WM entered that he hasn't won? I suppose the centerscape revamp since the winning design was JR's but WM eventually took over the graphics. Great work man!

I was pretty happy with 3rd place since I put in zero creativity and pretty much cleaned up Pep's map (mine was map G). But I and F were head and shoulders above the rest!

[WidowMakers]

What revamp competition has WM entered that he hasn't won? I suppose the centerscape revamp since the winning design was JR's but WM eventually took over the graphics. Great work man!

Brazil and Centerscape I did not win. RJ did. Plus I am sure RJ would have won this if he had entered. He has the best maps IMO.

[MrBenn]

With an overwhelming majority of the vote, the winner of the Germany Revamp Competition is WidowMakers. You can follow the final tweaks in this thread: viewtopic.php?f=64&t=108186

Congratulations to everybody who took part