Page 9 of 12
Re: Should the New Recruit Icon be changed?
Posted: Sun Aug 08, 2010 9:49 pm
by clapper011
it doesnt belong in here and I am sure Qh is aware of that .. lol keep suggestions in the suggestions forums. moved back and the suggs mods can decide if this should be merged or just locked.
have a great night!
Re: Should the New Recruit Icon be changed?
Posted: Mon Aug 09, 2010 12:50 am
by Woodruff
owenshooter wrote:qwert wrote:why? it doesn't belong in GD... take it back to suggestions...-0
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
These look more like question,not sugestion,so i think that this is right place
really? then why is there already this exact thread in SUGGESTIONS?
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=120521it is a suggestion and they are encroaching on the GD in an effort to garner support...-the black jesus
That isn't an exact thread, in fact. This thread resulted from a discussing within that thread.
clapper011 wrote:it doesnt belong in here and I am sure Qh is aware of that .. lol keep suggestions in the suggestions forums. moved back and the suggs mods can decide if this should be merged or just locked.
have a great night!
Queen_Herpes didn't start this thread, clapper. Queen_Herpes started the other thread that resulted in this one. If you'll read the two threads, you will see that they are NOT the same.
I really don't see how this is a Suggestions thread rather than General Discussion. I guess it's too much bother to have a good thread that actually has something to do with the site in General Discussion rather than the crap that's there now.
Re: Should the New Recruit Icon be changed?
Posted: Mon Aug 09, 2010 6:41 am
by Qwert
dont know who is drunk here?
First, person who are not Queen Herpes,open a >Discusion Topic< here in Sugestion forum, with question>Should the New Recruit Icon be changed?<, and Sugs mods realised that he dont give any sugestions with what he mean to change, and decision who sugs mod made its clear-these is discusion topic.
Now GD mods, decide that these not belong to GD forum? Maybe i need to use translator to understand what GD mods says?
Re: Should the New Recruit Icon be changed?
Posted: Mon Aug 09, 2010 11:05 am
by jefjef
qwert wrote:dont know who is drunk here?
First, person who are not Queen Herpes,open a >Discusion Topic< here in Sugestion forum, with question>Should the New Recruit Icon be changed?<, and Sugs mods realised that he dont give any sugestions with what he mean to change, and decision who sugs mod made its clear-these is discusion topic.
Now GD mods, decide that these not belong to GD forum? Maybe i need to use translator to understand what GD mods says?
Well qwert a few members of the community are having such a good time with the free style QH bash that she is even getting blamed for creating threads she didn't and then moving them to forums even though she can't.
Now as for this topic. It really does not matter as far as the 5 game icon BUT I do not care to see question marks. Give em a feather or something.
Re: Should the New Recruit Icon be changed?
Posted: Mon Aug 09, 2010 4:35 pm
by Woodruff
jefjef wrote:Well qwert a few members of the community are having such a good time with the free style QH bash that she is even getting blamed for creating threads she didn't and then moving them to forums even though she can't.
1. I'm pretty sure Clapper hasn't bashed Queen_Herpes.
2. I HAVE "bashed" (I don't agree with that term, but I know what you're getting at) Queen_Herpes a bit in other threads, but I stood up for her here.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon
Posted: Mon Aug 09, 2010 10:11 pm
by TheForgivenOne
Still waiting Queen.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2010 4:25 am
by jaimito101
TheForgivenOne wrote:Still waiting Queen.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2010 4:39 am
by 00iCon
Tags with N and R inscribed on them. or C and C, whatever.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2010 5:03 am
by Woodruff
TheForgivenOne wrote:Still waiting Queen.
She's still taking her game turns, so she appears to have "taken her toys and gone home" as far as posting goes.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2010 5:28 am
by TheForgivenOne
I gave her ample time to change it. I am taking her poll down, and adding in the "Leave it" option, as well as Merging The other thread into this one.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon
Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2010 10:04 am
by Doc_Brown
Can you modify the topic title to let everyone know the poll has been reset?
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon [Poll Reset]
Posted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 5:04 am
by 00iCon
what were the final results of the other poll?
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon [Poll Reset]
Posted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 7:48 am
by Darwins_Bane
there were no final results.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon [Poll Reset]
Posted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 8:10 am
by Qwert
hmm,how many time you will change poll to get results what will be satisfy for you? I think that its best for everybody to lock these topic,and after few month to open new topic,with some better balanced starting. With so many poll changes ,these all topic start to be pointless.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon [Poll Reset]
Posted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 10:47 am
by Darwins_Bane
the point of the poll reset was to add the option of keeping the symbol as is. Queen_Herpes refused to do so.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon [Poll Reset]
Posted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 12:14 pm
by Woodruff
qwert wrote:hmm,how many time you will change poll to get results what will be satisfy for you? I think that its best for everybody to lock these topic,and after few month to open new topic,with some better balanced starting. With so many poll changes ,these all topic start to be pointless.
The problem was that Queen_Herpes (the thread originator) changed the poll herself several times, all while refusing to add the option that was requested by the Suggestions moderators. So they've essentially added it themselves here.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon [Poll Reset]
Posted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 1:17 pm
by jefjef
As of right now It is 12 in favor of one of the choices other than leave as it is which is at 8. So will all totals for change be combined and recognized instead of spread and counted individually?
For an unskewed poll that you all were crying about should it not start just as:
No. Leave it as it is.
Yes. Replace it. (To be determined later)
Don't care.
As far as I see you all who demanded a fair poll are only trying to skew it to your point of view.
The same thing you all chastised QH for...
The thing about Queens sugg and poll is that it was intended to find an icon the community would like to see it changed to if it were to be changed. She would then have approached CC with a usable and supported sugg to replace the ? and some of you only turned this into a personal vendetta and now your being what some of you unjustifiable whined about in the 1st place.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon [Poll Reset]
Posted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 3:09 pm
by Ace Rimmer
if they don't care either way, then who needs their vote? We don't need a "don't care" option, anyone who doesn't vote obviously doesn't care.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon [Poll Reset]
Posted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 3:39 pm
by oVo
The NR/NR would be an improvement,
but I actually like the idea of a Green bugle best.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon [Poll Reset]
Posted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 6:40 pm
by Darwins_Bane
jefjef wrote:As of right now It is 12 in favor of one of the choices other than leave as it is which is at 8. So will all totals for change be combined and recognized instead of spread and counted individually?
For an unskewed poll that you all were crying about should it not start just as:
No. Leave it as it is.
Yes. Replace it. (To be determined later)
Don't care.
As far as I see you all who demanded a fair poll are only trying to skew it to your point of view.
The same thing you all chastised QH for...
The thing about Queens sugg and poll is that it was intended to find an icon the community would like to see it changed to if it were to be changed. She would then have approached CC with a usable and supported sugg to replace the ? and some of you only turned this into a personal vendetta and now your being what some of you unjustifiable whined about in the 1st place.
Agreed. I think the votes should be on one side keeping it as is, on the other everything else.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon [Poll Reset]
Posted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 7:07 pm
by Woodruff
jefjef wrote:As of right now It is 12 in favor of one of the choices other than leave as it is which is at 8. So will all totals for change be combined and recognized instead of spread and counted individually?
For an unskewed poll that you all were crying about should it not start just as:
No. Leave it as it is.
Yes. Replace it. (To be determined later)
Don't care.
As far as I see you all who demanded a fair poll are only trying to skew it to your point of view.
The same thing you all chastised QH for...
I suppose, other than the fact that you're ignoring that we DID EXACTLY THAT, but it was unceremoniously merged with this one (that is NOT our fault). I'm not really sure WHY you're ignoring that, unless it is YOU who is trying to make this into a personal vendetta.
jefjef wrote:The thing about Queens sugg and poll is that it was intended to find an icon the community would like to see it changed to if it were to be changed. She would then have approached CC with a usable and supported sugg to replace the ? and some of you only turned this into a personal vendetta and now your being what some of you unjustifiable whined about in the 1st place.
Again, she was trying to put the cart before the horse...it made no sense at all. There was NEVER any "personal vendetta" and for you to suggest that there was is beyond ludicrous and pushing into the assinine.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon [Poll Reset]
Posted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 8:42 pm
by Joodoo
I don't see a problem with the current icon.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon [Poll Reset]
Posted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 8:45 pm
by Doc_Brown
jefjef wrote:As of right now It is 12 in favor of one of the choices other than leave as it is which is at 8. So will all totals for change be combined and recognized instead of spread and counted individually?
For an unskewed poll that you all were crying about should it not start just as:
No. Leave it as it is.
Yes. Replace it. (To be determined later)
Don't care.
As far as I see you all who demanded a fair poll are only trying to skew it to your point of view.
The same thing you all chastised QH for...
The thing about Queens sugg and poll is that it was intended to find an icon the community would like to see it changed to if it were to be changed. She would then have approached CC with a usable and supported sugg to replace the ? and some of you only turned this into a personal vendetta and now your being what some of you unjustifiable whined about in the 1st place.
Jefjef, I suspect everyone would be in complete agreement with you on how to interpret the results of the poll. As it stands right now, 61% are in favor of changing it and 39% are in favor of keeping it the way it stands. The last time I saw the previous poll I made, it was a bit closer (and had quite a few more votes), but there was still a small majority (something like 52% I think) in favor of changing it.
Since I agree with you here (incidentally, I voted for the dog tags icon in this poll if it matters), does my opinion count even though I'm still freemium?
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon [Poll Reset]
Posted: Sat Aug 14, 2010 10:25 pm
by 00iCon
Doc_Brown wrote:Jefjef, I suspect everyone would be in complete agreement with you on how to interpret the results of the poll. As it stands right now, 61% are in favor of changing it and 39% are in favor of keeping it the way it stands. The last time I saw the previous poll I made, it was a bit closer (and had quite a few more votes), but there was still a small majority (something like 52% I think) in favor of changing it.
Since I agree with you here (incidentally, I voted for the dog tags icon in this poll if it matters), does my opinion count even though I'm still freemium?
Just about to say this. add up the votes for not not changing it. only 1 poll needed.
Of course your vote counts! this site is here to benefit all players. I got free premium, so if you don't count i shouldn't count! But it can't be traced.
Re: Replace ? icon with "Basic Training" icon [Poll Reset]
Posted: Sat Aug 14, 2010 10:38 pm
by Army of GOD
Joodoo wrote:I don't see a problem with the current icon.
Can you at least admit that the red/blue combo is really annoying?
It legitimately irks me.